Showing posts with label rateable value. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rateable value. Show all posts

Monday, 18 October 2021

Whether Municipal appeal is maintainable against issuance of property tax bill?

  It is now well-settled that the right to file an appeal is a creation of the statute. Section 406(1) provides of appeals against any rateable value or tax fixed or charged under this Act. Reference to rateable value in Sub-section (1) of Section 406, necessarily, pertains to tax on property. In view of the fact that under Section 127, other taxes such as taxes on vehicles, boats, animals, octroi, etc., are also levied, Sub-section (1) of Section 406 also refers to appeals against "tax fixed or charged" under the Act. Section 406(2)(b) specifically relates to appeal against a rateable value and Sub-clause (d) relates to appeal against any amendment made in the assessment book for property tax. It is not necessary to refer to Sub-clause (d) because that pertains to deposit of tax pending the entertainment of the appeal. Sub-clause (b) and (d), as we have already observed, postulate in relation to property tax appeals being filed only against rateable value. Sub-clause (c) of Section 406(2), no doubt, contemplates filing of an appeal against any tax. But, this sub-clause contemplates an appeal against such a tax in respect of which provisions exist for filing a complaint and the complaint being disposed of. Neither the Act, nor the Rules contemplate any complaint being filed against a bill a property tax and complaints, relating to property tax can only be filed against the rateable value. The Legislative intent, therefore, clearly is that it is only at the first stage, viz., the determination of the rateable value, that the appeals will be entertained and no appeal can be preferred against a bill levying tax as a consequence of the rateable value having been determined. The reason for this is obvious. The sending of a bill levying tax would amount to a mere mathematical calculation on the basis of the rateable value which is determined. If the determination of the rateable value can only be challenged by filing an appeal under Section 406(2)(b) or (d) and the same cannot be challenged once it has become final, then providing for appeal against the tax calculated on the basis of the rateable value would be meaningless.{Para 83}

84. It may happen that the rateable Value I may have been determined in gross violation of the provisions of the Act or the Rules and without following the procedure laid down in the Rules requiring giving the opportunity of filing a complaint by giving a public notice or a special notice. Where an owner has had an occasion or opportunity to file a complaint under the Rules against the proposed rateable value, but he fails to do so, no relief can be granted to him. If, on the other hand, in a rate case, such an opportunity has not at all been afforded, then merely for equitable reasons a Court should not and cannot entertain an appeal against the bill because such a provision does not exist. The appropriate remedy in such a case will be for the owner to take recourse to the constitutional remedies provided by Article 227 or Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

Gujarat High Court
Municipal Corporation Of The City ... vs Oriental Fire & General Insurance ... on 8 September, 1994
Print Page

Under which circumstances tenant can file a municipal appeal against fixation of rateable value?

 

