Showing posts with label triable issues. Show all posts
Showing posts with label triable issues. Show all posts

Sunday, 28 July 2024

Supreme Court: If the transaction is contained in more than one document between the same parties they must be read and interpreted together and they have the same legal effect for all purposes as if they are one document

 The defence so raised itself being the question of law, as the interpretation of documents itself goes to the root of the transactions/contract and the claim based upon it. In the present case, B.O.I. Finance Ltd. (Supra), as relied is not applicable on facts and the laws. That was a case of ready forward contract. In the case in hand, three documents and the transactions, of which two views of the learned Judges unless decided finally in due trial, it is difficult to accept the case that the view taken by the one learned Judge that transactions are sham and bogus and unseverable and other Judge hold it to be severable, without trial and by overlooking the earlier opinion, this itself is a triable issue. The Appellate Bench also may not decide such issue on such question of law, considering the scope and purpose of law on order XXXVII of the CPC, at this stage of the Summary Suit. It should be after final Judgment. In the present case, the same documents are interlinked and interconnected as observed by the earlier learned Judge, therefore, unless these findings are set aside, the findings in the impugned order that those are severable just cannot be accepted, without the trial. The case of misconstruction or interpretation of all connected documents itself made out a case of good defence. It cannot be treated as sham or bogus defence. The misinterpretation itself affects the rights and the transaction/claim. Therefore, the construction of documents is always question of law so is the position in case in hand. The distinction, therefore, at this stage, in summary proceedings like this, itself will not sufficient to deny the order of unconditional leave as granted by one Judge on the basis of same documents. (Sir Chunilal V. Mehta and sons Ltd. v. Century Spinning and Manufacturing Co. Ltd.11 and Hero Vinoth (Minor) v. Seshammal12) {Para 56}

Interpretation of documents and the nature of transactions-triable issue-

57. We have to consider the legal position in view of the contentions so raised by the learned counsel appearing for the parties. The Apex Court in Smt. Krishnabai Bhritar Ganpatrao Deshmukh v. Appasaheb Tuljaramarao Nimbalkar13, while dealing with the aspects of interpretation of any deed or documents, has held as under:-

“27. Secondly, there is ample authority for the proposition that when there is a dispute in regard to the true character of a writing, evidence de hors the document can be led to show that the writing was not the real nature of the transaction, but was only an illusory, fictitious and colourable device which cloaked something else, and that the apparent state of affairs was not the real state of affairs. [See Chandi Prasad Singh v. Piari Bidi C.A. No. 75 of 1964, decided on 16-3-1966, and Bhagwan Dayal v. Mst. Reoti Devi (supra)].

58. While dealing with the effect of various transactions, based upon the various documents, the Court required to deal with and take into consideration every connected transactions and the documents, to give total effect to the transactions by treating them all as one document. The Apex Court in (S. Chattanatha Karayalar v. The Central Bank of India Ltd.)14 has observed as under:-

3. ………. “The principle is well established that if the transaction is contained in more than one document between the same parties they must be read and interpreted together and they have the same legal effect for all purposes as if they are one document. In Manks v. Whiteley 1912-1 Ch. 735 at p. 754, Moulton, L.J. Stated:

“Where several deeds form part of one transaction and are contemporaneously executed they have the same effect for all purposes such as are relevant to this case as if they were one deed. Each is executed on the faith of all the others being executed also and is intended to speak only as part of the one transaction, and if one is seeking to make equities apply to the parties they must be equities arising out of the transaction as a whole.”

 In the High Court of Bombay

(Before Anoop V. Mohta and G.S. Kulkarni, JJ.)

Hubtown Limited Vs IDBI Trusteeship Service Limited, 

Commercial Appeal No. 7 of 2016


Decided on October 24, 2016

     

 Citation: 2016 SCC OnLine Bom 9019.
Read full Judgment here: Click here.
Print Page

Bombay HC: summary suit as originally filed, prior to the commencement of the and as now transferred, being commercial dispute matter, the original procedure as provided under Order XXXVII shall be applicable to such summary suits

