Showing posts with label formal defect. Show all posts
Showing posts with label formal defect. Show all posts

Sunday, 17 March 2024

Tripura HC: Formal defect’ for the purpose of withdrawal of suit must be given a liberal interpretation meaning various kinds of defects not affecting merits of plea

What is a “formal defect” has been explained by the Apex Court in a recent decision rendered in case of V. Rajendran and another versus Annasamy Pandian (Dead) through Legal representatives Karphyayani Natchiar reported in (2017) 5 SCC 63 wherein it was held as under:

“10. In K.S. Bhoopathy and Ors. vs. Kokila and Ors. (2000) 5 SCC 458, it has been held that it is the duty of the Court to be satisfied about the existence of “formal defect” or “sufficient grounds” before granting permission to withdraw the suit with liberty to file a fresh suit under the same cause of action. Though, liberty may lie with the plaintiff in a suit to withdraw the suit at any time after the institution of suit on establishing the “formal defect” or “sufficient grounds”, such right cannot be considered to be so absolute as to permit or encourage abuse of process of Court. The fact that the plaintiff is entitled to abandon or withdraw the suit or part of the claim by itself, is no licence to the plaintiff to claim or to do so to the detriment of legitimate right of the defendant. When an application is filed under Order XXIII Rule 1(3) CPC, the Court must be satisfied about the

“formal defect” or “sufficient grounds”. “Formal defect” is a defect of form prescribed by the Rules of procedure such as, want of notice under Section 80 CPC, improper valuation of the suit, insufficient court fee, confusion regarding identification of the suit property, misjoinder of parties, failure to disclose a cause of action etc. “Formal defect” must be given a liberal meaning which connotes various kinds of defects not affecting the merits of the plea raised by either of the parties.

 “Formal defect” has been described as a defect of form prescribed by the Rules of procedure such as, want of notice under Section80 CPC, improper valuation of the suit, insufficient court fee, confusion regarding identification of the suit property, misjoinder of parties, failure to disclose a cause of action etc. As held hereinabove by the Apex Court “Formal defect” must be given a liberal meaning which connotes various kinds of defects not affecting the merits of the plea raised by either of the parties. Evidently, lack of pecuniary jurisdiction in the instant case did not affect the merits of the case of either of the parties rather it would fall within the meaning of formal defect as provided under Order XXIII Rule 3(a). Since the trial had not even commenced and the lack of pecuniary jurisdiction was pointed out to the learned trial Court at the very outset, the plaintiff had an option either to seek return of the plaint to be presented before the concerned court or to seek withdrawal of the suit with a liberty to file a fresh suit after curing the defect.

{Para 8}

HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA

_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_

CRP No.59 of 2023

Sri Rathindra Chandra Das Vs Sri Barun Chandra Das and another

Coram: HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH

Dated: 13.02.2024

Print Page

Monday, 29 June 2020

Whether the court can permit withdrawal of suit if the plaintiff fails to plead that there is a formal defect in the suit?

 Under order 23 rule 1 (3) CPC, where the court is satisfied that a Suit must fail by reason of some formal defect or that there are sufficient grounds for allowing the Plaintiff to institute a fresh Suit for the subject-matter of a Suit or part of a claim, it may grant permission to withdraw with liberty to institute a fresh Suit.
16. Neither in the application, Respondent has contended that there is a formal defect because of which the Suit must fail or there are sufficient grounds for allowing the Plaintiff to institute a fresh Suit on the same cause of action nor has the Trial Court adverted on the said aspect.
17. Powers under Order 23 Rule 1 (3) CPC for granting liberty to institute a fresh Suit can be exercised only in the given two circumstances. In the present case, as noticed above neither is it so contended by the Respondent/Plaintiff nor has the Trial Court considered the said aspect.
18. I am in agreement with the submissions of Mr. Chandhiok learned senior counsel for the Petitioner that the impugned order permitting withdrawal with liberty is not sustainable since it does not satisfy the requirement of Order 23 Rule 1 (3) CPC for grant of liberty to file a fresh Suit on the same cause of action.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
 Judgment delivered on: 08th May, 2020
 C.R.P. No. 57/2019

M/S ASPEN BUILDTECH LTD Vs  M/S EPICURIA GALLEY PVT LTD 

CORAM:-
MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV SACHDEVA
Print Page

Saturday, 17 June 2017

What constitute formal defect permitting plaintiff to withdraw suit with liberty to file fresh suit?

