Showing posts with label alteration of charge. Show all posts
Showing posts with label alteration of charge. Show all posts

Friday, 3 October 2025

Alteration of Charge in Criminal Trials: Navigating the Nuances of Section 216 CrPC

 In the intricate process of criminal adjudication, the framing and alteration of charges form a critical pivot on which the quest for justice often turns. Section 216 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) empowers courts with the authority to alter or add to charges before the delivery of judgment, a provision that ensures the evolving factual matrix is reflected adequately in trials. Yet, this judicial power demands a careful balance to uphold the accused's right to a fair defense while adjusting the legal framing of offences.

Understanding Alteration of Charge

Print Page

Sunday, 15 June 2025

Can prosecution or accused apply for alteration of charge in criminal appeal?

 Power to Alter Charges: Exclusive Judicial Prerogative

The power to alter charges under Section 216 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) lies exclusively with the court and cannot be invoked through an application by either the prosecution or the accused. This principle applies equally to both trial courts and appellate courts.

No Right to Apply for Charge Alteration

Neither party can seek alteration as a matter of right. The Supreme Court has clearly established that there is no right in any party to seek addition or alteration of charges by filing any application as a matter of right. The Kerala High Court reinforced this principle, noting that while a prosecution's application for charge alteration could not be entertained, the trial court retained discretion to independently alter or add charges if deemed necessary based on evidence presented.

Print Page

Saturday, 28 September 2024

Whether the court can convict accused U/S 302 R/W S 34 of IPC if he was charged U/S 302 R/W S 149 of IPC?

 Be that as it may, the determination of common intention or common object should primarily be within the domain of the trial courts, and at the most the high courts. It should not be the role of this Court to directly adjudicate issues of common intention and common object. This Court has, in a catena of decisions, elaborated on the differences between Section 149 and Section 34, Indian Penal Code; the overlapping nature of Section 149 and Section 34, Indian Penal Code; and when can the offence Under Section 302 read with Section 149, Indian Penal Code be changed to Section 302 read with Section 34, Indian Penal Code. Such decisions do provide suitable guidance for the lower courts to draw from, to reach their conclusions. {Para 21}


22. In this connection, we may refer to paragraph 14 of the decision of this Court in Chittarmal v. State of Rajasthan   MANU/SC/0008/2003 : 2003:INSC:5 : (2003) 2 SCC 266. The relevant excerpt from such decision reads:


14. It is well settled by a catena of decisions that Section 34 as well as Section 149 deal with liability for constructive criminality i.e. vicarious liability of a person for acts of others. Both the Sections deal with combinations of persons who become punishable as sharers in an offence. Thus, they have a certain resemblance and may to some extent overlap. But a clear distinction is made out between common intention and common object in that common intention denotes action concert and necessarily postulates the existence of a prearranged plan implying a prior meeting of the minds, while common object does not necessarily require proof of prior meeting of minds or preconcert. Though there is a substantial difference between the two sections, they also to some extent overlap and it is a question to be determined on the facts of each case whether the charge Under Section 149 overlaps the ground covered by Section 34. Thus, if several persons numbering five or more, do an act and intend to do it, both Section 34 and Section 149 may apply. If the common object does not necessarily involve a common intention, then the substitution of Section 34 for Section 149 might result in prejudice to the Accused and ought not, therefore, to be permitted. But if it does involve a common intention then the substitution of Section 34 for Section 149 must be held to be a formal matter. Whether such recourse can be had or not must depend on the facts of each case. The non-applicability of Section 149 is, therefore, no bar in convicting the Appellants Under Section 302 read with Section 34 Indian Penal Code, if the evidence discloses commission of an offence in furtherance of the common intention of them all. 

23. In paragraph 17 of the decision of this Court in Chandra Pratap Singh v. State of M.P.   MANU/SC/1100/2023 : 2023:INSC:887 : (2023) 10 SCC 181, while dealing with conversion of charge from Section 302 read with Section 149, Indian Penal Code to Section 302 read with Section 34 thereof, the above passage has been quoted with approval.

