Showing posts with label non party. Show all posts
Showing posts with label non party. Show all posts

Sunday, 16 September 2018

Whether court should condone delay if application is made by aggrieved person not party to proceeding?

 In our opinion, having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case and further keeping in view of the fact that the appellants were not made parties  to the original writ petitions and became aggrieved by the order passed by the writ Court (Single Judge) in the writ petitions, a case for condonation of delay in filing the appeals was made out. It was, in our view, a sufficient cause for condonation of delay within the meaning of Section 5 of the Limitation Act. The High Court ought to have, in these circumstances, condoned the delay and granted permission to file the appeals to the appellants for being heard on merits.
NON-REPORTABLE
Supreme Court of India
Hetal Chirag Patel vs The State Of Gujarat on 11 July, 2018

Bench: [ U Lalit], [ M Sapre]
Citation: (2018) 7 SCC 703
Print Page

Saturday, 12 November 2016

Whether court can grant final relief at interim stage against non party to suit?

Upon hearing the learned Counsel, I find that admittedly defendant
no. 3 was not a party to the Appeal preferred before the Appellate Court. The relief
of cancellation of registration essentially affects the rights of the defendant no. 3. In
such circumstances, before directing the cancellation of the registration, the
learned Judge ought to have heard the defendant no. 3 in the matter. The findings
of the learned Judge that the Deed of Conveyance and the Tri-partite Lease Deed
was submitted for registration after the exparte Order was passed on 03.04.2004,
cannot be faulted. No doubt, there is a contention raised by the defendants to the
effect that the Deed of Conveyance was executed much before the service of the
Exparte Order. This aspect in any case would have to be examined by the learned
Judge while deciding the suit on merits. After examining the paramount
consideration of granting such injunctions, the Court also has to balance the
equities of the parties. No doubt, a contemptuous act cannot be condoned by a
Court of equity. But, in the present case, it is the contention of the defendants that
much prior to the exparte Order, there were documents executed between the
defendant inter se in connection with the shed, There are also allegations that
possession was also parted in favour of defendant no. 3 pursuant to documents
executed by the defendant nos. 1 and 2. In such circumstances, one will have to
examine whether in the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case and
considering that admittedly the defendant no. 3 and the Goa Industrial Corporation
were not parties to the suit, what could be a just and appropriate relief. The learned
Trial Judge on the basis of the findings in the impugned Order passed by the Lower
Appellate Court, has proceeded to dispose of the application under Order 39 Rule

2-A and 11 of the Civil Procedure Code by striking off the defence of the
defendants. No doubt, the rights of the Plaintiffs would have to be established in the
suit and ascertain whether the transactions intended to be executed were in fact
contrary to the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956 and the effects thereof. In
such circumstances, one will have to grant an appropriate relief in the facts of the
present case. By directing the cancellation of the registration of the deeds, the
learned Judge has in fact granted at this stage, a final relief when the rights of the
Plaintiffs have not been established. No doubt, an act committed in contravention
of an Order of the Court is to be dealt with severely and ensure that the illegality
which has been committed is undone in the facts and circumstances of each case.
Admittedly, the transactions which are impugned were with the consent of the Goa
Industrial Corporation who are not parties to the suit and the registration would also
effect their rights. In the present case, the party who is affected is in fact the
defendant no. 3 and the Industrial Corporation who were admittedly not parties to

the suit.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA
WRIT PETITION NOS. 279, 362 AND 626 OF 2006
WRIT PETITION NO. 279 OF 2006
Sachin Y.Mense,
V 
 Shri Sunil Noronha,
 Coram :- F. M. REIS, J
 Dated  : 16th January, 2015.
Citation:2016(5) ALLMR 146
Print Page

Saturday, 10 September 2016

Whether court can dismiss appeal filed by party on ground that appeal filed by non party is already dismissed?

