Showing posts with label documents of title. Show all posts
Showing posts with label documents of title. Show all posts

Thursday, 29 March 2018

Whether landlord can be denied rent from tenant if documents of title of property of tenant is laying with landlord as security?

In reply to both these applications, it is stated by the Defendants that the papers relating to the residential properties of the Defendants at 12, Malikpur, Model Town-I, Delhi-110009 are in the possession of the Plaintiff and that it is a sufficient security. It is only contended that the Plaintiff cannot be granted relief "based upon a disputed rent and a liability which has not been admitted by the Defendants".

15. As already observed, the word 'rent' in Order XVA CPC is not limited to the 'admitted' rent. In any event, it also envisages the Court determining an 'amount' payable towards either rent or future mesne profits. In the present case, after the termination of the tenancy, the Defendants continue to occupy the commercial property. The property, in which where they are running a restaurant, is located in a busy market area. The Defendants have not countered the documents placed on record by the Plaintiff to show that the current market rent for commercial property of a similar size in the area is more than Rs. 3 lakhs per month. The mere fact that the Plaintiff may have the title documents of the residential property of the Defendants cannot be said to constitute sufficient security for the purposes of Order XVA CPC. The object of this provision is to provide the landlord with some 'amount' for use and occupation of the property by the Defendant during the pendency of the litigation. Keeping these factors in view, the Court is of the opinion that pending the final decision in the suit, the Defendants should deposit towards use and occupation charges/falling within the meaning of the expression 'such amount' in Order XVA CPC, a sum of Rs. 1 lakh per month.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

CS (OS) 1698 of 2011

Decided On: 03.12.2013

 Prem Lata Vs. Raghubir Rai and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S. Muralidhar, J.
Print Page

Friday, 1 May 2015

Whether construction of documents which are not documents of title becomes issue of law?

A Construction of documents (unless they are documents of title) produced by the parties to prove a question of fact does not involve an issue of law, unless it can be shown that the material evidence contained in them was misunderstood by the Court of fact. The documents in this case, which have been the subject of three separate considerations, were the Land Registers the Amarkam, and Bhooband Accounts and the Adangal Registers, together with certain documents derived from the Zamindari records. None of these documents can be correctly described as a document of title, whatever its evidentiary value otherwise. We do not, however, wish to rest our decision on this narrow ground even if right, because the legal inference from the proved facts may still raise a question of law.

Supreme Court of India

Nedunuri Kameswaramma vs Sampati Subba Rao on 17 April, 1962
Equivalent citations: 1963 AIR 884, 1963 SCR (2) 208

Bench: Hidayatullah, M.
    
Print Page