24. It would be relevant at this juncture to consider Section 464 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. On its plain terms, Sub-section (1) of Section 464 clearly indicates that no finding, sentence or order by a court of competent jurisdiction shall be deemed invalid merely on the ground that no charge was framed or on the ground of any error, omission or irregularity in the charge including any misjoinder of charges, unless, in an appeal, confirmation or revision, a claim of "failure of justice" has been substantiated.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1389 of 2012

Decided On: 25.09.2024

Baljinder Singh and Ors. Vs. State of Punjab

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Dipankar Datta and Augustine George Masih, JJ.

Author: Dipankar Datta, J.

Citation: MANU/SC/1063/2024.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Whether convict can challenge conviction on the ground of conversion of charge if he fails to prove Failure Of Justice?

 In paragraph 17 of the decision of this Court in Chandra Pratap Singh v. State of M.P.   MANU/SC/1100/2023 : 2023:INSC:887 : (2023) 10 SCC 181, while dealing with conversion of charge from Section 302 read with Section 149, Indian Penal Code to Section 302 read with Section 34 thereof, the above passage has been quoted with approval. {Para 23}

24. It would be relevant at this juncture to consider Section 464 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. On its plain terms, Sub-section (1) of Section 464 clearly indicates that no finding, sentence or order by a court of competent jurisdiction shall be deemed invalid merely on the ground that no charge was framed or on the ground of any error, omission or irregularity in the charge including any misjoinder of charges, unless, in an appeal, confirmation or revision, a claim of "failure of justice" has been substantiated.

25. Law is well-settled that in order to judge whether a failure of justice has been occasioned, it will be relevant to examine whether the Accused was aware of the basic ingredients of the offence for which he is being convicted and whether the main facts sought to be established against him were explained to him clearly and whether he got a fair chance to defend himself. Reference in this connection may be made to the decision in Dalbir Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh   MANU/SC/0320/2004 : 2004:INSC:243 : (2004) 5 SCC 334.

26. Also, it is beyond any cavil of doubt that the burden to show that in fact a failure of justice has been occasioned is on the Accused. The decision in State of Uttar Pradesh v. Paras Nath Singh   MANU/SC/0973/2009 : 2009:INSC:669 : (2009) 6 SCC 372 can profitably be referred to in this regard.

27. We have no hesitation to hold that based on the above parameters, the Appellants have fairly and squarely failed in their pursuit to demonstrate any failure of justice, which would impel us to exercise power of the nature contemplated in Sub-section (2) of Section 464, Code of Criminal Procedure. We, therefore, see no reason to uphold the contention advanced on behalf of the Appellants to the contrary.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1389 of 2012

Decided On: 25.09.2024

Baljinder Singh and Ors. Vs. State of Punjab

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Dipankar Datta and Augustine George Masih, JJ.

Author: Dipankar Datta, J.

Citation: MANU/SC/1063/2024.

Read full Judgment here: Click here.

Print Page

Supreme Court: Under which circumstances prosecution case can not be dismissed for non examination of independent witnesses

 It is also settled law that examination of independent witness is not an indispensable requisite if the testimonies of other witnesses are deemed trustworthy and reliable. Non-examination of any independent witness by the prosecution will not go to the root of the matter affecting the decision of the court, unless other witnesses' testimonies and evidences are scant to establish the guilt of the Accused. {Para 29}

24.3. In Rizwan Khan v. State of Chhattisgarh   MANU/SC/0680/2020 : 2020:INSC:543 : (2020) 9 SCC 627, after referring to the decision of this Court in State of H.P. v. Pardeep Kumar   MANU/SC/0213/2018 : 2018:INSC:166 : (2018) 13 SCC 808, it is observed and held by this Court that the examination of the independent witnesses is not an indispensable requirement and such non-examination is not necessarily fatal to the prosecution case.

(emphasis supplied)

30. It has been rightly pointed out by the Trial Court that the prosecution's case is not that people from the surrounding locality gathered at the time of the incident. In the light of the aforenoted decisions of this Court and upon careful examination of the testimonies of P.W. 3, P.W. 4, and P.W. 5, along with the relevant other evidence on record, the prosecution's case cannot be dismissed solely on the ground of the absence of independent witness.

 IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 1389 of 2012

Decided On: 25.09.2024

Baljinder Singh and Ors. Vs. State of Punjab

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Dipankar Datta and Augustine George Masih, JJ.

Author: Dipankar Datta, J.

Citation: MANU/SC/1063/2024.

Print Page

Sunday, 1 September 2024

Supreme Court Deplores Practice Of Filing Applications U/S 216 CrPC For Alteration Of Charge After Refusal Of Discharge

 It is trite to say that Section 216 is an enabling provision which enables the court to alter or add to any charge at any time before judgment is pronounced, and if any alternation or addition to a charge is made, the court has to follow the procedure as contained therein. Section 216 does not give any right to the accused to file a fresh application seeking his discharge after the charge is framed by the court, more particularly when his application seeking discharge under Section 227 has already been dismissed. Unfortunately, such applications are being filed in the trial courts sometimes in ignorance of law and sometimes deliberately to delay the proceedings. Once such applications though untenable are filed, the trial courts have no alternative but to decide them, and then again such orders would be challenged before the higher courts, and the whole criminal trial would get derailed. Suffice it to say that such practice is highly deplorable, and if followed, should be dealt with sternly by the courts. {Para 11}

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. ……..OF 2024

(@SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (Crl.) No.2029 OF 2018

K. RAVI  Vs STATE OF TAMIL NADU & ANR. 

Author: BELA M. TRIVEDI, J.

Dated: AUGUST 29, 2024.

Citation: 2024 INSC 642.
Print Page

Wednesday, 5 August 2020

Whether the court should pass specific order for new trial/de novo trial after alteration or addition of charge?

 The matter can be viewed from another angle also. Section 216 of the Code empowers the Court to alter or add to any charge at any time before the judgment is pronounced and provides that after such alteration or addition of the charge the Court is required to read and explain the same to the accused in accordance with Sub-section (2) thereof. It is further laid down under Sub-section (3) that if in the opinion of the Court the alteration or addition to a charge is not likely to prejudice the accused in his defence or the prosecutor in the conduct of the case the Court may in its discretion proceed with the trial immediately with the altered or added charge. Sub-section (4) provides that if the alteration or addition is such that the proceeding immediately with the trial is likely to prejudice the accused or the prosecutor the Court may either direct a new trial or adjourn the trial for such period as may be necessary. Section 217 of the Code provides that whenever a charge is altered or added to by the Court after the commencement of the trial the prosecutor and the accused shall be allowed to recall or to summon and examine with reference to such alteration or addition any witness who has already been examined unless the Court for reasons to be recorded in writing considers that the desire to recall or re-examine such witness was only for the purposes of vexation or delay or defeating the ends of justice. Besides, it permits the prosecutor and the accused to call any further witness whom the Court may think it to be material. On a combined reading of the above two sections it is, therefore, evident that after an alteration or addition of the charge the interest of the prosecution and the accused has to be safeguarded by permitting them to further examine or cross examine the witness already examined, as the case may be, and by affording them an opportunity to call other witnesses. It is undoubtedly true that discretion has been given to the Court to direct a new trial after addition or alteration of any charge, but it does not mean that every such addition or alteration in the charge which has been read over and explained to the accused would lead to inevitable inference that the Court has directed a new trial for them. It, therefore, follows that unless the Court passes a specific order and directs a new trial it cannot be presumed that a new trial has commenced only because an alteration or addition to a charge which has been read over and explained to the accused has been made. Indeed the order dated April 30, 1987 shows that while directing the prosecution to examine the 4 witnesses afresh the 5th Court adjourned the case for further trial and did not direct fresh trial. This apart, any such direction given by the Court has to be judged on the touchstone of prejudice to the accused or the prosecution. In the instant case, as has already been noticed after the addition of charges the prosecution expressly stated that they did not want to further examine the four witnesses already examined but they were willing to produce them if the accused so wanted. The accused, however, did not avail of this opportunity in accordance with Section 217 of the Code and, therefore, it is too late in the day for them to raise a grievance on that score. We hasten to add that even if we had found that there was any irregularity in the continuation of the trial against the appellants after the additional charges were framed, we would not have been justified in setting aside the impugned judgment on that ground alone for there is not an iota of material on record wherefrom it can be said that a failure of justice has occasioned thereby. To put if differently, in our view in such a case Section 465 of the Code would have squarely applied.{Para 23}
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. 34 of 1992

Decided On: 21.03.1995

Ranbir Yadav  Vs.   State of Bihar
Print Page

Tuesday, 4 August 2020

Whether the Appellate Court can add to or alter the charge in criminal case?

