Showing posts with label abetment to commit suicide. Show all posts
Showing posts with label abetment to commit suicide. Show all posts

Saturday, 14 November 2026

Supreme Court: If Breakup or refusal to marriage Ends Up With Suicide, It Cannot Always Be Termed Abetment To Suicide

 That the death was by suicide is unequivocally

proved. It also happened in the house of the 1st appellant.

That the 1st appellant had a consensual relationship with the

deceased for the last few months, is also admitted by the first

informant. In that circumstance, it is not clear as to why the

first informant took away the deceased from the house of the

1st appellant. When a phone call came to the eldest sister

from the deceased, she did not do anything to avert the

suicide threatened. We are unable to find any instigation by

the accused/appellants to drive the deceased to death by

suicide. It was neither intended nor can it be said to be

abetment. At the worst, even if we fully believe what has

been stated by the 1st informant, there was a refusal of

marriage, which led to the woman committing suicide.

People react differently to situations and if a breakup ends up

with suicide, it cannot always be termed an abetment to

suicide. The refusal to marry was not with an intention to

drive the woman to death by suicide nor can knowledge be

attributed to the accused that on such refusal, she would

commit suicide. {Para 6}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. OF 2026

(Arising out of SLP (Crl.) No.7239 of 2026)

Chittibarika Chandra Shekar & Ors. Vs The State of Telangana & Anr. 

Dated: OCTOBER 05, 2026.
Print Page

Saturday, 26 September 2026

Supreme Court: Administrative directions, stern behavior, or official reprimands by a superior officer do not constitute abetment under Section 306 IPC unless there is clear mens rea and a direct, proximate act of instigation intended to drive the subordinate to commit suicide.

Further allegations against the Appellant principally arise out of the discharge of his official functions as the superior officer of the deceased. It has been alleged that on 22/23.03.2021 the Appellant reprimanded the deceased for watering of a water hole and engagement of a JCB driver for official work. However, ordinary administrative directions, disciplinary supervision, adverse remarks regarding official performance, or even stern behaviour on the part of a superior officer, however unpleasant they may have been perceived by the deceased, cannot, in the absence of additional material demonstrating a conscious intention to drive a subordinate to commit suicide, be elevated to the status of abetment Under Section 306 Indian Penal Code. As observed by this Court in Abhinav Mohan Delkar (supra), merely because the victim was continuously harassed and, at one stage, succumbed to the extreme act of taking his or her own life, cannot by itself lead to a finding of positive instigation constituting abetment. There must exist a proximate act amounting to instigation or intentional aid which creates such circumstances as would drive the victim to commit suicide. {Para 24}


25. We further find that the prosecution has failed to prima facie establish that the Appellant had any intention to instigate, aid or abet the deceased to commit suicide. The suicide notes undoubtedly reflect the anguish of the deceased, however, they do not disclose any act on the part of the Appellant from which the requisite mens rea can reasonably be inferred. There is also no material to suggest that the Appellant, by his words or conduct, intended to push the deceased into such a position that she was left with no reasonable alternative except to take her own life. No doubt, a young Range Forest Officer lost her life in an unfortunate incident. However, criminal liability Under Section 306 Indian Penal Code cannot rest upon the tragedy of the outcome alone; it must be founded upon the statutory ingredients of Section 306, which are absent in the present case.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 3874 of 2026 

Decided On: 14.08.2026

Vinod Shivakumar Vs. The State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

S.C. Sharma and N. Kotiswar Singh, JJ.

Author: S.C. Sharma, J.

Citation: 2026 INSC 867, MANU/SC/0898/2026.

Print Page

Sunday, 30 August 2026

Bombay HC: How to appreciate evidence in case of abetment of suicide of wife if evidence shows that everything was going on smoothly in her matrimonial home?

The evidence of complainant (PW 2) and other witnesses show that Mangalabai died within one and half months of the marriage. Out of this period, she lived in the house of her parents for more than 20 days. The evidence of complainant shows that even during the Mango season, she stayed with her parents for 10-15 days continuously. She was sent back to parents house as per custom on every occasion and the accused persons never prevented her from going to the house of her parents. All the customary rites and functions were arranged by the accused and also by the family of the complainant. The husband never avoided to visit the house of his in-laws. The message about the incident was given by the family of the accused to complainant immediately. They also approached police after the incident. It appears that in the early hours of 24.6.1992, they noticed that Mangalabai was dead. She had probably consumed poison on the night between 23rd and 24th. No neighbour of the accused is examined and all the witnesses examined are interested witnesses. These circumstances need to be kept in mind at the time of appreciation of evidence given by the complainant and his relatives. {Para 9}


10. The defence has not disputed that Mangalabai died due to consumption of insecticide. There is evidence of doctor and there is C.A. report to show that death took place due to insecticide. The evidence on record shows that accused persons do not own agricultural land and they are working as barber, having their hair cutting shop in the village. The evidence of complainant during cross examination and also the mention in the complaint show that accused No. 4 was living in Sillod due to his service. Thus, on the day of incident accused No. 4 was not there, but he was also involved in the case. No investigation was made by police to find out as to how and from where the deceased procured the insecticide, when accused are not agriculturists. These circumstances also need to be kept in mind at the time of appreciation of evidence of witnesses. Suggestions are given by the defence to prosecution witnesses that Mangalabai had no intention to cohabit with the accused for some reason and due to that she committed suicide. Though these suggestions are denied, the fact remains that for most of the period after the marriage Mangalabai was staying with her parents.