“Summary Suit” and “Summary Judgment”-

34. The conceptual position of “summary suit” as contemplated under Order XXXVII of CPC and its specific provisions are governed as per the original provisions of CPC. The amended CPC, in view of Section 16 of the Commercial Courts Act inserted the provision for a “summary judgment”, through Order XIII-A which is made applicable to the classes of Suits (commercial suits) which required to be decided by the Commercial Division/Court. It prescribes the procedure and stages for application for summary judgment. This also includes and provides the powers of a Commercial Judge to pass conditional order including for evidence for hearing of summary judgment. We are concerned with Order XIII-A, Rule 1(3) of CPC, whereby it is specifically provided “notwithstanding anything to the contrary, “an application” for summary judgment under this Order shall not be made in a Suit in respect of any commercial disputes that is originally filed as a summary suit under Order XXXVII.”. Therefore, once the summary suit as originally filed, prior to the commencement of the and as now transferred, being commercial dispute matter, the original procedure as provided under Order XXXVII shall be applicable to such summary suits. The parties are not entitled to prayer for summary judgment under XIII-A in view of the specific provision so referred above. This also means that the judgments and the issues so decided in summary suit shall for all purposes be governed by the CPC, even after such suits are transferred as commercial suits. The Commercial Division Judge is required to follow the original C.P.C. and is required to keep in mind the position in law revolving around all the facets of summary suits. The provisions of Section 13, therefore, is required to be interpreted and/or considered accordingly, when any decision is given by the Commercial Division/Court in such summary suit. 

 In the High Court of Bombay

(Before Anoop V. Mohta and G.S. Kulkarni, JJ.)

Hubtown Limited Vs IDBI Trusteeship Service Limited, 

Commercial Appeal No. 7 of 2016


Decided on October 24, 2016

     
                                           Citation: 2016 SCC OnLine Bom 9019.

Print Page

Saturday, 14 January 2023

Whether it is necessary to file pleadings, issues and judgment of previous suit to prove the plea of res judicata?

 The rule of res judicata does not strike at the root of the jurisdiction of the court trying the subsequent suit. It is a rule of estoppel by judgment based on the public policy that there should be a finality to litigation and no one should be vexed twice for the same cause. {Para 11}

12. The plea of res judicata is founded on proof of certain facts and then by applying the law to the facts so found. It is, therefore, necessary that the foundation for the plea must be laid in the pleadings and then an issue must be framed and tried. A plea not properly raised in the pleadings or in issues at the stage of the trial, would not be permitted to be raised for the first time at the stage of appeal (See: (Raja) Jagadish Chandra Deo Dhabal Deb v. Gour Hari Mahato and Ors. - MANU/PR/0022/1936, Madeapati Surava and Ors. v. Tondapu Bala Gangadhara Ramakrishna Reddi and Ors. - MANU/PR/0002/1947, Katragada China Anjanevulu and Anr. v. Kattragada China Ramava and Ors. - MANU/AP/0136/1965 : AIR1965AP177 ). The view taken by the Privy Council was cited with approval before this Court in The State of Punjab v. Bua Das Kaushal - MANU/SC/0492/1970 : (1971)ILLJ31SC . However, an exception was carved out by this Court and the plea was permitted to be raised, though not taken in the pleadings nor covered by any issue, because the necessary facts were present to the mind of the parties and were gone into by the Trial Court. The opposite party had ample opportunity of leading the evidence in rebuttal of the plea. The Court concluded that the point of res judicata had through out been in consideration and discussion and so the want of pleadings or plea of waiver of res judicata cannot be allowed to be urged.

13. Not only the plea has to be taken, it has to be substantiated by producing the copies of the pleadings, issues and judgment in the previous case. May be in a given case only copy of judgment in previous suit is filed in proof of plea of res judicata and the judgment contains exhaustive or in requisite details the statement of pleadings and the issues which may be taken as enough proof. But as pointed out in Syed Mohd. Salie Labbai (Dead) By Lrs. and Ors. v. Mohd. Hanifa (Dead) by Lrs. and Ors. - MANU/SC/0510/1976 : [1976]3SCR721 , the basic method to decide the question of res judicata is first to determine the case of the parties as put forward in their respective pleadings of their previous suit and then to find out as to what had been decided by the judgment which operates as res judicata.

