Showing posts with label liquidated damages. Show all posts
Showing posts with label liquidated damages. Show all posts

Sunday, 7 June 2026

Supreme Court on Liquidated Damages: Proof of Actual Loss is not Always Necessary

 Further, when the agreement categorically stipulated timelines for the commencement and completion of the construction and the consequences that were to follow thereupon, it was not necessary for the owners to adduce evidence separately in proof of the actual damage suffered by them owing to the breach of the agreement on the part of the builder. The very fact that the contractual Clause itself envisioned payment of penalty on a day-to-day basis for the delayed period indicated that the damage suffered by the owners was implicit therein. The Division Bench was, therefore, in error in holding that the owners would be disentitled to compensation on the ground that they failed to adduce evidence separately, in proof of having suffered damage or loss. This conclusion was opposed to the explicit covenant in the agreement and cannot be accepted. Therefore, non-suiting of the owners' claim on that ground by the Division Bench was manifestly erroneous and cannot be sustained. {Para 19}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 8192 and 8193 of 2026 

Decided On: 26.05.2026

Bhupesh Bhayana and Ors. Vs. Kunal Seth and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

P.V. Sanjay Kumar and K. Vinod Chandran, JJ.

Author: P.V. Sanjay Kumar, J.

Citation: 2026 INSC 546,MANU/SC/0544/2026

Print Page

Sunday, 29 October 2023

๐—œ๐—ณ ๐—ป๐—ผ ๐—น๐—ผ๐˜€๐˜€ ๐—ฐ๐—ฎ๐˜‚๐˜€๐—ฒ๐—ฑ ๐˜๐—ผ ๐˜๐—ต๐—ฒ ๐—–๐—น๐—ฎ๐—ถ๐—บ๐—ฎ๐—ป๐˜, ๐—น๐—ถ๐—พ๐˜‚๐—ถ๐—ฑ๐—ฎ๐˜๐—ฒ๐—ฑ ๐—ฑ๐—ฎ๐—บ๐—ฎ๐—ด๐—ฒ๐˜€ ๐˜„๐—ถ๐—น๐—น ๐—ป๐—ผ๐˜ ๐—ฏ๐—ฒ ๐—ฝ๐—ฎ๐˜†๐—ฎ๐—ฏ๐—น๐—ฒ ๐—ฒ๐˜ƒ๐—ฒ๐—ป ๐—ถ๐—ณ ๐˜๐—ต๐—ฒ ๐—ฅ๐—ฒ๐˜€๐—ฝ๐—ผ๐—ป๐—ฑ๐—ฒ๐—ป๐˜ ๐—ถ๐˜€ ๐—ต๐—ฒ๐—น๐—ฑ ๐˜๐—ผ ๐—ฏ๐—ฒ ๐—ถ๐—ป ๐—ฏ๐—ฟ๐—ฒ๐—ฎ๐—ฐ๐—ต ๐—ผ๐—ณ ๐˜๐—ต๐—ฒ ๐—–๐—ผ๐—ป๐˜๐—ฟ๐—ฎ๐—ฐ๐˜.

 As per the crystallized legal position, sum ascertained as liquidated damages in the contract is not in the nature of penalty, but is a pre-estimate of loss estimated by the parties likely to be suffered by a party in the event of breach of contract by the other party. Loss must be incurred by a party in order to claim the same. Liquidated damages are not payable merely as a penalty for breach of contract, if no loss is suffered. It is the quantification of loss that would require no further ascertainment by court/tribunal, which would quantify the same as per the pre-estimated loss or formula agreed to by the parties as liquidated damages in the contract. In view of the same, AT's rejection of claim No 3 is consistent with the prevalent legal position. {Para 20}

Ratio: Hon'ble Mr. Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri of the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi upheld the award of the Arbitral Tribunal wherein the inter alia claim for the balance rent for the lock in period was sought by the Claimant on the pre-mature termination of the Contract by the Respondent.


The claim was not granted to the Claimant even though the Respondent was held to be in breach of the Contract as the Claimant could not demonstrate the loss caused to it. The Respondent, rather, demonstrated that the Claimant was able to put the property up for rent the day after the Respondent vacated the premises.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

O.M.P. (Comm.) 266/2023, CAV 377/2023, I.A. 13723/2023, I.A. 13724/2023, I.A. 13725/2023 and I.A. 13726/2023

Decided On: 18.09.2023

Vivek Khanna Vs. OYO Apartments Investments LLP

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Manoj Kumar Ohri, J.

Citation: MANU/DE/6307/2023,2023/DHC/6763

Print Page

Sunday, 23 July 2023

Whether the government can claim liquidated damages from other party while extending time for completion of project contrary to terms of contract?