The High Court has while dismissing the application for
condonation of delay made by the State dismissed even the
appeal preferred by the appellants in RFA No.806 of 2000
after obtaining the leave of the Court. While doing so the
High Court has not gone into the merits of the controversy
and has simply declined to interfere with the impugned
judgment and decree with the following observations:
“In view of the State Government having filed an
appeal in respect of the very judgment and decree,
the appeal in RFA 806/2000 would not merit
consideration and accordingly rejected.”

10. We are, in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the
case, are of the opinion that the High Court was not correct
in dismissing RFA No.806 of 2000 summarily as it has done.
Whether or not an appeal was maintainable at the instance
of someone who was not a party to the suit was itself a
matter which ought to have engaged the attention of the
High Court. The High Court has not, however, adverted to
that aspect and dismissed the appeal simply because the
appeal preferred by the State had been dismissed. That
apart, since an appeal against the very same judgment and
decree as was challenged in RFA No.296 of 2011 was
already pending before the High Court, the High Court ought
to have taken a more pragmatic view of the matter and
condoned the delay in filing of the said appeal on such terms
as it may it consider it proper. It is no doubt true that the
delay in filing of the State appeal was considerable but given
the circumstances in which the delay had occurred, we are
inclined to condone the same. 
 REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 10418 OF 2014
(Arising out of S.L.P. (C) No. 19634 of 2012)
The Principal Govt. Pre-University
College & Anr. 
Vs.
Mr. Jambu Kumar Mutha 
Dated:November 20, 2014
Citation:AIR 2015 SC (SUPP)306
Print Page

Friday, 5 August 2016

Whether it is permissible to give effect to a document against a person not party to it?


There is no dispute that by the settlement deed dated 27.8.1981, late Shri B.P. Sandy had given House No. 23 admeasuring 2413 Sq. Ft. to the daughter – respondent no.1 and House No. 22 admeasuring 730 Sq. Ft. to the son – appellant. None of the attesting witnesses to these documents had been examined by either of the parties, to ascertain whether late B.P. Sandy, father of the parties, had expressed any intention in respect of the properties before them. Ex.A-6 dated 28.10.1983 a unregistered document is subsequent to Exs.A1 & A2, by which the father had expressed his will that House No. 23 should be given to the son – appellant. The appellant has examined one of the attesting witnesses Shri A. Bernard but the High Court came to the right conclusion that as the respondent no.1 was not a party to the document, it has no effect, whatsoever in law, on the case.

REPORTABLE
Supreme Court of India

Joseph Johan Peter Sandy vs Veronica Thomas Rajkumar & Anr on 12 March, 2013

Bench: B.S. Chauhan, Fakkir Mohamed Kalifulla
CIVIL APPEAL NOs. 2178-2179 OF 2004
Citation:(2013) 3 SCC 801
Print Page

Tuesday, 12 July 2016

Whether appeal is maintainable if court while deciding case on merits took note of terms of compromise?

 In the instant case, the impugned judgment is not passed as a consent decree. After the Issues were framed, both the parties have adduced oral and documentary evidence. In so far as Issue Nos. 1 to 5 and Issue No. 8 are concerned, in view of the compromise entered into between plaintiffs-1 and 2 on the one hand and defendants-1 to 5 on the other as per Ex. P-10, the rival contentions taken by them was held to be given up. Therefore it was held that Issue Nos. 1 to 5 and 8 do not survive for consideration. In so far as Issue Nos. 6 and 7 is concerned, on appreciation of the evidence on record, the finding is recorded. In so far as additional Issue Nos. 1 and 2 are concerned, on appreciation of oral and documentary evidence adduced in the case, a finding is given holding both the issues against defendants-9 and 10. Merely because, the Court while deciding the case on merits took note of the terms of the compromise and did not record a finding on merits in respect of the subject matter of compromise, that would not render the judgment and decree, a compromise decree. Admittedly, defendants-9 and 10 are not parties to the compromise. Their claim and contentions are decided on merits. As they are aggrieved by the said finding, they have a right to prefer an appeal under Section 96 of CPC. Therefore the appeal filed is maintainable and we do not see any substance in the contention that the appeal is not maintainable.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
R.F.A. No. 960/2003
Decided On: 31.01.2015

Syed Basheer Malik and Ors. Vs.  Jameela Begum and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:N. Kumar and B. Veerappa, JJ.
Citation:AIR 2016(NOC)395 KAR
Print Page

Sunday, 3 April 2016

When appeal filed by person who is not party to suit is tenable?

