Showing posts with label unregistered document. Show all posts
Showing posts with label unregistered document. Show all posts

Tuesday, 24 June 2025

The Priority Principle: How Section 50 of the Registration Act Protects Property Rights

 Understanding why registered documents trump unregistered ones in Indian property law

Property disputes are among the most complex and emotionally charged legal battles in India. At the heart of many such disputes lies a fundamental question: when multiple documents claim rights over the same property, which one prevails? Section 50 of the Registration Act, 1908 provides a clear answer that has shaped Indian property law for over a century.

The Golden Rule of Property Documentation

Print Page

Sunday, 3 October 2021

Whether court can consider an unregistered family settlement at the time of deciding temporary injunction?

 Similarly, it is yet to be established whether the alleged family settlement Ex.P-1 is a genuine document or not. It may, however, be noted that in this document there is no mention of oral family settlement alleged to have been arrived at on 24.5.1979. From this document it is also clear that the alleged family arrangement was with regard to the partition of the immoveable properties and was reduced in writing so that it could be used in future at the time of need. Such a document is required to be registered compulsorily under Section 17(1) (b) of the Registration

Act, 1908. In this connection reference may be made to the judgement of the Supreme Court in the case of Tek Bahadur (supra). In this case the Supreme Court held that “it is only when the parties reduce the family arrangement in writing with the purpose of using that writing as proof of what they had arranged and, where the arrangement is brought about by the document as such, that the document would require registration, as it is then that it would be a document of title declaring for future what rights and in what properties the parties possess.” In view of the law laid down by the Supreme Court, I am prima facie of the view that the document Ex.P-1 required registration under Section 17 of the Registration Act as the said document was with regard to the partition of the immoveable properties and was reduced to writing with the purpose of using the same as proof of what the parties had decided in respect of those properties. Since the said document was not registered under Section 17 of the Registration Act, the plaintiff and defendant No. 2 cannot be permitted to rely on this document at this stage.

 HIGH COURT OF DELHI

IAS No. 7532/88, 8290/88, 211/89 3160/90 and 8916/92 in S.NO. 159/86

K.G. Mal Vs Sham Behari Mal 

Sat Pal, J

Decided on : 5th July, 1994

Citation: 1994 SCC OnLine Del 388 : (1994) 30 DRJ 242 : (1994) 55 DLT 137 : PLR (1994) 108 Del 3

Print Page

Whether court can grant an interim injunction based on unregistered agreement?

  It may be pointed out that no suit for specific performance of unregistered agreements dated 31.3.1965 and 16.10.1965 was filed nor have the respondents sought cancellation of the registered sale deed dated 31.3.1965 and 19.10.1965. This would lead to a situation where the respondents are not avoiding the transaction in the registered instrument but are seeking to use the unregistered agreements dated 31.3.1965 and 16.10.1965 to seek mandatory and permanent injunction as also possession. Such is impermissible and any interim order in furtherance thereof cannot be granted. It has been held by the Supreme Court in S. Saktivel (dead) by LRs. v. M. Venugopal Pillai and Ors., 2000 (7) SCC 104, that registered document cannot be rescinded, varied or altered by unregistered document. Therefore, no final relief can be granted on the basis of unregistered agreement in the teeth of the registered sale deed. Consequently, where a final relief cannot be granted, an interim relief to the same effect is also barred.{Para 5}

6. I need hardly go into other aspects of the matter raised by learned counsel, but suffice it to say that the injunction order under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 CPC cannot be sustained in view of the registered sale deed not being canceled.

HIGH COURT OF DELHI

C.M. (M) 672 of 2002 & C.M. 1369 of 2003

Punjab National Bank  Vs Iqbal Ahmad 

R.S. Sodhi, J.

Decided on : November 7, 2003

Citation: 

2003 SCC OnLine Del 1060 : (2004) 72 DRJ 89 : (2003) 108 DLT 378
Print Page

Sunday, 28 July 2019

Whether a person can become owner of property by adverse possession on basis of unregistered sale deed?

 It was submitted by Mr. Prabhakar that document dated 12.11.1960, being an unregistered one, could certainly not be relied upon to advance the proposition that under the said document the title came to be vested in favour of the Defendant but said document could be relied upon for collateral purpose, in that to support that on and with effect from that date, the Defendant was put in possession. With the assistance of the learned Counsel, we have gone through the document in question and find that the Defendant was put in possession pursuant to said document.

11. The question then arises is whether such possession of the Defendant under a document which otherwise is inoperative in law could be held to be adverse to the original Plaintiff.
As held by this Court in the cases referred to hereinabove, once the mortgagee is claiming to be an absolute owner of the property, his/her status as mortgagee comes to an end and his/her possession becomes adverse to the original owner. Even if such sale is voidable (and not void), it will not alter the legal position and adverse title of the original mortgagee continues and if the period of twelve years expires, he/she becomes owner of the property by adverse possession.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 4985/2010

Decided On: 18.09.2018

 Venugopal Padayachi Vs. V. Pichaikaran (Dead) through L.Rs.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
U.U. Lalit and Sanjay Kishan Kaul, JJ.