The last question, which requires consideration is whether the occupiers or the tenants have a right of filing a complaint and thereafter, an appeal against the proposed assessments. Under Section 127 of the BPMC Act, various types of taxes are imposed. They are property taxes, and taxes, on vehicles, boats and animals. In addition thereto, the Corporation may also impose octroi, taxes on dogs, theatre tax, toll on animals and vehicles entering the city, etc. Section 406 is a provision, which, inter alia, provides for appeals against any rateable value or tax fixed or charged under this Act. Unlike other statutes, the Section does not specifically state as to who can file an appeal. The locus standi of the appellant will, however, have to be inferred from Sub-section (2) of Section 406. Clause (b) of Section 406(2) states that no appeal shall be entertained in respect of a rateable value unless a complaint has been previously, made to the Commissioner and such complaint has been disposed of. Clause (d) provides that an appeal against an amendment made in the assessment book shall be entertained only if a complaint has been disposed of. The implication of this, clearly, is that a right of appeal is given to such a person, who has a right to file a complaint to the Commissioner against the rateable value. This right to file a complaint is exercised only when, under Rule 16, a complaint is filed. The scheme of the Act and the Rules clearly is that the person primarily liable to pay the property tax is the owner or the lessor. Against the proposed rateable value, it is he, who is the person concerned or the person aggrieved. Rateable value once determiend can be adopted Under Rule 21 for the subsequent years. A tenant may come and go, but it is the owner, who is primarily concerned with the determination of the rateable value. As we have already observed, the Act and the Rules do not contemplate more than one complaint being filed in respect of the same property and for the same year. The Rules cannot be interpreted to lead to a result, where there will be conflicting assessment orders in respect of a single official year for the same property. It is no doubt true that it has been held in a number of cases that a person aggrieved will, certainly, have a right of appeal. But, who is the person aggrieved? In the case of rateable value, it can only be the owner and no one else. Under Section 139(1), the liability to pay the tax is fastened on the owner. The liability of the tenant of built-up premises is there only if tax remains unpaid and a notice under Section 140(1) arises'. Such a tenant, to whom a notice is issued under Section 140(1) may have a right to file an appeal under Section 406(2)(c), or under Section 406(1) itself. But, his right can only be in relation to the correctness of a notice issued under Section 140(1). He cannot challenge the fixation of the rateable value because that can only be challenged by the owner. Like other taxing statutes, direct or indirect, the right to file an appeal is only on the assessee. The fixation of rateable value cannot affect the tenant unless and until a notice under Section 140(1) is received by him. That notice is in the nature of a garnishee order and the payment made by him is not paid on his own account, but is paid on account of the landlord, or owner, and that is why Sub-section (4) of Section 140 provides that for any sum so paid by the occupier, he is entitled to the credit of the amount so paid by him. {Para 80}

81. It was vehemently contended that under Rule 15(2), notice is contemplated to be given to the occupier as well and, therefore, he can also file an appeal. As we have already noticed, the notice under Rule 15(2) to an occupier will necessarily be because of provisions of Rule 12(2). There may also be another category of tenants, who would be entitled to file complaints and receive notice under Rule 15(2). Those tenants would be the ones mentioned in Section 139(2). The said provision provides that if any land has been let for any term exceeding one year to a tenant and such tenant has built upon the land, the property taxes assessed upon the said land and upon the building erected thereon shall be primarily leviable on the said tenant or on any person deriving title through him. Therefore, when in Rule 15(2), reference is made to the owner or the occupier, it contemplates not only an occupier, who becomes liable by virtue of Rule 15(2), but it will also take in its ambit a tenant of land who becomes a person primarily liable to pay tax on the building erected on tenanted land. Because such a tenant is a person primarily liable to pay tax therefore, he will have a right to file an appeal.

82. It was also urged on behalf of the appellants, that the Small Cause Courts have, in some cases, been entertaining appeals against the bills raising the tax demand, even though no complaints had been filed and/or the rateable value had become final. Such appeals were filed by the tenants and, in some cases, by the owners themselves.

83. It is now well-settled that the right to file an appeal is a creation of the statute. Section 406(1) provides of appeals against any rateable value or tax fixed or charged under this Act. Reference to rateable value in Sub-section (1) of Section 406, necessarily, pertains to tax on property. In view of the fact that under Section 127, other taxes such as taxes on vehicles, boats, animals, octroi, etc., are also levied, Sub-section (1) of Section 406 also refers to appeals against "tax fixed or charged" under the Act. Section 406(2)(b) specifically relates to appeal against a rateable value and Sub-clause (d) relates to appeal against any amendment made in the assessment book for property tax. It is not necessary to refer to Sub-clause (d) because that pertains to deposit of tax pending the entertainment of the appeal. Sub-clause (b) and (d), as we have already observed, postulate in relation to property tax appeals being filed only against rateable value. Sub-clause (c) of Section 406(2), no doubt, contemplates filing of an appeal against any tax. But, this sub-clause contemplates an appeal against such a tax in respect of which provisions exist for filing a complaint and the complaint being disposed of. Neither the Act, nor the Rules contemplate any complaint being filed against a bill a property tax and complaints, relating to property tax can only be filed against the rateable value. The Legislative intent, therefore, clearly is that it is only at the first stage, viz., the determination of the rateable value, that the appeals will be entertained and no appeal can be preferred against a bill levying tax as a consequence of the rateable value having been determined. The reason for this is obvious. The sending of a bill levying tax would amount to a mere mathematical calculation on the basis of the rateable value which is determined. If the determination of the rateable value can only be challenged by filing an appeal under Section 406(2)(b) or (d) and the same cannot be challenged once it has become final, then providing for appeal against the tax calculated on the basis of the rateable value would be meaningless.