It is risky to speculate about the pleadings merely by a summary of recitals of the allegations made in the pleadings mentioned in the judgment. The Constitution Bench in Gurbux Singh v. Bhoralal - MANU/SC/0241/1964 : [1964]7SCR831 , placing on a par the plea of res judicata and the plea of estoppel under Order II Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, held that proof of the plaint in the previous suit which is set to create the bar, ought to be brought on record. The plea is basically founded on the identity of the cause of action in the two suits and, therefore, it is necessary for the defence which raises the bar to establish the cause of action in the previous suit. Such pleas cannot be left to be determined by mere speculation or inferring by a process of deduction what were the facts stated in the previous pleadings. Their Lordships of the Privy Council in Kali Krishna Tagore v. Secretary of State For India in Council and Anr. - (1887) 15 IA 186, pointed out that the plea of res judicata cannot be determined without ascertaining what were the matters in issues in the previous suit and what was heard and decided. Needless to say these can be found out only by looking into the pleadings, the issues and the judgment in the previous suit.

14. That apart the plea, depending on the facts of a given case, is capable of being waived, if not properly raised at an appropriate stage and in an appropriate manner. The party adversely affected by the plea of res judicata may proceed on an assumption that his opponent had waived the plea by his failure to raise the same. 

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 7653 and 7654 of 1997

V. Rajeshwari Vs. T.C. Saravanabava

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

R.C. Lahoti and Ashok Bhan, JJ.

Author: R.C. Lahoti, J.

Decided On: 16.12.2003

Citation: MANU/SC/1057/2003,(2004) 1 SCC 551
Print Page

Saturday, 28 September 2019

When plaint can not be rejected as barred by limitation?

It is clear that in order to consider Order 7 Rule 11, the court has to look into the averments in the plaint and the same can be exercised by the trial court at any stage of the suit. It is also clear that the averments in the written statement are immaterial and it is the duty of the Court to scrutinise the averments/pleas in the plaint. In other words, what needs to be looked into in deciding such an application are the averments in the plaint. At that stage, the pleas taken by the Defendant in the written statement are wholly irrelevant and the matter is to be decided only on the plaint averments. These principles have been reiterated in Raptakos Brett & Co. Ltd. v. Ganesh Property and Mayar (H.K.) Ltd. v. Vessel M.V. Fortune Express.


 In the present case, we find that the Appellants (Plaintiffs) have asserted that the suit was filed immediately after getting knowledge about the fraudulent sale deed executed by original Defendant Nos. 1 & 2 by keeping them in the dark about such execution and within two days from the refusal by the original Defendant Nos. 1 & 2 to refrain from obstructing the peaceful enjoyment of use and possession of the ancestral property of the Appellants. We affirm the view taken by the Trial Court that the issue regarding the suit being barred by limitation in the facts of the present case, is a triable issue and for which reason the plaint cannot be rejected at the threshold in exercise of the power Under Order VII Rule 11(d).

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 3500 of 2018 

Decided On: 10.04.2018

Chhotanben Vs.  Kiritbhai Jalkrushnabhai Thakkar and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dipak Misra, C.J.I., A.M. Khanwilkar and Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud, JJ.

Citation: 2019(2) MHLJ 17
Print Page

Tuesday, 10 September 2019

Whether prosecution for dishonour of cheque can be quashed on ground that notice was not served within statutory period?

After hearing counsel for the appellant, we
have no manner of doubt that the reason commended to
the High Court, is unacceptable. For, the fact that
notice was duly served on the respondent or
otherwise, is a triable issue; and cannot be
proceeded as an indisputable position-as is expounded
by this Court in ‘Ajeet Seeds Limited vs. K. Gopala
Krishnaiah’ reported in (2014) 12 SCC 685.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.1325 OF 2019

KISHORE SHARMA  Vs  SACHIN DUBEY 

Dated:SEPTEMBER 03, 2019
Print Page

Friday, 19 April 2019

Whether plaint can be rejected considering defence plea that suit is barred by limitation?