Citation: 2019(4) MHLJ 246
Print Page

Sunday, 27 November 2016

When unregistered document will be admissible in evidence for collateral purpose?

Now, it is to be seen whether the document in question can be
admitted in evidence for collateral purpose. Proviso to Section 49 of the Act
provides that an unregistered document affecting immovable property and
required to be registered as per Section 17, may be received as evidence of any
collateral transaction not required to be effected by registered instrument. Thus,
an unregistered document is admissible in evidence only for that collateral
purpose which in turn is not required to be effected by a registered instrument.
The expression 'collateral purpose' is a very vague one and the Court must decide
in each case whether the purpose for which it is sought to use the unregistered
document is really collateral one or it is to establish indirectly the title, interest or
right to immovable property sought to be conveyed by the document. In this
regard, Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of K. B. Saha & Sons Pvt. Ltd
Development Consultant Ltd reported in (2008) 8 SCC 654 has laid down
the following propositions : 
1. A document required to be registered, if unregistered is not
admissible into evidence under Section 49 of the Registration Act.
2. Such unregistered document can however be used as an evidence
of collateral purpose as provided in the proviso to Section 49 of the
Registration Act.
3. A collateral transaction must be independent of, or divisible from,
the transaction to effect which the law required registration.
4. A collateral transaction must be a transaction not itself required to
be effected by a registered document, that is, a transaction creating,
etc. any right, title or interest in immovable property of the value of
one hundred rupees and upwards.
5. If a document is inadmissible in evidence for want of registration,
none of its terms can be admitted in evidence and that to use a
document for the purpose of proving an important clause would not
be using it as a collateral purpose.
Hon'ble Allahabad High Court in the case of Ratan Lal Vs. Hari
Shankar reported in AIR 1980 Allahabad 180 has observed that 'collateral
purpose' referred to Section 49 of the Act has a limited scope and meaning. The
term would not permit the party to establish that the deed created, declared,
assigned, limited or extinguished a right to immovable property. The term
'collateral transaction' means a transaction other than creating, declaring,
assigning, limiting or extinguishing a right, interest or title in an immovable
property. Collateral purpose is that which is by the side or distinct from the main
purpose. In the present case, the petitioners are claiming that by way of the
document in question right of way was conferred upon them, they were allowed
to use it to have access to the land sold to them by respondent, but later on he
created hindrance in their use of the way. If the facts of the case are examined,
the suit being for permanent injunction and sole basis thereof being the document
dated 15.12.2000, which is not registered, on the strength of which the petitioners
are claiming their right of way over the other land of the respondent, the10
production of the said document cannot be said to be for 'collateral purpose'. This
is because the recital therein with regard to conferment of right of way is not
independent of or divisible from the transaction for the purpose to which the
document was executed, which is required to be registered. 'Collateral purpose' is
the purpose which is independent of or divisible from the purpose for which the
document was executed and of which the law required registration. A collateral
transaction must be independent of or divisible from the transaction to effect
which the law required registration. A collateral transaction must be a transaction
not itself required to be effected by a registered document, that is, a transaction
creating any right, title or interest in immovable property of the value of one
hundred rupees and upwards. In the present case, the purpose for which the
document in question is sought to be produced cannot be said to be a collateral
purpose.
REPORTABLE
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
AT JAIPUR BENCH, JAIPUR.

S. B. CIVIL WRIT PETITION No.18594/2011.
Shree Chand & Ors. Vs. Civil Judge (Sr.Div.) & Anr.
Date of Order : 25.5.2016
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRASHANT KUMAR AGARWAL

Citation:AIR 2016 Raj 191
Print Page

Whether right of way can be transferred by unregistered document?

