Showing posts with label unliquidated damages. Show all posts
Showing posts with label unliquidated damages. Show all posts

Saturday, 18 February 2023

Whether application for Summary Judgment is maintainable if Summary suit is converted into Commercial suit?

Assuming that plaintiffs' suit is initially filed as a summary suit under Order XXXVII of the Code, thereby taking it out of ambit of provisions of Order XIII-A of the Code, would it's subsequent conversion as commercial suit entail loss of both the rights viz. (i) to seek summary judgment under Order XIII-A as well as (ii) pronouncement of judgment under Order XXXVII, Rule 3 of the Code?. To paraphrase, would conversion of summary suit into a commercial suit would put a Plaintiff in a disadvantageous position where he loses right to seek pronouncement of judgment under Order XXXVII, Rule 3 of the Code as well as attracts the bar for seeking summary judgment under sub rule 3 of Rule 1 of Order XIII A of the Code?


15. Through Mr. Dawar strenuously pressed his objection about non-applicability of provisions of Order XIII-A to Plaintiff's application, upon being confronted with the above conundrum, he fairly concedes to the position that a Plaintiff in summary suit cannot be put to a disadvantageous position merely because his summary suit is converted into a commercial suit. The objective behind incorporating provision of sub-rule 3 of Rule 1 of Order XIII A of the Code is to prevent Plaintiff who once attempts pronouncement of judgment under Order XXXVII Rule 3 of the Code and upon conversion of his summary suit into commercial one, seeks to have another bite at the cherry by seeking pronouncement of judgment under Order XIII-A of the Code. The provisions of sub-rule 3 of Rule 1 of Order XIII A cannot be interpreted to mean that Plaintiff in a summary suit which is converted into commercial suit would loose both rights of pronouncement of judgment under Order XXXVII Rule 3 of the Code as well as seeking summary judgment under Order XIII A of the Code. Thus, the objection about non-maintainability of application for Summary Judgment filed by the Petitioners is repelled.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 10573 of 2022

Decided On: 31.01.2023

Ashok Commercial Enterprises and Ors. Vs.  Rajesh Jugraj Madhani

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Sandeep V. Marne, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/0251/2023,2023 Lawweb (Bom HC ) 10.

Print Page

Monday, 24 October 2022

Bombay HC: Undisputed Claims Can't Be Set-Off Against Unliquidated Damages That Are Not Ascertained

 Thus adverting to the above principles of law in their applicability to the facts of the present case, in my opinion, the petitioner has clearly made out a prima facie case for the relief, that the ONGC needs to deposit the undisputed invoice amounts in this Court pending the arbitral proceedings. There cannot be any justification for the ONGC to withhold such amount and more particularly on the premise that it has a claim of unliquidated damages against the petitioner on account of the incident which had taken place on 1 September 2019. The damages so claimed by the ONGC are certainly neither admitted nor ascertained in a manner known to law. {Para 27}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Commercial Arbitration Petition No. 135 of 2022

Decided On: 06.06.2022

 Ocean Sparkle Limited  Vs. Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

G.S. Kulkarni, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/1776/2022

Print Page

Thursday, 30 July 2020

Difference between Liquidated and unliquidated damages

1) Contracts generally include a provision for the one party to pay liquidated damages (or liquidated and ascertained damages, ) to the other party in the event that the contract is breached. Liquidated damages are a pre-agreed amount of money that is set out in advance in the contract, that fixes the sum payable as damages if the one party breaches the contract - typically by failing to perform contract.

Unliquidated damages are damages that are payable for a breach, the exact amount of which has not been pre-agreed. The sum to be paid as compensation is said to be ‘at large’ and is determined after the breach occurs by a court.
Print Page

Sunday, 24 July 2016

Whether unliquidated damages are debt?


It would be profitable in, this connection to refer to the concept of a 'debt', for a sum due is the same thing as a debt due. The classical definition of 'debt' is to be found in Webb v. Stenton (1) where Lindley, L. J., said : "a debt is a sum of money which is now payable or will become payable in the future by reason of a present obligation". There must be debitum in praesenti; solvendum maybe in praesenti or in future that is immaterial. There must be an existing obligation to pay a sum, of money now or in future. The following passage from the judgment of the Supreme Court of California in People v. Arguello. [1869] 37 Calif. 524 (1) [1883] 11 Q.B.D. 518. which, was approved by this Court inKesoram Industries v. Commissione of Wealth Tax  [1966] 2 S.C.R. 688. clearly brings out the essential characteristics of a debt "Standing alone, the word 'debt,' is as applicable to a sum of money which has been promised at a future day as to a sum now due and payable. If we wish to distinguish between the two, we say of the former that it is. a debt 'owing, and of the latter that it is debt due."
This passage indicates, that when there is an obligation to pay a sum of money at a future date, it is a debt owing but when the obligation, is to pay a sum of money in praesenti, it is a debt due. A sum due would, therefore, mean a sum for which there is an existing obligation to pay in praesenti or in other words, which is presently payable.. 
 Now the law is well settled that a claim for unliquidated damages does not give rise to a debt until the liability is adjudicated and damages assessed by a decree or order of a Court or other adjudicatory authority. When there is a breach of contract, the party who commits the breach does not eo instanti incur any pecuniary obligation, nor does the party complaining of the breach becomes entitled to a debt due from the other party. The only right which the party aggrieved by the breach of the contract has is the right to sue for damages. That is not in actionable claim and this position is made amply clear by the amendment in s. 6(e) of the Transfer of Property Act, which provides that a mere right to sue for damages cannot be transferred. This has always been the law in England and as far back as 1858 we, find it stated by Wightman, J., in Jones v. Thompson (1) "Exparte Charles and several other cases decide that the amount of a verdict in an action for unliquidated damages is not a debt till judgment has. been signed".
Supreme Court of India
Union Of India vs Raman Iron Foundry on 12 March, 1974
Equivalent citations: 1974 AIR 1265, 1974 SCR (3) 556

Bench: Bhagwati, P.N.
           
Print Page