11. It was arranged marriage. The evidence of complainant and other witnesses show that the accused had seen the deceased atleast twice and the husband had approved her for marriage. It is not the case of complainant that at the time of settlement of marriage, something was demanded by giving excuse that Mangalabai was black in complexion or her tooth were not properly arranged and she was looking ugly. As it was arranged marriage and Mangalabai was approved by Ganesh, it does not look probable that immediately after the marriage, accused Ganesh started saying that she was not liking Mangalabai. On the contrary, Ganesh took her to religious places after the marriage and all the ceremonies were performed and attended by Ganesh. It is not version of complainant that Ganesh had directly expressed to him that he was not liking Mangalabai. 

12. In any case, the story given by the interested witnesses do not appear to be probable in nature. Accused No. 3 was already having a colour T.V. set in his house. As it was settled marriage and accused No. 3 had approved the deceased for marriage, it does not look probable that such demand was made subsequent to marriage. If the complainant and his family had really promised to meet the demand at Diwali festival, there was no reason for the accused to give ill-treatment to the deceased. In any case, the stay of the deceased in the house of the accused was so short that there was no possibility of giving ill-treatment to the deceased as defined under section 498-A of I.P.C. It is already discussed that investigation was not made to find out as to how the deceased procured the bottle of insecticide. The evidence of Police Officer shows that after registration of A.D., some statements were recorded. Those statements were not brought before the Court. The neighbours of the accused are not examined. It appears that the trial Court had given much emphasis on so called conduct. The death took place in the night time and probably insecticide was consumed in the night time by deceased. Thus, there was no opportunity for the accused to know about the consumption of the insecticide. In view of all the circumstances, the appellate Court has acquitted the respondents. This Court sees no reason to interfere in the decision given by the first appellate Court. 

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Criminal Appeal No. 469 of 2000

Decided On: 28.01.2013

The State of Maharashtra Vs. Ramrao and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

T.V. Nalawade, J.

Citation: 2013 ALL M R (Cri) 3454,MANU/MH/1858/2013.

Print Page

Bombay HC: Whether the court can draw presumption U/S 113A of evidence Act, if there is no complaint of ill-treatment after resumption of co-habitation?

 It is the submission of learned senior counsel for the appellant that after resumption of co-habitation till unfortunate incident of drowning, there is no evidence to show that during this period of 3 months the deceased was subjected to cruelty except a bald statement of PW1 Ramchandra Bawane.


19. Though Exhibit 41 dated 10.5.1995 is available on record, which shows that on 10.3.1993 appellant Anandrao poured kerosene on deceased Sangeeta. According to the prosecution, it is under the signature of deceased Sangeeta. The said report was addressed to the Kothari Police Station. However, record shows that actually the report was not lodged with the Kothari Police Station. Said report Exhibit 41 is coming on record during the course of investigation by PW7 Subhash Shinde. His evidence shows that during inquiry, PW1 first informant Ramchandra handed over copy of Exhibit 41 to him. Learned Judge of the Court below, in my view, has rightly discarded the said document since PW1 first informant Ramchandra is totally silent about said report in his FIR lodged against the appellant. and also evidence of PW1 Ramchandra does not have any reference about same.


20. PW1 first informant Ramchandra has admitted that no report was lodged with the police after resumption of co-habitation. Non-filing of report after resumption of cohabitation has its own importance. Exhibit 35 is not only signed by appellant Anandrao, deceased Sangeeta, and pancha witnesses but signed by PW1 first informant Ramchandra also. Exhibit 35 was required to be executed because according to the prosecution, deceased Sangeeta was subjected to cruelty and only on execution of Exhibit 35 deceased was allowed to have co-habitation with appellant Anandrao.


Had there was any ill-treatment after execution of Exhibit 35 and prior to incident of drowning, it would have been a natural reaction on the part of PW1 Ramchandra to report the matter to the police or at least to Panchayat before whom Exhibit 35 was executed to point out them that in spite of execution of Exhibit 35, still appellant Anandrao is persistent in committing ill-treatment to deceased Sangeeta. Nothing such has happened. In my view, therefore, importance cannot be attached to bald statement made during the course of recording of evidence of PW1 first informant Ramchandra that after execution of Exhibit 35 ill-treatment continued. Therefore, I reject the evidence of PW1 first informant Ramchandra that there used to be ill-treatment even after execution of document Exhibit 35.


21. It is the obligation on the part of the prosecution to prove that deceased Sangeeta was subjected to cruelty within the meaning of Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code. On such proof only, the prosecution can press into service statutory presumption as available to it under Section 113A of the Evidence Act. In absence of proof of cruelty, merely because deceased Sangeeta met with an unnatural death within a span of 2 years of her marriage, ipso facto the prosecution cannot take recourse to Section 113A of the Evidence Act. Re-appreciation of the prosecution evidences shows that there was no ill-treatment after resumption of co-habitation after execution of document Exhibit 35 till the date of unfortunate incident on 20.5.1995. 

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Criminal Appeal No. 278 of 2001

Decided On: 11.07.2017

Anandrao Vs. The State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

V.M. Deshpande, J.

Citation: 2017 ALL M R (Cri) 3436,MANU/MH/1454/2017.
Print Page

Bombay HC: Non disclosure of ill treatment to wife by her family members to independent witness prior to her death whether fatal U/S 306 of IPC?