5.2 In the communication granting extension of time with levy

of penalty, penalty is levied by the State Government

invoking Clause 3.5.5(v) of the OPWD Code. However, it is

required to be noted that Clause 3.5.5(v) of the OPWD

Code shall be applicable in a case where the contract is

terminated. It permits the appropriate authority/State to

terminate the contract with penalty when the progress of

work is not as per the conditions of contract. Here, it is not

a case of termination of the contract. Therefore, Clause

3.5.5(v) of the OPWD Code which has been invoked in the

communication granting extension of time but with levy of

penalty shall not be applicable at all.

5.3 So far as the reliance placed upon Clause 3.5.30 of the

OPWD Code by learned counsel appearing on behalf of the

State is concerned, even under the said clause, there is no

provision for imposition of penalty while granting extension

of time. Clause 3.5.30 only provides that while

communicating to the contractor of extension of time, he

must be informed that extension is granted without

prejudice to State Government’s right to levy compensation

under relevant clause of the contract. If the relevant clause

of the contract is seen and/or considered, there is no

condition stipulated in the contract that while granting the

extension of time, there may be levy of penalty. The

relevant clause with respect to the extension of time is

Clause-4, which has been reproduced hereinabove. Neither

the contract nor the OPWD code provides for imposition of

penalty while extending the contract. Therefore, levy of

penalty while granting extension of time is wholly without

authority of the law and is illegal. The same has been

rightly set aside by the High Court.

5.4 Even otherwise, it is required to be noted that before the

levy of penalty of a particular percentage, while granting

extension of time, no opportunity of being heard has been

given to the contractor as to why the penalty may not be

imposed while granting extension of time and at what rate.

In a given case, the State Government might be justified in

imposing the penalty while granting the extension.

However, the contractor must be put to notice that

extension of time can be granted on imposition of

reasonable penalty. However, without putting the

contractor to notice, unilaterally, the State is not justified

in levying the penalty while granting extension of time.

6. In view of the above and for the reasons stated above, the

High Court has rightly set aside the penalty levied while

granting extension of time. 

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 4934 OF 2022

The State of Odisha & Ors. Vs Radheshyam Agrawal 

Author: M.R. SHAH, J.

Dated: MARCH 24, 2023.

Print Page

Monday, 7 February 2022

Whether arbitrator can award Liquidated Damages Over & Above Actual Damages?

 The expression “whether or not actual damage or loss is proved to have been caused thereby” means that where it is possible to prove actual damage or loss, such proof is not dispensed with. It is only in cases where damage or loss is difficult or impossible to prove that the liquidated amount named in the contract, if a genuine pre-estimate of damage or loss, can be awarded. {Para 43.6. }

22. In the present case as the actual damages suffered by the respondent were proven and accepted by the learned Sole Arbitrator, liquidated damages over and above such actual damages could not have been awarded. Accordingly, the Arbitral Award insofar as it grants Rs.8,38,656/- in favour of the respondent is set aside.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

FAO(OS) 415/2011& CM APPLs. 44584-5/2021

BHOPAL DAL UDYOG Vs FOOD CORPORTION OF INDIA 

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA

Author: NAVIN CHAWLA, J.

Date of Decision: 04.01.2022

Print Page

Sunday, 23 January 2022

When should a party prove loss or damages for breach of contract if there was a contract for grant of liquidated damages?

 Mr. Raheja's contention that HPCL was not required to either plead or prove any loss is difficult to accept. In Kailash Nath Associates v. Delhi Development Authority (supra), the Supreme Court had referred to Section 74 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 and had held as under:—

“43. On a conspectus of the above authorities, the law on compensation for breach of contract under Section 74 can be stated to be as follows:

43.1. Where a sum is named in a contract as a liquidated amount payable by way of damages, the party complaining of a breach can receive as reasonable compensation such liquidated amount only if it is a genuine pre-estimate of damages fixed by both parties and found to be such by the court. In other cases, where a sum is named in a contract as a liquidated amount payable by way of damages, only reasonable compensation can be awarded not exceeding the amount so stated. Similarly, in cases where the amount fixed is in the nature of penalty, only reasonable compensation can be awarded not exceeding the penalty so stated. In both cases, the liquidated amount or penalty is the upper limit beyond which the court cannot grant reasonable compensation.

43.2. Reasonable compensation will be fixed on well-known principles that are applicable to the law of contract, which are to be found inter alia in Section 73 of the Contract Act.

43.3. Since Section 74 awards reasonable compensation for damage or loss caused by a breach of contract, damage or loss caused is a sine qua non for the applicability of the section.