84. It may happen that the rateable Value I may have been determined in gross violation of the provisions of the Act or the Rules and without following the procedure laid down in the Rules requiring giving the opportunity of filing a complaint by giving a public notice or a special notice. Where an owner has had an occasion or opportunity to file a complaint under the Rules against the proposed rateable value, but he fails to do so, no relief can be granted to him. If, on the other hand, in a rate case, such an opportunity has not at all been afforded, then merely for equitable reasons a Court should not and cannot entertain an appeal against the bill because such a provision does not exist. The appropriate remedy in such a case will be for the owner to take recourse to the constitutional remedies provided by Article 227 or Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

85. In the case of a tenant to whom provisions of Section 139(2) are applicable, an opportunity is required to be given for filing a complaint and in such a case, the question of his filing an appeal only against the bill would not arise. Where, in respect of premises a tenant is required to make payment pursuant to a bill issue under Sub-section (1) of Section 140, the tenant may be a person aggrieved. His grievance, however, cannot be with respect to the rateable value, which is determined after notice is issued to the owner and the tenants grievance can only be limited to the validity of such a bill being issued to him under said Section 140(1). In such a case, as liability is fastened on him, but he had opportunity to challenge the rateable value, an appeal would be maintainable under Sub-section (1) of Section 406 itself. The scope of the appellate jurisdiction in such a case will, however, be very limited. As already observed, there can be no challenge to the fixation of the rateable value and the limited challenge which can be there is with regard to the calculation of the tax on the basis of the rateable value already finalised or when the necessary ingredients of Sub-section (1) of Section 140 exist which could justify the issuance of a bill under that provision.
Gujarat High Court
Municipal Corporation Of The City ... vs Oriental Fire & General Insurance ... on 8 September, 1994
Print Page

Will the reduction of property tax by the Appellate court affect property tax of subsequent year if the commissioner has adopted property tax of that year?

  It was further submitted that any judgment delivered by the Judge in respect of a particular official year, even though such judgment may be delivered after two years, becomes effective and operative retrospectively and would relate back to the commencement of the official years, for which the appeal is decided by the Judge. An example which was given was that if the appeal for 1981-82 was decided on 31st October, 1984, and the rateable value fixed by the Commissioner at Rs.5,000/- was reduced to Rs. 1,500/- then the judgment would have to be given effect to for the year commencing from 1-4-1981 and for all subsequent years notwithstanding that entries are made by the Commissioner, in the meantime, for the assessment years 1982-83, and 1983-84. It was contended that, by virtue of Section 413(2), the original entry of Rs. 5,000/- shall be deemed to have been made at Rs. 1,500/- on account of the effect of the judgment delivered by the Judge for the year 1981-82 and operation of law for the assessment years 1982-83 and 1983-84 the assessment must be regarded as having been reduced to Rs. 1,500/- and then, in respect of those years or future years if the rateable value is to be increased to the figure of Rs. 5,000/- a special written notice, as contemplated by R. 15(2), has to be given. {Para 76}