 In K.S. Bhoopathy and Ors. v. Kokila and Ors. MANU/SC/0395/2000 : (2000) 5 SCC 458, it has been held that it is the duty of the Court to be satisfied about the existence of "formal defect" or "sufficient grounds" before granting permission to withdraw the suit with liberty to file a fresh suit under the same cause of action. Though, liberty may lie with the Plaintiff in a suit to withdraw the suit at any time after the institution of suit on establishing the "formal defect" or "sufficient grounds", such right cannot be considered to be so absolute as to permit or encourage abuse of process of Court. The fact that the Plaintiff is entitled to abandon or withdraw the suit or part of the claim by itself, is no licence to the Plaintiff to claim or to do so to the detriment of legitimate right of the Defendant. When an application is filed under Order XXIII Rule 1(3) Code of Civil Procedure, the Court must be satisfied about the "formal defect" or "sufficient grounds". "Formal defect" is a defect of form prescribed by the Rules of procedure such as, want of notice Under Section 80 Code of Civil Procedure, improper valuation of the suit, insufficient court fee, confusion regarding identification of the suit property, mis-joinder of parties, failure to disclose a cause of action etc. "Formal defect" must be given a liberal meaning which connotes various kinds of defects not affecting the merits of the plea raised by either of the parties.

12. In the present case, the Appellants have filed the suit describing the suit property as Survey No. 192/9 but the Respondents are said to have transferred the patta for the suit property settling as Survey No. 192/14. The defect in the survey number of the suit property goes to the very core of the subject matter of the suit and the entire proceedings would be fruitless if the decree holder is not able to get the decree executed successfully and thus, the said defect will constitute to be a "formal defect" within the meaning of Order XXIII Rule 1(3)(a) Code of Civil Procedure. That apart the Respondents are said to have executed an Inam Settlement Deed on 21.09.2012, in favour of their son Aranmanai Pandian, mentioning the suit property as Survey No. 192/14. We are convinced that the case of the Appellants would fall under Clause (a) of Rule 1(3) Code of Civil Procedure.
13. In the facts and circumstance of the case, the trial court considered the allegation set out in the application as a ground for withdrawal. The view taken by the trial court that the suit suffered from a formal defect to allow the Appellants to withdraw the suit with permission to institute a fresh suit, is correct. 
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Civil Appeal No. 861 of 2017.
Decided On: 24.01.2017

V. Rajendran and Ors.Vs.   Annasamy Pandian (D) thr. L.Rs. Karthyayani Natchiar


 Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Dipak Misra and R. Banumathi, JJ.
Citation: AIR 2017 SC 685,(2017)5 SCC63
Print Page

Thursday, 23 March 2017

Whether civil suit becomes property of court as soon as it is filed?

This Court has come to a strange situation wherein repeatedly the suits and appeals were permitted to be withdrawn by the petitioner on the ground of formal defect. What is permitted under the court under Order XXIII Rule 1(3) is to permit the plaintiff/plaintiffs to 'withdraw from the suit' and not the suit as such. When a suit is filed, it is the property of the court and not that of the party. A party cannot be permitted to withdraw a suit; at the most he can only be permitted to withdraw from the suit.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
OP(C) No. 1130 of 2015 (O)
Decided On: 24.06.2015
Asok Kumar 
Vs.
 Koottala Kshethra Samithy and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:B. Kemal Pasha, J.
Print Page

Sunday, 5 March 2017

When court should not allow withdrawal of suit with liberty to file fresh suit?

