Showing posts with label right of appeal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label right of appeal. Show all posts

Friday, 28 December 2018

Whether right to appeal is available if special statute under which right is claimed which does not confer right to appeal?

In the case of R.M.A.R.A. Adaikappa Chettiar v. R. Chandrmekhara Thevar MANU/PR/0005/1947 : AIR 1948 PC 12, while considering a similar ratio of law Lord Simond observed:

"The true rule is that where a legal right is in dispute and the ordinary Courts of the country are seized of such dispute the Courts are governed by the ordinary rules of procedures applicable thereto and an appeal lies, if authorized by such rules, notwithstanding that the legal right claimed arises under a special Statute which does not in terms confer a right of appeal."

IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR

W.P.(227) No. 249 of 2018

Decided On: 22.03.2018

 Sita Devi Sharma Vs. Mukta Ben

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Goutam Bhaduri, J.

Citation: AIR 2018(NOC) 927 Chh
Print Page

Saturday, 29 October 2016

Leading Judgment on right of victim to file appeal against acquittal of accused

In Parmeshwar Mandal, a Division Bench of the Patna High Court also dealt with similar issues and answered the queries as follows:
"In the circumstances, after consideration of the entire matter, conclusions of this Court are as follows:-
(1) - By virtue of the Proviso, as inserted in Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 by the Criminal Procedure Code (Amendment) Act, 2008 (Act 5 of 2009), a "victim" has been put at a higher pedestal, than a prosecuting agency or a complainant, in the matter of preferring an appeal against any order of a criminal court acquitting the accused or convicting for a lesser offence or imposing inadequate compensation. This Proviso gives an unqualified "right" to a "victim" to prefer an appeal in its terms, as against the enabling Sections 377 and 378, which only give liberty to a District Magistrate, the State Government, the Central Government and the complainant, as the case may be, to prefer an appeal against an order of sentence on the ground of its inadequacy or against an order of acquittal.
(2) - The right of a "victim" to prefer an appeal in terms of the said proviso to Section 372 is an unqualified right and no "leave to appeal" or "special leave" is required to be obtained by him/her for the purpose, as required by the State or the complainant for maintaining an appeal in terms ofSection 378 of the Code.
(3) - No limitation of time has been provided by the Legislature for exercise of such a right of appeal by the "victim" in terms of the said Proviso. Hence, in the fact and circumstances of each case, the Court has to determine as to whether the appeal was entertainable, or not, on the ground of absence of bonafide explanation for delay by the appellant. The limitation laid down by the Full Bench of Punjab and Haryana High Court is a judicial fiat and not based on interpretation of the provisions of the Code or the Limitation Act, 1963. Hence the same is applicable only within the territorial jurisdiction of that High Court and not beyond.
(4) - However, in view of the legal presumption of innocence in favour of the accused, the yardsticks laid down by judicial pronouncements for consideration of appeals under Section 378shall be applicable in case of an appeal under he said proviso to Section 372.
(5) - The expression - long after the present incident - used under brackets by the Apex Court in paragraph 5 of its judgment in case of National Commission for Women Vs. State of Delhi and another [AIR 2011 SC (Sup.) 392] : [(2010) 122 SCC 599] is only an obiter dictum of the Court and it does not lay down a law in terms of Article 141 of the Constitution of India.
