Showing posts with label multiple dying declaration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label multiple dying declaration. Show all posts

Saturday, 25 April 2026

How session judge should appreciate multiple dying declaration?

 You can explain it in interview as a simple filtering process: first see whether each dying declaration is trustworthy by itself, then compare them with each other, and finally check which one fits the medical and surrounding evidence. If they are consistent, they can be relied on; if they materially contradict each other, the court should look for corroboration and may prefer a trustworthy Magistrate-recorded declaration.

Print Page

Tuesday, 10 February 2026

The Person Who Wrote It Matters: Why “Who Recorded the Dying Declaration” Can Make or Break a Case

 Proper Identification of the Recording Officer in Dying Declaration Cases

Proper identification of the recording officer is a critical procedural requirement in dying declaration cases that ensures the authenticity, reliability, and admissibility of such statements. This principle, established through various Supreme Court judgments and procedural guidelines, encompasses several key aspects that must be meticulously followed.

Hierarchy of Authority for Recording Officers

The Supreme Court has established a clear hierarchy of preferred authorities for recording dying declarations, with specific identification requirements for each level:

Print Page

Sunday, 6 July 2025

Principles To Be Followed In Case Of Multiple Dying Declarations

 Principles To Be Followed In Case Of Multiple Dying Declarations

The Supreme Court of India has established comprehensive principles for evaluating multiple dying declarations in criminal cases, recognizing that these statements, while powerful evidence, require careful judicial scrutiny to ensure justice.

Legal Foundation and Admissibility

Print Page

Wednesday, 2 July 2025

Supreme Court: Principles To Be Followed In Case Of Multiple Dying Declarations

 When dealing with multiple dying declarations, courts in India follow certain well-established principles to ensure that justice is served and that the declarations are reliable and admissible as evidence. The  Supreme Court judgment (Abhishek Sharma v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi), 2023 INSC 924) provides a comprehensive discussion of these principles, which can be summarized and explained as follows:

Principles to Be Followed in Case of Multiple Dying Declarations

1. Voluntariness, Reliability, and Mental Fitness

·       Every dying declaration must be voluntary, reliable, and made when the declarant was in a fit mental condition to make such a statement.

Print Page

Tuesday, 24 October 2023

Supreme court : Principles To Be Followed In Case Of Multiple Dying Declarations

 Having considered various pronouncements of this Court, the following principles emerge, for a Court to consider when dealing with a case involving multiple dying declarations:


9.1 The primary requirement for all dying declarations is that they should be voluntary and reliable and that such statements should be in a fit state of mind;


9.2 All dying declarations should be consistent. In other words, inconsistencies between such statements should be 'material' for its credibility to be shaken;


9.3 When inconsistencies are found between various dying declarations, other evidence available on record may be considered for the purposes of corroboration of the contents of dying declarations.


9.4 The statement treated as a dying declaration must be interpreted in light of surrounding facts and circumstances.


9.5 Each declaration must be scrutinized on its own merits. The court has to examine upon which of the statements reliance can be placed in order for the case to proceed further.


9.6 When there are inconsistencies, the statement that has been recorded by a Magistrate or like higher officer can be relied on, subject to the indispensable qualities of truthfulness and being free of suspicion.


9.7 In the presence of inconsistencies, the medical fitness of the person making such declaration, at the relevant time, assumes importance along with other factors such as the possibility of tutoring by relatives, etc.{Para 9}

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1473 of 2011

Decided On: 18.10.2023

Abhishek Sharma Vs. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi)

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Abhay Shreeniwas Oka and Sanjay Karol, JJ.

Author: Sanjay Karol, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/1159/2023.

Print Page

Saturday, 19 February 2022

Can the court convict the accused if the common thread runs through multiple dying declarations?

