Showing posts with label judgment writing tips. Show all posts
Showing posts with label judgment writing tips. Show all posts

Friday, 23 August 2024

Supreme Court Judgment writing tip: A judgment of the Court must not contain the Judge's personal opinions or his advise

JUDGMENT


13. When a Court deals with an appeal against an order of conviction, the judgment must contain (i) a concise statement of the facts of the case, (ii) the nature of the evidence adduced by the prosecution and the defence, if any, (iii) the submissions made by the parties, (iv) the analysis based on the reappreciation of evidence, and (v) the reasons for either confirming the guilt of the Accused or for acquitting the Accused. The appellate court must scan through the evidence, both oral and documentary, and reappreciate it. After reappreciating the evidence, the appellate court must record reasons for either accepting the evidence of the prosecution or for disbelieving the evidence of the prosecution. The Court must record reasons for deciding whether the charges against the Accused have been proved. In a given case, if the conviction is confirmed, the Court will have to deal with the legality and adequacy of the sentence. In such a case, there must be a finding recorded on the legality and adequacy of the sentence with reasons. The ultimate object of writing a judgment is to ensure that the parties before the Court know why the case is decided in their favour or against them. Therefore, judgment must be in a simple language. The conclusions recorded by the Court in the judgment on legal or factual issues must be supported by cogent reasons.


14. No doubt, the Court can always comment upon the conduct of the parties. However, the findings regarding the conduct of the parties must be confined only to such conduct which has a bearing on the decision-making. A judgment of the Court cannot contain the Judge's personal opinions on various subjects. Similarly, advisory jurisdiction cannot be exercised by the Court by incorporating advice to the parties or advice in general. The Judge has to decide a case and not preach. The judgment cannot contain irrelevant and unnecessary material. A judgment must be in simple language and should not be verbose. Brevity is the hallmark of quality judgment. We must remember that judgment is neither a thesis nor a piece of literature. However, we find that the impugned judgment contains personal opinion of the Judges advice to the younger generation and advice to the legislature.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Suo Motu Writ Petition (C) No. 3 of 2023 and Criminal Appeal No. 1451 of 2024

Decided On: 20.08.2024

In Re: Right to Privacy of Adolescents

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Abhay Shreeniwas Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan, JJ.

Author: Abhay Shreeniwas Oka, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/0904/2024.

Print Page

Thursday, 25 April 2024

Supreme Court: Conviction of accused will be vitiated if the court fails to consider and either accept or refuse defence of accused taken U/S 313 of CRPC by giving reasons in writing

Section 313, Code of Criminal Procedure cannot be seen simply as a part of audi alteram partem. It confers a valuable right upon an Accused to establish his innocence and can well be considered beyond a statutory right as a constitutional right to a fair trial Under Article 21 of the Constitution, even if it is not to be considered as a piece of substantive evidence, not being on oath Under Section 313(2), Code of Criminal Procedure The importance of this right has been considered time and again by this Court, but it yet remains to be applied in practice as we shall see presently in the discussion to follow. If the Accused takes a defence after the prosecution evidence is closed, Under Section 313(1)(b) Code of Criminal Procedure the Court is duty bound Under Section 313(4) Code of Criminal Procedure to consider the same. The mere use of the word 'may' cannot be held to confer a discretionary power on the court to consider or not to consider such defence, since it constitutes a valuable right of an Accused for access to justice, and the likelihood of the prejudice that may be caused thereby. Whether the defence is acceptable or not and whether it is compatible or incompatible with the evidence available is an entirely different matter. If there has been no consideration at all of the defence taken Under Section 313 Code of Criminal Procedure, in the given facts of a case, the conviction may well stand vitiated. To our mind, a solemn duty is cast on the court in dispensation of justice to adequately consider the defence of the Accused taken Under Section 313 Code of Criminal Procedure and to either accept or reject the same for reasons specified in writing. {Para 16}

  IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1330 of 2018.

Decided On: 31.10.2018

Reena Hazarika Vs. State of Assam

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Rohinton Fali Nariman and Navin Sinha, JJ.