It may be seen that there is no independent witness, to whom any of the family members of the victim had ever reported before her death that, the victim was subjected to ill-treatment. All the allegations about ill-treatment came after the unfortunate incident. Though the witnesses are parents and siblings of the victim, they speak in different voices. There is no unanimity amongst them as to what was the cause of the victim's ill-treatment and how it was meted out. It, therefore, seems that the entire story about ill-treatment is afterthought. The victim did not have any issue. {Para 13}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Criminal Appeal No. 361 of 1996

Decided On: 13.01.2006

Pandurang Vs. State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

R.C. Chavan, J.

Citation: 2006 ALL M R (Cri) 975, MANU/MH/0859/2006.
Print Page

Saturday, 22 August 2026

Supreme Court: Merely Lodging A False FIR Is Not Abetment Of Suicide

 In our view, lodging an FIR, even if

it is false, against a person, per se, does

not amount to instigating that person to

commit suicide. Besides, here the FIR was

lodged by the deceased’s wife who had

suffered injuries. Otherwise also, every

individual has a right to take recourse to

appropriate proceedings under law to protect

his or her rights. Therefore, if a person

sets the criminal justice delivery system in

motion, he cannot be held liable for

abetment to commit suicide, if the person

against whom proceedings were initiated

commits suicide. {Para 22}

23. Admittedly, the appellant(s) were

residing separate from the deceased and,

therefore, they cannot be considered having

such an overbearing influence over the

deceased that they could instigate him, or

drive him, to commit suicide.

24. While assessing whether a prima facie

case of abetment to commit suicide is made

out or not, the court must not merely

consider the allegations in the suicide note

but also the surrounding facts of the case.

Merely because a dejected husband, or lover,

out of frustration, ends his life and puts

the blame on the accused, in his suicide

note, is not enough to conclude that a prima

facie case is made out against those who are

blamed. The court would have to consider

whether the conduct of the accused

complained of in ordinary circumstances

would have driven an ordinary person, not an

over sensitive person, to take that drastic

step to end his life.

 REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

Criminal Appeal No(s). /2026

SLP (Crl.) No(s). 18705/2025

PATEL JOSHNABEN PRAVINKUMAR PATEL & ORS. Vs STATE OF GUJARAT & ANR.

Citation: 2026 INSC 886

Dated: August 18, 2026

Print Page

Saturday, 21 March 2026

Supreme Court: Under which circumstances, Creditor making phone call to the debtor for return of his money will not amount to abetment to Suicide?

The only basis on which the charge-sheet has been

laid against the accused is the suicide note

coupled with the call detail records which indicate

that 40 phone calls were made by the appellant to

the deceased in last six months. As far as the

suicide note is concerned, we find that it lacks

material particulars regarding the nature of those

threats and the time and place when those threats

were extended. Moreover, the suicide note indicts

as many as 9 accused without specifying the role of

any one of them. It is not the case of the

prosecution that all accused belong to one family

or were harassing the deceased as a group. Further,

the deceased has painted all creditors with one

brush. Therefore, a trial based on such a suicide

note would be a futile exercise. Besides, if a

creditor makes a phone call to the debtor for

return of his money that being a lawful act, it

cannot on its own constitute a ground to prosecute

the creditor. Moreover, the deceased may have

committed suicide on account of depression for not

being able to clear of the debt.

14. In such circumstances, particularly when

there is no material to indicate that the deceased

was beaten or physically assaulted to return the

dues, we are of the view that there is hardly any

material on basis whereof it could be inferred that

the appellant by demanding his dues abetted

commission of suicide by the deceased. In our view,

therefore, the continuance of the proceedings

against the appellant would be a futile exercise

and would amount to abuse of the process of the

Court. Hence, to secure the ends of justice, it is

necessary that the same be quashed.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

Criminal Appeal No(s). /2026

SLP (Crl.) No(s). 4644/2025

DHIRUBHAI NANJIBHAI PATEL LOTWALA  Vs STATE OF GUJARAT & ANR. 

Dated: March 10, 2026

Print Page

Monday, 20 January 2025

Supreme Court: Abetment Of Suicide' Offence Can't Be Invoked Only To Assuage Feelings Of Family

Section 306 IPC appears to be casually and too readily resorted to by the police. While the persons involved in genuine cases where the threshold is met should not be spared, the provision should not be deployed against individuals, only to assuage the immediate feelings of the distraught family of the deceased. The conduct of the proposed accused and the deceased, their interactions and conversations preceding the unfortunate death of the deceased should be approached from a practical point of view and not divorced from day-to-day realities of life. Hyperboles employed in exchanges should not, without anything more, be glorified as an instigation to commit suicide. It is time the investigating agencies are sensitised to the law laid down by this Court under Section 306 so that persons are not subjected to the abuse of process of a totally untenable prosecution. The trial courts also should exercise great caution and circumspection and should not adopt a play it safe syndrome by mechanically framing charges, even if the investigating agencies in a given case have shown utter disregard for the ingredients of Section 306.

 REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 221 OF 2025

(@ SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CRL.) NO. 11868 OF 2023)

MAHENDRA AWASE  Vs  THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH 

Author: K.V. Viswanathan, J.

Dated: 17th January, 2025.

