Assuming that plaintiffs' suit is initially filed as a summary suit under Order XXXVII of the Code, thereby taking it out of ambit of provisions of Order XIII-A of the Code, would it's subsequent conversion as commercial suit entail loss of both the rights viz. (i) to seek summary judgment under Order XIII-A as well as (ii) pronouncement of judgment under Order XXXVII, Rule 3 of the Code?. To paraphrase, would conversion of summary suit into a commercial suit would put a Plaintiff in a disadvantageous position where he loses right to seek pronouncement of judgment under Order XXXVII, Rule 3 of the Code as well as attracts the bar for seeking summary judgment under sub rule 3 of Rule 1 of Order XIII A of the Code?
15. Through Mr. Dawar strenuously pressed his objection about non-applicability of provisions of Order XIII-A to Plaintiff's application, upon being confronted with the above conundrum, he fairly concedes to the position that a Plaintiff in summary suit cannot be put to a disadvantageous position merely because his summary suit is converted into a commercial suit. The objective behind incorporating provision of sub-rule 3 of Rule 1 of Order XIII A of the Code is to prevent Plaintiff who once attempts pronouncement of judgment under Order XXXVII Rule 3 of the Code and upon conversion of his summary suit into commercial one, seeks to have another bite at the cherry by seeking pronouncement of judgment under Order XIII-A of the Code. The provisions of sub-rule 3 of Rule 1 of Order XIII A cannot be interpreted to mean that Plaintiff in a summary suit which is converted into commercial suit would loose both rights of pronouncement of judgment under Order XXXVII Rule 3 of the Code as well as seeking summary judgment under Order XIII A of the Code. Thus, the objection about non-maintainability of application for Summary Judgment filed by the Petitioners is repelled.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Writ Petition No. 10573 of 2022
Decided On: 31.01.2023
Ashok Commercial Enterprises and Ors. Vs. Rajesh Jugraj Madhani
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Sandeep V. Marne, J.
Citation: MANU/MH/0251/2023,2023 Lawweb (Bom HC ) 10.
Print Page