In Hasanbhai Valibhai Qureshi v. State of Gujarat MANU/SC/0302/2004 : AIR 2004 SC 2078, this Court held:

Therefore, if during trial the Trial Court, on a consideration of broad probabilities of the case, based upon total effect of the evidence and documents produced is satisfied that any addition or alteration of the charge is necessary, it is free to do so, and there can be no legal bar to appropriately act as the exigencies of the case warrant or necessitate.
16. Such power empowering alteration/addition of charge(s), can also be exercised by the appellate court, in exercise of its powers Under Sections 385(2) and 386 Code of Criminal Procedure.{Para 15}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal Nos. 46 and 171 of 2005

Decided On: 04.09.2012

 Bhimanna Vs.   State of Karnataka

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
P. Sathasivam and B.S. Chauhan, JJ.

Citation: MANU/SC/0720/2012,(2012) 9 SCC 650,AIR 2012 SC 3026
Print Page

Saturday, 25 January 2020

Whether court can alter or add charges against accused when case is closed for judgment?

In Jasvinder Saini v State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) (2013) 7 SCC 256, this Court dealt with
the question whether the Trial Court was justified in adding a charge under
Section 302 of the IPC against the accused persons who were charged under
Section 304B of the IPC. Justice T S Thakur (as he then was) speaking for the
Court, held thus:
“11. A plain reading of the above would show that the
court's power to alter or add any charge is unrestrained
provided such addition and/or alteration is made before
the judgment is pronounced. Sub-sections (2) to (5) of
Section 216 deal with the procedure to be followed once the
court decides to alter or add any charge. Section 217 of the
Code deals with the recall of witnesses when the charge is
altered or added by the court after commencement of the trial.
There can, in the light of the above, be no doubt about the
competence of the court to add or alter a charge at any time
before the judgment. The circumstances in which such
addition or alteration may be made are not, however,
stipulated in Section 216. It is all the same trite that the
question of any such addition or alternation would
generally arise either because the court finds the charge
already framed to be defective for any reason or because
such addition is considered necessary after the
commencement of the trial having regard to the evidence
that may come before the court.”
(Emphasis supplied)
20 From the above line of precedents, it is clear that Section 216 provides the
court an exclusive and wide-ranging power to change or alter any charge. The
use of the words “at any time before judgment is pronounced” in Sub-Section (1)
empowers the court to exercise its powers of altering or adding charges even
after the completion of evidence, arguments and reserving of the judgment. The
alteration or addition of a charge may be done if in the opinion of the court there


was an omission in the framing of charge or if upon prima facie examination of
the material brought on record, it leads the court to form a presumptive opinion as
to the existence of the factual ingredients constituting the alleged offence. The
test to be adopted by the court while deciding upon an addition or alteration of a
charge is that the material brought on record needs to have a direct link or nexus
with the ingredients of the alleged offence. Addition of a charge merely
commences the trial for the additional charges, whereupon, based on the
evidence, it is to be determined whether the accused may be convicted for the
additional charges. The court must exercise its powers under Section 216
judiciously and ensure that no prejudice is caused to the accused and that he is
allowed to have a fair trial. The only constraint on the court’s power is the
prejudice likely to be caused to the accused by the addition or alteration of
charges. Sub-Section (4) accordingly prescribes the approach to be adopted by
the courts where prejudice may be caused.

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Criminal Appeal No. 1934 of 2019

Dr Nallapareddy Sridhar Reddy Vs  The State of Andhra Pradesh 

Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, J

Dated:January 21, 2020.
Print Page

Friday, 20 September 2019

Whether victim can file application for alteration of charge U/S 216 of CRPC?