In the present petition the question relevant to be considered and
decided is not whether possession of the land comprising in the form of nine feet
wide way was delivered by the respondent to the petitioners or not or whether the
respondent is creating hindrance in the peaceful use of the same by petitioners or
not but the question to be addressed is whether conferment of right upon the
petitioners over the other land of the respondent to use it as a way to have access
to the land sold to them by way of the document in question amounts to creation,
declaration, assignment, limitation or extinguishment of a right, title or interest to
or in an immovable property within the meaning of Section 17 (1)(b) of the Act.
This provision provides that any instrument which purports or operates to create,
declare, assign, limit or extinguish, whether in present or in future, any right, title
or interest, whether vested or contingent, of the value and of one hundred
rupees, upwards to or in immovable property is compulsorily registrable. In the
present case, the petitioners are claiming that land measuring 599 square yards
was sold by the respondent to them by way of document dated 15.12.2000. A
reading of this document clearly shows that the land described therein was sold
by respondent to the petitioners in lieu of sale consideration of Rs.1,07,820/- and
possession of it was also delivered to them and from the date of its execution all
rights stood transferred in favour of the petitioners and that of the respondent got
extinguished. Thus, the document in question is an instrument requiring
compulsorily registration as per the requirement of Section 17(1)(b) of the Act.
Although, by way of document in question the respondent further agreed to
provide the petitioners right of way to have access to the land so sold over his
other land, but conferment of that right cannot be said to be a right separate and
independent from the land so sold and the same cannot be considered in isolation.
The respondent agreed to provide the petitioners right to way over his other land
only by the reason that the land described in the document was sold by him to the
petitioners. Thus, the right so conferred is part and parcel of the sale of land, and
the same has been conferred by the same document and, therefore, it also
required compulsory registration.
Apart from that, even if for the sake of arguments, it is admitted that
conferment of right of way is a separate right independent of the sale of land,
even then, in my considered opinion, such right of way can be conferred by a
registered document only. As per the document in question and as per the claim
of the petitioners themselves, the respondent agreed to provide them a nine feet
wide way over his other land. What are the consequences of such conferment ? In
my opinion as a result of such conferment right, title or interest in the land
comprising in the way which was vested in respondent, got extinguished and
limited and right to use it as a way got created and declared in favour of the
petitioners. Thus, as per the requirement of Section 17(1)(b) of the Act as a result
of conferment of right of way on the petitioners right, title and interest of the
respondent extinguished and limited and right was created and declared in favour
of the petitioners and any document conferring any such right is compulsorily
registrable. It is also to be noted that as per the definition of the term 'immovable
property' as provided under Section 2(6) of the Act, the term 'immovable property'
includes rights to ways also. In the light of the provisions of Section 17(1)(b) of
the Act, if the term 'immovable property' is considered, it becomes manifest that a
right of way can be created or conferred by a person over his land in favour of
any other person by a registered document only. In the present case also the
respondent could have conferred upon the petitioners right of way over his land
by executing a registered document only. In the case in hand although there is no
transfer of ownership in the land over which the right of way is being claimed by
the petitioners and which has been denied by the respondent but right of way is
included in the definition of immovable property as defined under Section 2 (6) of
the Act. Thus, the document which creates, declares, assigns, limits or
extinguishes a right of way in or over a land is required to be registered.
Effect of non-registration of documents required to be registered is
provided in Section 49 of the Act. It provides that no document required by
Section 17 of the Act to be registered shall affect any immovable property
comprised therein or shall be received as evidence of any transaction affecting
such property or conferring such rights unless it is registered. It is well settled
legal position that a document required to be registered, if unregistered, is not
admissible in evidence under Section 49 of the Act. In the present case,
conferment of right of way by respondent over his other land in favour of the
petitioners but transfer of immovable property as per the definition of the term as
provided under Section 2 (6) and it is not less than creation, declaration and
assignment of property rights in favour of the petitioners and extinguishing of
right, interest and title of the respondent in his land, it could be effected by a
registered document only and the document in question being unregistered is not
admissible in evidence.
REPORTABLE
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
AT JAIPUR BENCH, JAIPUR.

S. B. CIVIL WRIT PETITION No.18594/2011.

Shree Chand & Ors. Vs. Civil Judge (Sr.Div.) & Anr.

Date of Order : 25.5.2016
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRASHANT KUMAR AGARWAL

Citation:AIR 2016 Raj 191
Print Page

Sunday, 6 November 2016

How to ascertain tenancy if lease deed is unregistered?

So   far   as   the   substantial   question   of   law   at   Serial   No.2
regarding   admissibility   of   document   at   Exhibit   50   in   evidence   is
concerned, though such document is an unregistered document, it can
be used for collateral purposes and the decision of the Apex Court in
the case of  Anthony  v.  K.C. Ittoop  & Sons and others, reported in
(2000) 6 SCC 394, throws light in para 16 thereof on such issue,
which is reproduced below :
“16. Taking   a   different   view   would   be   contrary   to   the
reality when parties clearly intended to create a lease though
the document which they executed had not gone into processes
of registration.   That lacuna had affected the validity of the
document,   but   what   had   happened   between   the   parties   in
respect of the property became a reality.   Non­registration of
the document had caused only two consequences.  One is that
no lease exceeding one year was created.   Second is that the
instrument became useless so far as creation of the lease is
concerned.   Nonetheless   the   presumption   that   a   lease   not
exceeding one year stood created by conduct of parties remains
unrebutted.”    
In view of above, the non­registration of document would not come in
the way of the Court to hold that the relationship of “Landlord and
Tenant” between the plaintiff and the defendant No.1 in the present
case has been established, coupled with the other evidence available
on record.  The substantial questions of law at Serial No.2 is answered
accordingly.
There is no substance in this second appeal, and the same is
dismissed.  No order as to costs.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR
Second Appeal No.24 of 2002
Ganesh s/o Ramkisan Bairagi,
V
Yeshoda wd/o Purushottam Landge,
Coram : R.K. Deshpande, J.
Dated  : 16th June, 2016
Citation: 2016(6) MHLJ 393
Print Page

Friday, 13 November 2015

Whether unregistered partition deed can be used for collateral purpose if it is not properly stamped?

