Showing posts with label defence material. Show all posts
Showing posts with label defence material. Show all posts

Wednesday, 12 August 2026

Supreme Court explains 4-Steps To Test If Criminal Case Can Be Quashed Based On Defence Material Before Trial

 In Rajiv Thapar and Others v. Madan Lal

Kapoor8, this Court laid down a 4-step test to

determine if criminal proceedings can be

quashed on the basis of defense

material/official records prior to trial:

“30. Based on the factors canvassed in the

foregoing paragraphs, we would delineate the

following steps to determine the veracity of a

prayer for quashment raised by an accused by

invoking the power vested in the High Court

under Section 482 CrPC:

30.1. Step one: whether the material relied

upon by the accused is sound, reasonable, and

indubitable i.e. the material is of sterling and

impeccable quality?

30.2. Step two: whether the material relied

upon by the accused would rule out the

assertions contained in the charges levelled

against the accused i.e. the material is

sufficient to reject and overrule the factual

assertions contained in the complaint i.e. the

material is such as would persuade a

reasonable person to dismiss and condemn the

factual basis of the accusations as false?

30.3. Step three: whether the material relied

upon by the accused has not been refuted by

the prosecution/complainant; and/or the

material is such that it cannot be justifiably

refuted by the prosecution/complainant?

30.4. Step four: whether proceeding with the

trial would result in an abuse of process of the

court, and would not serve the ends of justice?

30.5. If the answer to all the steps is in the

affirmative, the judicial conscience of the High

Court should persuade it to quash such

criminal proceedings in exercise of power

vested in it under Section 482 CrPC. Such

exercise of power, besides doing justice to the

accused, would save precious court time,

which would otherwise be wasted in holding

such a trial (as well as proceedings arising

therefrom) specially when it is clear that the

same would not conclude in the conviction of

the accused.”{Para 19}

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. OF 2026

(ARISING OUT OF SLP (CRL.) NO.2939 OF 2026)

RAHUL  Vs  STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH

Author: AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH, J.

Citation: 2026 INSC 825.

Read full judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

No Inflexible Rule That Alibi Can Be Proved Only In Trial : Supreme Court Quashes S. 498A IPC Case Against BSF Personnel

 In these circumstances, continuing a full

sessions trial against the appellant alone,

while his co-accused stand acquitted on the

self-same evidence, would not further the

cause of justice but would subject the

appellant to the ordeal and stigma of a criminal

trial whose substratum has already collapsed.

The High Court, in the impugned judgment,

proceeded on the premise that the appellant's

reliance on the service certificate was a bare

plea of alibi of the kind considered in Rajendra

Singh (supra), and declined to examine

corroborating circumstances. This, in the

considered view of this Court, constituted a

failure to appreciate unimpeachable material

bearing directly on the question of abuse of

process, and calls for interference. {Para 34}

35. In light of the foregoing facts and

circumstances, and the analysis of the legal

precedents referred to above, this Court is of

the view that the four-steps as laid down in the

case of Rajiv Thapar (supra) are satisfied in

the present case. The service certificate is not

disputed as a document, its issuing authority

is not questioned, nor are its contents

disputed. Where the unimpeached

documentary record and the result of a

connected trial on identical evidence, taken

together, demonstrate that the continuation of

the prosecution against the appellant would be

a legal exercise in futility, the High Court, and

now this Court, would be failing in their duty

if they permitted the criminal process to

continue merely because a technical prima

facie case can be spelt out from the bare

averments of the F.I.R. The categories

identified in Bhajan Lal (supra) are

illustrative and not exhaustive, and the

present case falls squarely within the rationale

of categories 1, 3 and 6 concerning inherent

improbability of the allegations and abuse of

the process of the court.

36. For the foregoing reasons, this Court is

satisfied that the continuation of criminal

proceedings against the appellant amounts to

an abuse of the process of the court and

requires to be quashed qua the appellant

alone.

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. OF 2026

(ARISING OUT OF SLP (CRL.) NO.2939 OF 2026)

RAHUL  Vs  STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH

Author: AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH, J.

Citation: 2026 INSC 825

Print Page

Monday, 30 January 2017

Under which circumstances court can look in to defence material produced at time of framing of charge?