 I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and with their assistance I have gone through the record of the case.
4. Order 23 Rule 1(3) lays down that :-
"(3) Where the Court is satisfied,-
(a) that a suit must fail by reason of some formal defect, or
(b) that there are sufficient grounds for allowing the plaintiff to institute a fresh suit for the subject matter of a suit or part of a claim,
it may, on such terms as it thinks fit, grant the plaintiff permission to withdraw from such suit or such part of the claim with liberty to institute a fresh suit in respect of the subject-matter of such suit or such part of the claim."
5. A reading of the above provision would show that prayer under Order 23 Code of Civil Procedure can only be granted if the Court is of the opinion that the suit must fail on the ground of some formal defect. Formal defect has not been defined in the Code of Civil Procedure and it will depend upon the facts of each case. I am certain that formal defect has to be understood differently from the suit which is not legally maintainable. The case set up by the plaintiffs-respondents in the trial Court was that on the basis of the agreement, the entire land was sold in their favour and that the defendants are committing breach of agreement. If the time for specific performance of the agreement has not lapsed, the suit was always legally maintainable and if the time for specific performance of the agreement has already expired, the suit was also legally maintainable. In both the eventualities, there is no formal defect in the suit. In this view of the matter, the impugned order cannot be sustained in the eyes of law.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
Civil Revision No. 1923 of 1999
Decided On: 08.03.2001
Jagjit Singh
Vs.
Gursharan Singh
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.L. Anand, J.

Citation: 2002 (1) CIVIL LJ 302
Print Page

Sunday, 1 January 2017

Whether court can permit withdrawal of suit during pendency of appeal?

 In the present case, the suit was filed by the
respondent   on   behalf   of   a   registered   trust   namely
Pandurang   Vitthal   Firm   Private   Limited.     He   ought   to
have been authorised by the said trust to institute a

suit on its behalf.  No such authorisation was produced
by him with the plaint.  Therefore, it was held that the
respondent was not competent to file and prosecute the
suit.   In my view, this is clearly a formal defect in
the suit.  The valuable rights of the parties cannot be
allowed   to   be   defeated   on   account   of   such   formal
defects.   Consequently, in view of the judgments cited
by   the   learned   counsel   for   the   respondent,   which   are
fully applicable to the facts of the present case, I am
of the opinion that the learned Ad­hoc District Judge­1,
Latur   rightly   allowed   the   application   (Exh­15)   and
rightly   permitted   the   respondent   to   withdraw   the   suit
and file a fresh suit in respect of the same subjectmatter.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CIVIL REVISION APPLICATION NO. 185 OF 2014

 Sow. Saroj w/o Ramesh Jadhav, V Kongaree Veera Reddy,

­­­­
CORAM : SANGITRAO S. PATIL, J.

Dated : 8th SEPTEMBER, 2016
Citation: 2016 (5) ALLMR 903
Print Page

Sunday, 15 March 2015

Whether court should use power to allow withdrawal of suit liberally?



Withdrawal of suit-The term “sufficient
ground” used in second part of the provision needs to be
liberally interpreted. It is also observed that the discretion
given by the provision needs to be used for the ends of
justice. When such discretion is used by giving reasons,
the court exercising revisional power is not expected to

interfere in the order of the trial Court. The order cannot
be celled as illegal or improper. This Court holds that
there is no reason to interfere in the order made by the
trial Court.


IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
Civil Revision Application No.253 of 2013

Raosaheb s/o Shamrao Patwari Versus Vinod s/o Raosaheb Patwari


CORAM:
DATE
T.V. NALAWADE, J.
: 14th MARCH 2014
Citation; 2015(2) MHLJ36,2015(1)ALLMR322, 2014(5)BomCR326
Print Page