77. There can be no doubt that according to Rule 21, the entries of the earlier year can be adopted for the subsequent years. Furthermore every rateable value which is fixed, against which appeal is not filed or every appellate order, which becomes final, has to be given effect to. We, are however, unable to agree with the contention of the learned counsel that, in the example given above, by him, for the assessment years 1982-83 and 1983-'84 and onwards, a notice under Rule 15(2) has to be issued, because for the year 1981-'82, the appellate court had reduced the rateable value to Rs. 1,500/- after entries for 1982-'83 and 1983-'84 have been adopted. In the very example, which is given, it is contemplated that the entry for 1981-'82 was finalised after the issuance of a valid notice under Rule 15(2). As long as that entry of Rs. 5,000/- for the year 1981-'82 remains, the same could be adopted by the Commissioner in the subsequent years 1982-'83 and 1983-'84. If after such adoption for the years 1982-'83 and 1983-'84, the appellate court in respect of the assessment year 1981-'82 allows the appeal and reduces the rateable value, the decision in the said appeal can only be regarded as being given for the assessment year 1981-'82. In taxation, each year is to be regarded as distinct and separate. The Act does not postulate that the appellate decision for one year will, ipso facto, be regarded as a decision for the other years as well. As long as appeals have been filed before the Small Cause Court, or to the High Court, the assessment cannot be regarded as having become final.

Gujarat High Court
Municipal Corporation Of The City ... vs Oriental Fire & General Insurance ... on 8 September, 1994
Print Page

Should Municipal Corporation give general particulars like the assessment method in the special notice issued for assessing property tax?

 It was vehemently contended that the special notice, which is issued must mention material particulars, like method of assessment, carpet area, letting rate, as also the reasons for fixing the gross rateable value at a particular figure so that the concerned asses-see can effectively and specifically file his objections and meet with the case of the Tax Department and produce relevant and matching evidence in support of his contentions. {Para 74}

 What are the requirements of a notice which are stipulated in Rule 15(2)? Notice under Section 15(2) is issued after entry in the assesment book has been made. Sub-rule (2) of Rule 15 requires that the special written notice to the owner or the occupier shall specify the nature of such entry. In other words, the special notice must inform the owner about the entries mentioned in Rule 9, Clauses (a), (b), (c) and (d), because the said Rule 15 has to be read with Rules 9 and 13. When a statute specifies as to what should be the contents of a notice, and that is so specified in Rule 15(2), the general principles enunciated by the aforesaid decisions and of other High Courts would not be applicable.

For the purposes of giving an opportunity to an owner or an occupier to file a complaint, all that he has to be informed is what the Commissioner has entered in the assessment book. One of the items, which is entered, is the ratable value. The Commissioner is under no obligation to inform as to how the rateable value, which is entered in the assessment book, has been arrived at. It is for the owner to complain if he finds the rateable value to be high. The principles for fixation of rateable value are well-known. Ordinarily, a rateable value will be arrived at after particulars had been given by the owners or occupiers under Rule 8 of the Rules. On the receipt of the notice, it will be for the complainant to lead evidence and prove as to what should be the correct rateable value. A hearing is contemplated by Rule 18 and if the assessee requires any clarification with regard to the entry made in the assesssment book, we see no reason as to why this clarification would not, ordinarily, be given. Be that as it may, Rule 15(2) docs not require the giving of any particulars in addition to what is stated therein. The aforesaid decisions of various Courts, therefore, can be of no assistance to the respondents. {Para 75}

Gujarat High Court
Municipal Corporation Of The City ... vs Oriental Fire & General Insurance ... on 8 September, 1994
Print Page

Under which circumstances can the court determine the correct rateable value of the property for assessing property tax?

  But, where the principle of waiver does not apply and a notice under Rule 15(2) is not issued and an assessment is made, then after coming to the conclusion that the assessment is a nullity, can the Small Cause Court quash the assessment simpliciter or does it have a duty or jurisdiction to take further action in the matter. {Para 68}

69. The provisions of Rule 20 clearly show that the power of the Commissioner to make changes in the entry can be exercised only during the official year itself. Once this official year is over, the Commissioner will have no jurisdiction to make any alteration. In Anant Mills Co. Ltd. v. Municipal Corporation, Ahmedabad, 1993(2) G. L. H. 897, it was held by a Division Bench of this Court, after examining the scheme of the Act, that the assessment must be completed before the close of the relevant official year and once the official year has expired, the Commissioner cannot assess and levy property tax and, therefore, the Court also cannot issue direction to the Commissioner to do something which was not permissible under the Act. The quashing of the assessment would mean that the Commissioner would not be in a position to reassess and levy property taxes and the taxes for those official years would be totally lost to the Corporation. This being the position, the appellate court cannot and should not set aside the assessment and remand the case for de novo assessment by the Commissioner. Any remand would, obviously, serve no useful purpose.