 10.2 Kushal Rao V. State of Bombay, AIR 1958 SC 22:1958 SCR 552 is a watershed judgment on the law on the evidentiary value of dying declarations. This Court laid down the following principles as to the circumstances under which a dying declaration may be accepted, without corroboration: ­

“16. On a review of the relevant provisions of the Evidence Act and of the decided cases in the different High Courts in India and in this Court, we have come to the conclusion, in agreement with the opinion of the Full Bench of the Madras High Court, aforesaid, (1) that it cannot be laid down as an absolute rule of law that a dying declaration cannot form the sole basis of conviction unless it is corroborated; (2) that each case must be determined on its own facts keeping in view the circumstances in which the dying declaration was made; (3) that it cannot be laid down as a general proposition that a dying declaration is a weaker kind of evidence than other pieces of evidence; (4) that a dying declaration stands on the same footing as another piece of evidence and has to be judged in the light of surrounding circumstances and with reference to the principles governing the weighing of evidence; (5) that a dying declaration which has been recorded by a competent Magistrate in the proper manner, that is to say, in the form of questions and answers, and, as far as practicable, in the words of the maker of the declaration, stands on a much higher footing than a dying declaration which depends upon oral testimony which may suffer from all the infirmities of human memory and human character, and (6) that in order to test the reliability of a dying declaration, the court has to keep in view, the circumstances like the opportunity of the dying man for observation, for example, whether there was sufficient light if the crime was committed at night; whether the capacity of the man to remember the facts stated, had not been impaired at the time he was making the statement, by circumstances beyond his control; that the statement has been consistent throughout if he had several opportunities of making a dying declaration apart from the official record of it; and that the statement had been made at the earliest opportunity and was not the result of tutoring by interested parties.”
The relevant facts of the said case are that the deceased therein had given three successive dying declarations within a span of two hours, which were, to a certain degree contradictory to each other. However, one of the aspects that remained common and was narrated by the deceased in all three dying declarations was that he was attacked by two persons, namely Kushal Rao and Tukaram with swords and spears. This Court, relying on the common thread running through all dying declarations, which was consistent with medical evidence revealing punctured and incised wounds on various parts of the body, held that the said declarations could be relied upon in convicting the accused who had been named in all three dying declarations.

Supreme Court

JUSTICE M. R. SHAH JUSTICE B. V. NAGARATHNA

State of U.P. Vs. Veerpal & Anr.

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 34 OF 2022

1st February 2022

Author: M. R. Shah, J.

Citation: 2022 ALL SCR (ONLINE) 112

Print Page

Saturday, 11 September 2021

How to appreciate evidence if there are Oral and written multiple dying declarations?

Following are the principles laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Purushottam Chopra and another Vs. State (Government of NCT of Delhi) (supra), which are summed up as under :

“(1) A dying declaration could be the sole basis of

conviction even without corroboration, if it inspires

confidence of the Court.

(2) The Court should be satisfied that the declarant was

in a fit state of mind at the time of making the

statement; and that it was a voluntary statement,

which was not the result of tutoring, prompting or

imagination.

(3) Where a dying declaration is suspicious or is

suffering from any infirmity such as want of fit state

of mind of the declarant or of like nature, it should

not be acted upon without corroborative evidence.

(4) When the eyewitnesses affirm that the deceased

was not in a fit and conscious state to make the

statement, the medical opinion cannot prevail.

(5) The law does not provide as to who could record

dying declaration nor there is any prescribed format

or procedure for the same but the person recording

dying declaration must be satisfied that the maker is

in a fit state of mind and is capable of making the

statement

(6) Although presence of a Magistrate is not absolutely

necessary for recording of a dying declaration but to

ensure authenticity and credibility, it is expected

that a Magistrate be requested to record such dying

declaration and/or attestation be obtained from

other persons present at the time of recording the

dying declaration.

(7) As regards a burns case, the percentage and degree

of burns would not, by itself, be decisive of the

credibility of dying declaration; and the decisive

factor would be the quality of evidence about the fit

and conscious state of the declarant to make the

statement.

(8) If after careful scrutiny, the Court finds the

statement placed as dying declaration to be

voluntary and also finds it coherent and consistent,

there is no legal impediment in recording conviction

on its basis even without corroboration”.

19. Having regard to the parameters laid down by the Hon’ble

Supreme Court in case of Laxman (supra) and in case of Purushottam Copra (supra), it is absolutely necessary to examine dying declarations in the form of written as well as oral. In case of Laxman (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court has made it clear that oral dying declaration is admissible in evidence and there is no legal bar. There is no requirement of law that a dying declaration must necessarily be made to a Magistrate with certification of doctor about the mental fitness of the patient. What is essentially required is that the person who records a dying declaration must be satisfied that the deceased was in a fit state of mind. A certification by the doctor is essentially a rule of caution and therefore the voluntary and truthful nature of the declaration can be established otherwise.

