Showing posts with label substantive evidence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label substantive evidence. Show all posts

Thursday, 12 November 2026

Supreme Court: Statements of witnesses recorded under S 164 of CRPC are not substantive evidence

 16. Section 157 of the Evidence Act makes it clear that a statement recorded under Section 164 Code of Criminal Procedure, can be relied upon for the purpose of corroborating statements made by witnesses in the Committal Court or even to contradict the same. As the defence had no opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses whose statements are recorded under Section 164 Code of Criminal Procedure, such statements cannot be treated as substantive evidence.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1774 of 2010

Decided On: 04.02.2013

R. Shaji Vs. State of Kerala

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

B.S. Chauhan and V. Gopala Gowda, JJ.

Author: B.S. Chauhan, J.

Citation: 2013 INSC 72, MANU/SC/0087/2013,(2013) 14 SCC 266,AIR 2013 SC 651.

Read full judgment here: Click here.


Print Page

Saturday, 18 April 2026

Supreme Court: Under which circumstances Test identification Parade of accused becomes unreliable?

 Circumstance Six: Test Identification Parade


38. The investigating authorities conducted a test identification parade - asking PW-5 to identify the Appellant- convict from a long line of habitual offenders. He did so thrice. This has been taken as another circumstance against the convict Appellant. Before proceeding to the merits of this circumstance, let us appreciate the law on this point.


38.1 No provision of law casts an obligation upon the investigating authorities to conduct a test identification parade. If it is conducted, the provision that governs is Section 162, Code of Criminal Procedure [See: Munshi Singh Gautam v. State of M.P.   MANU/SC/0964/2004 : 2004:INSC:648 : (2005) 9 SCC 631; Malkhansingh v. State of M.P.   MANU/SC/0445/2003 : 2003:INSC:308 : (2003) 5 SCC 746; Visveswaran v. State   MANU/SC/0352/2003 : 2003:INSC:262 : (2003) 6 SCC 73; and Ashok Debbarma v. State of Tripura   MANU/SC/0168/2014 : 2014:INSC:167 : (2014) 4 SCC 747.]


38.2 The onus to show that the T.I.P. has been conducted in accordance with law lies on the prosecution, and only after this burden stands prima facie discharged, does the question of considering objections in this regard arise. [See: Umesh Chandra v. State of Uttarakhand   MANU/SC/1412/2021 : (2021) 17 SCC 616.]


38.3 It is not a substantive piece of evidence. Its only purpose is for the investigating authorities to analyse the correctness, or lack thereof, of the direction in which they are steering the investigation. [See: Hari Nath v. State of U.P.   MANU/SC/0229/1987 : 1987:INSC:315 : (1988) 1 SCC 14; and Iqbal v. State of U.P.   MANU/SC/0559/2015 : 2015:INSC:387 : (2015) 6 SCC 623]


38.4 If the prosecution does not establish, by examination of witnesses to the T.I.P., and the Magistrate entrusted therewith, it cannot be said that it was conducted per law. [See: Umesh Chandra (supra).]


38.5 There is no hard and fast Rule about delay in conducting T.I.P. being fatal to the case of the prosecution. In certain cases, relatively small delay has been considered fatal yet in others, a delay of as much as 40 days is not fatal. [See: Raja v. State   MANU/SC/1717/2019 : 2019:INSC:1346 : (2020) 15 SCC 562.]


38.6 The prosecution must establish that prior to the test identification parade being conducted, the witness had no opportunity to see the Accused. In other words, the Accused must be kept 'baparda'. [See: Gireesan Nair v. State of Kerala   MANU/SC/1486/2022 : 2022:INSC:1199 : (2023) 1 SCC 180; and Budhsen v. State of U.P.   MANU/SC/0103/1970 : 1970:INSC:131 : (1970) 2 SCC 128.]


38.7 If the above has not been ensured, the evidence of the T.I.P. becomes inadmissible. It has also been held that if, prior to the T.I.P. the witness has the opportunity to see even the photograph of the Accused person, such process becomes inconsequential. [See: Maya Kaur Baldevsingh Sardar v. State of Maharashtra   MANU/SC/7994/2007 : 2007:INSC:1014 : (2007) 12 SCC 654; C. Muniappan v. State of T.N.   MANU/SC/0655/2010 : 2010:INSC:553 : (2010) 9 SCC 567; and Sk. Umar Ahmed Shaikh v. State of Maharashtra   MANU/SC/1025/1998 : 1998:INSC:202 : (1998) 5 SCC 103.]


