Showing posts with label locus standi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label locus standi. Show all posts

Sunday, 17 December 2023

Relaxation of 'locus standi' rule for offences and proceedings arising out of marriage and its justification

 The concept of 'locus standi' in Indian law dictates who has the legal right to initiate court proceedings in a particular matter. Traditionally, the rule for matrimonial offenses and proceedings was strict, meaning only the directly affected spouses had the standing to file complaints or petitions. This often left vulnerable individuals, particularly women, facing challenges in seeking legal redressal for marital wrongs.

In recent years, however, there has been a growing recognition of the need to relax the locus standi rule for offences and proceedings arising out of marriage. This relaxation aims to improve access to justice for victims of domestic violence, adultery, cruelty, and other matrimonial offenses.

Print Page

Wednesday, 27 June 2018

Whether court can permit third party to be added as party in the suit?

Much water has been flown under the bridge after the decision is rendered. After this judgment, in 1977, amendment was brought to the Code of Civil Procedure and added a provision Order 1, Rule 8-A which reads as under :

"8-A. Power of Court to permit a person or body of persons to present opinion or to take part in the proceedings.---While trying a suit, the Court may, if satisfied that a person or body of persons is interested in any question of law which is directly and substantially in issue in the suit and that it is necessary in the public interest to allow that person or body of persons to present his or its opinion on that question of law, permit that person or body of persons to present such opinion and to take such part in the proceedings of the suit as the Court may specify."
5. By the above amendment, the Parliament has widened the scope of locus in tune with changing times. Courts were also relaxing the rigid rule of locus in the interest of justice.

6. Impleadment of a third party in a suit is an attribute of principle of natural justice. 
 Without much difficulty one can see that concept of locus standi and principle of natural justice are closely intertwined that one cannot be separated from another as the opportunity of being heard is the main attribute of locus standi. When a third party approaches Court with contention that he is interested in the subject matter of the suit or in the dispute between the plaintiff and defendant, the Court shall ordinarily give an opportunity to such a party to put his case. It may be remembered that a third party is coming to the Court on his own risk, whereas a party sought to be impleaded at the instance of the defendant is dragged on to the litigation without his will. These two incidents are therefore entirely different and require different treatment at the hands of the Court. Therefore, observation made by the Single Judge that for all impleadment the plaintiff is dominus litus cannot be applied in all cases. Of course, it can be applied where the defendant insisted in the written statement or in his reply that the particular person is necessary party and the plaintiff can resist the impleadment because he is dominus litus and he can decide who is to be the necessary party. In such an event, he is taking the risk of suit being thrown out in the absence of the necessary party. But in the case of impleadment of third party who approaches the Court and says that he is vitally interested in the dispute that is going on between the plaintiff and defendant, and therefore, he may be given an opportunity of being heard, naturally consistent with the principle of natural justice and fair play, the Court will not refuse his impleadment, unless the Court feels that he is totally a stranger and unless the Court feels that it is employing a delaying tactics.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Civil Revision Application No. 1306 of 1999

Decided On: 09.08.2000

 Gulab Babusaheb Bargiri Vs.  Executive Engineer, Maharashtra State Electricity Board and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
T.K. Chandra Shekhara Das, J.


Citation: 2001(1) MHLJ 63

Print Page

Sunday, 16 April 2017

Whether post acquisition allottee of land has locus standi to be heard in matters of determination of compensation?

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
(Before Adarsh Kumar Goel and Uday Umesh Lalit, JJ.)
Civil Appeal Nos. 1587-1636 of 2017
Satish Kumar Gupta etc. etc. 
v.
State of Haryana & Ors. etc. 
Decided on February 21, 2017
Citation: 2017 SCC OnLine SC 159
 Land Acquisition Act, 1894 — Whether a post acquisition allottee of land is necessary or proper party or has any locus to be heard in the matter of determination of compensation — Held, the post-acquisition allottee has no locus to be heard in the matter and is neither a necessary nor a proper party 
Print Page

Sunday, 4 December 2016

Whether Third Party Has Locus Standi To Present Civil Contempt Petition under contempt of court Act?

 It is a settled position in law that the power conferred
on a High Court under Article 215 of the Constitution of India
to punish for contempt of court must be exercised in
accordance with the provisions of the Contempt of Courts
Act, 1971. Therefore, having regard to the provisions of the
Act, petition to initiate action for civil contempt as defined
under Section 2(b) of the Act can be presented only by a
party aggrieved, except where the Court which passed the
order has given liberty to third parties, who are not parties to
the order, to initiate action for contempt of court. We may
state that Section 14 of the Act relates to procedure where - -

contempt is in the face of the Supreme Court or a High Court
and Section 15 of the Act relates to procedure in the case of
a criminal contempt; they are exceptions to the rule of locus
standi relating to civil contempt stated above.
6. The complainant is not a party to the order in his
personal capacity. As the complainant has presented this
petition in his personal capacity and in his personal name and
not as administrator of the Masjid, he cannot be said to be a
‘party aggrieved’. It is relevant to state that, in the order, no
liberty is given to any third party to initiate action for
contempt of court. Hence, the petition as brought is not
maintainable and is accordingly dismissed. This order will not
come in the way of administrator of the Masjid to initiate
action in the matter in accordance with law.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED : 9TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2016
PRESENT
 MR. JUSTICE H.G.RAMESH
AND
 MR. JUSTICE K.N.PHANEENDRA
CCC No.1149/2016 (CIVIL)

SRI SHAMSHUDDIN Vs SRI HARIS M.Y.
Citation: 2016 SCC ONLINE KAR 6468
Print Page

Wednesday, 17 August 2016

How to ascertain locus standi of third party to file appeal under Article 136 of constitution?