Citation:2025 INSC 76.
Print Page

Wednesday, 4 December 2024

Whether the court can quash prosecution against accused for an offence U/S 306 of IPC if no material is available him in chargesheet regarding that offence?

In the present case, at the outset, we must note that the

Applicant, a Judicial Officer, was never involved in the pending

lis, as the suit property was purchased by his brother

exclusively and only he was party to the litigation. There is no

reason for the deceased to have implicated the Applicant, as he

was not connected with the dispute at all. The material in the

charge-sheet in form of statements implicating the Applicant,

are too far fetched and definitely fall short of any instigation/

incitement and a bare reference to his presence in Miraj in the

month of May, where he is alleged to have threatened the

deceased and asked him to vacate the subject property is not

sufficient to attract instigation/incitement, as the offence is

registered on 24/06/2016. In any case, even it is not the

allegation of the prosecution that the Applicant abetted the

suicide by instigating or inciting the deceased in any manner,

as abetment involves a mental process of instigating a person

or intentionally aiding a person in doing of a thing and without

a positive act on part of the Applicant to instigate or aid in

commission of suicide by the deceased, he cannot be convicted

for an offence punishable under Section 306 of IPC.

In order to attract the offence under Section 306, clear

mens rea to commit the offence has to be established, as it

requires active/direct act, leading the deceased to commit

suicide left with no other option, but in the present case, the

material in the charge-sheet falls short of proving the

ingredients of Section 306 and, hence, in our view, by

exercising the inherent power conferred under Section 482,

the purpose of it being to prevent the abuse of process or to

secure the ends of justice, we deem it appropriate to safeguard

the interest of the Applicant.

In absence of we exercising the power, the Applicant will

have to unnecessarily face the rigmarole of trial, which

ultimately would result in acquittal, as no material in the

charge-sheet collected by the prosecution attract the

ingredients of Section 306 of IPC and we would be failing in

discharge of our duty, if we do not step in and save the

Applicant from undergoing the long drawn process of trial, as

the material in the charge-sheet through close scrutiny, do not

in any manner, establish the ingredients of abetment of suicide

under Section 306 of IPC against him.

For the reasons recorded above, we are satisfied that

human liberty, which is the most cherished constitutional

value, must be protected by us, by exercising the inherent

power conferred under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure

Code. {Para 20}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO.959 OF 2016

WITH

INTERIM APPLICATION NO.2060 OF 2024

Nasirhusen Mohiddin Jamadar Vs  The State of Maharashtra & Anr. 

CORAM: BHARATI DANGRE & MANJUSHA DESHPANDE, JJ.

 DATED : 18 th  NOVEMBER, 2024

ORDER (PER BHARATI DANGRE, J.) :-

Citation: 2024:BHC-AS:45637-DB.
Print Page

Sunday, 21 November 2021

Whether an offence of abetment to commit suicide is made out against accused if there was quarrel on the day of suicide?

 Now so far as the offence under Section 306 IPC is concerned, in a case where if any person instigates other person to commit suicide and as a result of such instigation the other person commits suicide, the person causing the instigation is liable to be punished for the offence under Section 306 IPC for abetting the commission of suicide. Therefore, in order to bring a case within the provision of Section 306 IPC, there must be a case of suicide and in the commission of the said offence, the person who is said to have abetted the commission of suicide must have played an active role by an act of instigating or by doing a certain act to facilitate the commission of suicide. As observed and held by this Court in the case of Amalendu Pal (supra), mere harassment without any positive action on the part of the accused proximate to the time of occurrence which led to the suicide would not amount to an offence under Section 306 IPC.


9.1 Abetment by a person is when a person instigates another to do something. Instigation can be inferred where the accused had, by his acts or omission created such circumstances that the deceased was left with no other option except to commit suicide. In the instant case, the allegation against the appellant is that there was a quarrel on the day of occurrence. There is no other material on record which indicates abetment. There is no material on record that the appellant-accused played an active role by an act of instigating the deceased to facilitate the commission of suicide. On the contrary, in the present case, even the appellant-accused also tried to commit suicide and consumed pesticide. Under the circumstances and in the facts and circumstances of the case and there is no other material on record which indicates abetment, both the High Court as well as the learned trial Court have committed an error in convicting the accused for the offence under Section 306 IPC.

Supreme Court

JUSTICE M.R. Shah JUSTICE Aniruddha Bose

Velladurai Vs. State represented by the Inspector of Police

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 953 OF 2021

14th September 2021


Author: M.R. SHAH, J.

Citation: 2021 ALL SCR (ONLINE) 441

Print Page

Tuesday, 15 September 2020

Whether the bank manager refusing to sanction loan can be held guilty for abetment of suicide?

