Showing posts with label recall of witnesses. Show all posts
Showing posts with label recall of witnesses. Show all posts

Friday, 29 May 2026

S.311 CrPC Power Can't Be Invoked To Fill Up Lacunae In Defence : Supreme Court Quashes Order To Recall Rape Victim For Cross Examination

By the time the recall application was moved, 19 other prosecution witnesses had already been examined and the trial had substantially progressed. The trial has already been prolonged unduly, and the Court has a duty to ensure its expeditious conclusion. The trial in this case has been pending for over eight years.

16. Secondly, the principal ground urged in support of the

application under Section 311 CrPC is that certain facts arising

from the CDRs of the relevant mobile numbers could not be

brought on record during the earlier cross-examination due to

inadvertence. However, it is an admitted position that the said

CDRs were filed by the prosecution itself along with the chargesheet and formed part of the record throughout the course of the trial. The defence was thus aware of the said material and had adequate opportunity to examine the prosecutrix with reference thereto. The power under Section 311 CrPC cannot be exercised merely to fill up lacunae in the defence case.

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 2848 OF 2026

THE STATE OF TRIPURA Vs  PANNA AHMED 

Author: SATISH CHANDRA SHARMA, J.

Citation:  2026 INSC 584.

Dated: May 26, 2026.

Print Page

Monday, 11 August 2025

Bombay HC: Under which circumstances the court can permit recall of witness in criminal case?

 Learned Counsel for the applicants has relied upon ruling in the case of (Riyazuddin & ors. Vs. State of UP)1, reported in MANU/UP/0868/2001 : 2001 Cri.L.J. 3907. It appears that the Apex Court in the case of Riyazuddin and ors. (supra) had granted an opportunity and had directed the learned Additional Sessions Judge, in view of section 311 of the Code to allow reexamination/cross-examination of witnesses on the particular specified date subject to costs and expenses. Under section 311 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the trial Court possesses powers to summon, re-call, re-examine any witness if his evidence appears to be essential for just decision of the case. After all, object of the criminal trial is to find out truth and it is the right of the accused to have fair opportunity. {Para 3}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Criminal Application No. 401 of 2011

Decided On: 09.08.2011

Mansaram Shaligram Sawalkar and Ors. Vs. State of Maharashtra

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

A.P. Bhangale, J.

Citation: 2011 ALLMR(CRI) 3651, MANU/MH/1965/2011

Print Page

Tuesday, 21 May 2024

What procedure the court should follow if defence is seeking to recall a prosecution witness on the ground that he has given inconsistent statement before another forum?

 In our opinion, the procedure adopted by the Sessions Judge was not strictly in accordance with law. Once the witness was examined in-chief and cross- examined fully, such witness should not have been recalled and re-examined to deny the evidence he had already given before the court, even though that witness had given an inconsistent statement before any other court or forum subsequently. A witness could be confronted only with a previous statement made by him. At the time of examination of PW-2 Mokam Singh on 6.2.1991, there was no such previous statement and the defence counsel did not confront him with any statement alleged to have been made previously. This witness must have given some other version before the Juvenile Court for extraneous reasons and he should not have been given a further opportunity at a later stage to completely efface the evidence already given by him under oath. The courts have to follow the procedures strictly and cannot allow a witness to escape the legal action for giving false evidence before the court on mere explanation that he had given it under the pressure of the police or some other reason. Whenever the witness speaks falsehood in the court, and it is proved satisfactorily, the court should take a serious action against such witnesses. {Para 6}

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Criminal Appeal No. ... of 2008 

Decided On: 13.10.2008

Hanuman Ram Vs. The State of Rajasthan and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Dr. Arijit Pasayat and J.M. Panchal, JJ.

Author: Arijit Pasayat, J.

Citation: 2009 (64) ACC 895 (SC),MANU/SC/8107/2008.

Print Page

Allahabad HC: Revision against order refusing recall of witness for further cross examination when not to be allowed.

  The application under Section 311 Cr.P.C. was moved by the revisionist on the ground that P.W.-1 has to be cross examined on some important points. What were the questions, which had to be asked from P.W.-1 in further cross examination were not mentioned in the application nor important points, which required cross examination were mentioned. Earlier, the revisionist had already availed the opportunity of cross examination. Application under Section 311 Cr.P.C. was vague and was rightly rejected by learned Sessions Judge.

