Showing posts with label gratuitous licensee. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gratuitous licensee. Show all posts

Saturday, 6 March 2021

Questions and answers on law part 20

Q 1:-  What is transit bail and when court should grant it?

Ans:- A transit bail is a bail granted by a Court not having jurisdiction over the place where offence was committed.

The purpose of transit anticipatory bail is to grant bail to a person till the time he/she reaches the appropriate Court so that in case the police wants to effect the arrest, the person will be released on bail. However, such bail is given at the condition that the accused has to cooperate in the investigation throughout the ongoing investigative process.

Q. 2:- Whether court can grant interim compensation as per O 15A of CPC(Maharashtra amendment) if eviction suit is filed against gratuitous licensee?

Ans: In case reported in AIR 2007 Bombay 83 Radheshyam v\s Tuljaprasad Honble Bombay High court has taken a view that the the provisions of order 15 A of C.P.C. would come into play only when there is prima facie evidence to show that the rent or licence fees was agreed between the parties.

In case of gratuitous licensee, there is no any fixed amount payable. Therefore no question of grant of interim compensation..

Q 3:-  Whether court should send order of cancellation of registered will to sub registrar?

Ans:- S 31 of specific relief Act,

(1) Any person against whom a written instrument is void or voidable, and who has reasonable apprehension that such instrument, if left outstanding may cause him serious injury, may sue to have it adjudged void or voidable; and the court may, in its discretion, so adjudge it and order it to be delivered up and cancelled.


(2) If the instrument has been registered under the Indian Registration Act, 1908 (16 of 1908), the court shall also send a copy of its decree to the officer in whose office the instrument has been so registered; and such officer shall note on the copy of the instrument contained in his books the fact of its cancellation.
Hence As will is registered, court should send it to sub-registrar.


Print Page

Sunday, 22 November 2020

Whether the Small cause court can grant reconnection of electric supply or water supply to the occupant of premises if he is gratuitous licensee as per landlord?

Mr. Vora further submitted that section 29 of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999 cannot be invoked by the Petitioners since they are not tenants or subtenants but they are mere gratuitous licensee and hence, no relief could have been granted in their favour even by the Trial Court. Mr. Vora, therefore, submitted that the Appeal was rightly allowed by the Appellate Court and prays for dismissal of this Writ Petition.

13. I have carefully considered the rival contentions and I am inclined to partly set aside the impugned orders for the following reasons :

i The fact that the Petitioners are in physical possession of the suit premises is not in dispute. In fact the Trial Court and the Appellate Court have both recorded a finding of fact in that respect. The very fact that the Respondent Defendant has now filed L.E. & C. Suit No. 91/120 of 2011 for possession clearly shows that the Petitioners herein are in physical possession. In this situation the law is well established that a person in possession of immovable property even when his possession is wrongful, cannot be dispossessed without following due procedure prescribed by law and there is series of Judgments of the Supreme Court and other High Courts who have taken this view. The learned Judge of the Trial Court had rightly granted an injunction that Plaintiffs could not be dispossessed by the Defendant without following due process of law and virtually no reason is given by the learned Judges of the Appellate Court as to why even this injunction has been set aside.


ii In so far as electricity supply is concerned, the Trial Court had rightly observed that the Plaintiffs can obtain any independent electricity supply from BEST or other service provider but after having observed this, the Trial Court ought to have moulded the relief in such a manner that it's observations in paragraph 13 of the impugned Judgment are capable of being implemented. This is not done by the Trial Court.


iii In so far as the Judgment of the Appellate Court is concerned, once having found that the Plaintiffs are in physical possession even when the Appellate Court was justified in observing that the nature of possession and the status of the Plaintiffs was in doubt, even without having regard to the provisions of section 29 of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999, the Appellate Bench has overlooked the provisions of section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 which reserves inherent power with the Court and provides that nothing in the Code shall be deemed to limit or otherwise affect the inherent power of the Court to make such orders as may be necessary for the ends of justice, or to prevent abuse of the process of the Court.

(Emphasis supplied)

iv If the Petitioners are in physical possession of the suit premises, which fact is accepted even before me by the learned Advocate for the Respondent during the course of the argument, then one fails to understand as to why they should be deprived of electricity and water supply which is absolutely bare necessity and essential for even the basic day-to-day life in the modern world. This aspect is completely overlooked by the learned Judges of the Appellate Court. Merely because the documents which were relied upon by the Plaintiffs at the time of hearing of the interim application were not sufficient to establish a plea of tenancy, the Appellate Court could not have overlooked the fact that the suit is yet to be tried and the evidence is yet to be led. At the prima facie stage, the material available on the record was sufficient to infer at least one thing that the Plaintiffs were in exclusive physical possession of the suit premises and also that the said possession of the Petitioners is not a forcible possession and even the Defendant has not raised a plea that just prior to the filing of the suit, the Plaintiffs have forcibly entered the suit premises. This being the state of affairs, in my opinion, learned Judges of the Appellate Court have committed a manifest error in interfering with the Judgment of the Trial Court.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 7315 of 2011

Decided On: 18.10.2011


 Hansa Bhaskar Dave Vs. Harihar Himmatlal Mehta


Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

G.S. Godbole, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/1339/2011,2012(1) Mh.LJ630

Print Page

Monday, 2 October 2017

Whether daughter in law can file counter claim under domestic violence Act before small cause court?


