Showing posts with label instigation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label instigation. Show all posts

Friday, 17 September 2021

Whether an offence of Abetment of suicide By Instigation Depends On Intention Of Accused or Victim's Actions?

 The note is scribed by the deceased few hours before

she took the extreme step and is an expression of despair and her

anguish; it reflect her desperation and pain.

She is a girl in formative years and her writing give an

impression that she feel trapped. It is possible that any other girl

in similar circumstances would have responded to the situation in a different way, but as stated above, the applicant was her own

uncle and considering the close association of the family with

him, there was an absolute inhibition on her part to blame him

and embroil him in accusation. The screen shots from the mobile

make it apparent that the applicant was harassing the deceased

and inspite of her strong protest, was seeking something from her, leaving her in a despondent state.

12 The accepted legal position being to the effect that

the word ‘instigation’ is to goad, urge, forward, provoke, incite or

encourage to do an act. However, to satisfy the requirement of

instigation, though it is necessary that the actual words must be

used to that effect, but what constitutes instigation must

necessarily and specifically be suggestive of the consequences.

The position of law which emerges from the authoritative

pronouncements is that a reasonable certainty to incite, the

consequences must be capable of being spelt out. The offence of

abetment by instigation depends upon the intention of the person

who abets and not upon the act which is done by the person who

was abetted.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL BAIL APPLICATION NO. 2687 OF 2021

Gaurav  Sopan Narkhede Vs  The State of Maharashtra 

CORAM: BHARATI DANGRE, J.

DATED : 1st SEPTEMBER, 2021

Print Page

Tuesday, 15 September 2020

Whether the bank manager refusing to sanction loan can be held guilty for abetment of suicide?

Law is well crystallized by various pronouncements of
the Honourable Apex Court and of this Court. It would be useful
to have a reference of few cases of the Honourable Apex Court
without detailing facts in those cases:

(1) Sanju alias Sanjay Singh Sengar vs. State of
Madhya Pradesh, reported at 2002(3) Cri.L.J.
2796,
(2) Madan Mohan Singh vs. State of Gujarat and
anr, reported at 2010 ALL MR (Cri) 3245 (SC).
13. One of leading case on this issue is, Dilip s/o Ramrao
ALL MR (Cri) 4328, this Court discussed in detail various
pronouncements of the Honourable Apex Court. The ratio of the
said is that it is incumbent upon prosecution to at least show prima
facie case that accused had an intention to aid or instigate or abet
deceased to commit suicide. In the absence of availability of such
material, the accused cannot be compelled to face trial for the
offence punishable under Section 306 of the Indian Penal Code.
14. Admittedly, in this case, the Loan Account of the
complainant was showing outstanding to the tune of
Rs.2,32,689/-. The said aspect is not denied by the prosecution.
Sudhir Gawande, the deceased, was not having any loan
outstanding in his name. Even, according to the prosecution,
Sudhir Gawande, the deceased, went to the Bank of Maharashtra,
Morshi Branch, District Amravati for loan. If previous loan amount
is outstanding and if the applicant, who is Branch Manager of the
said Bank, is refusing to grant any further loan, can be said as act
of a vigilant and prudent banker and if he is not granting any
further loan, it cannot be termed that by such act he instigated
and/or abetted the person to commit suicide.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY,
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR
CRIMINAL APPLICATION (APL) NO.63 OF 2016

Santoshkumar Raj Kishor Prasad Singh, Vs  The State of Maharashtra 

CORAM : V.M.DESHPANDE, &
ANIL S.KILOR, JJ.
DATE : SEPTEMBER 9, 2020.

ORAL JUDGMENT (Per : V.M.Deshpande, J.)
Print Page

Sunday, 3 March 2019

Whether slapping husband in presence of others amounts to instigation to commit suicide?


 In the present case, the allegation against the petitioner is that she had slapped the deceased 3 days prior to the deceased committing suicide. There is nothing to suggest that the petitioner instigated, conspired or aided in commission of suicide by the deceased. There is no allegation against the petitioner that the petitioner instigated or exhorted the deceased to commit suicide.
18. The allegation is that the petitioner slapped the deceased in presence of others. Even if one were to consider the incident of alleged slapping as instigation then one has to keep in mind that the alleged conduct should be such as to drive any normal prudent person into committing suicide. Mere act of slapping the husband in presence of others would not under normal circumstances instigate a husband to commit suicide.
19. Further, alleged suicide note relied on by the prosecution does not refer to any incident of slapping. On the other hand, the suicide note alleges that the father of the petitioner had not revealed about the deformity in the back of the petitioner on account of which the deceased's life had become a joke. The suicide note alleges that the accused had made allegations about the relationship between the deceased and his sister-in-law (brother's wife) and had also alleged that the deceased's brother was mentally unsound. The suicide note does not make any reference to any incident of slapping.