Then the next question that falls for consideration is whether
these can be used for any collateral purpose. The larger Bench of
Andhra Pradesh High Court in Chinnappa Reddy Gari Muthyala
Reddy Vs. Chinnappa Reddy Gari Vankat Reddy , AIR 1969 A.P.
(242) has held that the whole process of partition contemplates
three phases i.e. severancy of status, division of joint property by
metes and bounds and nature of possession of various shares. In a
suit for partition, an unregistered document can be relied upon for
collateral purpose i.e. severancy of title, nature of possession of
various shares but not for the primary purpose i.e. division of joint
properties by metes and bounds. An unstamped instrument is not
admissible in evidence even for collateral purpose, until the same is
impounded. Hence, if the appellants/defendants want to mark these
documents for collateral purpose it is open for them to pay the
stamp duty together with penalty and get the document impounded
and the Trial Court is at liberty to mark Exhibits B-21 and B- 22 for
collateral purpose subject to proof and relevance.
Accordingly, Civil Appeal is partly allowed holding that Exhibits
B-21 and B-22 are admissible in evidence for collateral purpose
subject to payment of stamp duty, penalty, proof and relevancy.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 8441 OF 2015
ARISING OUT OF
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 12788 OF 2014

YELLAPU UMA MAHESWARI  V BUDDHA JAGADHEESWARARAO & ORS.

Dated: October 08, 2015
Author: N.V. RAMANA, J.
Citation:(2015) 16SCC787
Print Page

Monday, 24 August 2015

Whether rate of interest mentioned in Mortgage deed can be varied by unregistered document?

Equivalent Citation: AIR1974Bom46, ILR1974 Bom 1011, 1973MhLJ851
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT NAGPUR
Appeal No. 96 of 1963
Decided On: 28.06.1973
 Shankar Madhaorao Gampawar and Ors. Vs. Maltibai
Coram:
M.N. Chandurkar, J.

Where for a immovable property involved worth more than Rs100, and a mortgage deed for the same did not provided for the interest while by a subsequent unregistered letter, paying the interest was agreed, it was held that the letters was not admissible in the evidence for the want of registration and the interest could not be claimed on its basis
Print Page

Sunday, 6 January 2013

Whether any variation of rent reserved by registered lease deed should be made by another registered instrument?

Any variation of rent reserved by registered lease deed must be made by another registered instrument. The agreement between the landlord and the tenant by which the rent was increased being in variation of a written contract,evidence of that was barred under section 92 of the Evidence Act.

Supreme Court of India
Raval & Co vs K. C. Ramachandran & Ors on 11 December, 1973
Citations: 1974 AIR 818, 1974 SCR (2) 629
Print Page

Tuesday, 24 April 2012

Madras HC: Registered Deed shall have priority over unregistered deed

Section 50 of the Registration Act contemplates a conflict between two bona fide transactions relating to the same property, and not a case where a subsequent purchaser or mortgagee having notice that there is a buna fide and valid encumbrance on the property seeks to make use of the Registration Act to avoid it, thus making an enactment intended to prevent fraud an instrument of fraud.
Madras High Court
Simanapalli Krishnamma vs Rongali Suranna And Ors. on 29 September, 1892
Equivalent citations: (1893) 3 MLJ 54
Author: M Aiyar
JUDGMENT
1. The question referred to the Full Bench is whether when it is proved that a subsequent incumbrancer under a registered conveyance had notice of a valid prior unregistered incumbrance and of possession by such incumbrancer or of such conveyance without possession, the courts are bound to interpret Section 50 of the present Registration Act so as to defeat the title of the prior incumbrancer.
2. The first attempt to compel the registration of deeds &c, in India was by Regulation XVII of 1802, a regulation for establishing a Registry for Wills and Deeds for the transfer or mortgage of real property and it was enacted by Section 6, Clause 3, that, "it being the object, however, of the rules in the two preceding clauses, to prevent persons being defrauded by purchasing or receiving in gift, or taking in mortgage, real property which may have been before sold, given, or mortgaged, subsequent to the period fixed for
Print Page