Showing posts with label unregistered agreement of sell. Show all posts
Showing posts with label unregistered agreement of sell. Show all posts

Sunday, 25 September 2022

Whether the court can refuse to grant relief of permanent injunction if it is claimed on the basis of unregistered agreement of sell?

Having conscious of the fact that the plaintiff might not succeed in

getting the relief of specific performance of such agreement to sell as the same was unregistered, the plaintiff filed a suit simplicitor for permanent injunction only. It may be true that in a given case, an unregistered document can be used and/or considered for collateral purpose. However, at the same time, the plaintiff cannot get the relief indirectly which otherwise he/she cannot get in a suit for substantive relief, namely, in the present case the relief for specific performance.

Therefore, the plaintiff cannot get the relief even for permanent injunction on the basis of such an unregistered document/agreement to sell, more particularly when the defendant specifically filed the counter-claim for getting back the possession which was allowed by the learned trial Court. The plaintiff cleverly prayed for a relief of permanent injunction only and did not seek for the substantive relief of specific performance of the agreement to sell as the agreement to sell was an unregistered document and therefore on such unregistered document/agreement to sell, no decree for specific performance could have been passed. The

plaintiff cannot get the relief by clever drafting.

7. In view of the above and for the reasons stated above, both, the

learned first appellate Court and the High Court have committed a grave error in passing a decree for permanent injunction in favour of the plaintiff as against the defendant and dismissing the counter-claim filed by the original defendant. {Para 6}

 REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 6733 OF 2022

Balram Singh  Vs Kelo Devi 

Author: M.R. SHAH, J.

Dated: SEPTEMBER 23, 2022.
Print Page

Sunday, 24 March 2019

Whether court can grant decree for specific performance on contract on basis of insufficiently and unregistered agreement of sale if it is exhibited?

 It is also settled that receiving a document in evidence and its admissibility under the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 and the Registration Act, 1908 are different matters. A document, which is not required to be stamped or registered stands on a different footing after the same was received in evidence, but a document which requires to be sufficiently stamped and registered before it is made admissible in evidence would not be made admissible in evidence merely because it is exhibited and received in evidence. For such document marking of exhibit is only for convenience and it does not decide the admissibility of the document. Holding it otherwise would make the provisions of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 and the Registration Act, 1908 redundant and the Court's would allow decree for specific performance on the basis of documents which are not enforceable.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR

FA No. 87 of 2012

Decided On: 22.02.2019

 Mahadev Singh Vs.  Bihari Lal Sanadaya

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Prashant Kumar Mishra and Vimla Singh Kapoor, JJ.

Print Page

Sunday, 30 December 2018

Whether terms of registered agreement of sale can be varied by unregistered document?

The reliance of the counsel for plaintiff on the judgment of M/s. A. R.C. Overseas Pvt. Limited (2008 (2) All LJ 663) (supra) and the judgement of Hamda Ammal (supra) for the purpose of substantiating his argument that unregistered document can be admitted in evidence for collateral purpose, it is required to be stated that unregistered receipts, paper Nos. 77ka/1 and 78ka/1, were not the documents to be received in evidence for collateral purpose but these documents varied the terms of the original agreement to sell between the parties and therefore, they did not served any collateral purpose but were direct evidence, evidencing variation of the terms of contract, of a registered document and the terms of a registered document cannot be varied by a unregistered document executed in future.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD

Second Appeal No. 64 of 2001

Decided On: 02.07.2018

 Shanti Mishra  Vs. Samuel

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Siddhartha Varma, J.

Citation: AIR 2019 ALL 242
Print Page

Saturday, 16 June 2018

Whether suit for specific performance is maintainable on basis of unregistered agreement of sale?