38.8 Dock identification by the informant, even in the absence of T.I.P., can be accepted, but generally, as a matter of prudence, a witness's identification of an Accused in Court is sought to be corroborated by the identification by the former of the latter in previously conducted identification proceedings [Rajesh v. State of Haryana   MANU/SC/0818/2020 : 2020:INSC:628 : (2021) 1 SCC 118; and Mukesh v. State (NCT of Delhi)   MANU/SC/0575/2017 : 2017:INSC:448 : (2017) 6 SCC 1.]


38.9 Considering the facts and circumstances of the case at hand, it is open for the Court to draw an adverse inference against the witness, should they put forth a refusal to participate in the identification proceedings. [See: Mohd. Anwar v. State (NCT of Delhi)   MANU/SC/0602/2020 : 2020:INSC:496 : (2020) 7 SCC 391.]


39. It is plain as day that the above principles were not observed in the present case. We are constrained to record our astonishment as to how the Courts below considered the identification proceedings as a circumstance accruing against the Appellant-convict. It is undoubted that PW-50, in his testimony, gives sufficient detail as to the procedure followed in conducting the T.I.P., and on that count, no assault can be made thereon, however, as the preceding paragraph establishes, there are other equally crucial factors. It is a matter of record that PW-5 (the witness who participated in the T.I.P.), in his testimony, stated that about a week after he gave information to the concerned police about the incident of 14th May, 2011, he saw the Appellant- convict at the said police station. Most importantly, as has come on record, the police officials had informed him about the Appellant-convict committing the crime. As held by Budhsen (supra) as far back as the year 1970, by Suryamoorthy v. Govindaswamy   MANU/SC/0591/1989 : (1989) 3 SCC 24 in 1989, Suresh Chandra Bahri v. State of Bihar   MANU/SC/0500/1994 : 1994:INSC:246 : 1995 Supp. (1) SCC 80 in 1995, Mulla v. State of U.P   MANU/SC/0091/2010 : 2010:INSC:89 : (2010) 3 SCC 508 in 2010, i.e., well before the judgment of the learned Trial Court was pronounced, that if the said witness had the opportunity to see the Accused, in any form, after the incident the subject matter of testimony, but prior to the identification proceedings, it would render the same to be ineffective. Then, in our view, the courts below committed an error of elephantine proportions in considering these proceedings as forming one of the chains of circumstances against the Appellant-convict.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1672 of 2019 

Decided On: 15.07.2025

Kattavellai Vs. State of Tamilnadu

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Vikram Nath, Sanjay Karol and Sandeep Mehta, JJ.

Author: Sanjay Karol, J.

Citation: 2025 INSC 845, MANU/SC/0917/2025.

Read full judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Thursday, 26 March 2026

Bombay HC: Statement recorded U/S 164 of CRPC is not a substantive evidence and it can be used only to corroborate or to contradict the witness

The learned trial Court accepted the statement made by Prashant PW12 under Section 164 of the Code to the effect that the accused had come out of his shop with a broken glass bottle when otherwise Prashant PW12 had not deposed to any such statement in his evidence before the Court. The learned trial Court accepted such a statement by placing reliance on the case of Sachin Shivaji Kadam & Ors. v. State of Maharashtra 2000 (2) MLR 54. As far as this aspect is concerned the law on the use of statements-recorded under Section 164 of the Code appears to be quite well settled in that the said statements can be used only for the purpose of contradiction under Section 145 or for corroboration under Section 157 of the Evidence Act. Learned counsel on behalf of the accused has placed reliance on the case of Gurjant Singh v. State of Rajasthan, MANU/SC/0198/1970 : AIR 1970 SC 1305 wherein the Apex Court has stated that the statements recorded under Section 164 of the Code Could not be considered as evidence but were corroborative of what was stated earlier in the committal Court. Some other decisions on the same point could also be referred to. Generally, statements under Section 164 of the Code are recorded with the avowed hope that the witnesses will not resile from the earliest versions given by them in respect of an incident out of fear of punishment. The Apex Court in Ram Kishan Singh v. Harmit Kaur Anr. MANU/SC/0169/1971 : AIR 1972 SC 468 has reiterated that the statement recorded under Section 164 of the Code is not a substantive evidence and it can be used only to corroborate or to contradict the witness. The same is also the view held by a learned Division Bench of Allahabad High Court in the case of Ram Lakhan Sheo Charan & Anr. v. State of U.P. MANU/UP/0302/1991 : 1991 Cri LJ 2790 wherein the learned Division Bench after considering catena of cases (more particularly referred to in para 12 of the judgment) came to the conclusion that the statements under Section 164 of the Code cannot be used as substantive piece of evidence. The learned trial Court therefore was not right on relying on any part of the statement of Prashant PW12 as recorded earlier under Section 164 of the Code when such a statement was not adhered to by him in his evidence before the Court, Moreover, Prashant PW12 had clearly stated that he had given such statement earlier because he was threatened by the police. This is another error committed by the learned trial Court. {P ara 8}