Law is well crystallized by various pronouncements of
the Honourable Apex Court and of this Court. It would be useful
to have a reference of few cases of the Honourable Apex Court
without detailing facts in those cases:

(1) Sanju alias Sanjay Singh Sengar vs. State of
Madhya Pradesh, reported at 2002(3) Cri.L.J.
2796,
(2) Madan Mohan Singh vs. State of Gujarat and
anr, reported at 2010 ALL MR (Cri) 3245 (SC).
13. One of leading case on this issue is, Dilip s/o Ramrao
ALL MR (Cri) 4328, this Court discussed in detail various
pronouncements of the Honourable Apex Court. The ratio of the
said is that it is incumbent upon prosecution to at least show prima
facie case that accused had an intention to aid or instigate or abet
deceased to commit suicide. In the absence of availability of such
material, the accused cannot be compelled to face trial for the
offence punishable under Section 306 of the Indian Penal Code.
14. Admittedly, in this case, the Loan Account of the
complainant was showing outstanding to the tune of
Rs.2,32,689/-. The said aspect is not denied by the prosecution.
Sudhir Gawande, the deceased, was not having any loan
outstanding in his name. Even, according to the prosecution,
Sudhir Gawande, the deceased, went to the Bank of Maharashtra,
Morshi Branch, District Amravati for loan. If previous loan amount
is outstanding and if the applicant, who is Branch Manager of the
said Bank, is refusing to grant any further loan, can be said as act
of a vigilant and prudent banker and if he is not granting any
further loan, it cannot be termed that by such act he instigated
and/or abetted the person to commit suicide.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY,
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR
CRIMINAL APPLICATION (APL) NO.63 OF 2016

Santoshkumar Raj Kishor Prasad Singh, Vs  The State of Maharashtra 

CORAM : V.M.DESHPANDE, &
ANIL S.KILOR, JJ.
DATE : SEPTEMBER 9, 2020.

ORAL JUDGMENT (Per : V.M.Deshpande, J.)
Print Page

Wednesday, 2 September 2020

Whether court can convict father-in-law for offence U/S 202 of IPC if he fails to inform the authorities about the suicide of daughter-in-law?

The learned Counsel for the respondent State of Rajasthan, however, submitted that the accused would atleast be liable of having committed other offences. It may be noted that the question whether they would be liable under Section 498-A or 304-B does not arise for consideration inasmuch as these provisions were not on the statute on the day of occurrence. However, A 1 was atleast under an obligation to give information about the death of the deceased since the same was unnatural. Assuming that the prosecution has not positively proved that the death was homicidal yet from the medical evidence it is clear that it was not a natural death and consequently the death should atleast be noted as one of suicide. Even in the case of suicide an offence of abetment punishable under Section 306 is inherent. There- fore, even in the case of a suicide there is an obligation on the person, who knows or has reason to believe that such a suicidal death has occurred , to give information. In Kalidas Achamma v. The State of A.P., S.H.O. Karimnagar. I Town P.S. [1987] 2 ALT 937 it was observed as under:

In the case of every suicide abetment is inherent. Whether ultimately it is proved or not, it is a different aspect. Abetment of suicide is an offence punishable under Section 306 IPC and therefore whenever a case of suicide is there, the body cannot be disposed of without informing the Police and further as provided under Section 174 Cr. PC the Police have to hold an inquest since it is an unnatural death.
In the instant case A 1, who reached his house on 18.3.82 knowing fully well that the deceased had already died, informed P.W. 8 that the deceased was in a serious condition. Likewise he informed P.W. 12 on telephone without disclosing that the deceased was already dead. However, when P.W. 6, the brother of the deceased, came to the house where the dead body was lying, A 1 told him that the body would be cremated. To the same effect is the evidence of P.W. 13. P.W. 6, the brother of the deceased, on his own went and gave a report to the police. It can thus be seen that A 1 intentionally omitted to give the information in respect of the death of the deceased which he was legally bound to give. Section 202 1. P. C. is in the following terms:

202. Intentional omission to give information of offence by person bound to inform-Whoever, knowing or having reason to believe that an offence has been committed, intentionally omits to give any information respecting that offence which he is legally bound to give, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to six months, or with fine, or with both.

This Section punishes the illegal omission of those who under law are bound to give information in respect of an offence which he is legally bound to give particularly being the head of the family. Under this provision it is necessary for the prosecution to prove (1) that the accused had knowledge or reason to believe that some offence had been committed (2) that the accused had intentionally omitted to give information respecting that offence and (3) that the accused was legally bound to give that information. Shri R.K. Jain, however, relied on a judgment of this Court in Harishchandrasing Sajjansingh Rathod and Another v. State of Gujarat MANU/SC/0114/1979 : 1979CriLJ1025 and contended that the word "Whoever" occurring in the opening part of the Section refers to a person other then the offender and has no application to the person who is alleged to have committed the principal offence. In that case the accused were tried for offences punishable under Sections 331 and 304 read with Section 34 IPC in respect of the death of the deceased and were acquitted.-On appeal by the State the High Court, however, convicted them under Section 202 IPC A Bench of this Court while reversing the order of High Court observed thus:

We have gone through the entire evidence bearing on the aforesaid offence under Section 202 but have not been able to discern anything therein which may go to establish the aforesaid ingredients of the offence under Section 202 of the Penal Code. The offence in respect of which the appellants were indicted viz. having intentionally omitted to give information respecting an offence which he is legally bound to give not having been established, the appellants could not have been convicted under Section 202 of the Penal Code. It is well settled that in a prosecution under Section 202 of the Penal Code, it is necessary for the prosecution to establish the main offence before making a person liable under this section. The offence under Section 304 (Part II) and the one under Section 331 of the Penal Code not having been established on account of several infirmities it is difficult to sustain the conviction of the appellants under Section 202 of the Penal Code. The High Court has also missed to notice that the word 'whoever' occurring at the opening part of Section 202 of the Penal Code refers to a person other than the offender and has no application to the person who is alleged to have committed the principal offence. This is so because there is no law which casts a duty on a criminal to give information which would incriminate himself That apart the aforementioned ingredients of the offence under Section 202 of the Penal Code do not appear to have been made out against the prosecution. There is not an iota of evidence to show that the appellants knew or had reason to believe that the aforesaid main offences had been committed.
(emphasis supplied)