70. In view of the aforesaid position in law, it was submitted by the learned counsel for the Corporation that in such cases, the Chief Judge or the Judges of the Small Cause Court themselves should determine the rateable value in accordance with law. The counsel for the respondents, however, contended that if the assessment is a nullity, because of non-compliance with the provisions of Rule 15(2), or otherwise, then the Small Cause Court has no option but to quash the assessment, in toto.

71. The principle underlying the judgment in Anant Mill's case clearly answers the aforesaid question in favour of the Corporation. In that case, it had been contended that the Chief Judge has no jurisdiction to entertain the grounds affecting legality of the assessment. It was also submitted in that case, on behalf of the assessee, that if the Chief Judge came to the conclusion that the method of assessment was illogical or irrelevant and the assessment, therefore, invalid, then it would not be competent for the Chief Judge to determine the rateable value afresh by applying the appropriate method in a correct manner. Elaborating further, it was submitted that all that the Chief Judge would be able to do would be to declare the assessment invalid and leave it to the Commissioner to make a fresh assessment according to the correct method and this would, again, result in the Corporation losing the tax altogether. Similar is the contention raised before us, namely, that the assessment is bad as proper procedure is not followed. Rejecting the submission, the Division Bench, in Anant Mills' case, at page 922, observed as follows :--

".....This contention is also, in our opinion, without substance. It ignores the scheme of the provisions in regard to appeals contained in the Act. We have already pointed out that an appeal may be preferred against the rateable value and in this appeal the assessee would challenge the determination of the rateable value made by the Commissioner. He may challenge it on any ground available to him and such ground may well relate to the method of valuation adopted for the purpose of determining the rateable value. It is apparent from the provision in Section 409 Sub-section (1) and particularly the words "before evidence as to value has been adduced" that the appeal against rateable value is in the nature of an original proceeding where evidence as to value may be led by both parties. The Chief Judge may on the application of a party to the appeal appoint a competent person to make the valuation and such person may be called as a witness and if he is so-called, he may be cross-examined by the other side. The evidence as to value which may be adduced before the Chief Judge in the appeal may be based on any method which is regarded by the party or his witness as appropriate. It cannot be restricted to the method of valuation adopted by the Commissioner. So also when a competent person is directed to make a valuation, he may value it according to the method which he regards as proper there is no requirement in the statute that his, valuation must be based on the method adopted by the Commissioner. The entire question as to retable value would be open before the Chief Judge and as contemplated under Section 411 Clause (a), it would be for the Chief Judge to fix the ratable value and the decision of the Chief Judge fixing the ratable value would be final, subject to appeal to the High Court and the Commissioner would be bound to give effect to such decision as provided in Section 413. The whole scheme of the provisions clearly contemplates that in the appeal against the ratable value, the Chief Judge would have to fix the ratable value after considering the evidence as to value which may be adduced before him and it is implicit in this process that he would also have to decide which method of valuation should be adopted. If, therefore, the Chief Judge takes the view that the contractor's test method is inappropriate or inapplicable, he can decide which other method should be adopted and fix the rateable value by applying such method on the basis of the evidence before him."

It was contended by Shri Modi that such a course would be clearly contrary to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Martin Burn Limited v. Calcutta Municipal Corproation, AIR 1966 SC 529 and that if the order of assessment is not valid, because of non-compliance with Rule 15(2), or any other Rule, then the Court would have no jurisdiction to undertake the exercise of fixing the ratable value itself. Similar contention was also raised in Anant Mills case. The Court examined the relevant provisions of the Calcutta Municipal Act, 1928, and compared the same with the provisions of the Bombay Provisional Municipal Corporation Act, and then observed as follows:--