When Appeal No. 81 of 1948 was called on before us counsel for the respondent took a preliminary objection that the Province of Bombay not having been a party to the petition it was not competent to the Province of Bombay to file the appeal. It was contended that it was only the parties to the proceedings before the lower Court that had a right of appeal and those persons who were not parties to the proceedings were not competent to file any appeal even though the judgment and the decree appealed from might adversely affect their interests. Our attention was directed to the relevant provisions of the Civil Procedure Code, namely, Sections 96 and 146 and Order XLI, Rule 1, of the Civil Procedure Code. It may be noted however that in none of these provisions of the Civil Procedure Code has it been laid down who can prefer an appeal It was further pointed out that in the commentary of Sir Dinshah Mulla on the Civil Procedure Code and also in a judgment of Mr. Justice Madhavan Nair in Indian Bank Ltd. v. Seth Bansiram Jeshamal Firm [1933] I.L.R. 57 Mad. 670 it was stated that no person who is not a party to the suit or proceedings has a right of appeal. This is no doubt the position so far as the right of appeal is concerned. A person who is not a party to the suit or proceedings has no right to appeal against the decision and this is the position where a person who is not such party is aggrieved by the decision and wants to appeal against it. He can only ask for leave to appeal from the appellate Court before he can be allowed to file an appeal. There is no right of appeal vested in him by any of the provisions of the Civil Procedure Code or by any other provision of law. The only remedy open to him, if his interests are adversely affected or if he is aggrieved by a decision of the Court, is to approach the Appellate Court and ask for leave to appeal which the appellate Court would grant in proper cases. This is the position in England as one finds it laid down in In re Securities Insurance Company [1894] 2 Ch. 410 where Lindley L.J. observed (p. 413):
Now, what was the practice of the Court of Chancery before 1862, and what lias it been since ? I understand the practice to be perfectly well settled that a person who is a party can appeal (of course within the proper time) without any leave, and that a person who without being a party is either bound by the order or is aggrieved by it, or is prejudicially affected by it, cannot appeal without leave. It does not require much to obtain leave. If a person alleging himself to be aggrieved by an order can make out even a prima facie case why he.should have leave he will get it; but without leave he is not entitled to appeal.
Bombay High Court
The Province Of Bombay vs Western India Automobile ... on 9 September, 1948
Equivalent citations: (1949) 51 BOMLR 58, AIR1949Bom141,

Bench: M Chagla, Bhagwati
Print Page

Sunday, 6 March 2016

When appeal filed by non party to suit is maintainable?

The appellant herein filed application seeking leave of this Court to file appeal on the ground that without determination of the priorities of the parties or without giving opportunity to the appellant herein, who is not a party to the proceedings, the order dated 06-10-1998 has been passed prejudicial to their interest by the learned single Judge of the original side of this Court. This Court, although granted leave by order dated 13-10-1998 kept open the question of maintainability.
13. As a general principle, no one can appeal unless he was a party to the proceedings or was treated as such or legal representative of the party or unless his privity in estate, title or interest is apparent on the face of the record. However, any person have a legal grievance which might have deprived him of the benefit or bound by the order passed is certainly entitled to the leave. It is more appropriate to refer the judgments of the Honourable Supreme Court reported in (Adi Pheroz Shah Gandhi Vs. H.M. Servai, Advocate General of Maharashtra, Bombay) MANU/SC/0044/1970 : [1971]1SCR863 and (State of Punjab and others Vs. Amarsingh and others) MANU/SC/0351/1974 : [1974]3SCR152 . It is from that point of view the appellant is an aggrieved person. Even in case of doubt as to the existence of the right of appeal, the appellant should get the benefit of doubt, hence we hold that the appellant is entitled to file the appeal as such the appeal is maintainable.
Equivalent Citation: AIR2004Mad498, (2004)1MLJ525
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADRAS
O.S.A. No. 175 of 1998 and C.M.P. Nos. 14624 of 1998, 14828 to 14830 of 1998, 2565 and 2566 of 1999 and 981 and 1174 of 2003
Decided On: 27.11.2003
Petromarine Products Ltd., Company incorporated under the laws of Cyprus, rep. by Constituted Attorney
Vs. Ocean Marine Services Co. Ltd., rep. by its Power of Attorney Agent, Mr. T. Satakopan and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Nelavoy Dhinakar and A. Kulasekaran, JJ.