Author: Navin Sinha, J.

Citation:  MANU/SC/1249/2018,(2019) 13 SCC 289.

Print Page

Wednesday, 24 April 2024

Supreme Court: An appellate court is not competent to impose a punishment higher than the maximum that could have been imposed by the trial court.

We have seen the three decisions to which the learned Judge has made reference and they undoubtedly support his conclusion. This decision was followed in Emperor v. Abasali Yusufalli MANU/NA/0039/1935 : A.I.R. 1935 Nag. 139 and also in Mehi Singh v. Mangal Khandu I.L.R. 39 Cal. 157; Emperor v. Muhammad Yakub Ali I.L.R. 45 All. 594; and Maung E Maung v. The King A.I.R. 1940 Rang.113. In in re Tirumal RajuA.I.R. 1947 Mad. 868 it has been held that an appellate court is not competent to impose a punishment higher than the maximum that could have been imposed by the trial court. It seems to us that these cases lay down the correct law. An appeal court is after all "a court of error", that is, a court established for correcting an error. If, while purporting to correct an error, the court were to do something which was beyond the competence of the trying court, how could it be said to be correcting an error of the trying court ? No case has been cited before us in which it has been held that the High Court, after setting aside an acquittal, can pass a sentence beyond the competence of the trying court. Therefore, both on principle and authority it is clear that the power of the appellate court to pass a sentence must be measured by the power of the court from whose judgment an appeal has been brought before it. The High Court was thus in error in sentencing the appellant to undergo imprisonment in respect of the offence under s. 392 for a period exceeding two years. Accordingly we allow the appeal partially and reduce the sentence of imprisonment in respect of the offence under s. 392 from rigorous imprisonment of four years to a period of two years. Subject to this modification we dismiss the appeal. {Para 8}

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 156 of 1963

Decided On: 30.11.1965

Jagat Bahadur Singh Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

A.K. Sarkar, J.R. Mudholkar and R.S. Bachawat, JJ.

Author: J.R. Mudholkar, J.

Citation:  1965 INSC 271, MANU/SC/0096/1965,AIR 1966 SC 945.

Print Page

Tuesday, 23 April 2024

Important Supreme Court Caselaws on Judgment writing

 

1) Supreme Court: Court should direct to take departmental action against investigating officer or experts witness who are guilty of dereliction of Duty in investigation and trial



2) Supreme Court: Life imprisonment shall always be Rigorous Imprisonment



3) Whether prosecution must prove that nobody had knowledge about the existence of dead body before information given by accused for proof of discovery statement U/S 27 of Evidence Act?


Print Page

Supreme Court: Life imprisonment shall always be Rigorous Imprisonment

As limited notice was issued in both the SLPs, we heard arguments on the point of rigorous imprisonment while convicting a person Under Section 302 Indian Penal Code. Mr. A. Sirajudeen, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Petitioner in SLP (Crl.) No. 6220 of 2018, submitted that the issue is no more res integra as it is covered by a judgment of this Court in Naib Singh v. State of Punjab and Ors. MANU/SC/0125/1983 : (1983) 2 SCC 454. {Para 6}

8. In Naib Singh (supra) the Petitioner was originally sentenced to death for committing an offence of murder Under Section 302 Indian Penal Code. Later, the death sentence was commuted to imprisonment for life by the Government of Punjab. After having undergone sentence of 22 years, Naib Singh filed a Writ Petition Under Article 32 of the Constitution of India challenging his continued detention. One of the points argued by the Petitioner relates to sentence of imprisonment for life not to be equated to rigorous imprisonment for life. By taking into account the earlier judgments of this Court in Pandit Kishori Lal v. King Emperor MANU/PR/0017/1944 : AIR 1945 PC 64 and Gopal Vinayak Godse v. State of Maharashtra MANU/SC/0156/1961 : 1961 3 SCR 440, this Court in Naib Singh's case held that the sentence of imprisonment for life has to be equated to rigorous imprisonment for life. The law laid down by this Court in Naib Singh's was followed by this Court in three judgments Dilpesh Balchandra Panchal v. State of Gujarat, Sat Pal alias Sadhu v. State of Haryana MANU/SC/0531/1992 : (1992) 4 SCC 172 and Mohd. Munna v. Union of India MANU/SC/0566/2005 : (2005) 7 SCC 417.