33. In case of Suresh Arjun Dodorkar (Sonar) Vs. State of

Maharashtra (supra), the Division Bench of this Court, bench at

Aurangabad has observed that, “where there are multiple dying

declarations and acceptance of one dying declaration falsifies the

other, the dying declarations have to be necessarily rejected. The

dying declaration has to pass all the tests of reliability as the declarant is not available for cross examination”.

In the case in hand, there are three oral dying declarations and two written dying declarations. All of them are found to be consistent about the role of the accused in setting his wife ablaze after pouring kerosene from a can in the house when both of them were alone. We are unable to accept the argument advanced by Mr. Chatterji, learned counsel for the appellant/accused in this regard.


IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 295 OF 2014

Sanjay Maruti Doule Vs  The State of Maharashtra

CORAM : V. K. JADHAV AND

SHRIKANT D. KULKARNI, JJ.

Pronounced on : 08.09.2021

JUDGMENT (PER SHRIKANT D. KULKARNI, J.) :-

Print Page

Friday, 15 November 2019

Supreme Court Judgment on appreciation of evidence in case of multiple dying declaration

A survey of the decisions would show that the principles can be culled out as follows:

a. Conviction of a person can be made solely on the basis of a dying declaration which inspires confidence of the court;

b. If there is nothing suspicious about the declaration, no corroboration may be necessary;

c. No doubt, the court must be satisfied that there is no tutoring or prompting;

d. The court must also analyse and come to the conclusion that imagination of the deceased was not at play in making the declaration. In this regard, the court must look to the entirety of the language of the dying declaration;

e. Considering material before it, both in the form of oral and documentary evidence, the court must be satisfied that the version is compatible with the reality and the truth as can be gleaned from the facts established;

f. However, there may be cases where there are more than one dying declaration. If there are more than one dying declaration, the dying declarations may entirely agree with one another. There may be dying declarations where inconsistencies between the declarations emerge. The extent of the inconsistencies would then have to be considered by the court. The inconsistencies may turn out to be reconciliable.

g. In such cases, where the inconsistencies go to some matter of detail or description but is incriminatory in nature as far as the Accused is concerned, the court would look to the material on record to conclude as to which dying declaration is to be relied on unless it be shown that they are unreliable;

h. The third category of cases is that where there are more than one dying declaration and inconsistencies between the declarations are absolute and the dying declarations are irreconcilable being repugnant to one another. In a dying declaration, the Accused may not be blamed at all and the cause of death may be placed at the doorstep of an unfortunate accident. This may be followed up by another dying declaration which is diametrically opposed to the first dying declaration. In fact, in that scenario, it may not be a question of an inconsistent dying declaration but a dying declaration which is completely opposed to the dying declaration which is given earlier. There may be more than two.

i. In the third scenario, what is the duty of the court? Should the court, without looking into anything else, conclude that in view of complete inconsistency, the second or the third dying declaration which is relied on by the prosecution is demolished by the earlier dying declaration or dying declarations or is it the duty of the court to carefully attend to not only the dying declarations but examine the rest of the materials in the form of evidence placed before the court and still conclude that the incriminatory dying declaration is capable of being relied upon?

OUR CONCLUSION ON MULTIPLE DYING DECLARATION

31. We would think that on a conspectus of the law as laid down by this Court, when there are more than one dying declaration, and in the earlier dying declaration, the Accused is not sought to be roped in but in the later dying declaration, a summersault is made by the deceased, the case must be decided on the facts of each case. The court will not be relived of its duty to carefully examine the entirety of materials as also the circumstances surrounding the making of the different dying declarations. If the court finds that the incriminatory dying declaration brings out the truthful position particularly in conjunction with the capacity of the deceased to make such declaration, the voluntariness with which it was made which involves, no doubt, ruling out tutoring and prompting and also the other evidence which support the contents of the incriminatory dying declaration, it can be acted upon. Equally, the circumstances which render the earlier dying declaration, worthy or unworthy of acceptance, can be considered.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 967 of 2015

Decided On: 04.09.2019

Jagbir Singh  Vs.  State (N.C.T. of Delhi)

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Sanjay Kishan Kaul and K.M. Joseph, JJ.