It is significant to mention that the aforesaid decision has been relied on by the petitioner but it is evident from paragraph 6 of the judgment that section 216 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is an enabling provision for the Court to exercise its power under certain contingencies which comes to its notice or brought to its notice. In the case in hand, the error or omission in framing the charge was brought to the notice of the trial court by the defacto complainant and accordingly the charge was altered upon perusal of the material which was overlooked. 
 By virtue of Section 216 of the Code of Criminal Procedure the Court is vested with the power to alter or add to any charge at any time before judgment is pronounced. In view of the specific provision in the Code of Criminal Procedure under section 216 the bar under section 362 Cr.P.C. is not applicable in the case of alteration of charge by the Court.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA

C.R.R. 2533 of 2018

Decided On: 12.06.2019

 Satrajit Roy Vs. The State of West Bengal and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Asha Arora, J.

Print Page

Wednesday, 14 June 2017

Whether fresh sanction for prosecution of public servant is required if there is addition or alteration of charge?

In regard to C.R.R. 3512 of 2011 with C.R.R. 1494 of 2011 this Court is
of the view that Section 197(4) of Cr.P.C. gives power to the sanctioning
authority to specify the offences for prosecution. Therefore, there is no
apparent error committed by the learned trial court. Naturally the trial
would proceed against the police officials under Sections 506/120B of IPC.One may be confused that there is an apparent conflict in between the
Section 197(4) of Cr.P.C. and Section 216(5) of Cr.P.C. One may raise a
question, if any Court wants to add or alter the charge in respect of a
specific offence for which no sanction was granted but sanction was granted
in respect of other offences on the same facts, whether Section 197(4) of
Cr.P.C. shall overlap Section 216(5) of Cr.P.C. or not? The Section 197(4) of
Cr.P.C. is as good as a passport to go on for a trial. So it is to be considered
only up to pre-trial stage. The Section 216(5) of Cr.P.C. comes into picture
only after the pre-trial stage and that can be applied any time before delivery
of judgment. So scope of the Section 216(5) of Cr.P.C. is wide enough than
that of the Section 197(4) of Cr.P.C. In the interest of academic discussion I
want to amplify the Section 216(5) of Cr.P.C. The Section 216(5) Cr.P.C.
speaks “if the offence stated in the altered or added charge is one for
the prosecution of which previous sanction is necessary, the case
shall not be proceeded with until such sanction is obtained, unless
sanction has been already obtained for a prosecution on the same
facts as those on which the altered or added charge is founded.”
(Emphasis supplied) In the aforesaid section it has been specified by the
legislature “…..unless sanction has been already obtained for a
prosecution on the same facts…..” For application of Section 216(5) of
Cr.P.C. the necessary requirement of law is a sanction to prosecute on same
facts and here legislature did not specify the term ‘offence’ as mentioned in
Section 197(4) of Cr.P.C. Therefore, if there is already a sanction given by
the competent authority and the amended charge is based on the same
facts, no fresh sanction is necessary for the addition and alteration of
charge. Giving of sanction confers a jurisdiction to try but the court can proceed with the altered or added charge without fresh sanction on the same
facts, which were already been considered by the sanctioning authority. In
this instant case, the sanction was obtained for Section 306/120B/506 of
I.P.C. The governor has granted sanction in respect of Section 506/120B of
I.P.C. but did not grant sanction in connection with the alleged offence
under Section 306 of I.P.C. If one considers both the sections in its proper
perspectives, then the logical conclusion would be that fresh sanction under
Section 306 of I.P.C. is not required at the time of addition and alteration of
charge under Section 216(5) of Cr.P.C. if situation so warrants, because
sanction has been already obtained for a prosecution on the same facts.
Since Section 216(5) of Cr.P.C. comes into play during trial so Section 197(4)
of Cr.P.C. has no manner of application after the trial commences.
Therefore, if any sanction has been granted for prosecution on the same
facts, the Court has the power to add or alter the charge in respect of a
specific offence despite no specific sanction, was there in respect of the
offence for which charge is contemplated to be added/altered. It can be
summarised in this way that at the time of dealing with the Section 216(5) of
Cr.P.C. the court is to see if any sanction has been given on same facts or
not, irrespective of any offence.
 IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION)
C.R.R. No. 1396 of 2011
(Ahok Kr. Todi vs. C.B.I.)