    I do not find any good ground to interfere in the matter.

Allahabad High Court

Anurag Srivastava vs State Of U.P. & Another on 6 October, 2010

Author: S.C. Agarwal

Dated:  6.10.2010.
Citation: 2010 (71) ACC 504 (All).
Print Page

Sunday, 5 March 2023

Whether the court can permit accused to recall prosecutrix/ victim in an offence Under POCSO Act?

Of course, as per Section 33 of the POCSO Act, the  prosecutrix/victim and shall not be called frequently for cross-examination by the Court. However, that does not mean there shall not be any opportunity given to the accused for the

purpose of prosecution cross-examination of the prosecution

witness. {Para 6}

7. Of course, there was a defect on the part of the

learned counsel for the accused for not cross-examined the

prosecution witness and he sought time. However, the Court at

first instance, though rejected ought to have considered

sympathetically and allowed the applicant to cross-examine

P.W.1.

8. This Court in a catena of decisions held that fair

trial is a fundamental right which is guaranteed under Article 21

of the Constitution of India. Of course, the trial is to be

concluded within one year under the POCSO Act. The delay

should be curtailed but that does not mean the Court should

allow cross-examination without giving a fair opportunity to the

accused to defend the case. The trial Court ought to have

given one more opportunity to the petitioner for

cross-examination of the witness. Accordingly, the order of the

trial Court deserves to be set aside.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

CRIMINAL PETITION NO. 3987 OF 2022

SRI. JAYANNA B @ JAYARAM Vs  STATE OF KARNATAKA 

BEFORE

 Coram: MR JUSTICE K.NATARAJAN

DATED:  13TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2023

Print Page

Saturday, 25 June 2022

Can the court recall the prosecution witness if he has given a different statement in another case?

Code of Criminal Procedure 1973; Section 311 - Merely because a different statement given by the same prosecution witness in another case that itself would not be a reason for recalling the witness.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA 

Coram: C.T. RAVIKUMAR; SUDHANSHU DHULIA, JJ.

 Special Leave to Appeal (Crl.) No(s). 5647/2022;

Dated: 21-06-2022 

SAUD FAISAL Vs STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH & ANR.


Print Page

Saturday, 19 February 2022

Can the court recall a witness as per S 311 of CRPC to confront him with his later evidence before another forum?

The learned Counsel for the appellants seriously attacked the evidence of PW 2 Mokam Singh. This witness was examined by the Sessions Judge on 6.2.1991 and cross-examined on the same day by the defence counsel. Thereafter, it seems, that on behalf of the accused persons an application was filed and PW 2 Mokam Singh was recalled. PW-2 was again examined and cross-examined on 31.7.1991. It may be noted that some of the persons who were allegedly involved in this incident were minors and their case was tried by the Juvenile Court. PW 2 Mokam Singh was also examined as a witness in the case before the Juvenile court. In the Juvenile Court, he gave evidence to the effect that he was not aware of the persons who had attacked him and on hearing the voice of the assailants, he assumed that they were some Banjaras. Upon recalling, PW-2 Mokam Singh was confronted with the evidence he had given later before the Juvenile Court on the basis of which the accused persons were acquitted of the charge under Section 307 IPC for having made an attempt on the life of this witness.

In our opinion, the procedure adopted by the Sessions Judge was not strictly in accordance with law. Once the witness was examined in-chief and cross-examined fully, such witness should not have been recalled and re-examined to deny the evidence he had already given before the court, even though that witness had given an inconsistent statement before any other court or forum subsequently. A witness could be confronted only with a previous statement made by him. At the time of examination of PW 2 Mokam Singh on 6.2.1991, there was no such previous statement and the defence counsel did not confront him with any statement alleged to have been made previously. This witness must have given some other version before the Juvenile Court for extraneous reasons and he should not have been given a further opportunity at a later stage to completely efface the evidence already given by him under oath. The courts have to follow the procedures strictly and cannot allow a witness to escape the legal action for giving false evidence before the court on mere explanation that he had given it under the pressure of the police or some other reason. Whenever the witness speaks falsehood in the court, and it is proved satisfactorily, the court should take a serious action against such witnesses.

 Supreme Court of India

Mishrilal & Ors vs State Of M.P. & Ors on 11 May, 2005
Print Page

Saturday, 28 October 2017

When court can permit recalling of witness for cross examination?

