Showing posts with label unregistered tenancy agreement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label unregistered tenancy agreement. Show all posts

Sunday, 19 April 2020

Whether court can dismiss eviction suit on ground that rent deed was not registered?

Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999 - Sec. 15 - Arrears of rent - Suit for eviction Decree - High Court setting aside decree - Validity - No dispute regarding relationship of landlord and tenant between parties - Admission of part of tenant about amount of rent payable by him - Admission of tenant about not paying rent right from day one when tenancy commenced - High Court setting aside decree on ground that rent deed was not registered document and as such not admissible in evidence - Not proper - Admission of party in proceedings either in pleading or oral is best evidence and same does not need any further corroboration - Held, Dismissal of suit simply on ground that rent deed was not registered cannot be accepted and liable to be set aside
            IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
[Bombay High Court]

(Before T S Thakur ; F M Ibrahim Kalifulla, JJ.)
CIVIL APPEAL NOS. 5316-5318 OF 2012 
Ahmedsaheb 
Vs
Sayed Ismail

Citations: 
2012(8)SCC516; 2012(6)JT581; 2012(6)SCALE505; 2012(6)SCR984;



Print Page

Friday, 20 December 2019

Chhatis HC: Eviction suit is not liable to be dismissed if tenancy agreement is not registered

Reading of Section 4 of the Act of 2011 speaks about the tenancy agreement. It shows that notwithstanding anything contained in Section 107 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (Central Act 4 of 1882), the lease shall not be created on rent of any accommodation except by in writing and the tenancy which is continuing before the commencement of the Act, the existing agreement is required to be filed before the Rent Controller and in case of no agreement is existing, the same is required to be executed and thereafter to be filed before the Rent Controller. Reading of Section 4 and the non-compliance thereof, no consequence is provided in the Act of 2011 qua eviction proceeding.

When we turn to the objection made by tenant it contains the pleading of non-registration of the tenancy agreement as per Section 4 of the Act of 2011. In view of the the principles as has been stated above, this Court is of the opinion that for noncompliance of Section 4 of the Act of 2011, the landlord cannot be non-suited as it is only directory in nature.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH

WP (227) No. 2 of 2018

Decided On: 09.08.2018

Utsav Dey Vs. Sushil Kumar Bhadraja and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Goutam Bhaduri, J.

Citation: 2019(1) RCR(Rent) 188
Print Page

Thursday, 21 March 2019

Whether tenant is bound to pay stamp duty on copy of lease agreement if it is insufficiently stamped?

 Countering the said submissions, Mr. Asan Ali Khan, learned Counsel for the respondent submitted that when admittedly Exs.R1 to R8 are copies of the originals of the lease deeds executed between the petitioner and the respondent and they are for a period not exceeding 11 months, they are not compulsorily registrable and as such they can be looked into for collateral purposes. According to the learned Counsel, the copy available with the respondent need not be stamped and the original available with the petitioner alone are liable to be stamped in accordance with Indian Stamp Act; even if it is insufficiently stamped, it can be looked into for collateral purpose, namely, to ascertain the address of the premises, which is leased out and the question of insufficiency of stamp duty can be gone into only at the time of final disposal of RCOP. 
At the outset it has to be pointed out that when an agreement of lease is executed between the landlord and tenant, normally, lease agreement is prepared in duplicate i.e., both are originals, signed by both the landlord and tenant. If that being so, it cannot be contended by the respondent that the agreement available with the tenant is only a copy and not the original and therefore it need not be sufficiently stamped. Therefore, the contention of the learned Counsel for the respondent that Exs.R1 to R8 need not be stamped as contemplated in the Indian Stamp Act but the original agreement available with the petitioner alone has to be stamped in accordance with Indian Stamp Act cannot be countenanced.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADRAS

C.R.P. (PD) No. 853 of 2010 and M.P. No. 1 of 2010

Decided On: 07.07.2010

V. Jayaraman Vs. K.A. Ubaidur Rahman

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
K. Mohan Ram, J.


Print Page

Sunday, 9 December 2018

Whether civil suit will be barred if tenancy agreement is not registered?

 This Court, in the matter of Raj Prasanna Kondur v. Arif Taher Khan and Ors., reported in MANU/MH/1264/2004 : 2005 (4) Bom.C.R. 383, has held that the right of a landlord under Section 24 to get a person evicted from the premises on expiry of license is not curtailed in any manner on account of absence of the agreement being in writing or registered, as contemplated by Section 55 of the Act.

Section 55 of the Act nowhere provides for "any other consequence" for failure on the part of the landlord to get the agreement drawn in writing or getting the same registered, except those provided in Sub-section (3) of Section 55. In other words, on account of failure of the landlord to get the agreement registered, he cannot be precluded or prohibited from presenting a plaint in Civil Court seeking recovery of rent. The consequence of failure to record the agreement in writing and to get it registered, would put the tenant in an advantageous position at trial, as his contention as regards the terms and conditions of tenancy will have to be accepted, unless proved otherwise. Section 55 of the Act nowhere puts an embargo in respect of entertain ability of any civil action by the landlord either for recovery of rent or for recovery of possession of the tenanted premises on account of his failure to secure an agreement of tenancy in the form, as contemplated by Section 55(1) of the Act.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Civil Revision Application No. 7 of 2011

Decided On: 19.04.2011

Shashikant  Vs.  Nirmala

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R.M. Borde, J.

Citation:2011(5) MHLJ 251:2011(3) ALLMR 832
Print Page

Sunday, 6 November 2016

How to ascertain tenancy if lease deed is unregistered?

So   far   as   the   substantial   question   of   law   at   Serial   No.2
regarding   admissibility   of   document   at   Exhibit   50   in   evidence   is
concerned, though such document is an unregistered document, it can
be used for collateral purposes and the decision of the Apex Court in
the case of  Anthony  v.  K.C. Ittoop  & Sons and others, reported in
(2000) 6 SCC 394, throws light in para 16 thereof on such issue,
which is reproduced below :
“16. Taking   a   different   view   would   be   contrary   to   the
reality when parties clearly intended to create a lease though
the document which they executed had not gone into processes
of registration.   That lacuna had affected the validity of the
document,   but   what   had   happened   between   the   parties   in
respect of the property became a reality.   Non­registration of
the document had caused only two consequences.  One is that
no lease exceeding one year was created.   Second is that the
instrument became useless so far as creation of the lease is
concerned.   Nonetheless   the   presumption   that   a   lease   not
exceeding one year stood created by conduct of parties remains
unrebutted.”    
In view of above, the non­registration of document would not come in
the way of the Court to hold that the relationship of “Landlord and
Tenant” between the plaintiff and the defendant No.1 in the present
case has been established, coupled with the other evidence available
on record.  The substantial questions of law at Serial No.2 is answered
accordingly.
There is no substance in this second appeal, and the same is
dismissed.  No order as to costs.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR
Second Appeal No.24 of 2002
Ganesh s/o Ramkisan Bairagi,
V
Yeshoda wd/o Purushottam Landge,
Coram : R.K. Deshpande, J.
Dated  : 16th June, 2016
Citation: 2016(6) MHLJ 393
Print Page

Sunday, 12 July 2015

Whether unregistered rent note can be used for collateral purpose?

It is true that the non-registration of the rent note does not debar the use of a document that is compulsorily registerable for collateral purposes but that aspect would in the instant case pale into insignificance keeping in view the state of pleadings on the question of month of tenancy and the legal implications thereof.

Supreme Court of India

Shibani Basu vs Sandip Ray on 26 November, 2010

Bench: Markandey Katju, T.S. Thakur
Citation;AIR 2011 SC 509
Print Page