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Criminal Appeal No. 27 of 2007

Decided On: 20.08.2008

Shivaji Gaonkar Vs. State

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

N.A. Britto, J.

Citation: 2008(4) MHLJ (Crl) 419, 2009 ALLMR (Cri) 359,MANU/MH/1632/2008

Print Page

Saturday, 26 October 2024

Supreme Court: if the genuineness of any document filed by prosecution is not disputed by defence it can be read as substantive evidence U/S 294(3) CrPC

  Also, this Court in the case of Akhtar vs. State of Uttaranchal (2009) 13 SCC 722 has held in para 21 as

under:

“21. It has been argued that non-examination of the

 concerned medical officers is fatal for the prosecution.

 However, there is no denial of the fact that the defence

admitted the genuineness of the injury

reports and the post-mortem examination

reports before the trial court. So the

genuineness and authenticity of the

documents stands proved and shall be

treated as valid evidence under Section 294

of the CrPC. It is settled position of law that

if the genuineness of any document filed by

a party is not disputed by the opposite party

it can be read as substantive evidence under

sub-section (3) of Section 294 CrPC.

Accordingly, the post-mortem report, if its

genuineness is not disputed by the opposite

party, the said post-mortem report can be

read as substantive evidence to prove the

correctness of its contents without the doctor

concerned being examined.” {Para 20}

21. On a plain reading of section 294 CrPC

and its interpretation by this Court in the above

judgments, we do not find any error in the

judgment of the Trial Court and particularly

considering the facts of the present case where

the defence repeatedly continued to admit the

genuineness of the prosecution documents

exempting them from formal proof.

Reportable

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS. OF 2024

SHYAM NARAYAN RAM Vs  STATE OF U.P. & ANR. ETC.

Coram: VIKRAM NATH, J.

Citation: 2024 INSC 800.

Print Page

Monday, 26 August 2024

Whether the court can convict accused based on evidence of Judicial Magistrate who recorded statement of victim U/S 164 of CRPC if victim has turned hostile?

Even Supreme Court in case of Brij Nath Sah v. State of Bihar MANU/SC/0344/2010 : 2010:INSC:255 : (2010) 6 SCC 736 has reiterated same principles. The Hon'ble Apex Court has held that a statement under Section 164 is not substantive evidence and can be utilized only to corroborate or contradict the witness vis-a-vis statement made in court. {Para 68}

 70. Trial Court was wrong in convicting the Appellant by taking recourse to statement under Section 164 of the Criminal Procedure Code. On the basis of the evidence of the learned Magistrate and the medical evidence, statement recorded under Section 164 of the Code can be treated as previous statement only. 

71. So if we look at the weightage and value of evidence of judicial officer from all the angles, we may find that his evidence cannot be said direct on the point of happening of the incident. Because he is not giving the evidence on the basis of facts seen by him. His evidence is on the point of what he has heard through the mouth of the victim.


72. So for what purpose this provision is included in the Code. The mechanism created by the Code is investigation carried out by the police including recording the statement of the witnesses. Recording statement through the Magistrate is also a part of investigation. Such statement stands on higher pedestal than the police statement. Still we can not attach more value than recognized by the law. Such statement falls within the category of 'previous statement' only. Its use is permissible in the mode prescribed in the Evidence Act only.