 I have given due consideration to the rival submissions. It is true that on plain reading of provisions of 0.18 R. 17 of the Code, it appears that only the Court is empowered to recall the witness to put such questions to elicit any clarification. However, the Supreme Court in case of K.K. Velusamy, [2011(3) ALL MR 455 (S.C.)] (supra) had an occasion to consider the provisions of 0.18 R.17 and also the provisions of Section 151 of the Code. Upon considering the said provisions, the Supreme Court in para 9 of the judgment held that, the inherent powers of the court u/s 151 of the Code is not affected by the express power conferred upon the court under Order 18 Rule 17 of the Code to recall any witness to enable the Court to put such question to elicit any clarifications. The Supreme Court, in para 11 of the judgment has also considered that, the Code earlier had a specific provision in Order 18 Rule 17A for production of evidence not previously known or the evidence which could not be produced despite due diligence. It enabled the court to permit a party to produce any evidence even at a belated stage, after the conclusion of his evidence, if he satisfied the court that even after the exercise of due diligence, the evidence was not within his knowledge and could not be produced by him when he was leading the evidence. That provision was deleted with effect from 1.7.2002. It is held that, deletion of the said provision does not mean that no evidence can be received at all, after a party closes his evidence. It only means that the amended structure of the Code found no need for such a provision, as the amended Code contemplated little or no time gap between completion of evidence and commencement and conclusion of arguments. Another reason for its deletion was the misuse thereof by the parties to prolong the proceedings under the pretext of discovery of new evidence. In para 12 of the said judgment, the Supreme Court has observed that, in appropriate cases, the Court may exercise its inherent powers u/s 151 of the Code, permitting the production of such evidence if it is relevant and necessary in the interest of justice, subject to such terms as the court may deem fit to impose.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (AURANGABAD BENCH)

Writ Petition No. 9626 of 2011

Decided On: 18.07.2012

Anand S/o Rangrao Ingle & Anr. Vs. Govind S/o Rangrao Ingle & Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.S. Shinde, J.

Print Page

Sunday, 30 April 2017

Principles to be followed by court while deciding application for recalling of witnesses

In Mohanlal Shamji Soni (supra), Supreme
Court has reiterated the same principle after
analyzing Section 540 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1898 as well as Section 311 Cr.P.C.
The Court held:
“The next important question is
whether Section 540 gives the court
carte-blanche drawing no underlying
principle in the exercise of the
extraordinary power and whether the
said Section is unguided, uncontrolled
and uncanalised. Though
Section 540 (Section 311 of the new
Code) is, in the widest possible terms
and calls for no limitation, either with
regard to the stage at which the powers
of the court should be exercised, or
with regard to the manner in which they
should be exercised, that power is
circumscribed by the principle that[30]
underlines Section 540, namely,
evidence to be obtained should appear
to the court essential to a just decision
of the case by getting at the truth by all
lawful means. Therefore, it should be
borne in mind that the aid of the
section should be invoked only with the
object of discovering relevant facts or
obtaining proper proof of such facts for
a just decision of the case and it must
be used judicially and not capriciously
or arbitrarily because any improper or
capricious exercise of the power may
lead to undesirable results. Further it is
incumbent that due care should be
taken by the court while exercising the
power under this section and it should
not be used for filling up the lacuna left
by the prosecution or by the defence or
to the disadvantage of the accused or
to cause serious prejudice to the
defence of the accused or to give an
unfair advantage to the rival side and
further the additional evidence should
not be received as a disguise for a
retrial or to change the nature of the
case against either of the parties.”
“The principle of law that emerges
from the views expressed by this Court
in the above decisions is that the
Criminal Court has ample power to
summon any person as a witness or
recall and re-examine any such person
even if the evidence on both sides is
closed and the jurisdiction of the court
must obviously be dictated by exigency
of the situation, and fair-play and good
sense appear to be the only safe guides
and that only the requirements of
justice command the examination of
any person which would depend on the
facts and circumstances of each case.”[31]
30. In Rajendra Prasad (supra), Supreme Court,
while examining power under Section 311
Cr.P.C. to recall or re-summon a witness,
reiterated the principle that power cannot be
exercised to fill up lacuna in prosecution case.
However, while construing the meaning of the
term “lacuna in prosecution case”, the Court
observed that oversight or mistakes during
conducting of a case cannot be understood as
lacuna and so can be corrected. The Court held:
“It is a common experience in
criminal courts that defence counsel
would raise objections whenever courts
exercise powers under Section 311 of
the Code or under Section 165 of the
Evidence Act, 1872 by saying that the
Court could not “fill the lacuna in the
prosecution case”. A lacuna in the
prosecution is not to be equated with
the fallout of an oversight committed by
a public prosecutor during trial, either
in producing relevant materials or in
eliciting relevant answers from
witnesses. The adage “to err is human”
is the recognition of the possibility of
making mistakes to which humans are
prone. A corollary of any such latches
or mistakes during the conducting of a
case cannot be understood as a lacuna
which a court cannot fill up.
Lacuna in the prosecution must be
understood as the inherent weakness or
a latent wedge in the matrix of the
prosecution case. The advantage of it
should normally go to the accused in
the trial of the case, but an over sight
in the management of the prosecution
cannot be treated as irreparable lacuna.
No party in a trial can be foreclosed
from correcting errors. If proper
evidence was not adduced or a relevant
material was not brought on record due
to any inadvertence, the court should
be magnanimous in permitting such
mistakes to be rectified. After all,
function of the criminal Court is
administration of criminal justice and
not to count errors committed by the
parties or to find out and declare who
among the parties performed better.”
Taking into account the fact situation in the
instant case, while accepting the legal
proposition adumbrated in the verdict, in the
considered opinion of this Court, in the backdrop
of facts and circumstances of the instant case,
the judgment cannot render any assistance to
the petitioner.
Reportable
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
AT JODHPUR