The Appellant got married with son of the Respondent. The Appellant started residing in the suit flat alongwith her husband. The flat was allotted to the Respondent by the Society. A daughter was born from their wedlock. The husband of Appellant left her at the suit flat and shifted to live with his parent. The Respondent along with his wife had been residing in another flat nearby. The Appellant was treated with cruelty by her husband and other members of the family. A suit for divorce on the basis of cruelty was filed by the Appellant against her husband. A notice was sent on behalf of the Respondent to the Appellant revoking the gratuitous licence and asking the Appellant to stop the use and occupation of the suit flat. The Appellant replied the notice. The Respondent filed suit in the Small Causes Court. The Appellant filed a written statement in the suit pleading that she was residing in the suit flat along with her husband and daughter. Her husband who was also residing along with her left her to live with the Respondent. It was pleaded that suit flat was intended to be used by the joint family as a joint family property and although the agreement of purchase of the suit flat bore the name of the Respondent, the suit flat was used as joint family property. The allegation that Respondent was the sole owner of the flat was denied. The Respondent/Plaintiff filed an application Under Section 9A (Maharashtra Amendment) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. In the application, the Respondent claimed that declaration sought by the Appellant in the suit was not maintainable, hence, a preliminary issue Under Section 9A of Code of Civil Procedure be framed. The application was objected by the Appellant. The Appellant claimed that since she had been subjected to domestic violence she was entitled for the reliefs sought by way of counter claim as provided in the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (Act, 2005). It was contended that the reliefs sought by way of counter claim were not barred as per Section 15 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, 1887 (Act, 1887). The Trial Court framed preliminary issue "as to whether the Court has jurisdiction to entertain the counter claim". Judge Small Causes Court held that Court had no jurisdiction to entertain the counter claim. Revision was filed against the order passed by the Small Causes Court before the District Judge. The District Judge rejected the revision which order was challenged by the Appellant by means of writ petition which was dismissed by judgment. The High Court held that in view of the express language in Section 15 as also the Second Schedule of Act, 1887, the Small Causes Court constituted under Act, 1887 cannot entertain and try the counter claim. Aggrieved by the order of the High Court, the Appellant filed the present appeal. 


(i) The Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, 1887 was enacted to consolidate and amend the law relating to Courts of Small Causes established beyond the Presidency-towns. The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 has been enacted to provide for more effective protection of the rights of women guaranteed under the Constitution who are victims of violence of any kind occurring within the family and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto. Act, 2005 was enacted by the Parliament to give effect to various international conventions. There cannot be any dispute that proceeding before the Judge, Small Causes Court is a legal proceeding and the Judge, Small Causes Court is a civil court. On the strength of Section 26 any relief available Under Section 18 to 22 of Act, 2005, thus, can also be sought by the aggrieved person. [13],[17] and[20]

(ii) "Notwithstanding anything contained elsewhere in this Act" as used in Section 26(1) of Act, 1887 are words of expression of the widest amplitude engulfing the contrary provisions contained in the Act. The suit in question was filed by the Plaintiff for enforcement of his right as a licensor after allegedly terminating the gratuitous licence of the Appellant. On a plain reading Item No. 11 of Schedule II covers determination or enforcement of any such right or interest in immovable property. But by virtue of Section 26 Sub-section (1) as applicable in State of Maharashtra, Item No. 11 of Schedule 2 has to give way to Section 26(1) and a suit between licensor and licensee which is virtually a suit for recovery of immovable property is fully maintainable in Judge, Small Causes Court that is why the suit was instituted by the Plaintiff in the Judge, Small Causes Court claiming the right and interest in the immovable property. [29]

(iii) When the suit filed by the Plaintiff for determination or enforcement of his right as a licensor can be taken cognizance by Judge, Small Causes Court the relief claimed by the Appellant in the Court of Small Causes within the meaning of Section 26 of Act. 2005 can be considered by the Judge, Small Causes Court. In facts of the present case, the bar and embargo under Item No. 11 of Schedule II read with Section 15 of Act, 1887 stand whittled down and engulfed by virtue of Section 26 Sub-section (1) as applicable in the State. [30]

(iv) Section 26 of the Act, 2005 has to be interpreted in a manner to effectuate the very purpose and object of the Act. Unless the determination of claim by an aggrieved person seeking any order as contemplated by Act, 2005 is expressly barred from consideration by a civil court, this Court shall be loath to read in bar in consideration of any such claim in any legal proceeding before the civil court. When the proceeding initiated by Plaintiff in the Judge, Small Causes Court alleged termination of gratuitous licence of the Appellant and prays for restraining the Appellant from using the suit flat and permit the Plaintiff to enter and use the flat, the right of residence as claimed by the Appellant is inter-connected with such determination and refusal of consideration of claim of the Appellant as raised in her counter claim shall be nothing but denying consideration of claim as contemplated by Section 26 of the Act, 2005 which shall lead to multiplicity of proceeding, which can not be the object and purpose of Act, 2005. The counter claim filed by the Appellant before Judge, Small Causes Court was fully entertainable and courts below committed error in refusing to consider such claim. The judgment of the High Court and order of Small Causes Court as well as judgment of the District Judge were set aside. 
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 6448 of 2017 
Decided On: 09.05.2017

Vaishali Abhimanyu Joshi Vs. Nanasaheb Gopal Joshi

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
A.K. Sikri and Ashok Bhushan, JJ.
Citation: (2017) 14 SCC 373.

Print Page