This decision has been followed by a Ld. Single Judge of this Court in
Vinod Kumar v. Ajit Singh (2013) 138 DRJ 324 where the Court held
“10. In the instant case, the plaintiff has not sought
relief based on part performance under Section 53A of
the Transfer of Property Act and that being so, Section
17(1A) of the Registration Act, which was only meant
for the provisions of Section 53A of the Transfer of
Property Act, was not attracted and thus, the
agreement did not require registration. Such an
agreement falls under the mischief of Section 17(2)(v)
of the Registration Act, and it itself does not create,
declare, assign, limit or extinguish any right, title or
interest in the property. Rather as held in Sukhwinder
Kaur (supra) it creates a right to obtain another
document which will, when executed, create, declare,
assign, limit or extinguish right, title or interest in the
property. Not only this, provisions of Section 49 of the
Registration Act make the position more clear. It
envisages that an unregistered document affecting
immovable property and required by this Act and the
Transfer of Property Act to be registered may be
received as evidence of a contract in a suit for specific
performance under Chapter -II of Specific Relief Act,
1877. As further held in Sukhwinder Kaur (supra), a
conjoint reading of Section 17(2)(v) and proviso of
Section 49 of the Act leaves no room for doubt that
agreement to sell property itself does not create any 
right or title over the property. It is the sale deed,
which when executed will create such right in the
property. Hence, an agreement to sell is not required
to be registered and the same is receivable in evidence
in a suit for specific performance under Chapter-II of
the Specific Relief Act, 1877.”
24. Based on the above judgments it is clear that it is permissible in law to
seek specific performance of an unregistered agreement to sell, when
possession of the property has not been handed over. 

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 22nd May, 2018
 RFA 700/2016 & CM APPL. 44927/2017

RISHI RAJ & ORS  Vs  RAKESH YADAV 

CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
Print Page

Saturday, 13 January 2018

Whether doctrine of part performance as per S 53A of transfer of property Act can be used by plaintiff as shield?

 The first contention raised by learned advocate Mr. Vimal Purohit is that the suit agreement requires to be registered compulsorily in view of the provisions contained under Section 17(aa) of the Registration Act. Since, it is not registered, it cannot be admitted in evidence as provided under Section 49 of the Registration Act. It is true that the agreement to sale is required to be registered as per amended Section 17(aa) of the Registration Act. Since there is no corresponding amendment in Section 49 of the Registration Act, the suit of the plaintiff would not fail on the ground of non-registration of the agreement to sale. Even otherwise, document, required to be registered, if unregistered, can be admitted in evidence as evidence of contract in a suit for specific performance. Thus, unregistered agreement can be used as an evidence of collateral purpose as provided in proviso to Section 49 of the Registration Act. Therefore, it is neither appropriate nor necessary to consider the contention raised by learned advocate Mr. Vimal Purohit about maintainability of the suit as framed by the plaintiff. If any issue in that regard is settled by the learned trial Court, obviously, such issue would be decided in accordance with law. There is no doubt in the mind of this Court that the sale agreement by itself does not create any interest or charge in the immovable property. In the case of Suraj Lamp & Industries Pvt. Ltd. (supra), the Hon'ble Apex Court has held that the immovable property can be legally and lawfully transferred/conveyed only by registered deed of conveyance. While holding so, the Hon'ble Apex Court held that observations regarding SA/GPA/WILL transactions are not intended to apply to such bona fide/genuine transactions. Therefore, contention raised by learned advocate Mr. Purohit that doctrine of part performance incorporated in Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act can be pressed into service only as a defence and the holder of agreement of contract cannot file a suit against the transferor in respect of the suit property for any purpose, cannot be accepted. Scrutiny of Section 53A of the Transfer of Property Act would indicate that when necessary conditions for application of the provisions are fulfilled, the transferor or any person claiming under him is debarred from enforcing against the transferee or any person claiming under him any right in respect of the property in question, even though, required to be registered, is not registered or where there is an instrument of transfer, the transfer is not legally complete. So, attempt on the part of learned advocate Mr. Purohit is to drive the Court to hold that the transferee can use the unregistered deed as shield only as a defendant and not as a plaintiff would defeat the very spirit of Section 53A for it will be possible for an over-powering transferor to forcibly dispossess the transferee even against the covenants in the contract and compel him to go to the court as a plaintiff. If the right as a shield is available to the transferee as a defendant, there is no justification that it would be denied to the transferee even if by force of circumstances, he is compelled to approach the Court as a plaintiff to use that shield.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

Appeal From Order No. 457 of 2016 and Civil Application No. 12575 of 2016 in Appeal From Order No. 457 of 2016

Decided On: 10.01.2017

Ghnshyambhai Dhirubhai Barvaliya Vs. Rasikbhai Dhirubhai Ambaliya and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.H. Vora, J.
Citation: AIR 2017 Gujarat 164
Print Page

Sunday, 8 January 2017

Whether suit for specific performance of contract based on unregistered document is maintainable?

