Showing posts with label presumption for consideration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label presumption for consideration. Show all posts

Sunday, 17 March 2019

Whether complainant should prove source of fund in cheque dishonour case if accused has not discharged presumption U/S 139 of NI Act?

 Hereinabove, we have examined in detail the findings of the Trial Court
and those of the High Court and have no hesitation in concluding that the
present one was clearly a case where the decision of the Trial Court suffered
from perversity and fundamental error of approach; and the High Court was
justified in reversing the judgment of the Trial Court. The observations of the
Trial Court that there was no documentary evidence to show the source of
funds with the respondent to advance the loan, or that the respondent did not
record the transaction in the form of receipt of even kachcha notes, or that
there were inconsistencies in the statement of the complainant and his
witness, or that the witness of the complaint was more in know of facts etc.
would have been relevant if the matter was to be examined with reference to
the onus on the complaint to prove his case beyond reasonable doubt. These
considerations and observations do not stand in conformity with the
presumption existing in favour of the complainant by virtue of Sections 118
and 139 of the NI Act. Needless to reiterate that the result of such
presumption is that existence of a legally enforceable debt is to be presumed
in favour of the complainant. When such a presumption is drawn, the factors
relating to the want of documentary evidence in the form of receipts or
accounts or want of evidence as regards source of funds were not of relevant
consideration while examining if the accused has been able to rebut the
presumption or not. 

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 508 OF 2019


ROHITBHAI JIVANLAL PATEL VS. STATE OF GUJARAT 

Dinesh Maheshwari, J.
Dated: 15th March, 2019.
Print Page

Saturday, 22 July 2017

How to appreciate evidence in case of subletting of premises?

 In Kunhikrishnan v. Madhavi (1991 (1) KLT 515) this Court held that on establishing that the tenant has transferred exclusive possession to another person, the Court may legitimately draw a presumption under Section 114 of the Evidence Act that the transfer was for valuable consideration so as to shift the burden of proof to the tenant to disprove the prima facie case of subletting established by the landlord. The terms and conditions under which the subtenant has occupied the premises may be unknown to the landlord and known only to the tenant and the subtenant. If the landlord has to prove positively by adducing evidence that the transfer of possession was for valuable consideration, it may not be possible to prove subletting in any case except in rarest of rare cases. Same is the view taken by this Court in Abdul Rahiman Kunju v. Rent Control Revisional Authority (1992 (2) KLT 600).

17. In Bharat Sales Ltd. v. Life Insurance Corporation of India (MANU/SC/0131/1998 : AIR 1998 SC 1240), the Supreme Court held that to prove subletting, production of affirmative evidence showing payment of monetary consideration by the subtenant to the tenant is not necessary. The law does not require such payment to be proved by affirmative evidence and the Court is permitted to draw its own inference upon the facts of the case proved at the trial.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA

R.C.R.A. No. 58 of 2005

Decided On: 21.02.2005

 Mohammed Sageer
Vs.
 Prakash Thomas

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R. Bhaskaran and K.T. Sankaran, JJ.
Print Page

Sunday, 23 October 2016

How to appreciate evidence in suit for recovery of money based on Bahi Khata?

The case of plaintiff is that the defendant in token of
acknowledgment made bahi entry of the plaintiff. The alleged entry
has been stamped and even signatures are obtained on revenue

stamp. Plaintiff has not produced the bahi itself. He has produced
only a folio i.e. one page of the bahi.
[11]. The fact shows that plaintiff maintains a bahi. The
production of one page i.e. folio from the original bahi has to be
proved by the plaintiff himself with regard to continuity of pages. It is
not the case of plaintiff that it was the only entry appearing in the
bahi which is subject matter of the present suit. In the absence of
such averment, bahi pre-supposes maintenance of account book of
monetary advances made by plaintiff in the capacity of professional
money lender.
 Since onus of issue No.1 was on the plaintiff and he has
failed to discharge the same, therefore, he is not entitled to any
decree for recovery of the amount. The defendant has specifically
pleaded in the written statement that he has not signed any bahi
entry, rather his signatures have been obtained when he was in the
state of intoxication. Since the plaint does not contain any name of

the person who scribed the bahi entry, therefore, evidence of Satbir
Singh has to be treated out of context being beyond pleadings.
[14]. The signature appearing on the alleged bahi entry in Hindi
and his signatures on affidavit and statement in the Court in English
further aggravates the plea of the plaintiff and creates suspicion
whether Satbir Singh is the same person who allegedly signed the
bahi entry and has also appeared in the witness box. Father's name
of Satbir Singh further adds to the mystery as to whether he is son of
Bharat Singh-plaintiff or somebody else? Since the plaintiff has not
removed the cloud in his evidence, rather much of the evidence of
plaintiff is beyond the pleadings.
In respect of questions of law it is relevant to highlight that
mere exhibition of document does not dispense with proof of
execution. The name of the scribe as shown in the document has not
been pleaded by plaintiff in the plaint. Moreover the scribe who
allegedly prepared the bahi entry has signed the same in Hindi
whereas while appearing as witness his signatures are appearing in
English on affidavit as well as on the statement. There is no mention
about the scribe that he used to sign in both languages i.e. in Hindi
as well as in English. The pleadings in bahi entry as well as in the
plaint are at variance inasmuch that in the bahi entry, recital has
been made that amount would be repaid in the month of Jeth,
whereas there is no such averment mentioned in the plaint.
[17]. In view of aforesaid, bahi entry Ex.P1 is surrounded by
mysterious circumstances, hence cannot be read in evidence.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
RSA No.1454 of 2011
Date of Decision: 28.08.2015

Bharat Singh  Vs  Ram Chander 

CORAM:  MR. JUSTICE RAJ MOHAN SINGH
Citation:AIR 2016 (NOC) 654 P&H
Print Page