CRL. MISC. (PET.) (CRLMP) NO. 3661 of 2015

Sant Shri Asharamji Bapu V/s. State of Rajasthan

DATED : November 3, 2016
MR. JUSTICE P.K. LOHRA


Print Page

Sunday, 9 April 2017

Whether court can permit recalling of witness on ground of change of Advocate?

Their Lordships of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in State (NCT of Delhi) v. Shiv Kumar Yadav and another reported in (2016)2 SCC 402 have held that plea of recalling a witness has to be bonafide and mere change of a counsel, can not be a ground for recalling a witness. Their lordships have held as under:
"11. It is further well settled that fairness of trial has to be seen not only from the point of view of the accused, but also from the point of view of the victim and the society. In the name of fair trial, the system cannot be held to ransom. The accused is entitled to be represented by a counsel of his choice, to be provided all relevant documents, to cross-examine the prosecution witnesses and to lead evidence in his defence. The object of provision for recall is to reserve the power with the court to prevent any injustice in the conduct of the trial at any stage. The power available with the court to prevent injustice has to be exercised only if the Court, for valid reasons, feels that injustice is caused to a party. Such a finding, with reasons, must be specifically recorded by the court before the power is exercised.
The above observations cannot be read as laying down any inflexible rule to routinely permit a recall on the ground that cross-examination was not proper for reasons attributable to a counsel. While advancement of justice remains the prime object of law, it cannot be understood that recall can be allowed for the asking or reasons related to mere convenience. It has normally to be presumed that the counsel conducting a case is competent particularly when a counsel is appointed by choice of a litigant. Taken to its logical end, the principle that a retrial must follow on every change of a counsel, can have serious consequences on conduct of trials and the criminal justice system. Witnesses cannot be expected to face the hardship of appearing in court repeatedly, particularly in sensitive cases such as the present one. It can result in undue hardship for victims, especially so, of heinous crimes, if they are required to repeatedly appear in court to face cross-examination."
8. In the present case also, one of the grounds for recalling the witness is change of counsel. It is not permissible. Witness can not be expected to face the ordeal of appearing in the Court repeatedly. No acceptable grounds have been made out for recalling the witness. There is neither any perversity nor any illegality in the order passed by the learned trial Court.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA
Cr. MMO No. 254/2016
Decided On: 05.09.2016

 Mohd. Tariq Vs. Jaspal Singh and Ors.


Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Rajiv Sharma, J.

