Hereinabove, we have examined in detail the findings of the Trial Court
and those of the High Court and have no hesitation in concluding that the
present one was clearly a case where the decision of the Trial Court suffered
from perversity and fundamental error of approach; and the High Court was
justified in reversing the judgment of the Trial Court. The observations of the
Trial Court that there was no documentary evidence to show the source of
funds with the respondent to advance the loan, or that the respondent did not
record the transaction in the form of receipt of even kachcha notes, or that
there were inconsistencies in the statement of the complainant and his
witness, or that the witness of the complaint was more in know of facts etc.
would have been relevant if the matter was to be examined with reference to
the onus on the complaint to prove his case beyond reasonable doubt. These
considerations and observations do not stand in conformity with the
presumption existing in favour of the complainant by virtue of Sections 118
and 139 of the NI Act. Needless to reiterate that the result of such
presumption is that existence of a legally enforceable debt is to be presumed
in favour of the complainant. When such a presumption is drawn, the factors
relating to the want of documentary evidence in the form of receipts or
accounts or want of evidence as regards source of funds were not of relevant
consideration while examining if the accused has been able to rebut the
presumption or not.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 508 OF 2019
ROHITBHAI JIVANLAL PATEL VS. STATE OF GUJARAT
Dinesh Maheshwari, J.
Dated: 15th March, 2019.
Print Page
and those of the High Court and have no hesitation in concluding that the
present one was clearly a case where the decision of the Trial Court suffered
from perversity and fundamental error of approach; and the High Court was
justified in reversing the judgment of the Trial Court. The observations of the
Trial Court that there was no documentary evidence to show the source of
funds with the respondent to advance the loan, or that the respondent did not
record the transaction in the form of receipt of even kachcha notes, or that
there were inconsistencies in the statement of the complainant and his
witness, or that the witness of the complaint was more in know of facts etc.
would have been relevant if the matter was to be examined with reference to
the onus on the complaint to prove his case beyond reasonable doubt. These
considerations and observations do not stand in conformity with the
presumption existing in favour of the complainant by virtue of Sections 118
and 139 of the NI Act. Needless to reiterate that the result of such
presumption is that existence of a legally enforceable debt is to be presumed
in favour of the complainant. When such a presumption is drawn, the factors
relating to the want of documentary evidence in the form of receipts or
accounts or want of evidence as regards source of funds were not of relevant
consideration while examining if the accused has been able to rebut the
presumption or not.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 508 OF 2019
ROHITBHAI JIVANLAL PATEL VS. STATE OF GUJARAT
Dinesh Maheshwari, J.
Dated: 15th March, 2019.