 The next submission of the Learned Counsel appearing on

behalf   of   the   Appellants   was   that   the   suit   in   question   for   specific
performance is based on a document which is unregistered and executed
on a Rs.20/­ stamp paper and therefore was not maintainable having
regard   to   Section   49   of   the   Registration   Act.   In   so   far   as   the   said
contention is concerned, it is required to be noted that the proviso to
Section 49 itself carves out an exception in respect of a suit for specific
performance. The said proviso reads thus :­ 
“49. Effect of non­registration of documents required to
be registered. ­ No document required by section 17 [or by
any provision of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882,] to be
registered shall­ 
(a) …......
(b)............
(c).................
[Provided   that   an   unregistered   document   affecting
immovable   property   and   required   by   this   Act,   or   the
Transfer of Property Act, 1882, to be registered may be
received as evidence  of  a contract in  a suit  for   specific
performance under Chapter II of the Specific Relief Act,
1877,   or   as   evidence   of   any   collateral   transaction   not
required to be effected by registered instrument.]” 
In the light of the proviso, there is no substance in the said contention.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
FIRST APPEAL NO.795 OF 2016
ALONGWITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.2212 OF 2014

Sham Pundlalik Dhumatkar 
V
 Smt. Pushpa Mohanlal Talreja  
CORAM  :  R.M. SAVANT, J.


Dated  : 09.08.2016
Citation:2016(6) MHLJ736
Print Page

Sunday, 11 December 2016

Whether suit for specific performance of contract is maintainable on the basis of unregistered agreement of sell?

 The next submission of the Learned Counsel appearing on

behalf   of   the   Appellants   was   that   the   suit   in   question   for   specific
performance is based on a document which is unregistered and executed
on a Rs.20/­ stamp paper and therefore was not maintainable having
regard   to   Section   49   of   the   Registration   Act.   In   so   far   as   the   said
contention is concerned, it is required to be noted that the proviso to
Section 49 itself carves out an exception in respect of a suit for specific
performance. The said proviso reads thus :­ 
“49. Effect of non­registration of documents required to
be registered. ­ No document required by section 17 [or by
any provision of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882,] to be
registered shall­ 
(a) …......
(b)............
(c).................
[Provided   that   an   unregistered   document   affecting
immovable   property   and   required   by   this   Act,   or   the
Transfer of Property Act, 1882, to be registered may be
received as evidence  of  a contract in  a suit  for   specific
performance under Chapter II of the Specific Relief Act,
1877,   or   as   evidence   of   any   collateral   transaction   not
required to be effected by registered instrument.]” 
In the light of the proviso, there is no substance in the said contention. 
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
FIRST APPEAL NO.795 OF 2016
ALONGWITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.2212 OF 2014
ALONGWITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.2364 OF 2015
 Sham Pundlalik Dhumatkar 
V
Smt. Pushpa Mohanlal Talreja  
CORAM  :  R.M. SAVANT, J.

JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED ON  : 09.08.2016
Citation: 2016(6)MHLJ 736
Print Page

Saturday, 23 July 2016

When bonafide purchaser is entitled to retain property in suit for specific performance of contract?