Citation: 2017 CRLJ 784 HP
Print Page

Saturday, 25 March 2017

Basic principles to be followed by court while allowing application for recall of witnesses

The respondent filed the application under Rule 17 read with
Section 151 of the CPC invoking the inherent powers of the court to
make orders for the ends of justice or to prevent abuse of the
process of the court. The basic purpose of Rule 17 is to enable the
court to clarify any position or doubt, and the court may, either suo
motu or on the request of any party, recall any witness at any stage
in that regard. This power can be exercised at any stage of the suit.
No doubt, once the court recalls the witness for the purpose of any
such clarification, the court may permit the parties to assist the
court by examining the witness for the purpose of clarification
required or permitted by the court. The power under Rule 17 cannot
be stretched any further. The said power cannot be invoked to fill up
omission in the evidence already led by a witness. It cannot also be
used for the purpose of filling up a lacuna in the evidence. ‘No
prejudice is caused to either party’ is also not a permissible ground
to invoke Rule 17. No doubt, it is a discretionary power of the court
but to be used only sparingly, and in case, the court decides to
invoke the provision, it should also see that the trial is not
unnecessarily protracted on that ground.
The settled legal position under Order 18 Rule 17 read with
Section 151 of the CPC, being thus very clear, the impugned orders
passed by the trial court as affirmed by the High Court to recall a
witness at the instance of the respondent “for further elaboration on
the left out points”, is wholly impermissible in law.
Reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 1684 OF 2016
(Arising from S.L.P. (C) No. 22141 of 2013)
RAM RATI 
V
MANGE RAM 
Dated:February 23, 2016.

Citation:(2016) 11 SCC 296

Print Page

Tuesday, 14 March 2017

Whether trial court can recall order of acquittal if it is obtained by impersonating witnesses?

An application was moved by the opposite party no.3 i.e. complainant on 26.5.2006 stating that the persons produced before the court as P.W.1, P.W.2, P.W.3 and P.W. 4 are forged. Real persons were not produced before the Court. Judgment was obtained after playing fraud upon court which should be set aside. Retrial of the accused should be held. 
 As pithily stated in Jennison v. Baker (1972) 1 All ER 997 "The law should not be seen to sit by limply, while those who defy it free, and those who seek its protection lose hope." 
Courts have to ensure that accused persons are punished and that the might authority of the State are not used to shield themselves or their men. It should ensured that they do not wield such powers which under the Constitution has to held only in trust for the public and society at large. If deficiency in investigation prosecution is visible or can be perceived by lifting the veil trying to hide realities or covering the obvious deficiencies, courts have to deal with the same was an iron hands appropriately within the framework of law. It is as much the duty of prosecutor as of the court to ensure that full and material facts are brought on record so that there might not be miscarriage of justice, (See Shakila Abdul Gafar Khan Vasant Raghunath Dhoble (2003) 7 SCC 749). 
41. Learned trial court has rightly held that the prosecution agency i.e. concerned police of concerned police station was also in connivance with accused and produced the witnesses who has impersonated themselves as P.W.1, P.W.2, P.W. 3 and P.W.4. 
42. In the case of Tribhuvan vs. State of U.P. 1992 (LCR R) Lucknow Criminal Report 165; a Division Bench of this Court has held that in Para 13 and 14. 
"13. The power to recall a judgment in such a situation has been held to be available to the High Court in the case of Prem Singh vs. State, Full Bench decision of Jammu & Kashmir High Court reported in (1982 Cr. LJ 297). Relying upon the decision of Madras and Calcutta High Courts it was held that where the conditions laid down by law as precedent and requisite to the hearing of the case are not observed, the court acts without jurisdiction and its order is, therefore, void ab initio and the case can be reheard and that such rehearing would not be barred by Section 369 Cr.P.C. This corresponds to Section 362 of the present Code. 
14. In this case a revision was also filed, decided in absence of the revisionist and the question whether such an order can be recalled and revision reheard was under consideration. The Full Bench answered accordingly in affirmative." 
43. Power of Section 362 Cr.P.C. are defined but at the same time when a fraud is played upon the Court, Court cannot became a silent spectator. Even for the sake of argument it is expected that the learned trial court was not having such power than this Court in exercise of inherent power also can quash the earlier judgment of the learned trial court which was obtained by the accused after playing fraud upon the court. It is a case where the bar of section 362 Cr.P.C. would not come into play. 
44. Accordingly, I am of the view that the learned trial court has rightly passed the impugned order and issued necessary direction. Revision is devoid of any merit and is liable to be dismissed and is accordingly dismissed.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD, LUCKNOW BENCH 

Case :- CRIMINAL REVISION No. - 477 of 2006


 Bimal Kumar  Arun Kumar Dixit Vs  State of U.P. through Principal Secretary,


Dated:
 10.3.2017 
Hon'ble Anil Kumar Srivastava-II,J. 