73. Does it mean to say that this statement can be the basis for conviction just because it is recorded by judicial official and oath is administered? Answer is 'No'. The reason is this statement is not recorded in the presence of the accused and there is no opportunity of the cross-examination to the maker of the statement when such statement is recorded by the Magistrate. So ultimately, when Magistrate gives evidence, his evidence is not the evidence about the witnessing the incident but it is evidence of facts stated before him by the victim.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Criminal Appeal No. 990 of 2019

Decided On: 09.05.2024

Deelip Tatoba Raje Vs. The State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

S.M. Modak, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/3173/2024.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Whether trial court is justified in convicting Appellant only on basis of corroborative evidence particularly when there is no substantive evidence?

Criminal - Conviction - Appeal against - Sections 376(2)(f) of Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC), Sections 3, 4, 8 and 12 of Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO Act), Section 164 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC) and Section 157 of Indian Evidence Act, 1872 - Present appeal filed to challenge judgment of conviction passed against appellant herein for commission of offence punishable under Sections 376(2)(f) of IPC and Sections 3, 4, 8 and 12 of POCSO Act - Whether trial court is justified in convicting Appellant only on basis of corroborative evidence particularly when there is no substantive evidence - Held, statement under Section 164 of CrPC is not substantive evidence - Same can be utilized only to corroborate or contradict witness vis-a-vis statement made in court - Victim's reiterated statement can be used for corroboration under Section 157 of Evidence Act - If there are discrepancies between statement and oral evidence, it can be used for contradiction by defense - Likewise, if victim recants statement, it can be used for cross-examination by prosecution, as done in this case - Judicial officer's evidence cannot be relied upon to convict accused, as witness did not support prosecution's case on crucial points - Trial court cannot solely convict accused based on presumption -Presumptions only apply when foundational facts are established, such as victim's age or commission of acts specified under POCSO Act - In this case, foundational facts are not proven - Evidence from Section 164 of CrPC statements and medical case papers cannot be considered for drawing inferences about accused's involvement - Trial court erred in relying on presumption under Section 29 of POCSO Act - Impugned judgment of conviction set aside - Appeal allowed.[68],[74],[75],[88],[89],[90]

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Criminal Appeal No. 990 of 2019

Decided On: 09.05.2024

Deelip Tatoba Raje Vs. The State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

S.M. Modak, J.

Citation: MANU/MH/3173/2024.

Print Page

Wednesday, 19 May 2021

Can the Court treat the witness's statement identifying the suspect in the Test identification parade as substantive evidence?

  Thus, it is clear that the Test Identification Parade is conducted by the Magistrate only in aid of investigation and the statement of the witness identifying the suspect in the parade cannot be treated as a substantive evidence of identification in the trial of the accused. It is only corroborative evidence.{Para 83}

In the High Court of Madras

(Before Indira Banerjee, C.J. and P.N. Prakash, J.)


Murugasamy  Vs  State 

Print Page

Tuesday, 31 December 2019

When postmortem report can be treated as substantive evidence without examining doctor?

Learned counsel for the appellants at the first instance
submitted that the doctor, who conducted the postmortem
examination of the deceased Smt. Ram Devi, was not
examined in the court, though the same has been marked as
exhibit by the court. Such a procedure adopted by the trial court
could not be approved, as the contents of the postmortem
report could not be admitted under Section 294 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, unless, the same was duly proved by the
doctor, who had prepared the same.
11. The submission of the learned counsel for the appellants
is legally not sustainable, in view of the settled position of law
that if the genuineness of any document filed by a party is not
disputed by the opposite party, it can be treated as substantive
evidence under sub-section (3) of Section 294 Cr.P.C. The
Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of Akhtar Vs State of
Uttaranchal (2009) 13 SCC 722, has observed that if the
defence has admitted the genuineness of the postmortem
report before the trial court, the genuineness and veracity of the
document stands proved and shall be treated as valid evidence
under Section 294 Cr.P.C. The relevant portion is quoted
below:-
“21. It has been argued that non-examination of the
concerned medical officers is fatal for the prosecution.
However, there is no denial of the fact that the defence
admitted the genuineness of the injury reports and the post
mortem examination reports before the trial court. So the
genuineness and authenticity of the documents stands
proved and shall be treated as valid evidence under
Section 294 of the CrPC. It is settled position of law that if
the genuineness of any document filed by a party is not
disputed by the opposite party it can be read as
substantive evidence under sub-Section (3) of Section 294
CrPC. Accordingly, the post-mortem report, if its
genuineness is not disputed by the opposite party, the said

post-mortem report can be read as substantive evidence to
prove the correctness of its contents without the doctor
concerned being examined.”
ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT

Case :- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. - 3079 of 1985

Bijendra Singh  Vs State of U.P.