Present : The Hon’ble Justice Siddhartha Chattopadhyay

Judgment Delivered On : 12.06.2017.
Siddhartha Chattopadhyay, J.:
Print Page

Saturday, 10 June 2017

Whether any party can seek addition or alteration of charge as of right?

Having heard learned Counsel for the respective parties, we find force in the submission of learned senior Counsel for Respondent No. 1. Section 216 Code of Criminal Procedure empowers the Court to alter or add any charge at any time before the judgment is pronounced. It is now well settled that the power vested in the Court is exclusive to the Court and there is no right in any party to seek for such addition or alteration by filing any application as a matter of right. It may be that if there was an omission in the framing of the charge and if it comes to the knowledge of the Court trying the offence, the power is always vested in the Court, as provided Under Section 216 Code of Criminal Procedure to either alter or add the charge and that such power is available with the Court at any time before the judgment is pronounced. It is an enabling provision for the Court to exercise its power under certain contingencies which comes to its notice or brought to its notice. In such a situation if it comes to the knowledge of the Court that a necessity has arisen for the charge to be altered or added, it may do so on its own and no order need be passed for that purpose. After such alteration or addition when the final decision is rendered, it will be open for the parties to work out their remedies in accordance with law.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Criminal Appeal No. 1709 of 2014.
Decided On: 12.08.2014
 P. Kartikalakshmi
Vs.
 Ganesh and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
F.M. Ibrahim Kalifulla and Shiva Kirti Singh, JJ.
Citation: (2017) 3 SCC347
Print Page

Wednesday, 17 August 2016

Whether court can alter charge if no evidence is adduced?

After so stating, the Court opined that there was no
material on which the trial court could have amended the
charge under Section 227 CrPC and the learned Judge
therefore had no power to direct an amendment and a
continuation of the same trial as he purported to do. The
purpose of laying stress on the said authority is that the
trial court could issue a direction for alteration of the
charge if there were materials before it in the complaint or
any evidence to justify such action. On the aforesaid

three-Judge Bench decision, it is quite vivid that if there are
allegations in the complaint petition or for that matter in
FIR or accompanying material, the court can alter the
charge. In Thakur Shah v. King Emperor (supra), what
the Court has held is that alteration or addition of a charge
must be for an offence made out by the evidence recorded
during the course of trial before the court. It does not
necessarily mean that the alteration can be done only in a case where evidence is adduced.
16. From the aforesaid, it is graphic that the court can
change or alter the charge if there is defect or something is
left out. The test is, it must be founded on the material
available on record. It can be on the basis of the complaint
or the FIR or accompanying documents or the material
brought on record during the course of trial. It can also be
done at any time before pronouncement of judgment. It is
not necessary to advert to each and every circumstance.
Suffice it to say, if the court has not framed a charge
despite the material on record, it has the jurisdiction to add
a charge. Similarly, it has the authority to alter the charge.
The principle that has to be kept in mind is that the charge
so framed by the Magistrate is in accord with the materials
produced before him or if subsequent evidence comes on
record. It is not to be understood that unless evidence has

been let in, charges already framed cannot be altered, for

that is not the purport of Section 216 CrPC.

Reportable

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.131 of 2016


Anant Prakash Sinha @ Anant Sinha V State of Haryana & Anr. 

Dated:March, 4, 2016
Citation:2016 ALL SCR(CRI)577
Dipak Misra, J.

Print Page

Whether magistrate can entertain application filed by first informant for alteration of charge?