 What is relevant for answering the matter in issue in the context of the application Under Order VII Rule 11(d), is to examine the averments in the plaint. The plaint is required to be read as a whole. The defence available to the Defendants or the plea taken by them in the written statement or any application filed by them, cannot be the basis to decide the application Under Order VII Rule 11(d). Only the averments in the plaint are germane. The limitation to challenge the registered sale deed ordinarily would start running from the date on which the sale deed was registered. However, the specific case of the Appellants (Plaintiffs) is that until 2013 they had no knowledge whatsoever regarding execution of such sale deed by their brothers-original Defendant Nos. 1 & 2, in favour of Jaikrishnabhai Prabhudas Thakkar or Defendant Nos. 3 to 6. They acquired that knowledge on 26.12.2012 and immediately took steps to obtain a certified copy of the registered sale deed and on receipt thereof they realised the fraud played on them by their brothers concerning the ancestral property and two days prior to the filing of the suit, had approached their brothers (original Defendant Nos. 1 & 2) calling upon them to stop interfering with their possession and to partition the property and provide exclusive possession of half (1/2) portion of the land so designated towards their share. However, when they realized that the original Defendant Nos. 1 & 2 would not pay any heed to their request, they had no other option but to approach the court of law and filed the subject suit within two days therefrom. According to the Appellants, the suit has been filed within time after acquiring the knowledge about the execution of the registered sale deed. In this context, the Trial Court opined that it was a triable issue and declined to accept the application filed by Respondent No. 1 (Defendant No. 5) for rejection of the plaint Under Order VII Rule 11(d). That view commends to us.
 In the present case, we find that the Appellants (Plaintiffs) have asserted that the suit was filed immediately after getting knowledge about the fraudulent sale deed executed by original Defendant Nos. 1 & 2 by keeping them in the dark about such execution and within two days from the refusal by the original Defendant Nos. 1 & 2 to refrain from obstructing the peaceful enjoyment of use and possession of the ancestral property of the Appellants. We affirm the view taken by the Trial Court that the issue regarding the suit being barred by limitation in the facts of the present case, is a triable issue and for which reason the plaint cannot be rejected at the threshold in exercise of the power Under Order VII Rule 11(d).

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 3500 of 2018 (Arising out of SLP (Civil) No. 26401 of 2017)

Decided On: 10.04.2018

 Chhotanben  Vs.  Kiritbhai Jalkrushnabhai Thakkar and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dipak Misra, C.J.I., A.M. Khanwilkar and Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud, JJ.
Citation: 2019(2) MHLJ 17
Print Page

Sunday, 30 September 2018

Whether court should reject plaint as barred by limitation if it was triable issue?

 What is relevant for answering the matter in issue in the context of the application Under Order VII Rule 11(d), is to examine the averments in the plaint. The plaint is required to be read as a whole. The defence available to the Defendants or the plea taken by them in the written statement or any application filed by them, cannot be the basis to decide the application Under Order VII Rule 11(d). Only the averments in the plaint are germane. It is common ground that the registered sale deed is dated 18th October, 1996. The limitation to challenge the registered sale deed ordinarily would start running from the date on which the sale deed was registered. However, the specific case of the Appellants (Plaintiffs) is that until 2013 they had no knowledge whatsoever regarding execution of such sale deed by their brothers-original Defendant Nos. 1 & 2, in favour of Jaikrishnabhai Prabhudas Thakkar or Defendant Nos. 3 to 6. They acquired that knowledge on 26.12.2012 and immediately took steps to obtain a certified copy of the registered sale deed and on receipt thereof they realised the fraud played on them by their brothers concerning the ancestral property and two days prior to the filing of the suit, had approached their brothers (original Defendant Nos. 1 & 2) calling upon them to stop interfering with their possession and to partition the property and provide exclusive possession of half (1/2) portion of the land so designated towards their share. However, when they realized that the original Defendant Nos. 1 & 2 would not pay any heed to their request, they had no other option but to approach the court of law and filed the subject suit within two days therefrom. According to the Appellants, the suit has been filed within time after acquiring the knowledge about the execution of the registered sale deed. In this context, the Trial Court opined that it was a triable issue and declined to accept the application filed by Respondent No. 1 (Defendant No. 5) for rejection of the plaint Under Order VII Rule 11(d). That view commends to us.



16. In the present case, we find that the Appellants (Plaintiffs) have asserted that the suit was filed immediately after getting knowledge about the fraudulent sale deed executed by original Defendant Nos. 1 & 2 by keeping them in the dark about such execution and within two days from the refusal by the original Defendant Nos. 1 & 2 to refrain from obstructing the peaceful enjoyment of use and possession of the ancestral property of the Appellants. We affirm the view taken by the Trial Court that the issue regarding the suit being barred by limitation in the facts of the present case, is a triable issue and for which reason the plaint cannot be rejected at the threshold in exercise of the power Under Order VII Rule 11(d).