9. In view of the authoritative pronouncements of this Court on the issues that arise for consideration in these SLPs, there is no need to re-examine the limited point for which notice was issued.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

SLP (Crl.) Nos. 6220 and 7110 of 2018

Decided On: 14.09.2021

Md. Alfaz Ali Vs. The State of Assam

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

L. Nageswara Rao and B.R. Gavai, JJ.

Citation: 2021 INSC 480, MANU/SC/0640/2021, (2021) 19 SCC 751.

Print Page

Sunday, 21 April 2024

Whether defence counsel can make out contradictions from statement made in FIR without putting its contents to informant at the time of his evidence?

Some contradictions were sought to be pointed out in the statement as given in the First Information Report and in the evidence of the witness P.W. 11 but we do not think it is open to the learned advocate to comment upon it because none of those contradictions have been put to the witness at the time of his giving evidence. According to the F.I.R. it would appear that Indradeo Singh accompanied by Chait Ahir, Vikrama Singh, Musan Pandey, Billar Ahir and Mongru Ahir resident of the village went there and forbade the accused persons from cutting paddy crops from his field, but the accused persons did not listen to them. Indradeo Singh made many entreats requested them not to commit such high handedness nor did he say Indradeo Singh fell in the field of Sumer Singh. In the first place it may be noticed that F.I.R. is not a substantial piece of evidence. It is an information of a cognizable offence given under Section 154 of the Criminal Procedure Code and if there is any statement made therein it can only be used for the purposes of contradicting and discrediting a witness under Section 145 of the Evidence Act. In the second place the statement given by the informant need not necessarily be an eye witness account of what he has actually seen. There were others who had gone along with him who could have furnished him with information as to what transpired in so far as it was in their knowledge. If these aspects had been put to P.W. 11, he would have had an opportunity of explaining the statement made in the F.I.R. but since that opportunity was not given, any comment based on the statement given by P.W. 11 in the F.I.R. would be without effect.

{Para 7}

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 279 of 1968

Decided On: 21.04.1972

Nanhku Singh and Ors. Vs. State of Bihar

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

K.K. Mathew and P. Jaganmohan Reddy, JJ.

Author: P. Jaganmohan Reddy, J.

Citation: MANU/SC/0185/1972.

Print Page

Supreme Court: Judgment writing Tip- The court should not use the word complainant for state in criminal prosecution initiated by state

 Before we part with the case, we may observe a common error creeping in many of the judgments including the present one. No distinction is made while using the words 'informant' and 'complainant'. In many of the judgments, the person giving the report under Section 154 of the Code is described as the 'complainant' or the 'de facto complainant' instead of 'informant', assuming that the State is the complainant. These are not words of literature. In a case registered under Section 154 of the Code, the State is the prosecutor and the person whose information is the cause for lodging the report is the informant. This is obvious from Sub-section (2) of Section 154 of the Code which, inter alia, provides for giving a copy of the information to the 'informant' and not to the 'complainant'. However the complainant is the person who lodges the complaint. The word 'complaint' is defined under Section 2(d) of the Code to mean any allegation made orally or in writing to a Magistrate and the person who makes the allegation is the complainant, which would be evident from Section 200 of the Code, which provides for examination of the complainant in a complaint-case. Therefore, these words carry different meanings and are not interchangeable. In short, the person giving information, which leads to lodging of the report under Section 154 of the Code is the informant and the person who files the complaint is the complainant. {Para 12}

Words and phrases - Words "informant" and "complainant"--Carry different meanings and are not interchangeable.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1948 of 2013 

Decided On: 19.11.2013

Ganesha Vs. Sharanappa and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

C.K. Prasad and Kurian Joseph, JJ.

Author: C.K. Prasad, J.

Citation: 2013 INSC 762,MANU/SC/1185/2013.

Print Page