 Being of this view, this Court upheld the order passed
by the High Court. The said decision is, in our opinion, is
distinguishable on facts. The instant case does not pertain
to trial or any area by which a private lawyer takes control
of the proceedings. As is evident, an application was filed
by the informant to add a charge under Section 406 IPC as
there were allegations against the husband about the
criminal breach of trust as far as her stridhan is concerned.
It was, in a way, bringing to the notice of the learned
Magistrate about the defect in framing of the charge. The
court could have done it suo motu. In such a situation, we
do not find any fault on the part of learned Magistrate in
entertaining the said application.
Reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.131 of 2016
(@ Special Leave Petition (Criminal) No. 837 of 2016)
Anant Prakash Sinha @ Anant Sinha 
V
State of Haryana & Anr
Dated:March, 4, 2016
Citation:2016 ALL SCR(CRI)577: 2016(2) Supreme 385
Dipak Misra, J.
Print Page

What safeguards are provided to accused if charge is altered?

 The bare reading of Section 216 reveals that though it is permissible for any Court to alter or add to any charge at any time before judgment is pronounced, certain safeguards, looking into the interest of the accused person who is charged with the additional charge or with the alteration of the additional charge, are also provided specifically under Sub-sections (3) and 4 of Section 216 of the Code. Sub-section (3), in no uncertain term, stipulates that with the alteration or addition to a charge if any prejudice is going to be caused to the accused in his defence or the prosecutor in the conduct of the case, the Court has to proceed with the trial as if it altered or added the original charge by terming the additional or alternative charge as original charge. The clear message is that it is to be treated as charge made for the first time and trial has to proceed from that stage. This position becomes further clear from the bare reading of Sub-section (4) of Section 216 of the Code which empowers the Court, in such a situation, to either direct a new trial or adjourn the trial for such period as may be necessary. A new trial is insisted if the charge is altogether different and distinct.
10. Even if the charge may be of same species, the provision for adjourning the trial is made to give sufficient opportunity to the accused to prepare and defend himself. It is, in the same process, Section 217 of the Code provides that whenever a charge is altered or added by the Court after the commencement of the trial, the prosecutor as well as the accused shall be allowed to recall or re-summon or examine any witnesses who have already been examined with reference to such alteration or addition. In such circumstances, the Court is to even allow any further witness which the Court thinks to be material in regard to the altered or additional charge.
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Criminal Appeal Nos. 2375/2009, 2376/2009 and 2377/2009
Decided On: 05.05.2016

 R. Rachaiah Vs.  Home Secretary, Bangalore

Coram:A.K. Sikri and R.K. Agrawal, JJ.

Citation:2016 ALL SCR(CRI)916:, AIR 2016 SC 2447
Print Page

Thursday, 12 November 2015

Whether court can refuse to recall witnesses after alteration of charge?

It has to be borne in mind in terms of Section 217 Crl. P.C. whenever a charge is altered or added to by the Court after the commencement of the trial, the prosecution and the accused shall be allowed to recall or resummon, and examine, any witness who may have been examined, unless the Court for reasons to be recorded in writing, considers that the prosecutor or the accused, as the case may be, desires to recall or re-examine such witness for the purpose of vexation or delay or defeating the ends of justice. In his order dated 10-11-1980 rejecting the 2nd appellant's application dated 3-11-1980, the learned Sessions Judge has not stated that it was considered that the application was made for the purpose of vexation or delay or defeating the ends of justice. No such reason having been recorded, and there being nothing to indicate that the learned Sessions Judge had considered that it was made for the purpose of vexation or delay or defeating the ends of justice, the application filed by the 2nd appellant in assertion of his statutory right under Section 217 Crl. P.C. ought to have been allowed; that is especially so considering the gravity of the charges which include one for murder, besides the direction in the section being mandatory in character.
Kerala High Court
Moosa Abdul Rahiman And Anr. vs State Of Kerala on 2 April, 1982
Equivalent citations: 1982 CriLJ 1384

Bench: P S Poti, P J Amma, K Sukumaran
Print Page

Necessary conditions for alteration of charge by court

Equivalent Citation: 2011CriLJ1710
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA
Cr. Rev. No. 194 of 2010
Decided On: 19.11.2010
Appellants: Rakesh Kumar Luthra
Vs.
Respondent: State of H.P.
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Dev Darshan Sud, J.