".... This decision given on the basis of a scheme of taxation contained in the Calcutta Act can hardly be of any relevance when we are considering a question arising under a totally different scheme of taxation contained in the Corporation Act. The power of the Court of Small Cause under the Calcutta Act was to cancel the assessment or to revise or alter the valuation and the Supreme Court held that since the method on the basis of which the valuation was made by the Corporation was illegal, the Court of Small Cause could not do anything except cancel the assessment; it would not make an independent valuation itself by adopting the correct method, for that would not be revision or alteration of the valuation. But here under the Corporations Act the power of the Chief Judge in appeal against rateable value is not restricted merely to revision or alteration of the valuation. On the contrary it is a wide power conferred in general terms without any words of limitation. It says that an appeal against the rateable value shall be heard and determined by the Chief Judge. The Chief Judge is empowered to fix the rateable value after considering the evidence a to value adduced before him and the Commissioner is enjoined to give effect to the decision of the Chief Judge. The principles of the decision in Martin Burn's case can, therefore, have no application under the Corporation Act.

30. The result of this discussion is that if we quash and set aside the assessment made by the Deputy Municipal Commissioner on any of these grounds urged on behalf of the petitioners, the tax for the official years 1967-68 and 1968-69 would be lost to the Corporation whereas no such drastic consequence would ensue if these grounds are left to be decided by the Chief Judge in the appeals preferred by the petitioners. The Chief Judge can entertain these grounds and if he is of the view that the contractors method adopted by the Deputy Municipal Commissioner is not proper or relevant to the determination of the annual rental value, he can determine the annual rental value of the premises by applying the appropriate method and the tax can be levied on the petitioners on the basis of such ratable value. The latter alternative would do full justice to the peitioners without causing grave and undue hardship which would inevitably result to the Corporation if the former alternative were adopted. We, therefore, refuse to entertain these grounds in the exercise of our jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution. They can be decided by the Chief Judge in the appeals preferred by the petitiones...."

We are in respectful agreement with the aforesaid observations in Anant Mill's case. Following the said ratio, it would mean that even if the assessment is held to be not in accordance with law, whether because of the wrong method followed with regard to determining the rateable value or because of any irregularity or illegality in procedure or because of violaton of the principles of natural justice or because notice under Rule 15(2) had not been issued, then the Small Cause Court would itself have the jurisdiction to examine evidence and determine the correct rateable value. It would be wholly inappropriate for the Small Cause Court to merely quash the assessment, which would have the effect that for the official years in question, the entire tax would be lost to the Corporation. In effect, the ratio decidendi of the decision in Anant Mills' case is that the Small Cause Court exercises the same power and will have the same jurisdiction, which is exercised by the Commissioner for the purposes of determining what should be the correct rateable value.


Gujarat High Court
Municipal Corporation Of The City ... vs Oriental Fire & General Insurance ... on 8 September, 1994
Print Page

Tuesday, 24 August 2021

Whether court can direct Municipal Corporation to follow a particular method for assessing the property's rateable value?

  So far as first question is concerned, it has to be noted that there are number of methods for arriving at a rateable value such as i) Direct Rental Evidence, ii) Rental Evidence Based on Comparables, iii) Contractor's Test or Standard Rent Theory, iv) Profit Method or Accounting Method and v) Percentage of Gross Takings, a variant of Account Method. The Apex Court in the case of Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay v. Royal Western India Turf Club Ltd. (supra) and Division Bench of this Court in the case of Kantilal Dharsi Desai v. Karmala Nagar Palika and Ors. (supra) have held that discretion was vested with the Corporation to decide which method should be followed for the purpose of assessing rateable value of the property and what was essential was different method to be followed. The rateable value which was arrived at was required to be fair and impartial. Submissions made by the learned Counsel for the appellants, therefore, that "Profit Method" ought to have been adopted by the Corporation, cannot be accepted. Ratio of the judgments on which reliance has been placed by the appellants that "Profit Method" should be adopted, therefore, will not be applicable to the facts of the present case. {Para 8}

Bombay High Court
Pranlal K. Doshi And Ors. vs Municipal Corporation Of Greater ... on 31 October, 2007
Print Page