Hon'ble Govind Mathur,Chief Justice
Hon'ble Vivek Varma,J.
(Per.:-Hon. Vivek Varma, J)
Print Page

Saturday, 28 December 2019

Supreme Court: Prior contradictory statement of witness is not substantive evidence

There is a cardinal distinction between a party who is the author of a prior statement and a witness who is examined and is sought to be discredited by use of his prior statement. In the former case an admission by a party is substantive evidence if it fulfils the requirements of Section 21 of the Evidence Act; in the latter case a prior statement is used to discredit the credibility of the witness and does not become substantive evidence. In the former there is no necessary requirement of the statement containing the admission having to be put to the party because it is evidence proprio vigore : in the latter case the Court cannot be invited to disbelieve a witness on the strength of a prior contradictory statement unless it has been put to him, as required by Section 145 of the Evidence Act. This distinction has been clearly brought out in the ruling in Bharat Singh v. Bhagirathi MANU/SC/0362/1965 : [1966]1SCR606 . This Court disposed of a similar argument with the following observations :

Admissions are substantive evidence by themselves, in view of Sections 17 and 21 of the Indian Evidence Act, though they are not conclusive proof of the matters admitted. We are of opinion that the admissions duly proved are admissible evidence irrespective of whether the party making them appeared in the witness box or not and whether that party when appearing as witness was confronted with those statements in case it made a statement contrary to those admissions. The purpose of contradicting the witness under Section 145 of the Evidence Act is very much different from the purpose of proving the admission. Admission is substantive evidence of the fact admitted while a previous statement used to contradict a witness does not become substantive and merely serves the purpose of throwing doubt on the veracity of the witness.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 1787 of 1967

Decided On: 30.10.1973

Bishwanath Prasad  Vs. Dwarka Prasad

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
H.R. Khanna, R.S. Sarkaria and V.R. Krishna Iyer, JJ.

Citation: AIR 1974 SC 117,
Print Page

Monday, 30 September 2019

Whether admission given by accused during investigation is substantive evidence?

 Bar Under Section 162 Code of Criminal Procedure, no doubt, operates in regard to the statement made to a Police Officer in between two points of time, viz., from the beginning of the investigation till the termination of the same. In a case where statement containing not a confession but admission, which is otherwise relevant and which is made before the investigation commences, may be admissible. We need not, however, say anything more.

42. In Central Bureau of Investigation v. V.C. Shukla and Ors. MANU/SC/0168/1998 : AIR 1998 SC 1406, a Bench of three learned Judges, after approving Pakala Narayana Swami (supra), had occasion to consider the distinction between confession and admission. This Court went on to hold as follows:

45. It is thus seen that only voluntary and direct acknowledgement of guilt is a confession but when a confession falls short of actual admission of guilt it may nevertheless be used as evidence against the person who made it or his authorised agent as an "admission" Under Section 21. The law in this regard has been clearly - and in our considered view correctly - explained in Monir's Law of Evidence(New Edn. at pp. 205 and 206), on which Mr. Jethmalani relied to bring home his contention that even if the entries are treated as "admission" of the Jains still they cannot be used against Shri Advani. The relevant passage reads as under:

The distinction between admissions and confessions is of considerable importance for two reasons. Firstly, a statement made by an Accused person, if it is an admission, is admissible in evidence Under Section 21 of the Evidence Act, unless the statement amounts to a confession and was made to a person in authority in consequence of some improper inducement, threat or promise, or was made to a Police Officer, or was made at a time when the Accused was in custody of a Police Officer. If a statement was made by the Accused in the circumstances just mentioned its admissibility will depend upon the determination of the question whether it does not amount to a confession. If it amounts to a confession, it will be inadmissible, but if it does not amount to a confession, it will be admissible Under Section 21 of the Act as an admission, provided that it suggests an inference as to a fact which is in issue in, or relevant to, the case and was not made to a Police Officer in the course of an investigation under Chapter XIV of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Secondly, a statement made by an Accused person is admissible against others who are being jointly tried with him only if the statement amounts to a confession. Where the statement falls short of a confession, it is admissible only against its maker as an admission and not against those who are being jointly tried with him. Therefore, from the point of view of Section 30 of the Evidence Act also the distinction between an admission and a confession is of fundamental importance.