43.4. The section applies whether a person is a plaintiff or a defendant in a suit.

43.5. The sum spoken of may already be paid or be payable in future.

43.6. The expression “whether or not actual damage or loss is proved to have been caused thereby” means that where it is possible to prove actual damage or loss, such proof is not dispensed with. It is only in cases where damage or loss is difficult or impossible to prove that the liquidated amount named in the contract, if a genuine pre-estimate of damage or loss, can be awarded.

43.7. Section 74 will apply to cases of forfeiture of earnest money under a contract. Where, however, forfeiture takes place under the terms and conditions of a public auction before agreement is reached, Section 74 would have no application.”  {Para 52}

53. HPCL had neither pleaded that it was not feasible to establish the loss nor had led any material to establish that it had suffered loss on account of non-supply of ethanol by DSM. There is also no pleading to the effect that ethanol was otherwise not readily available or available at a price higher than as agreed between DSM and HPCL. DSM's contention that HPCL had failed to establish any loss was contested on an erroneous premise that HPCL was not required to establish the same.

54. In the given circumstances, this Court is of the view that the award of Rs. 88,14,785/- in favour of HPCL, is not sustainable.

In the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi

(Before Vibhu Bakhru, J.)

O.M.P. (COMM) 164/2020 and I.A. No. 2870/2015

Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd.  Vs Dhampur Sugar Mills Ltd.

O.M.P. (COMM) 164/2020, I.A. No. 2870/2015 and O.M.P. (COMM) 190/2020

Decided on January 6, 2022

Citation: 2022 SCC OnLine Del 42

Print Page

Saturday, 25 December 2021

Whether a party is entitled to recover liquidated damages for breach of contract if waived it at the time of the first extension?

This brings us to the waiver. It may be noted that ONGC waived liquidated damages twice before giving extension with pre-estimated damages. The approach of the Arbitral Tribunal was to hold that once liquidated damages were waived in the first extension, subsequent extension could not be coupled with liquidated damages unless a clear intention flowed from the contract; while this Court recognizes the autonomy of the party to engage in contractual obligation. Such obligation must be contracted in clear terms. From the aforesaid discussion, it is clear that the promisee (ONGC) waived the liquidated damages initially and the same cannot be imposed, unless such imposition was clearly accepted by parties. In this case, the interpretation of the Arbitral Tribunal could not be faulted as being perverse, for the reasons stated above.

 In the Supreme Court of India

(Before N.V. Ramana, C.J. and Surya Kant, J.)

Civil Appeal Nos. 2826-2827 of 2016

Welspun Specialty Solutions Limited (Formerly Known As Remi Metals Gujarat Ltd.) VsvOil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd.


Decided on November 13, 2021

Citation: 2021 SCC OnLine SC 1053

Print Page

Thursday, 30 July 2020

Difference between Liquidated and unliquidated damages

1) Contracts generally include a provision for the one party to pay liquidated damages (or liquidated and ascertained damages, ) to the other party in the event that the contract is breached. Liquidated damages are a pre-agreed amount of money that is set out in advance in the contract, that fixes the sum payable as damages if the one party breaches the contract - typically by failing to perform contract.

Unliquidated damages are damages that are payable for a breach, the exact amount of which has not been pre-agreed. The sum to be paid as compensation is said to be ‘at large’ and is determined after the breach occurs by a court.
Print Page

Monday, 10 October 2016

Whether grant of liquidated damages by arbitrator without following basic principles is permissible?

Both the parties have not complied with and performed, their reciprocal obligations in time. The delay cannot be attributed to the breaches of reciprocal promises only on the party. The termination, even if accepted, was only with a rider to claim reasonable compensation. If the party, who makes a claim, fails to lead evidence in support of the same, particularly for claiming liquidated damages based upon agreement between the parties, grant of such claim by the Arbitrator, without considering the basic principle of granting such liquidated damages, in our view, is clearly unacceptable and therefore, rightly interfered with by the learned Judge, based upon the facts and the law.
"(g) In Saw Pipes (Supra), the Apex Court has observed that the party who relied upon such clause, may lead evidence to claim more, if the damage/compensation amount is not reasonable. The Court may also direct the parties to lead evidence to confirm that the action of delay amounts to breach of contract and which has caused the damages and therefore, entitled for a reasonable compensation/ amount. The reasonable amount/ compensation cannot be equated with the fixed amount and/or maximum amount as per the liquidated damages clause in question. The observations that other side to prove that the claimant has not suffer any loss or damage itself contemplates necessity of leading evidence by both the parties. The burden is always on the parties who claimed compensation to prove actual loss, even for the reasonable compensation.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Appeal No. 11 of 2016 in Arbitration Petition No. 868 of 2014 and Notice of Motion (Stamp) No. 3175 of 2015 in Appeal No. 11 of 2016
Decided On: 31.03.2016
 Raheja Universal Pvt. Limited
Vs.
B.E. Billimoria and Co. Limited
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:Anoop V. Mohta and S.C. Gupte, JJ.
Citation:2016(5) MHLJ 229
Print Page

Saturday, 10 September 2016

What are basic principles for grant of compensation S 74 of contract Act?