(6) - Proviso to Section 372 of the Code came into operation w.e.f. December 31, 2009. Hence, in absence of any legislative intent to the contrary, in all cases, in which a judgment and order has been passed by a criminal court on and after that date, a right accrues to the "victim" to prefer appeal in terms of the said Proviso, irrespective of the date of occurrence and any subsequent event in the case prior to such judgment and order.
(7) - If the subject of the crime is dead or incapacitated to the extent or suffers from such a disability that he/she cannot take steps to exercise his/her right under the Proviso to Section 372, any of his/her next of kin, who can establish before the Court, to its satisfaction, that the crime had caused "loss" or "injury" to him/her also, besides to the subject of the crime, can maintain an appeal under the said proviso.
(8) - The "loss" and "injury" to an appellant before it (if he/she is other than the de-facto sufferer) has to be assessed by the Court in each and every case in the backdrop of definition of "injury" Patna High Court CR. APP (DB) No.1078 of 2012 dt.26-11-2013 provided in Section 44 of the Indian Penal Code, and not beyond it, before entertaining the appeal, in terms of the proviso toSection 372 on merits.
(9) - If any person prefers an appeal in terms of the proviso to Section 372, solely on the basis of his status as a "guardian" or a "legal heir", he/she will have to establish the legal basis of his/her such status in reference to the law, as may be applicable in the matter, with all its limitations and qualifications, or otherwise also (e.g. judicial order).
(10) - Once an appeal preferred in terms of the said proviso to Section 372, against an order is entertained by an appellate court on merit, to whatever result, no fresh/second appeal by any party/person can/should be entertained against the same order.
(11) - No distinction can be made between a case instituted by a complainant/ informant with the police and by a complainant before the Court directly, and an absolute right of a victim (a complainant or not) to file an appeal under Proviso to Section 372 does not get fettered by any other section of the Code contained in Chapter XXIX, which includes Section 378."
31. Since, subsequent to the Full Bench reference, the Supreme Court in Satyapal Singh interpreted these provisions, we are duty bound to follow the same to the extent it binds us. With that in mind and in the light of the above legal precedents and the discussion, we answer the questions posed by the Referral Judge as follows:-
(1) A victim of the crime, who has prosecuted an accused by way of a private complaint, has a statutory right of appeal within the limits prescribed under Section 372 of Cr.P.C.
(2) A complainant (in a private complaint), who is not a victim, has a remedy and can file an appeal in the event of acquittal of the accused after obtaining leave to appeal under Section 378(4) of Cr.P.C (3) In a private complaint, even if the victim is not a complainant, he has a right to appeal under the proviso to Section 372 of Cr.P.C., but he has to seek leave as held by the Supreme Court in Satyapal Singh.
(4) The term victim? has been correctly interpreted by the Full Bench of the Delhi High Court in Ramphal and we are in agreement with the same.
(5) A victim (as defined under Section 2(wa) of the Cr.P.C does not cease to be a victim merely because he also happens to be a complainant and he can avail all the rights and privileges of a victim also and (6) The decision of the Single Judge in Selvaraj holding that the term victim? found in Section 372 excludes a complainant, is not legally correct and in a given case, a complainant, who is also a victim, can avail right granted under Section 372 of Cr.P.C.
Madras High Court
S.Ganapathy vs N.Senthilvel on 5 April, 2016