Sunday, 25 September 2016

Rateable value for payment of property tax is to be fixed on the basis of standard rent

In my opinion, the Small Causes Court has erred in allowing the appeal. The observation of the learned Judge that there can be no distinction in the rateable value payable in respect of commercial premises and residential premises is without any basis. As rightly submitted by Mr.Ketkar, the provisions of Section 129 of the Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporations Act indicate that there can be a distinction drawn between the rates of taxes paid for commercial and residential premises. The rateable value is to be fixed dependent upon the standard rent. It is obvious that the standard rent payable by a tenant in respect of commercial premises and residential premises would be different. The standard rent for commercial premises would obviously be higher and consequently the rateable value for those premises. The learned Judge has erred in accepting Rs.107 as the standard rent for the shop only because that was the standard rent payable in respect of a residential flat in the same building.
Bombay High Court
Pune Municipal Corporation ... vs Dnyaneshwar Nivrutti Narhare on 25 March, 2008
Equivalent citations: 2008 (3) MhLj 853:2008(4) ALLMR375

Bench: Nishita Mhatre, J.
Print Page

Whether rateable value for payment of property tax can be fixed for self occupied premises?

In the case of Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay v/s. Kamla Mills Ltd., (2003) 6 SCC 315, the Supreme Court did not accept the contention of the assessee in that case that no rateable value can be fixed in respect of the premises occupied by the owner himself. The Court observed that the ratable value had to be determined on the basis of what an hypothetical tenant would offer as reasonable rent.
Bombay High Court
Pimpri Chinchwad Municipal ... vs Tata Engineering And Locomotive ... on 11 August, 2009
Bench: Nishita Mhatre
Citation:2009(5) ALLMR 529:2009(5)MHLJ647 Bom
Read full judgment here:click here
Print Page

How to determine rateable value of of property for levy of property taxes?

 In Dr.Balbir Singh & ors. v/s. M/s.M.C.D. & Ors., AIR 1985 SC 339, it was held that the ratable value of a building, whether tenanted or self occupied, is limited by the measure of standard rent arrived at by the assessing authority by applying principles laid down in the Rent Act. It has also been held that the test for determining the standard rent is not what the standard rent actually is but the rent which the owner reasonably expects to receive from an hypothetical tenant. Such expectation cannot go beyond the standard rent.
Bombay High Court
Pimpri Chinchwad Municipal ... vs Tata Engineering And Locomotive ... on 11 August, 2009
Bench: Nishita Mhatre
Citation:2009(5) ALLMR 529:2009(5)MHLJ647 Bom
Read full judgment here:click here
Print Page

Basic concept of contractors' method of valuation of property for payment of property taxes

 In the case of Godhara Borough Municipality, Godhara v/s. Godhara Electricity Co. Ltd., AIR 1968 SC 1504, the Supreme Court has described the contractors' method of calculating the valuation of a property thus:
9. Rule 4 of Godhra Municipal Rules shows what properties are to be valued on the capital basis. What the capital basis is not defined. The capital value however can be determined in the way laid down in Gordhandas's case, (1964) 2 SCR 608 = (AIR 1963 SC 1742) (supra) by adopting the contractor's method. What that method is has been explained in Ryde on Rating (Eleventh Edition) Chapter 20. In R. v. School Board for London, (1885) 55 LJMC 33 on appeal (1886) 17 QBD 733 Cave, J. applied the contractor's test to schools. Ryde points out that it was tacitly recognised as applicable in various other cases. The principle on which the contractor's basis rests are given by the author at page 439 and the method of its applications is given at page 442. The learned author notes that in "applying the contractor's basis it is possible to discern five stages. The first stage is the estimation of the cost of construction of the building." There is a difference of view as to whether it is better to take the cost of replacing the actual building but otherwise in an up- to-date form. The second stage is "to make deductions from the cost of construction to allow for age, obsolescence and any other factors necessary to arrive at the effective capital value". The third stage is to estimate the cost of the land. The fourth stage is to apply the market rate or rates at which money can be borrowed or invested to the effective capital value of the building and the land. The fifth stage is to consider whether the result of the fourth stage really represents what the hypothetical tenant would pay for the annual tenancy on the statutory terms and to make any adjustments necessary to ensure that no higher rent is fixed as the basis of assessments than that which it is believed the owner would really be willing to pay for the occupation of the premises.
10. The contractors' method of calculation of the ratable value has thus been approved by the Supreme Court. In the present case, the Corporation has calculated the annual letting value at 8% of the cost of construction. In the case of Century Spinning and Manufacturing Co. ltd. And Ors. v/s. District Municipality of Ulhasnagar & Ors., AIR 1968 SC 859, the Supreme Court observed that a municipal Corporation can arrive at the annual letting value by choosing one or the other of the recognised methods, the only restriction being that it must specify the method which it proposes to adopt for the purposes of calculation of the amount.
Bombay High Court
Pimpri Chinchwad Municipal ... vs Tata Engineering And Locomotive ... on 11 August, 2009
Bench: Nishita Mhatre
Citation:2009(5) ALLMR 529:2009(5)MHLJ647 Bom
Print Page