 In   the   judgment   given   in   the   case   of  Rukhmini   Narvekar   V/s.   Vijaya
Satardekar and others (cited supra) the Hon'ble Supreme Court has laid down, in
paragraph no.22, as follows:
“22. Thus in our opinion, while it is true that ordinarily defence
material cannot be looked into by the Court while framing of the
charge in view of D.N. Padhi' case 6, there may be some very rare
and exceptional cases where some defence material when shown
to   the   trial   court   would   convincingly   demonstrate   that   the
prosecution version is totally absurd or preposterous, and in such
very rare cases the defence material can be looked into by the
court at the time of framing of the charges or taking cognizance. In
our opinion, therefore, it cannot be said as an absolute proposition
that under no circumstances can the court look into the material
produced by the defence at the time of framing of the charges,
though   this   should   be   done   in   very   rare   cases   i.e.   where   the
defence produces some material which convincingly demonstrates
that   the   whole   prosecution   case   is   totally   absurd   or   totally
concocted.”
The learned advocate for the applicants has not been able to show that the
present   case   is   one   of   the   exceptional   cases   and   that   the   documents
(communications) produced by the applicants convincingly demonstrate that the
prosecution version is totally absurd or concocted.  
Considering   the   facts   of  the   case  and   the   proposition   laid   down   in   the
judgment given in the case of Rukhmini Narvekar v. Vijaya Satardekar and others,
the other judgments referred by the learned Advocate for the   applicants, do not
assist the applicants.  
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH AT NAGPUR
CRIMINAL REVISION APPLICATION NO.92/2015
 Prabhakar S/o Rupnarayan Jha V  The Central Bureau of Investigation, 

­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­ ­
CORAM  :  Z.A. HAQ, J.
DATE  :    25.2.2016
Citation:2016 ALLMR(CRI)4600
Print Page

Sunday, 4 December 2016

When court can take in to consideration material produced by accused at the time of framing of charge?

We have carefully perused the decision of this Court in the State of Orissa vs. Debendra Nath Padhi (supra). Though the observations in paragraph 16 of the said decision seems to support the view canvassed by by Shri Rohatgi, it may be also pointed out that in paragraph 29 of the same decision it has been observed that the width of the powers of the High Court under Section 482 of Cr.P.C and Article 226 of the Constitution is unlimited whereunder in the interests of justice the High Court can make such orders as may be necessary to prevent abuse of the process of the court or otherwise to secure the ends of justice within the parameters laid down in Bhajan Lal's case (supra). Thus we have to reconcile paragraphs 16 and 23 of the decision inState of Orissa vs. Debendra Nath Padhi (supra). We should also keep in mind that it is well settled that a judgment of the Court has not to be treated as a Euclid formula vide Dr. Rajbir Singh Dalal vs. Chaudhari Devi Lal University, Sirsa & Anr. JT 2008(8) SC 621. As observed by this Court in Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd. & Anr. vs. N.R. Vairamani & Anr AIR 2004 SC 4778, observations of Courts are neither to be read as Euclid's formula nor as provisions of the statute. Thus in our opinion while it is true that ordinarily defence material cannot be looked into by the Court while framing of the charge in view of D.N. Padhi's case (supra), there may be some very rare and exceptional cases where some defence material when shown to the trial court would convincingly demonstrate that the prosecution version is totally absurd or preposterous, and in such very rare cases the defence material can be looked into by the Court at the time of framing of the charges or taking cognizance.
18. In our opinion, therefore, it cannot be said as an absolute proposition that under no circumstances can the Court look into the material produced by the defence at the time of framing of the charges, though this should be done in very rare cases, i.e. where the defence produces some material which convincingly demonstrates that the whole prosecution case is totally absurd or totally concocted. We agree with Shri Lalit that in some very rare cases the Court is justified in looking into the material produced by the defence at the time of framing of the charges, if such material convincingly establishes that the whole prosecution version is totally absurd, preposterous or concocted.

Reportable
Supreme Court of India
Rukmini Narvekar vs Vijay Sataredkar & Ors on 3 October, 2008

Bench: Altamas Kabir, Markandey Katju
Print Page