 On a conspectus of the above authorities, the law on
compensation for breach of contract under Section 74 can be stated to be as follows:-
1. Where a sum is named in a contract as a liquidated amount payable by way of damages, the party complaining of a breach can receive as reasonable compensation such
liquidated amount only if it is a genuine pre-estimate of
damages fixed by both parties and found to be such by the
Court. In other cases, where a sum is named in a contract as
a liquidated amount payable by way of damages, only
reasonable compensation can be awarded not exceeding the
amount so stated. Similarly, in cases where the amount fixed
is in the nature of penalty, only reasonable compensation can
be awarded not exceeding the penalty so stated. In both
cases, the liquidated amount or penalty is the upper limit
beyond which the Court cannot grant reasonable
compensation.
2. Reasonable compensation will be fixed on well known
principles that are applicable to the law of contract, which
are to be found inter alia in Section 73 of the Contract Act.

3. Since Section 74 awards reasonable compensation for
damage or loss caused by a breach of contract, damage or
loss caused is a sine qua non for the applicability of the
Section.
4. The Section applies whether a person is a plaintiff or a
defendant in a suit.
5. The sum spoken of may already be paid or be payable in
future.
6. The expression “whether or not actual damage or loss is
proved to have been caused thereby” means that where it is
possible to prove actual damage or loss, such proof is not
dispensed with. It is only in cases where damage or loss is
difficult or impossible to prove that the liquidated amount
named in the contract, if a genuine pre-estimate of damage
or loss, can be awarded.
7. Section 74 will apply to cases of forfeiture of earnest money
under a contract. Where, however, forfeiture takes place
under the terms and conditions of a public auction before
agreement is reached, Section 74 would have no application.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 193 OF 2015
[ARISING OUT OF SLP (CIVIL) NO.32039 OF 2012]

M/s. Kailash Nath Associates  V  Delhi Development Authority & Anr.  
Dated:January 09, 2015.
Citation:AIR 2015 SC(Supp)780
Print Page

Tuesday, 5 April 2016

When it is not necessary to prove that damages were caused due to breach of employment bond for recovery of damages?

 On the decisions as aforesaid, the principles which follow in the matter of application ofSection 74 are that where an agreement provides that an amount is to be paid in case of breach thereof whether the amount so payable is penalty or liquidated damages what is payable is reasonable compensation. The Court, therefore, is conferred the jurisdiction in adjudicating any such claim whether the amount claimed really represents the reasonable compensation or not and whether the party claiming such amount has suffered any damage or not to sustain such a claim. The Court is to decide this on consideration of all the facts and circumstances proved including the agreement itself so that if on the agreement proved it is found that the money made payable is liquidated damages bated on a genuine pre-estimate of the damage to be suffered and is not excessive or unconscionable with reference to the damage likely to have suffered by the party claiming the amount, the Court can certainly decree the amount so estimated by the party and mere absence of an independent proof of damage or the quantum thereof would not necessarily induce the Court to overrule the claim and dismiss the suit. The claim now under consideration when adjudged in the aforesaid light is quite sustainable. The agreement has been proved between the parties and on our findings made hereinbefore, the amount payable on the breach is based on a genuine pre-estimate of the damage to be suffered by the plaintiff/respondent in case of breach thereof by the defendant/appellant and that amount again on our findings already made, represents a sum which can only reasonably compensate the loss that the company must have suffered on training up the appellant for 6 months Therefore, even if we accept the contention of Mr. Bagchi that the plaintiff/respondent in the present case had not specifically plead any damage nor proved the same, since the plaintiff/respondent had sued for recovery of a liquidated damage it can rely upon the agreement itself for proof of the damage and the quantum of compensation payable there for to sustain the decree in its favour, fn this view, the second point raised by Mr. Bdgchi fails and is overruled.
Calcutta High Court
Subir Ghosh vs Indian Iron & Steel Co. on 12 September, 1976
Equivalent citations: (1977) IILLJ 120 Cal

Bench: A Sen, M Roy
Print Page