Citation:2016 ALLMR(CRI)JOURNAL492,2017 CRLJ602
Coram 
 Mr.Justice V.RAMASUBRAMANIAN,       
 Mr.Justice N.KIRUBAKARAN     
and 
 Mr.Justice  S.VAIDYANATHAN     

Print Page

Saturday, 27 August 2016

What is distinction between substantive and procedural law?


Mr. Dada, argued that the amendment to Section 36
affects the substantive right of an award-debtor and hence it must
take prospective effect. He refers to the decision of the Apex Court
in Thirumala Chemicals Ltd. V/s. Union of India and Ors. reported in
(2011) 6 SCC page 739 to support his submission. In that decision,
the question considered was, whether the Appellate Tribunal
constituted under the Foreign Exchange Management Act (“FEMA”
for short) was right in dismissing an appeal preferred under Section
19(1) of FEMA by applying the first proviso to Section 52(2) and
Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973 (“FERA” for short) holding
that, it had no power to condone the delay beyond 90 days. Although

the cause of action had arisen when FERA was in force, show cause
notices and impugned notices were issued, when FEMA was imposed
and appeals were also preferred under Section 19(1) of FEMA. The
Apex Court, in that decision considered, the distinction between
substantive and procedural law at paras-23 to 27. The same reads as
under :-
“23. Substantive law refers to a body of rules that
creates, defines and regulates rights and liabilities.
Right conferred on a party to prefer an appeal against
an order is a substantive right conferred by a statute
which remains unaffected by subsequent changes in
law, unless modified expressly or by necessary
implication. Procedural laws establishes a mechanism
for determining those rights and liabilities and a
machinery for enforcing them. Right of appeal being a
substantive right always act prospectively. It is trite
law that every statute is prospective unless it is
expressly or by necessary implication made to have
retrospective operation.
24. Right of appeal may be a substantive right but
the procedure for filing the appeal including the
period of limitation cannot be called a substantive
right, and an aggrieved person cannot claim any
vested right claiming that he should be governed by
the old provision pertaining to period of limitation.
Procedural law is retrospective meaning thereby that
it will apply even to acts or transactions under the
repealed Act.
25. Law on the subject has also been elaborately
dealt with by this Court in various decisions and
reference may be made to a few of those decisions.
This Court in Garikapati Veeraya v. N. Subbiah
Choudhry, reported in AIR 1957 SC 540, New India
Insurance Co. Ltd v. Shanti Misra,reported in (1975)

2 SCC page 840, Hitendra Vishnu Thakur v. State of
Maharashtra, reported in (1994) 4 SCC page 602,
Maharaja Chintamani Saran Nath Shahdeo v. State
of Bihar, reported in (1999) 8 SCC page 16 and
Shyam Sunder v. Ram Kumar, reported in (2001) 8
SCC page 24, has elaborately discussed the scope and
ambit of an amending legislation and its
retrospectivity and held that every litigant has a
vested right in substantive law but no such right exists
in procedural law. This Court has held that the law
relating to forum and limitation is procedural in
nature whereas law relating to right of appeal even
though remedial is substantive in nature.
26. Therefore, unless the language used plainly
manifests in express terms or by necessary implication
a contrary intention a statute divesting vested rights is
to be construed as prospective, a statute merely
procedural is to be construed as retrospective and a
statute which while procedural in its character, affects
vested rights adversely is to be construed as
prospective.
27. Rights of appeal conferred under Section 19(1) of
FEMA is therefore a substantive right. The procedure
for filing an appeal under sub-section (2) of Section 19
as also the proviso to sub-section (2) of Section 19
conferring power on the Tribunal to condone delay in
filing the appeal if sufficient cause is shown, are
procedural rights.”
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION

CHAMBER SUMMONS NO.1530 OF 2015
IN
EXECUTION APPLICATION (L) NO.2481 OF 2015
IN
ARBITRAL AWARD DATED 22ND JUNE, 2015

In the matter between :
M/s Rendezvous Sports World 
Vs.
The Board of Control for Cricket 
in India

Coram : Smt. R.P. SondurBaldota, J.
Date : 14th June, 2016.

Print Page

Monday, 4 January 2016

Distinction between right of appeal and forum before which such right is available

 The next question is whether such as amendment
would apply to the pending suit. The submission on behalf of the
respondent no. 1 that the decree passed in the suit relates back to
the filing of the suit, even if accepted, cannot come to the aid of
the respondent no. 1. This is because assuming so, this would
necessarily presuppose that the suit is maintainable in accordance
with law. It is trite that although a right of appeal is a substantive
right, it does not include a right as to forum. Thus, a distinction
has to be drawn between a right of appeal and the forum before
which such right is available. The provision as to forum is
essentially a part of adjectival law or procedural law. It is further
well settled that a change in procedural law would apply and would
cover the pending dispute/litigation unless otherwise provided
either expressly or by necessary implication. Rule 87-A of the
Rules of 1986 as it stands, does not show that any pending
proceedings, have been saved thereunder. In this regard a useful
reference may be made to the case of New India Insurance Co.
Ltd. Vs. Smt. Shanti Misra, reported in AIR 1976 SC 237
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA
FIRST APPEAL NO. 41 OF 2007

Smt. Nanda N. Haldankar Vs   Smt. Nalini K. Kulkarni,

CORAM:- C.V. BHADANG, J.

 PRONOUNCED ON:- 10th APRIL, 2015
Citation;2015(6) MHLJ 901
Print Page