Print Page

Saturday, 12 November 2016

Whether court should dismiss suit for breach of order of recall of plaintiff for cross examination?

Normally, it
is for the parties to the suit to decide which evidence
to be led and which witness to be examined. Section 120
of the Evidence Act shows that the parties to the Civil
Suit and their wives or husbands shall be competent
witnesses. In the present case the Plaintiff No 2, apart
from being the wife is also the power of attorney holder
of the Plaintiff No. 1. She had expressed willingness to
examine herself on behalf of the Petitioner. The only
question is whether a breach of the Order (passed at the
instance of the Respondents/Defendants permitting recall
of the Plaintiff No. 1 for cross-examination) would
entail consequences under Order 39 Rule 11 CPC or the
failure to remain present for cross-examination in such
case, would only entitle the Court to draw adverse
inference if any, as may be permissible in the facts and
circumstances of the case. In my considered view, the
Order passed at the instance of one of the parties to the
suit seeking recall of a witness of the adversary for
subjecting such witness for cross-examination cannot be
an Order which is contemplated under Order 39 Rule 11 of
CPC. The Court in adversarial litigation only acts on
the basis of the request by one of the parties seeking to
recall a witness for subjecting such witness for crossexamination.
This cannot be said to be an Order by which
Court has directed to do or not to do a thing during the
pendency of the suit.
6. It is not necessary to express any opinion as to
what would be the nature of orders, the breach of which,
would entail consequences under Order 39 Rule 11 of CPC.
For the present purpose suffice it to mention, that in
the present case the only course open to the
Respondents/Defendants in this case would be to insist
for drawing appropriate adverse inference, if any.
7. In the given facts it would not be necessary to
refer to the decisions relied upon in details. In the
case of Sheshrao Ingale (supra) it has been held that
striking out defence does not necessarily mean that
plaintiff's suit automatically stands decreed. In the 
case of Ganpat Shankar Waghmare (supra) it has been held
that a breach of direction issued by Court results into
defence of the defendants being struck of and the
defendant would have no right to cross-examine the
plaintiff or his witnesses. In the case of Sitabai Kerba
Deotarse (supra) there was an Order passed restraining
the defendant nos. 4 to 10 from alienating the suit
property and there was no serious dispute that subsequent
thereto the property was transferred by defendant no. 4
to 10. The case of Ratnakar D. Patade (supra) has been
since overruled by the division bench of this Court, in
the case of Ramavatar Surajmal Modi (supra). The
division bench of this Court holds that the word 'may' in
sub-rule (1) of Rule 11 of Order 39 of the CPC merely
vests power in the Court to stike of defence. It does
not oblige it to do so in every case of default. It can
thus be seen that the division bench has held that the
power under Order 39 Rule 11 is discretionary and it is
not mandatory for the court in every case to pass such
order. I find that the impugned order proceeds on the
erroneous assumption that breach of the order recalling a
witness would entail consequences under Order 39 Rule 11
of the Code of Civil Procedure when, in fact, this may 
only result in the Court drawing appropriate adverse
inference (in the event the witness remains absent). In
the facts and circumstances of the case, I find that the
impugned order cannot be sustained and will have to be
set aside.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA
WRIT PETITION NO. 711 OF 2015.
Shri Augustinho C. Braganza

 V/s
Shri. Sebastiao C. Braganza

Coram:- C. V. BHADANG, J.

 Pronounced on: 04.05.2016
Citation: 2016(5) ALLMR234
Print Page

Friday, 30 September 2016

How to balance right of accused to have fair trial with right of victim while deciding application for recall of witness?

Neither the
accused nor the prosecution nor the victim which is a part of
the society can claim absolute predominance over the other.
Once absolute predominance is recognized, it will have the
effect potentiality to bring in an anarchical disorder in the
conducting of trial defying established legal norm. There
should be passion for doing justice but it must be commanded
by reasons and not propelled by any kind of vague instigation.
It would be dependent on the fact situation; established norms
and recognized principles and eventual appreciation of the
factual scenario in entirety. 
Simultaneously the concept of fair trial
cannot be allowed to such an extent so that the systemic order
of conducting a trial in accordance with CrPC or other
enactments get mortgaged to the whims and fancies of the
defence or the prosecution. The command of the Code cannot 
be thrown to winds. In such situation, as has been laid down
in many an authority, the courts have significantly an eminent
role. A plea of fairness cannot be utilized to build Castles in
Spain or permitted to perceive a bright moon in a sunny
afternoon. It cannot be acquiesced to create an organic
disorder in the system. It cannot be acceded to manure a fertile
mind to usher in the nemesis of the concept of trial as such.