(Emphasis supplied)

43. Section 21 of the Evidence Act provides as follows:

21. Proof of admissions against persons making them, and by or on their behalf.-Admissions are relevant and may be proved as against the person who makes them, or his representative in interest; but they cannot be proved by or on behalf of the person who makes them or by his representative in interest, except in the following cases:

(1) An admission may be proved by or on behalf of the person making it, when it is of such a nature that, if the person making it were dead, it would be relevant as between third persons Under Section 32.

(2) An admission may be proved by or on behalf of the person making it, when it consists of a statement of the existence of any state of mind or body, relevant or in issue, made at or about the time when such state of mind or body existed, and is accompanied by conduct rendering its falsehood improbable.

(3) An admission may be proved by or on behalf of the person making it, if it is relevant otherwise than as an admission.

44. Thus, what amounts to an admission can be used against the maker of the admission or his representative in interest. As to what constitutes an admission is to be found in Section 17 of the Evidence Act, which defines admission as follows:

17. Admission defined.-An admission is a statement, oral or documentary or contained in electronic form, which suggests any inference as to any fact in issue or relevant fact, and which is made by any of the persons, and under the circumstances, hereinafter mentioned.

45. In Bharat Singh and Ors. v. Mst. Bhagirathi MANU/SC/0362/1965 : AIR 1966 SC 405, the true nature of the evidentiary value of admission, and whether without confronting the maker of the admission, it could be used, has been referred to and this is what this Court had to say:

19. Admissions have to be clear if they are to be used against the person making them. Admissions are substantive evidence by themselves, in view of Sections 17, and 21 of the Indian Evidence Act, though they are not conclusive proof of the matters admitted. We are of opinion that the admissions duly proved are admissible evidence irrespective of whether the party making them appeared in the witness box or not and whether that party when appearing as witness was confronted with those statements in case it made a statement contrary to those admissions. The purpose of contradicting the witness Under Section 145 of the Evidence Act is very much different from the purpose of proving the admission. Admission is substantive evidence of the fact admitted while a previous statement used to contradict a witness does not become substantive evidence and merely serves the purpose of throwing doubt on the veracity of the witness. What weight is to be attached to an admission made by a party is a matter different from its use as admissible evidence.

(Emphasis supplied)

46. From the statement of the law contained in V.C. Shukla and others (supra), it becomes clear as to what constitutes confession and how if it does not constitute confession, it may still be an admission. Being an admission, it may be admissible under the Evidence Act provided that it meets the requirements of admission as defined in Section 17 of the Evidence Act. However, even if it is an admission, if it is made in the course of investigation under the Code of Criminal Procedure to a Police Officer, then, it will not be admissible Under Section 162 of the Code of Criminal Procedure as it clearly prohibits the use of statement made to a Police Officer Under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure except for the purpose which is mentioned therein. Statement given Under Section 161, even if relevant, as it contains an admission, would not be admissible, though an admission falling short of a confession which may be made otherwise, may become substantive evidence.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 714 of 2019 

Decided On: 24.04.2019

 Dipakbhai Jagdishchandra Patel Vs. State of Gujarat and Ors.
Print Page

Saturday, 27 May 2017

Whether statements of witnesses recorded U/ S 161 and S 164 of CRPC are substantive evidence?