Print Page

When a person who is not party to suit can file appeal?

 Presently, it is apt to note that Sections 96 and 100
of the Code make provisions for preferring an appeal
from any original appeal or from a decree in an
appeal respectively. The aforesaid provisions do not

enumerate the categories of persons who can file an
appeal. If a judgment and decree prejudicially
affects a person, needless to emphasize, he can
prefer an appeal. In this context, a passage from
Smt. Jatan Kanwar Golcha v. M/s. Golcha
Properties Private Ltd. AIR 1971 SC 374
 is worth noting: -
“It is well settled that a person who is not a
party to the suit may prefer an appeal with
the leave of the appellate Court and such
leave should be granted if he would be
prejudicially affected by the judgment.”
14. In State of Punjab v. Amar Singh and another
 AIR 1974 SC 994,Sarkaria, J., while dealing with the maintainability of
an appeal by a person who is not a party to a decree
or order, has stated thus: -
“84. Firstly there is a catena of authorities
which, following the doctrine of Lindley,
L.J., in re Securities Insurance Co., (1894) 2
Ch 410 have laid down the rule that a
person who is not a party to a decree or
order may with the leave of the Court,
prefer an appeal from such decree or order
if he is either bound by the order or is
aggrieved by it or is prejudicially affected
by it. As a rule, leave to appeal will not be
refused to a person who might have been
made ex nominee a party – see Province of
Bombay v. W.I. Automobile Association,
AIR 1949 Bom 141,

Reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 102 OF 2013
(Arising out of S.L.P. (C) No. 35271 of 2011)

Hardevinder Singh Vs  Paramjit Singh.

Dated;January 07, 2013
Citation; 2013(1)ALLMR(SC)946, 2014(2)MhLj126, , (2013)9SCC261,
Print Page

Monday, 17 February 2014

Whether person not party to decree can file separate suit to avoid execution of decree?


 These provisions are considered by the Hon'ble Apex Court by time and again. In Prasantha Banerji v . Pushpa Ashoke Chandani and Ors., 2002 (9) SCC 554, the Hon'ble Apex Court has held that a person not party to a decree cannot file separate suit to avoid its execution. He has to raise objection in the execution. In Noorduddin v. Dr.K.L.Anand, 1995 (1) SCC 242, particularly, in paragraph-9, the Hon'ble Apex Court has held that procedure under order 20 rules 98, 100 and 101 is sine qua non for finality of the execution. The judgment reported in Anwarbi v. Pramod D.A.Joshi, 2000 (10) SCC 405 shows that a person in possession should not be dispossessed till his objection is decided. 2004 (11) SCC 511- P Janardhan Rao vs. Kannan & Others, following .
Noorduddin v. Dr.K.L.Anand,supra, the Hon'ble Apex Court has found the provisions of Order XXI rule 97 rightly applied upon an application by a decree holder to remove obstruction to facilitate further execution. There proceedings have been decided after recording of evidence. The judgment reported in Bhanwar Lal v. Satyanarain & Anr, 1995 (1) SCC 6 also shows same law.
Bombay High Court
Smt Malti Vijaysingh Kapadia vs And At Present At: on 6 November, 2012
Bench: B. P. Dharmadhikari
Citation; 2014 (1) ALLMR 803 Bom
Print Page