Sunday, 28 August 2016

Whether cost of plant or machinery fixed in building can be included for determination of rateable value of building?

In the result, we allow the appeals and hold as under :-
(1) Sections 116(3) is declared invalid as it delegates unguided and uncanalised legislative powers to the Commissioner to declare any plant or machinery as part of land or building for the purpose of determination of the rateable value thereof;
(2) The cost of plant or machinery, lifts and air conditioners fixed on the land or building of the appellant in question shall not be liable to be included for the determination of the rateable value of the land or building;
(3) The decisions in Pragati Builders (supra) and that of the Full Bench of the High Court under appeal do not lay down the law correctly. Consequently, they are hereby over ruled (4) The appeals are accordingly allowed and impugned judgments of the High Court are set aside. The impugned assessment orders are set aside and remitted to the assessing authority under the DMC Act for passing orders afresh in accordance with law and the observations made in the judgment.
Supreme Court of India
Krishna Mohan Pvt. Ltd vs Municipal Corporation Of Delhi ... on 28 July, 2003
Bench: Ruma Pal, B.N. Srikrishna
           CASE NO.:
Appeal (civil)  3312 of 2000
Citation:2003 AIR SCW3399:2003(5)Scale237:
2003(4) supreme 530
Print Page

Whether burden to show that fixation of rateable value by commissioner is unreasonable is on assessee?

In the result, though we accept the proposition urged by the respondent that in the facts of the present case the standard rent would be the limit of the rateable value, we find that there was no material produced on record at any stage by the respondent to show what the standard rent was either in respect of the vacant land or in respect of the land on which the building was constructed and demolished, or in respect of the building after it was constructed. We accept the contention of the appellant that the hurden of proving this fact, while objecting to the rateable value fixed by the Commissioner, is always on the respondent-assessee. We also accept the contention of the appellant that the respondent was less than fair to the appellant in not disclosing that its property had been occupied by National Stock Exchange of India Ltd. and National Security Depository Ltd. and in not disclosing the amounts paid by them. The respondent ought to have disclosed the fact, fairly and fully, and urged the legal contentions open to it based thereupon. These facts would have justified our allowing the appeal fully and restoring the assessment orders made by the appellant officers. However, we are not inclined to do so for the reason that the attention of the parties has not been focused on the core issue, as a result of which, perhaps, there was failure to produce relevant material before the assessor to show what was the standard rent. The interests of justice would require that the issue be reconsidered after giving an opportunity to the respondent to discharge the burden placed upon it under law.
Supreme Court of India
Municipal Corporation Of Greater ... vs Kamla Mills Ltd on 11 July, 2003
Bench: Ruma Pal, B.N. Srikrishna
           CASE NO.:
Appeal (civil)  2452 of 2000

Citation:2003 AIR SCW3399:2003(5)Scale237:
2003(4) supreme 530
Print Page