19. From these observations it is clear that there was no evidence to show that the accused therein knew or had reason to believe that the said offences have been committed and on the other hand they were made principal offenders. In such a situation the ingredients of Section 202 can not be said to have been made out. It is in this context that the meaning of the word "whoever" has been considered. But in the instant case A 1 returned to his house where the dead body was lying on 18.3.82 and the circumstances clearly go to show that he had knowledge that the deceased died of an unnatural death. Therefore he had knowledge or atleast had reason to believe that an offence had been committed even if, at that stage, he thought that it was only a suicide. Therefore it was his bounden duty particularly as head of the family to inform the authorities. He omitted to do so. On the other hand, he went about telling that the deceased was still alive and her condition was serious. But when P.W. 6, the brother of the deceased, came to the house and enquired, A 1 told him that the body would be cremated and he intended to do so without informing the authorities. Therefore all the ingredients of Section 202 are made out against him and he clearly committed the offence punishable under this Section at that stage. The fact that he himself was made an accused in other offences subsequently does not absolve him of his complicity in respect of the offence punishable under Section 202 IPC So far A 2 is concerned, he came to the house only after the investigation commenced. Therefore his case stands on a different footing. In the result the convictions and sentences awarded against A 1 and A 2 l are set aside. A 1, however, is convicted under Section 202 IPC and sentenced to undergo six months' R.I. The appeal is disposed of accordingly.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 303 of 1984

Decided On: 28.08.1991

Bhagwan Swarup  Vs. State of Rajasthan
Print Page

Thursday, 6 August 2020

Whether court can convict accused for an offence U/S 306 of IPC if he was charged under S 498A and 304B of IPC?

 Both the Courts below have found the husband guilty of cruel treatment of his wife and as a result the wife committed suicide within seven years of their marriage. On such evidence the presumption which arises under Section 113A of the Evidence Act is that the husband abetted the suicide. The word "cruelty" as mentioned in the Explanation below Section 113A of the Evidence act has been given the same meaning as contained in the Explanation below Section 498A, IPC. On the fact found, 'the wilful' conduct of the husband in forcing the deceased to part with her land which she had received in marriage as "stridhana" and for that purpose concealing her postal mail was so cruel that she was driven to commit suicide. A case of conviction and sentence of accused No. 1 under Section 306, IPC has thus clearly been made out even though his acquittal for commission of the offence of 'dowry death' punishable under Section 304B, IPC is not found liable to be disturbed.

20. The learned counsel for the accused has argued that in the absence of a charge framed against the accused under Section 306 IPC, the accused cannot be convicted under the said Section.

21. From the record we find that although a charge specifically under Section 306 IPC was not framed but all facts and ingredients constituting that offence were mentioned in the Statement of Charges framed under Section 498A and Section 304B of IPC. 

22. Mere omission or defect in framing charge does not disable the Criminal Court from convicting the accused for the offence which is found to have been proved on the evidence on record. The Code of Criminal procedure has ample provisions to meet a situation like the one before us. From the Statement of Charge framed under Section 304B and in the Alternative Section 498A, IPC (as quoted above) it is clear that all facts and ingredients for framing charge for offence under Section 306, IPC existed in the case. The mere omission on the part of the trial Judge to mention of Section 306, IPC with 498A, IPC does not preclude the Court from convicting the accused for the said offence when found proved. In the alternate charge framed under Section 498A of IPC, it has been clearly mentioned that the accused subjected the deceased to such cruelty and harassment as to drive her to commit suicide. The provisions of Section 221 of Cr.P.C. take care of such a situation and safeguard the powers of the criminal court to convict an accused for an offence with which he is not charged although on facts found in evidence, he could have been charged for such offence.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Appeal (crl.) 1457 of 1995

Decided On: 25.10.2002

 K. Prema S. Rao  Vs.  Yadla Srinivasa Rao and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
M.B. Shah, K.G. Balakrishnan and D.M. Dharmadhikari, JJ.

Citation: MANU/SC/0890/2002,(2003) 1 SCC 217
Print Page

Tuesday, 23 June 2020

Whether accused can be prosecuted for abetment of suicide if suicide note bears his name?

Death by commission of suicide must have been the desired object of the abettors; and with that in view they must have instigated, goaded, urged or encouraged the victim in commission of suicide. The instigation may be by provoking or inciting the person committing suicide and this instigation may be gathered by positive acts done by the abettors or by omission in the doing of a thing. Thus, the acts or omission committed by the abettors immediately before the commission of suicide are vital. The mere fact that certain persons have been named in the suicidal note to be responsible for his death is not by itself a ground to fasten one with the charge of abetment. In terms of Section 107, it must prima facie appear to hold that the person named in the suicide note to be responsible for commission of suicide has abetted in the act. The act for conduct of the accused, even if there may be any, however, insulting and abusive those may be, will not by themselves suffice to constitute abetment of commission of suicide, unless those are reasonably capable of suggesting that the accused intended by such acts consequence of suicide.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)


Criminal Writ Petition No. 164 of 2018



Decided On: 30.01.2019



Gulab   Vs.  The State of Maharashtra and Ors.



Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

S.S. Shinde and R.G. Avachat, JJ.

Print Page

Sunday, 12 January 2020

Whether father can be held guilty for abetment of suicide of son if father is drunkard?

 In Father Peter Paul Antony Vs. State of Maharashtra,
reported in 2014 ALL MR (Cri) 3429, in paragraph nos. 20 and
21, this Court observed thus:
“20. In the light of above facts and settled legal
position, it is noted that even if a person would
commit suicide because of certain acts of the accused,

the accused cannot be said to have committed
abetment of suicide by the deceased unless the
accused would intend, while causing such acts to the
victim, that he/she should commit suicide. As such, it
is necessary for the prosecution to establish that by his
acts, the applicant/accused could reasonably foresee
that because of his conduct, the victim was almost
certain or at least, quite likely to commit suicide.
Unless this is established, a person cannot be charged
of having abetted commission of suicide, even if,
suicide has been committed as a result of some of the
acts committed by the accused.
In the case of Sanju (supra), it is seen that
even in the case where the accused had uttered words
such as "go and die" in abusive and humiliating
language which, allegedly, led to committing of
suicide, it was held that it would not amount to
instigation and consequently, there would be no
offence of abetment of suicide.
21. In the application on hand, there is
absolutely no evidence to establish that on the day of
incident or immediately prior to the deceased
committing suicide, applicant has instigated or
abetted deceased to commit the same. In that view of
the matter, applicant cannot be attributed the
requisite mens rea so as to hold him guilty as abettor.
This appears to be fundamental defect in the case of
prosecution and it does not spell out any offence
punishable under Section 305 of Indian Penal Code.
19. Thus, I am of the view that the deceased was not
denied any basic amenities to his life by the appellant. Further,

though it is the case of the prosecution that the deceased used to
prosecute his studies, there is nothing brought on record to show
that at any point of time, the deceased was declared unsuccessful
in any of his academic year. In the light of evidence of Hemant
(PW4) and Pooja (PW2), it is clear that there was no objection for
the deceased even to withdraw huge amounts from the account of
appellant by using ATM though the deceased, who was only in the
9th standard. Not only that, this evidence would show that the
deceased was also permitted to retain an amount of Rs.1,000/-
and looking to his age, in my view, it is a very huge amount. The
admitted position also speaks that the mother of the deceased was
a psychic patient having nothing to do with drinking of the
appellant. Therefore, he used to be always under depressed
condition. Different persons may react differently to the same
situation. Therefore, merely because the deceased by writing a
note mentioning about the drinking habit of his father and
committed suicide, in my view, it cannot be treated as an
abetment, especially when the prosecution evidence falls short to
show that there used to be ill treatment at the hands of the
appellant under the influence of liquor to the deceased so as to
drive the deceased to take the extreme step of his life.

In my view, the learned Judge of the Court below has
swayed away with the fact that the deceased boy was required to
commit suicide for an admitted position that the appellant was a
drunkard. Merely drinking can never be an abetment for a person
to commit suicide.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH AT NAGPUR
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.391/2015

Ramrao Kisan Rathod, Vs State of Maharashtra 

CORAM:- V. M. DESHPANDE, J.
DATED :- 04.01.2020.
Print Page

Saturday, 23 March 2019

Whether higher officer can be held guilty for abetment of suicide if he taking extra work from employee after office hours?

 In the context of aforesaid legal positions, this court is of

the view that alleged act of mis-behaviour and taking extra work
after the office hours from the deceased cannot be equated into
abetting the deceased to commit suicide. If any higher officer
compels his sub-ordinate to do extra work which is unbearable,
then he has other options and it cannot be said that he had no
other option except to commit suicide. Under these
circumstances, the appellant cannot be held responsible for
abetting the deceased to commit suicide.
High Court of Madhya Pradesh: Bench at Indore
Single Bench: Hon'ble Shri Justice S.K. Awasthi
Cr.A. No.4509/2018

Satendra Jha vs. State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors.

(Passed on 06/03/2019)
Print Page

Sunday, 3 March 2019

Whether slapping husband in presence of others amounts to instigation to commit suicide?


 In the present case, the allegation against the petitioner is that she had slapped the deceased 3 days prior to the deceased committing suicide. There is nothing to suggest that the petitioner instigated, conspired or aided in commission of suicide by the deceased. There is no allegation against the petitioner that the petitioner instigated or exhorted the deceased to commit suicide.
18. The allegation is that the petitioner slapped the deceased in presence of others. Even if one were to consider the incident of alleged slapping as instigation then one has to keep in mind that the alleged conduct should be such as to drive any normal prudent person into committing suicide. Mere act of slapping the husband in presence of others would not under normal circumstances instigate a husband to commit suicide.
19. Further, alleged suicide note relied on by the prosecution does not refer to any incident of slapping. On the other hand, the suicide note alleges that the father of the petitioner had not revealed about the deformity in the back of the petitioner on account of which the deceased's life had become a joke. The suicide note alleges that the accused had made allegations about the relationship between the deceased and his sister-in-law (brother's wife) and had also alleged that the deceased's brother was mentally unsound. The suicide note does not make any reference to any incident of slapping.

In the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi
(Before Sanjeev Sachdeva, J.)

Shikha Gupta v. State (GNCT of Delhi) .