Criminal - Alteration of charge - Section 216 of Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (Cr.P.C.) - Rules 47 and 48 of Indian Arms Rules, 1962 - Trial Court allowed Application of prosecution filed under Section 216 of Cr.P.C. and altered charges against Petitioner - Hence, this Petition - Whether, order passed by Trial Court was justified - Held, Accused along with co-accused had crossed toll tax barrier in his car without payment of tool tax and picked up quarrel and fired one shot from his revolver - Charge under Section 307/34 I.P.C. framed against Accused was not made out from final report under Section 173 Cr.P.C. and accompanying documents filed by police - Accused was found to had prima facie committed offence of preparation of false documents and violation of Rules 47 and 48 of Rules, 1962 - However, application preferred by Accused under Section 216 Cr.P.C. was left to be considered at later stage - Both applications could not be disposed of together, was not indicated on record and even application filed by Accused was not considered - Evidence of prosecution being already on record, there was no bar to have considered both applications together - Further, Section 216 of Cr.P.C. itself requires indication of probability on basis of which charge requires to be altered - Therefore, order passed by Trial Court was set aside - Petition allowed.

"Charge against accused shall not be altered if it is not made out from final report and accompanying documents filed by police."
Print Page

Whether it is necessary to hear accused prior to alteration in charge?

 In view of the rival submissions and the legal position discussed hereinabove, the issues which require consideration are, whether the petitioners were entitled to an opportunity of being heard before effecting the impugned alteration in the charge and whether any failure of justice was occasioned thereby. In absence of any of the material which could have prompted the trial court to alter or add to the charge by the impugned order, it would be hazardous, if not impossible, to hold that there was nothing in the evidence before the court to require alteration of the charge. Even otherwise, it would be improper to re-appreciate the evidence at the stage of trial and interfere with an interlocutory order of the trial court in exercise of the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court under Section 482 of the Code. Nothing could be pointed out from the scheme of the Code which would suggest that an opportunity of being heard was envisaged at the stage of framing of charge or at the stage of altering or adding to any charge at any time. Instead, the provisions of Section 216 of the Code expressly empowers the court to alter or add to any charge at any time before judgment is pronounced; even as no opportunity of being heard is envisaged while framing charge under Section 228 of the Code. As for the prejudice likely or apprehended to be caused to the accused persons, adequate provisions are made in Sub-sections (4) and (5) of Section 216 and Section 217 of the Code. There is no dispute about the fact that framing of alternative charges is expressly permissible under Section 221 of the Code and even conviction for the offences with which the accused was not charged is permissible under the provisions of Sub-section (2) of Section 221. In that view of the matter, the impugned order of altering the charge appears to have been justified and, in fact, required to give to the parties adequate opportunity of recalling or re-examining the witnesses or calling any other witnesses.
Gujarat High Court
Abdul Masjid Shaikh And 3 Ors. vs State Of Gujarat on 6 December, 2006
Bench: D Waghela
Citation;2007GLH(1)321, 2007 CRLJ(NOC) 485
Print Page

Whether court can refuse to alter charge on the ground that it will prolong proceeding?

 It is ignoring that, the learned Magistrate refused
to have the petition disposed on merits with a reason that
this Court has prescribed time limit for disposal of the case.
It is not at all a good reasoning and it can no way be
allowed.     The reasoning that altering of charge would
prolong the trial is also erroneous and not sustainable. A
request made by the prosecutor to alter the charge with an
allegation that the charge is not in accordance with the
report of the investigating officer could be dismissed, only if
the allegation is not true. A trial without a proper charge
would only lead to miscarriage of justice.            In such
circumstances, this Court shall not hesitate to interfere in
exercise of the inherent powers vested on this Court under
Sec.482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, though no
revision is maintainable.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
Crl.Rev.Pet.No. 3162 of 2009()
AKBAR.A., PUTHEN VEEDU, NORTH MSM
                   
                        Vs
STATE OF KERALA, REP. BY PUBLIC
                   
The Hon'ble MR. Justice P.S.GOPINATHAN
 Dated :24/11/2009
Citation: 2010CriLJ2555, ILR2010(2)KeralaKER, ILR2010(2)Kerala875, 2010 (1) KHC 738, 2010(1)KLT714
Print Page