Showing posts with label plea. Show all posts
Showing posts with label plea. Show all posts

Saturday, 24 March 2018

Whether party can take inconsistent plea in addition written statement?

But this does not and cannot the mean that the Court should allow liberty to the defendant to deal with the matter in an arbitrary manner and ignore the stand he had disclosed to the Court on the earlier occasion and plead something contrary to what he had done before.

8. If any support for the view which I have mentioned above is needed, recourse can had to be the case of Dittu Ram v. Amar Chand MANU/HP/0018/1961. In this judgment it has been laid down in a clear and categorical manner by the judicial Commissioner that a party does not have a right to amend a previous pleading without the permission of the Court and it would be a violating of the principles of pleadings and in general of provision of O.6,R.7 of the Civil Procedure Code in particular if on the amendment of the plant a defendant is allowed to put forward pleas which are not in answer to the fresh matter introduction by the amendment of the plaint are inconsistent with the pleas previously put forward.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT

Second Appeal No. 465 of 1971

Decided On: 29.03.1976

Thakkar Babulal Dayashanker Vs. Mehta Natwarlal Kaluram and Anr.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
N.H. Bhatt, J.
Citation: AIR 1978 Gujarat 94
Print Page

Thursday, 14 December 2017

Whether Plea not taken in Arbitration proceeding can be raised in S.34 or in SLP?

It is not in dispute that the appellant did not raise the plea based on clause 13(3) of the GCC against respondent No. 1 at any stage of the proceedings either in their reply filed before the Arbitral Tribunal or/and in submissions except raising it, for the first time, before this Court in this appeal.
21. On the other hand, we find that in Section 11(5) proceedings, the appellant did not raise this objection in their reply and instead gave their express consent to refer the issue of award of interest payable on various claims (1 to 17) to Arbitral Tribunal considering the said claim to be arbitrable under the contract.
22. In our opinion, the appellant could have registered their objection before the Single Judge at the time of making a reference to the Arbitral Tribunal by pointing out Clause 13(3) of GCC or could have reserved their right to raise such objection before the Arbitral Tribunal. It was, however, not done.
23. Not only that, we further find that the appellant, in their reply, filed before the Arbitral Tribunal also did not raise this plea and allowed the Arbitral Tribunal to adjudicate the said issue on merits.
24. If the appellant was so keen to place reliance on clause 13(3) of GCC to defeat the claim of respondent No. 1 relating to the award of interest on various claims, then it was necessary for the appellant to have raised such plea specifically, in their reply, before the Arbitral Tribunal. No such plea was raised even before the Arbitral Tribunal.
25. Though we find that the appellant raised this ground, for the first time, in Section 34 proceedings [see-ground (cc)] before the Single Judge but again this ground was not pressed at the time of arguments. It is clear from the perusal of the Single Judge's order. Not only that, the appellant again did not raise this plea before the Division Bench.
26. In the light of aforementioned factual scenario emerging from the record of the case, we cannot grant any indulgence to the appellant (Union of India) to raise such plea for the first time here. In our view, it is a clear case of waiver or/and abandonment of a plea at the initial stage itself.
27. Everyone has a right to waive and to agree to waive the advantage of a law made solely for the benefit and protection of the individual in his private capacity, which may be dispensed with without infringing any public right or public policy.Cuilibet licet renuntiare juri pro se introducto. (See Maxwell on The Interpretation of Statutes 12th Edition at page 328)
28. If a plea is available-whether on facts or law, it has to be raised by the party at appropriate stage in accordance with law. If not raised or/and given up with consent, the party would be precluded from raising such plea at a later stage of the proceedings on the principle of waiver. If permitted to raise, it causes prejudice to other party. In our opinion, this principle applies to this case.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
(Before Abhay Manohar Sapre and Navin Sinha, JJ.)

Union of India v. M/s. Susaka Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.

Civil Appeal No. 8530 of 2009
Decided on December 8, 2017
Citation: 2017 SCC OnLine SC 1436
Print Page

Sunday, 23 April 2017

Whether burden of proof will be on defendant if he takes plea of loan transaction?

Submissions of Mr. Thorat that when there is a registered document, then the sale is to be considered as a genuine, would have been accepted if the defendant would not have challenged the truth-fullness of the contents of the sale-deed and not contended that it is a sham document given as a security. The case of the defendant squarely falls under proviso Section 92 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. Obviously, the burden lies on the defendant to prove that the document executed was intended for something else than what is mentioned in the document.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Second Appeal No. 22 of 1990
Decided On: 31.10.2012
Shripati Ramchandra Choudhari

Vs.
Rajaram Bhau Shinde

Coram:

Mrs. Mridula Bhatkar, J.

Citation: 2013(1) MHLJ 304
Print Page

Sunday, 16 April 2017

What pleas can be taken by legal heirs of deceased defendant in counter claim filed by them?

 The position aforestated would however not apply in so far as the
counter­claim is concerned.  A counter­claim has the same effect as a crosssuit.
 If the legal representative can bring an independent action for seeking
relief, the same can  also be sought by filing a counter­claim.
            The counter­claim being based on the Will dated 26/05/1994 and it
being   open   for   the   said   legal   representative   to   assert   his   right   in   his
independent capacity, the same can be permitted to be filed on record. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR.
WRIT PETITION NO.4924 OF 2015

 Nilkanth  Pandurang Wath Vs  Amarkanth Pandurang Wath, 
    
CORAM  : A.S.CHANDURKAR, J. 
  DATE   :  July 22, 2016 
Citation:2017(1) ALLMR819,2016(6) MHLJ 46
Print Page

Sunday, 11 December 2016

Whether legal heirs of deceased defendant can take plea contrary to one taken by deceased defendant?

I have heard the respective counsel for the parties at length. The
defendant No.1 had filed his written statement on record on 22/04/1996.  It
is not in dispute that the defendant No.1(ii) has been brought on record in
the capacity of legal heir of the original defendant No.1.     The impleadment
of the defendant No.1(ii) is under provisions of Order XXII Rule 4 of Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short, the Code).  As per provisions of Order XXII
Rule 4(2) of the Code, the defence appropriate to the character of defendant
No.1(ii) as legal representative of deceased defendant No.1 was permissible
to the taken.  The impleadment being as legal heir of the deceased defendant
No.1,   the   legal   representative   would   merely   step   into   the   shoes  of   said
defendant.  A plea contrary to the one taken by the deceased defendant as
well as a plea personal to the legal representative could not be permitted to
be taken by him by virtue of such impleadment.  This position is clear from

the   ratio   of   the   decisions   relied   upon   by   the   learned   counsel   for   the
petitioner.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR.
WRIT PETITION NO.4924 OF 2015
  Nilkanth s/o Pandurang Wath 
vs­
 Amarkanth s/o Pandurang Wath, 
 
CORAM  : A.S.CHANDURKAR, J. 
   DATE   :  July 22, 2016 
 Citation: 2016(6) MHLJ 46,2017(1) ALLMR 819
Print Page