 It may be mentioned here that P.W. 6 and P.W. 7 have narrated the incident as disclosed by the victim girls and as recorded in their statements under section 161 of Cr.P.C. The learned trial Judge has also taken on record and exhibited these statements at Exhs. 75 and 78 colly. Needless to state that the statement recorded under section 161 of Cr.P.C. is not a substantive evidence. The statement under section 161 of Cr.P.C. cannot be used for the purpose of corroboration of any other witness. Under the proviso to section 162 of Cr.P.C., the statement made by the witness under section 161 of the Cr.P.C. can be used by the accused, and with the permission of the Court by the prosecution, to contradict such witness in the manner indicated in section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act. Similarly, a statement under section 164 of the Cr.P.C. is not substantive evidence. It can be used to corroborate the statement of a witness or to contradict a witness. The records of the present case indicate that the learned trial Judge has used the statements of the victims recorded under section 161 as well as 164 of Cr.P.C. as substantive evidence. The learned Judge has therefore committed a manifest illegality in taking on record and relying upon the wholly inadmissible evidence. The manner in which the learned trial Judge has conducted the trial is not satisfactory. However, these irregularities are not fatal as the same have not caused any prejudice to the accused.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Confirmation Case No. 03 of 2013, Criminal Appeal Nos. 426, 416, 452, 508, 528, 600 of 2013, 896 of 2014 and Criminal Application No. 191 of 2014 in Appeal 452 of 2013
Decided On: 11.03.2016
 State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Vs.
 Ramchandra Sambhaji Karanjule and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

R.V. More and Anuja Prabhudesai, JJ.

Citation: 2017 ALLMR(CRI) 1347
Print Page

Tuesday, 22 November 2016

How to prove contradiction in criminal case?

In her further Cross-Examination, however, she admitted that her statement was properly recorded by Narender Singh Patel (PW-9), Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Baramandal, District Almora. She also admitted that she had stated in her dying declaration that there was one jerry can. In our opinion, the witness, in her dying declaration dated 1.7.1989, mentioned about one jerry can as she had seen the accused throwing the petrol from one jerry can. Very strangely, this contradiction was not got proved from Narender Singh Patel (PW-9), Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Baramandal, District Almora nor was it put to him. Unless a contradiction is proved by putting it to the person who records the original statement, such contradiction is of no consequence. The only Cross-Examination of Narender Singh Patel (PW-9), Sub-Divisional Magistrate was to the effect that there was no certification on the dying declarations to the effect that both the witnesses were in fit condition to give the statement. When we see again the evidence of Vimla Devi (PW-1), even she was not specifically questioned about her previous statement nor was she given an opportunity to explain as to why she had made the statement in her evidence that there were three jerry cans as in her statement in dying declaration that there was one jerry can. Unless the witness is specifically given an opportunity to explain such contradiction, it cannot be taken note of. The very purpose of putting the contradiction to the witness is to give an opportunity to him/her to explain a contradictory statement, if any. There can be no dispute that when a witness making a dying declaration survives, the said dying declaration does not remain substantive evidence. However, as held inRamprasad v. State of Maharashtra [1999 (5) SCC 30] when such dying declaration has been recorded by a Magistrate then it can be used as a corroboration to the oral evidence of such witness. This Court in the aforementioned decision of Ram Prasad (cited supra) specifically held that where such statement is recorded by a Police Officer, its user is barred under Section 162Cr.P.C. However, where it is recorded by a Magistrate under Section 164, Cr.P.C. it becomes usable to corroborate the witness as proved under Section 157 of the Evidence Act. 
Reportable
Supreme Court of India
Sunder Singh vs State Of Uttaranchal on 16 September, 2010

Bench: V.S. Sirpurkar, A.K. Patnaik
Citation:(2010) 10 SCC611,2011 AIR SCW2455
Print Page

When dying declaration recorded by magistrate can be used for corroboration to evidence of said witness?

There can be no dispute that when a witness making a dying declaration survives, the said dying declaration does not remain substantive evidence. However, as held inRamprasad v. State of Maharashtra [1999 (5) SCC 30] when such dying declaration has been recorded by a Magistrate then it can be used as a corroboration to the oral evidence of such witness. This Court in the aforementioned decision of Ram Prasad (cited supra) specifically held that where such statement is recorded by a Police Officer, its user is barred under Section 162Cr.P.C. However, where it is recorded by a Magistrate under Section 164, Cr.P.C. it becomes usable to corroborate the witness as proved under Section 157 of the Evidence Act.
Reportable
Supreme Court of India
Sunder Singh vs State Of Uttaranchal on 16 September, 2010

Bench: V.S. Sirpurkar, A.K. Patnaik
Citation:(2010) 10 SCC611,2011 AIR SCW2455
Print Page

Friday, 25 December 2015

Whether evidence of handwriting expert is substantive evidence?