Further, it is
pertinent here to observe that it may not be possible
to strictly enumerate as to who all will have locus
to maintain an appeal before this Court invoking
Article 136 of the Constitution of India, it depends
upon the factual matrix of each case, as each case
has its unique set of facts. It is clear from the
aforementioned case law that the Court should be
liberal in allowing any third party, having bonafide
connection with the matter, to maintain the appeal
with a view to advance substantial justice. However,
this power of allowing a third party to maintain an
appeal should be exercised with due care and caution.
Persons, unconnected with the matter under
consideration or having personal grievance against
the accused should be checked. A strict vigilance is
required to be maintained in this regard.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 299 OF 2016

AMANULLAH AND ANR  Vs. STATE OF BIHAR AND ORS. 

V.GOPALA GOWDA, J.
Citation:2016 ALLSCR (CRI)763:(2016) 6 SCC 699
Print Page

Saturday, 14 May 2016

What is term “entitled to defend” and its connection with principles of natural justice?

At this juncture, it is necessary to state that in Udit
Narain (Supra) question arose whether a tribunal is a
necessary party. Recently a two-Judge Bench in Asstt. G.M
State Bank of India v. Radhey Shyam Pandey 
2015 (3) SCALE 39 referred
to Hari Vishnu Kamath v. Ahmad Ishaque and
 Ors.AIR 1955 SC 233
and adverted to the concept of a tribunal being a necessary
party and in that context ruled that:-
“In Hari Vishnu Kamath (supra), the larger
Bench was dealing with a case that arose from
Election Tribunal which had ceased to exist and
expressed the view how it is a proper party. In
Udit Narain Singh (supra), the Court was really
dwelling upon the controversy with regard to the
impleadment of parties in whose favour orders
had been passed and in that context observed
that tribunal is a necessary party. In Savitri
Devi (supra), the Court took exception to courts
and tribunals being made parties. It is apposite
to note here that propositions laid down in each
case has to be understood in proper perspective.
Civil courts, which decide matters, are courts in
the strictest sense of the term. Neither the court
nor the Presiding Officer defends the order before
the superior court it does not contest. If the High
Court, in exercise of its writ jurisdiction or
revisional jurisdiction, as the case may be, calls
for the records, the same can always be called for
by the High court without the Court or the

Presiding Officer being impleaded as a party.
Similarly, with the passage of time there have
been many a tribunal which only adjudicate and
they have nothing to do with the lis. We may cite
few examples; the tribunals constituted under
the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, the
Custom, Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal,
the Income Tax Appellate Tribunals, the Sales
Tax Tribunal and such others. Every
adjudicating authority may be nomenclatured as
a tribunal but the said authority(ies) are different
that pure and simple adjudicating authorities
and that is why they are called the authorities.
An Income Tax Commissioner, whatever rank he
may be holding, when he adjudicates, he has to
be made a party, for he can defend his order. He
is entitled to contest. There are many authorities
under many a statute. Therefore, the proposition
that can safely be culled out is that the
authorities or the tribunals, who in law are
entitled to defend the orders passed by them, are
necessary parties and if they are not arrayed as
parties, the writ petition can be treated to be not
maintainable or the court may grant liberty to
implead them as parties in exercise of its
discretion. There are tribunals which are not at
all required to defend their own order, and in that
case such tribunals need not be arrayed as
parties.”
The principle that has been culled out in the said case
is that a tribunal or authority would only become a
necessary party which is entitled in law to defend the order.
17. The term “entitled to defend” confers an inherent right
to a person if he or she is affected or is likely to be affected
by an order to be passed by any legal forum, for there would

be violation of natural justice. The principle of audi alteram
partem has its own sanctity but the said principle of natural
justice is not always put in strait jacket formula. That
apart, a person or an authority must have a legal right or
right in law to defend or assail.
18. We may first clarify that as a proposition of law it is
not in dispute that natural justice is not an unruly horse.
Its applicability has to be adjudged regard being had to the
effect and impact of the order and the person who claims to
be affected; and that is where the concept of necessary party
become significant.
Reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 6774 of 2015
(@ SLP(C) NO. 16650 OF 2012)
Poonam
 V
State of U.P. & Ors
Citation;(2016) 2 SCC779
Dipak Misra, J.
Dated;October 29, 2015
Print Page

Sunday, 8 February 2015

Basic concept of locus standi


The word locus (plural loci) is Latin for "place". “Locus standi” is Latin for ‘place to stand’- In law, the right to bring an action.
It is the ability of a party to demonstrate to the court sufficient connection to and harm from the law or action challenged to support that party's participation in the case. In United States law, the Supreme Court of the United States has stated -In essence the question of locus standi is whether the litigant is entitled to have the court decide the merits of the dispute or of particular issues.
There are three constitutional standing requirements:
Injury: The plaintiff must have suffered or imminently will suffer injury - an invasion of a legally protected interest which is concrete and particularized. The injury must be actual or imminent, distinct and palpable, not abstract. This injury could be economic as well as non-economic.
Causation: There must be a causal connection between the injury and the conduct complained of, so that the injury is fairly traceable to the challenged action of the defendant and not the result of the independent action of some third party who is not before the court.
Redress ability: It must be likely, as opposed to merely speculative, that a favorable court decision will redress the injury.
Print Page