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal No. 3500 of 2018 (Arising out of SLP (Civil) No. 26401 of 2017)

Decided On: 10.04.2018

 Chhotanben Vs. Kiritbhai Jalkrushnabhai Thakkar and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dipak Misra, C.J.I., A.M. Khanwilkar and Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud, JJ.

Citation:(2018) 6 SCC 422
Print Page

Monday, 6 February 2017

When court should grant unconditional leave to defend in summary suit?

 Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that even if it is presumed that the petitioner has admitted else where that sum of Rs. 2,30,000/- is due that does not imply that learned trial Judge could ask the petitioner to deposit a sum of Rs. 2,50,000/- as a condition for granting leave to defend. He submits that question as to when defendant could be ordered to deposit amount in the Court has been considered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Sunil Enterprises And Another Vs. SBI Commercial & International Bank Ltd. Reported in (1998)5 Supreme Court Cases 354 and the law on the point has been summarized by the Supreme Court in para 4 of its judgment in the following words:
"The propositions laid down in these decisions may be summed up as follows:
[a] If the defendant satisfies the court that he has a good defence to the claim on merits, the defendant is entitled to unconditional leave to defend.
[b] If the defendant raises a triable issue indicating that he has a fair or bona fide or reasonable defence, although not a possibly good defence, the defendant is entitled to unconditional leave to defend.
[c] If the defendant discloses such facts as may be deemed sufficient to entitle him to defend, that is, if the affidavit discloses that at the trial he may be able to establish a defence to the plaintiff's claim, the court may impose conditions at the time of granting leave to defend - the conditions being as to time of trial or mode of trial but not as to payment into court or furnishing security.
[d] If the defendant has no defence, or if the defence is sham or illusory or practically moonshine, the defendant is not entitled to leave to defend.
[e] If the defendant has no defence or the defence is illusory or sham or practically moonshine, the court may show mercy to the defendant by enabling him to try to prove a defence but at the same time protect the plaintiff imposing the condition that the amount claimed should be paid into court or otherwise secured."
He submitted that after having held that the defendant has raised a triable issue and there is fair dispute to be tried, it was not open to the learned Judge to impose condition of depositing sum of Rs.
2,50,000/-. He submitted that Clause [b] of the aforesaid observation by the Supreme Court would show that if the defendant raises a triable issue indicating that he has fair, bona fide or reasonable defence, although not a possibly good defendant, the defendant is entitled to unconditional leave to defend.
6] Learned counsel for the respondent submitted that this judgment has been considered by the Apex Court subsequently in SIFY Ltd. Vs. First Flight Couriers Ltd. 2008(4) Maharashtra Law Journal 620. He submitted that the order passed by the learned trial Judge granting leave to defend is a discretionary order and therefore ordinarily higher forum should not interfere in exercise of said discretion. He submitted that in the face of observations of the Court that some of Rs. 2,30,000/- was due from the petitioner there is absolutely no warrant for interfering in the exercise of the discretion by the trial Court to direct the petitioner to deposit sum of Rs. 2,50,000/-.
7] I have carefully considered both the submissions. There can be no doubt that writ court need not interfer in an order passed by the trial Judge in exercise of its discretion. However, if the discretion is shown to have been exercised disregarding law laid down by the Supreme Court and would result in virtually shutting out the defence it would be necessary to interfere, and therefore, since learned trial judge could not have imposed a condition asking the petitioner to deposit a sum of Rs. 2,50,000/- in the light of the observations by the Supreme Court quoted above, the order cannot be sustained. 
Bombay High Court
Smita w/o Yashwant Lipte vs Suryakant Sadashiv Arade 
on 9 March, 2010
Bench: R. C. Chavan
Print Page

Sunday, 5 February 2017

Whether court should grant leave to defend in summary suit if triable issues are raised?

 In the case of International Computer's Consultants v. Home Computers Services (P) Limited, (1997-3) 117 P.L.R. 10, a Division Bench took the view that once triable issues are raised with bonafide and firm defence, leave should be granted. But if the defence is frivolous or vexatious, leave should be refused. Where there is reasonable doubt and the Court feel it just and reasonable, the Court may impose such condition while granting the leave, as it may deem fit and proper.
Punjab-Haryana High Court
Mrs. Ramesh Rani vs Harsh Malhotra And Ors. on 12 August, 1999
Equivalent citations: (1999) 123 PLR 453

Bench: Swatanter Kumar, J.
Print Page