Citation: (2019) 8 SCC 779
Print Page

Friday, 6 September 2019

Latest Supreme Court Judgment on dying declaration

 A survey of the decisions would show that the
principles can be culled out as follows:
a. Conviction of a person can be made solely on
the basis of a dying declaration which inspires
confidence of the court;
b. If there is nothing suspicious about the
declaration, no corroboration may be necessary;
c. No doubt, the court must be satisfied that
there is no tutoring or prompting;

d. The court must also analyse and come to the
conclusion that imagination of the deceased was
not at play in making the declaration. In this
regard, the court must look to the entirety of
the language of the dying declaration;
e. Considering material before it, both in the
form of oral and documentary evidence, the court
must be satisfied that the version is compatible
with the reality and the truth as can be gleaned
from the facts established;
f. However, there may be cases where there are
more than one dying declaration. If there are
more than one dying declaration, the dying
declarations may entirely agree with one another.
There may be dying declarations where
inconsistencies between the declarations emerge.
The extent of the inconsistencies would then have
to be considered by the court. The
inconsistencies may turn out to be reconciliable.

g. In such cases, where the inconsistencies go to
some matter of detail or description but is
incriminatory in nature as far as the accused is
concerned, the court would look to the material
on record to conclude as to which dying
declaration is to be relied on unless it be shown
that they are unreliable;
h. The third category of cases is that where there
are more than one dying declaration and
inconsistencies between the declarations are
absolute and the dying declarations are
irreconcilable being repugnant to one another. In
a dying declaration, the accused may not be
blamed at all and the cause of death may be
placed at the doorstep of an unfortunate
accident. This may be followed up by another
dying declaration which is diametrically opposed
to the first dying declaration. In fact, in that
scenario, it may not be a question of an
inconsistent dying declaration but a dying

declaration which is completely opposed to the
dying declaration which is given earlier. There
may be more than two.
i. In the third scenario, what is the duty of the
court? Should the court, without looking into
anything else, conclude that in view of complete
inconsistency, the second or the third dying
declaration which is relied on by the prosecution
is demolished by the earlier dying declaration or
dying declarations or is it the duty of the court
to carefully attend to not only the dying
declarations but examine the rest of the
materials in the form of evidence placed before
the court and still conclude that the
incriminatory dying declaration is capable of
being relied upon?
OUR CONCLUSION ON MULTIPLE DYING DECLARATION
31. We would think that on a conspectus of the law as
laid down by this court, when there are more than one

dying declaration, and in the earlier dying
declaration, the accused is not sought to be roped in
but in the later dying declaration, a summersault is
made by the deceased, the case must be decided on the
facts of each case. The court will not be relived of
its duty to carefully examine the entirety of materials
as also the circumstances surrounding the making of the
different dying declarations. If the court finds that
the incriminatory dying declaration brings out the
truthful position particularly in conjunction with the
capacity of the deceased to make such declaration, the
voluntariness with which it was made which involves, no
doubt, ruling out tutoring and prompting and also the
other evidence which support the contents of the
incriminatory dying declaration, it can be acted upon.
Equally, the circumstances which render the earlier
dying declaration, worthy or unworthy of acceptance,
can be considered.

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 967 OF 2015

JAGBIR SINGH Vs  STATE (N.C.T. OF DELHI) 

K.M. JOSEPH, J.
Dated:September 4, 2019.
Print Page

Tuesday, 11 October 2016

Whether dying declaration recorded by magistrate will be preferred over dying declaration recorded by police?