Crl. Rev. P. 330/2017
Decided on January 8, 2019,
Citation: 2019 SCC OnLine Del 6394
Print Page

Sunday, 16 December 2018

Whether a woman can be prosecuted for abetment of suicide of her husband if she has phone sex with friend of husband?


The learned Senior Counsel Mr.Mundargi has made out a
point that this communication was secretly done. It is true that this
fact is crucial and has direct bearing on deciding whether this Act
can be called as an abetment. Undoubtedly, this communication
was clandestinely done with a view that it should not be known to
the deceased. This was very private and in a way immoral
behaviour of the accused. Such phone sex or chatting is not an
adultery falling under the definition of adultery under section 13(1)
of Hindu Marriage Act, which expressly states that adultery means
having voluntary sexual intercourse with person other than spouse.
Thus, when the Indian Penal Code or Hindu Marriage Act were
enacted in those days, such kind of sexual intercourse by SMSs
was never imagined by the law makers. It is not an adultery but
these are instances of infidelity and unfaithfulness, which is not
expected when the marriage is solemnised. Such acts of infidelity
are bound to cause emotional trauma to the spouse, who may
react by taking extreme step like suicide. Thus, in the
circumstances like a case in hand, the spouse who indulges into
such activity is responsible for reaction of the other spouse.

18. Thus, when one partner does such activity clandestinely,
then it pre-supposes guilty mind. However, such an act or guilty
mind cannot be substituted for mens rea which is the requirement
for abetment under section 107 of the Indian Penal Code. The
intention of the partner who is engaged into such phone sex or
causing ill-treatment should be, that the other spouse should finish
his or her life. For example, if at all, the applicant/accused would
have indulged into phone sex deliberately disclosing this
repeatedly to the deceased albeit warning given by the deceased
of discontinuing such activity, it would have been considered a
planned harassment to the deceased and therefore, such
repeated, deliberate sexual SMSs would have manifested the
intention to drive the victim to the decision of committing suicide.
The guilty mind is to be necessarily linked with infidelity but not
abetment to commit suicide. It is not the case of the prosecution
in the present case. No such material is produced on record in the
present case. To commit suicide is a very unfortunate reaction of
the accused, who was deeply hurt. It was beyond his capacity to
bear such behaviour of his wife. However, this also cannot be said
that the applicant abetted the deceased to commit suicide.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL REVISION APPLICATION NO.57 OF 2018
WITH
CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO.435 OF 2018
IN
CRIMINAL REVISION APPL
ICATION NO.57 OF 2018

Anagha Hitesh Arya Vs. The State of Maharashtra 

CORAM: Mrs.MRIDULA BHATKAR, J.

Dated: DECEMBER 14, 2018

Print Page

Wednesday, 23 May 2018

SHORT NOTES ON MURDER,CULPABLE HOMICIDE AND SUICIDE

The first offence against human life is culpable homicide. The word 'Homicide' comes from latin word 'homa' means man and 'cide' means cut. Killing of a human being by another human being is homicide.
Kinds if homicide- Homicide is either lawful or unlawful. Lawful homicide includes cases falling under the general exceptions that is S 76 to S 106.

Read important judgments on Murder.
Click here
S 299 of IPC defines culpable homicide as,Whoever causes death,
  1. with intention of causing death,
  2. with intention of causing such bodily injury as is likely to cause death.
  3. With knowledge that he is likely by such act to cause death.
    Explanation to S 299 of IPC.
Print Page

Friday, 29 December 2017

Whether offence U/S 498A of IPC is made out if husband is having extra-marital relationship?

True it is, there is some evidence about the illicit relationship and even if the same is proven, we are of the considered opinion that cruelty, as envisaged under the first limb of Section 498A Indian Penal Code would not get attracted. It would be difficult to hold that the mental cruelty was of such a degree that it would drive the wife to commit suicide. Mere extra-marital relationship, even if proved, would be illegal and immoral, as has been said in Pinakin Mahipatray Rawal (supra), but it would take a different character if the prosecution brings some evidence on record to show that the accused had conducted in such a manner to drive the wife to commit suicide. In the instant case, the accused may have been involved in an illicit relationship with the Appellant No. 4, but in the absence of some other acceptable evidence on record that can establish such high degree of mental cruelty, the Explanation to Section 498-A which includes cruelty to drive a woman to commit suicide, would not be attracted.


16. The concept of mental cruelty depends upon the milieu and the strata from which the persons come from and definitely has an individualistic perception regard being had to one's endurance and sensitivity. It is difficult to generalize but certainly it can be appreciated in a set of established facts. Extra-marital relationship, per se, or as such would not come within the ambit of Section 498-A Indian Penal Code. It would be an illegal or immoral act, but other ingredients are to be brought home so that it would constitute a criminal offence. There is no denial of the fact that the cruelty need not be physical but a mental torture or abnormal behaviour that amounts to cruelty or harassment in a given case. It will depend upon the facts of the said case. To explicate, solely because the husband is involved in an extra-marital relationship and there is some suspicion in the mind of wife, that cannot be regarded as mental cruelty which would attract mental cruelty for satisfying the ingredients of Section 306 Indian Penal Code.



IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA


Criminal Appeal Nos. 1138-1139 of 2016 (Arising out of S.L.P. (Crl.) Nos. 5928-5929 of 2016)


Decided On: 22.11.2016


K.V. Prakash Babu Vs. State of Karnataka
Print Page