In the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi
(Before Sanjeev Sachdeva, J.)

Shikha Gupta v. State (GNCT of Delhi) .

Crl. Rev. P. 330/2017
Decided on January 8, 2019,
Citation: 2019 SCC OnLine Del 6394
Print Page

Saturday, 29 October 2016

When accused can be discharged for offence of abetment to commit suicide?

 The offence which has been sought to be charged against the
applicant is the one which is punishable under Section 306 of the Indian
Penal Code.  This offence is of abetment to commit suicide.  For abeting a
thing, as required under Section 107 of the Indian Penal Code, there has
to be instigation given by one person to the another for doing the thing
or engagement with one or more other persons in any conspiracy for
doing of an illegal thing or illegal omission or intentional aiding by any
act   or   illegal   omission  or   willfully  misrepresenting  or  concealing   the
material fact which is bound to be disclosed.  Having regard to the facts
of this case, we shall be concerned in this case only with those aspects of
abetment of a thing which are in the nature of instigation or intentional
aiding.   In the case of  Sanju alias Sanjay Singh Sengar vs. State of

M.P., reported in  (2002) 5 SCC 371, referred to me by the learned
counsel for the petitioner, the Hon'ble Apex Court has explained the
requirement of offence of abetment to commit suicide from this view
point.  The Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that for an instigation to be
completed,   as   contemplated   under   the   law,   there   must   be   some
incitement or urging to do some drastic or inadvisable action or in other
words presence of mens rea is the necessary ingredient of the instigation.
Relevant   observations   of   the   Hon'ble   Apex   Court   as   they   appear   in
paragraph 12 are re­produced as under :
“Even if we accept the prosecution story that
the appellant did tell the deceased “to go and die”, that
itself does not constitute the ingredient of “instigation”.
The word “instigate” denotes incitement or urging to do
some   drastic   or   inadvisable   action   or   to   stimulate   or
incite.   Presence of mens rea, therefore, is the necessary
concomitant of instigation.”
7. Bearing in mind the above referred principles of law that we
have to consider if there are sufficient grounds for proceeding against the
accused or not, which is the basic requirement of Section 227 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure.  Sufficiency of the material for proceeding further
against   the   accused   would   depend   upon   what   is   disclosed   by   the
witnesses, when their statements are accepted as they are.  If it is found
that if the statements of the witnesses taken at their face value, do not
disclose any material sufficient to fulfill the necessary ingredients of the
offence of abetment to commit suicide, it would have to be held that
there is no sufficient ground for proceeding further against the accused.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR
CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION No.146 OF 2015
Dr. Dashrath Bhande,

V
State of Maharashtra,

        CORAM  :   S.B. SHUKRE, J.
        DATE      :       19thSEPTEMBER, 2016.
Citation: 2016 ALLMR(CRI)4394
Print Page

Sunday, 5 May 2013

Concept of instigation in criminal law




 Law does not require instigation to be in a particular form or that it should only be in words. The instigation may be by conduct. Whether there was instigation or not is a question to be decided on the facts of each case. It is not necessary in law for the prosecution to prove that the actual operative cause in the mind of the person abetting was instigation and nothing else, so long as there was instigation and the offence has been committed or the offence would have been committed if the person committing the act had the same knowledge and intention as the abettor. The instigation must be with reference to the thing that was done and not to the thing that was likely to have been done by the person who is instigated. 
It is only if this condition is fulfilled that a person can be guilty of abetment by instigation. 


Supreme Court of India
Arjun Singh vs State Of H.P. on 6 February, 2009
Print Page

Friday, 4 January 2013

A word uttered in a fit of anger or emotion without intending the consequences to actually follow, cannot be said to be instigation.

“Instigation is to goad, urge forward, provoke, incite or encourage to do “an act”. To satisfy the requirement of “instigation”, though it is not necessary that actual words must be used to that effect or what constitutes “instigation” must necessarily and specifically be suggestive of the consequence. Yet a reasonable certainty to incite the consequence must be capable of being spelt out. Where the accused had, by his acts or omission or by a continued course of conduct, created such circumstances that the deceased was left with no other option except to commit suicide, in which case, an “instigation” may have to be inferred. A word uttered in a fit of anger or emotion without intending the consequences to actually follow, cannot be said to be instigation.

Supreme Court of India
Praveen Pradhan vs State Of Uttranchal & Anr on 4 October, 2012

Bench: B.S. Chauhan, Fakkir Mohamed Kalifulla

Print Page