From perusal of above dying declarations it is evident that in the first
dying declaration, deceased made no allegation against anyone but
termed the incident as an accident, whereas in the second dying
declaration the deceased accused her appellant husband of pouring
kerosene oil and then setting her on fire, but this did not contain the
certificate of the doctor that the deceased was in a fit state of mind to
make a declaration. However, the Magistrate, who recorded the second
declaration, clarified in his evidence that since the police had already
obtained opinion of the doctor as to fitness of mind of the deceased to
make statement, he himself did not enquire in this regard.
Besides the aforesaid two declarations, there is yet another
statement of the deceased recorded by a police officer in a routine
manner as Dehati FIR (Ex.P-12) and not as a dying declaration wherein
she accused her husband of pouring kerosene oil on her and then setting
her on fire. According to evidence of A.K. Prajapati (PW-12), after getting
certificate from the doctor that the deceased was in a fit condition to give
her statement, he recorded Dehati FIR Ex.P-12 in the manner as was
told by her. Though various suggestions have been put to this witness to
make Ex.P-12 doubtful, he has denied all those adverse suggestions and
remained very firm. Thus, this version of the deceased in Dehati FIR
(Ex.P-12) can also be treated as dying declaration after her death and for
this view I am fortified from the judgment of the Supreme Court in the
matter of Paras Yadav vs. State of Bihar reported in (1999) 2 SCC 126wherein it has been held by the Supreme Court that “a statement of the
deceased recorded by a police officer in a routine manner as a complaint
and not as a dying declaration can also be treated as dying declaration
after the death of the injured and relied upon if the evidence of the
prosecution witnesses clearly establishes that the deceased was
conscious and was in a fit state of health to make the statement”.
On comparison of Ex.P-8 & Ex.P-12, we find that Ex.P-12 is
consistent with Ex.P-8 i.e. second dying declaration recorded by the
Executive Magistrate. More so, it also stands corroborated by the oral
declaration made by the deceased to her brothers Budheshwar (PW-1) &
Kamlesh Kumar (PW-7) in the hospital. The defence has not been able
to elicit anything in the cross-examination of aforesaid witnesses to
discredit their testimonies to the extent that the deceased has not made
any dying declaration before them.
True it is that first dying declaration of the deceased was totally tilted
in favour of appellant husband and the version put forward was that she
had caught fire from the stove while cooking, but the settled position is
that in case there are more than one dying declaration and there are
inconsistencies between them, then the dying declaration recorded by
the higher officer like a Magistrate can be relied upon as the same would
stand on a much higher footing than the declaration recorded by officer of
lower rank. Furthermore, evidence available on record reflects that the
deceased was admitted in the hospital by the appellant husband and thus
the possibility of the deceased making first statement in favour of the
accused under threat, duress or compulsion by her husband that she
would be admitted in hospital only if she would give a statement in his
favour, cannot be ruled out.
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH, BILASPUR
CRA No. 1068 of 2012
 Tumendra Kumar Gahare @ Vijay Kumar Gahare 
V
State Of Chhattisgarh 
Per P. Diwaker, J
DATED:18/03/2016
Citation:2016 CRLJ3138 Chhatis
Print Page

Thursday, 14 April 2016

How to appreciate evidence when there are multiple dying declarations?

Before we proceed to scrutinize the evidence adduced by the
prosecution in support of its case, it will be useful to refer to the judgment
in the case of Suresh s/o Arjun Dodorkar (Sonar) Vs. State of Maharashtra
[2005 ALL MR (Cri) 1599] to which one of us (Shri P.V. Hardas, J.) was a
member, wherein while dealing with the issue of multiple dying

declarations, it has been held in para-9 that-
“in cases resting on multiple written dying declarations, the
Courts cannot pick and choose any one dying declaration. All
the dying declarations have to be consistent in respect of
material aspects of the incident. According to us, consistency is
expected in multiple dying declarations in respect of the names
and the number of accused, the prelude to the incident and the
incident itself.”
It has been further held that-
“If in the dying declaration the truthfulness of the narration itself
is rendered doubtful, no reliance whatsoever can be placed on
the dying declaration. Merely because the overt act attributed to
the accused is consistent in both the dying declarations would
not make the dying declarations a reliable piece of evidence. The
dying declaration has to pass all the tests of reliability as the
declarant is not available for cross-examination. In cases where
there are multiple dying declarations and acceptance of one
dying declaration falsifies the other, the dying declarations have
to be necessarily rejected.”

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
 CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 512 OF 2007

Shri Rajendra Madhukar Kadam, V The State of Maharashtra

 CORAM: P. V. HARDAS &
 A.S. GADKARI, JJ.

 March 19, 2014.
Citation; 2016 ALLMR(CRI)1022
Print Page