The last contention urged is whether Defendant Nos. 12 to 15 (the Appellants herein) are protected Under Section 19(b) of the Specific Relief Act as they being the bona fide purchasers. Learned Counsel for Defendant Nos. 12 to 15 has rightly invited our attention that the non-compliance of the contract regarding payment of balance consideration to Defendant Nos. 1 to 11 on the part of the Plaintiff within nine months is an undisputed fact and further the agreement of sale is not registered, as is evidenced from the encumbrance certificate obtained by Defendant Nos. 12 to 15 before they entered into an agreement (Exhibit B-1). Both the Courts below have erroneously recorded an erroneous finding on the non existent fact holding that the agreement of sale in favour of the Plaintiff is a registered document which, in fact, is not true. The same is evidenced from the encumbrance certificate. More so, Defendant Nos. 12 to 15 before entering into the agreement with Defendant Nos. 1 to 11 have made proper verification from the competent authority to purchase the part of the suit schedule property and got the agreement of sale (Exhibit B-1) executed in their favour, from Defendant Nos. 1 to 11 and thereafter, they got the sale deed registered by paying sale consideration amount. As could be seen from the agreement of sale and registered sale deed, which is marked as Exhibit B-3, it is very clear that Defendant Nos. 12 to 15 have paid the sale consideration amount of the property, therefore, the reliance placed upon Section 19(b) of the Specific Relief Act as they being the bona fide purchasers, the specific performance of contract cannot be enforced against the transferees. Defendant Nos. 12 to 15 being the transferee as they have purchased the suit schedule property for value and have paid the money in good faith and without notice of the original contract.
In view of the aforesaid facts, the purchase of the suit schedule property by Defendant Nos. 12 to 15 for a valuable consideration is established by the above Defendants by adducing evidence on their behalf before the trial court. Both the Courts below have omitted to consider this important piece of pleadings as also the material evidence on record thereby the concurrent finding recorded on the contentious issues has been rendered erroneous in law and is liable to be set aside. Accordingly, we answer the said issues in favour of Defendant Nos. 12 to 15.
Equivalent Citation : 2016 (2)MhLj 307
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Civil Appeal No. 3570 of 2015 (Arising out of S.L.P. (C) No. 1169 of 2008)
Decided On: 07.04.2015
Appellants: Padmakumari and Ors.
Vs.
Respondent: Dasayyan and Ors.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:V. Gopala Gowda and C. Nagappan, JJ.


Print Page

Sunday, 8 May 2016

Whether suit for specific performance of contract can be decreed on the basis of unregistered agreement of sale?

To the aforesaid principles, one more
principle may be added, namely, that a
document required to be registered, if
unregistered, can be admitted in evidence as
evidence of a contract in a suit for specific
performance.
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH, PRINCIPAL
SEAT AT JABALPUR
First Appeal No.323/2014
Akshay Doogad ..…. Appellant
Versus
State of M.P. and others ……Respondents

CORAM:
Hon'ble Shri Justice A. M. Khanwilkar, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Justice J. K. Maheshwari, Judge

 (18/8/2015)
Citation; AIR 2016 MP83

Print Page

Saturday, 9 April 2016

Whether decree for specific performance of contract can be granted on the basis of unregistered agreement of sell?

The aforesaid evidence shows that the plaintiff gave
evidence to prove both the documents. Though the agreement was not
registered, there is a separate evidence of agreement of sale and
payment of consideration. For collateral purpose, these documents can
be used.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY.
BENCH AT AURANGABAD.
SECOND APPEAL NO. 132 OF 2015
 Shakuntala W/o Yeshwant Bhujange,

VERSUS
 Chandrakant S/o Hiraman Bhujange,

 CORAM : T. V. NALAWADE, J.
 DATE : 30TH SEPTEMBER, 2015.
Citation; 2016(2) ALLMR342

Print Page

Friday, 6 February 2015

Whether decree for specific performance of contract can be granted on the basis of unregistered contract of sale?

This Court then culled out the following principles:-
“1. A document required to be registered, if
unregistered is not admissible into evidence
under Section 49 of the Registration Act.
2. Such unregistered document can however be
used as an evidence of collateral purpose as
provided in the proviso to Section 49 of the
Registration Act.
3. A collateral transaction must be independent
of, or divisible from, the transaction to effect
which the law required registration.
4. A collateral transaction must be a transaction
not itself required to be effected by a
registered document, that is, a transaction
creating, etc. any right, title or interest in
immovable property of the value of one
hundred rupees and upwards.
5. If a document is inadmissible in evidence for want
of registration, none of its terms can be admitted
in evidence and that to use a document for the
purpose of proving an important clause would not
be using it as a collateral purpose.”
To the aforesaid principles, one more principle may be added,
namely, that a document required to be registered, if unregistered,
can be admitted in evidence as evidence of a contract in a suit for
specific performance.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 3192 OF 2010
[Arising out of SLP (C) No. 1451 of 2009]
S. Kaladevi Vs. V.R. Somasundaram & Ors. 
Citation;2010(5) MHLJ SC320
R.M. LODHA,J.
Read orginal judgment here; click here
Print Page