The evidence of identification of hand writing as furnished by a hand writing expert is opinion evidence. It is not substantive evidence. Therefore, the law that has developed of this point is that a conviction could not be based merely on evidence furnished by a hand writing expert unless there were intrinsic or other circumstances corroborating the inference at which the expert had arrived or the Court concerned being proficient in that language came to a conclusion similar to the conclusion of the expert. The earliest case to which my attention was invited is Ram Chandra and another v. State of Uttar Pradesh, . Jagannadhadas, J. delivering the judgment on behalf of the Court observed in paragraph 8:
"It may be that normally it is not safe to treat expert evidence as to handwriting as sufficient basis for conviction. It may be, however, relied upon along with other various items of external and internal evidence relating to the documents in question."
Bombay High Court
R. Parmeshwar Menon And Ganesh ... vs State Of Maharashtra on 7 July, 1981

Bench: R Padhye
Citation;1982 CR L R(MAH)39
Print Page

Wednesday, 19 February 2014

Whether statement recorded u/s 164 of CRPC is substantive evidence?


The second submission which is made by the learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant is that the statement of the prosecutrix which was recorded under Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure cannot be used as a substantive evidence also in my view has to be accepted. It is a settled position that a statement under Section 164 can be used only for the purpose of corroboratiou and contradiction and cannot be used as a substantive piece of evidence. In the case reported in Audumbar Digambar Jagdane and Anr. v. State of Maharashtra,1999 Cri. L. L. 1936 a Division Bench of this Court has observed in para 12 as under:-
"In our opinion once Narayan has not supported the prosecution, the statement given under 164. even if proved, can never be accepted as substantive evidence. In that behalf reference to the decision of the Privy Council is extremely
fruitful. The Committee of the Privy Council speaking through Sir John Beaumont, J. in the aforesaid decision on page 41 (of AIR): (at p.338 of Cri.L.J.) of the report has observed as under:
"...The learned Judges discussed in great detail the statements made by Haliman and Mahabir under Section 164 and gave reasons for accepting the facts or most of the facts, deposed to in those statements, in preference to the evidence given by the witnesses in Court, which in no way helped the prosecution. This was an improper use of such statements. A statement under Section 164 can be used to cross-examine the person who made it, and the result may be to show that the evidence of the witness is false. But that does not establish that what he stated out of Court under Section 164 is true".
8. The Supreme Court also in a number of cases has time and again held that a statement which is recorded under Section 164 can be used only for the purpose of corroboration and contradiction and not as a substantive piece of evidence.1

Bombay High Court
Sajji Kumar S/O Pappu Kumar vs State Of Goa (Through Public ... on 10 June, 2005

V.M. Kanade, J.
Print Page

Saturday, 26 January 2013

Supreme Court: FIR cannot be used as substantive evidence or corroborating a statement of third party,

It is contended that the FIR mentions the names of above persons who were specifically mentioned and it lends corroboration to the evidence of P.W. 2 We find no substance in this contention. The FIR cannot be used as substantive evidence or corroborating a statement of third party, i.e., P.W. 2 FIR cannot be used to corroborate the evidence of P.W. 2 It can be used either to corroborate or for contradiction of its maker.

Supreme Court of India
State Of Madhya Pradesh vs Surbhan on 15 April, 1996
Equivalent citations: 1996 IIAD SC 192, AIR 1996 SC 3345, 1996 (2) ALD Cri 96
Print Page

Saturday, 22 September 2012

Whether statement of witness recorded under s.164 of crpc is substantive evidence?

The learned Judges discussed in great detail the statements made by Haliman and Mahabir under Section 164 and gave reasons for accepting the facts, or most of the facts, deposed to in those statements, in preference to the evidence given by the witnesses in Court, which in no way helped the prosecution. This was an improper use of such statements. A statement under Section 164 can be used to cross-examine the person who made it, and the result may be to show that the evidence of the witness is false. But that does not establish that what he stated out of Court under Section 164 is true.
13. The Apex Court in the decision ) in
paragraph 8 has observed that a statement under Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is not substantive evidence. It can be used to corroborate the statement of a witness. It can be used to contradict a witness.
Bombay High Court
Audumbar Digambar Jagdane And ... vs State Of Maharashtra on 14 August, 1998
Equivalent citations: 1999 CriLJ 1936
Print Page