 The power under Section 311 CrPC must
therefore, be invoked by the court only in order to
meet the ends of justice for strong and valid
reasons and the same must be exercised with
care, caution and circumspection. The court
should bear in mind that fair trial entails the
interest of the accused, the victim and the society
and, therefore, the grant of fair and proper
opportunities to the persons concerned, must be
ensured being a constitutional goal, as well as a
human right.”
[Emphasis supplied]

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS. 805-806 OF 2016
(@ S.L.P. (Crl.) Nos. 3278-79 of 2016)
State of Haryana 
 V
Ram Mehar & Others Etc.
Citation:AIR 2016 SC 3942,(2016) 8 SCC762


Print Page

Whether court can permit recall of witness U/S 311 of CRPC on ground of change of counsel?

The Court in Shiv Kumar Yadav (supra) case explained
the said authority by opining thus:-
“15. …..While advancement of justice remains the
prime object of law, it cannot be understood that
recall can be allowed for the asking or reasons
related to mere convenience. It has normally to be
presumed that the counsel conducting a case is
competent particularly when a counsel is
appointed by choice of a litigant. Taken to its
logical end, the principle that a retrial must follow
on every change of a counsel, can have serious
consequences on conduct of trials and the criminal
justice system. The witnesses cannot be expected
to face the hardship of appearing in court
repeatedly, particularly in sensitive cases such as
the present one. It can result in undue hardship
for the victims, especially so, of heinous crimes, if
they are required to repeatedly appear in court to
face cross-examination.”
We respectfully agree with the aforesaid exposition of law.
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS. 805-806 OF 2016
(@ S.L.P. (Crl.) Nos. 3278-79 of 2016)
State of Haryana 
 Versus
Ram Mehar & Others Etc. Etc. 
Citation:AIR 2016 SC 3942
Print Page

Sunday, 4 September 2016

Rights of accused to recall witness Vs rights of victim and witness



18.Section 311 Cr.P.C. is in two parts. It's 1st part is discretionary in
nature. However, its second part is mandatory in nature. If the Court finds
that it is just and necessary that the evidence have to be produced before
the Court then it has to be done. It may be also through the cross-
examination of witness, also has been already examined in chief.

19.A Court cannot forget victims of crime, the duty of the State and the
interest of the State to prosecute the offenders. The victims have suffered
already at the hands of the accused. Their agony prolongs during the trial
also. Harassing of witnesses under the pretext of cross examination has
become order of the day. In certain circumstances, during the trial,
practically victims suffers more than the accused. When the victims/witnesses
attend the Court they must be treated as guest, as they have come to assist
the Court to render correct finding on a disputed facts. Making the witnesses
to wait till the close of the day and asking them to come on some other day
for their examination has become a routine ordeal in the trial Courts.
Sometimes, the accused employ some tricks to dilute or efface the evidence
already recorded, either by bargaining or browbeating the witnesses. In one
way or other the witnesses are being gained over. Major gain is to the
accused. Net result is failure of justice and collapsing of the trial.

20.In this scenario, in VINOD KUMAR (supra) the Hon'ble Supreme Court 
expressed its anguish on this appalling situation prevailing in the trial
Courts and advised them to discourage indiscriminate and indefinite deferring
of the cross examination of the witnesses and also adjourning of the cases
for no reason or for flimsy reasons. But, in VINOD KUMAR (supra) the Hon'ble
Supreme Court did not say never recall any witness for his cross examination,
whatever might be the reason. Referring to Section 309 Cr.P.C. the Hon'ble
Supreme Court, advised the trial Courts to avoid unnecessary adjournments and
try to finish the cross-examination of the witnesses on the same day or
atleast on the next day. Thus VINOD KUMAR (supra) cannot be used to turn the 
table even when there is a genuine case for recalling the witnesses for
cross-examination.
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT               

DATED: 22.08.2016  

CORAM   
THE HONOURABLE DR.JUSTICE P.DEVADASS            

Crl.O.P.(MD) Nos.14889 of 2016 and 15234 of 2016  

Vincent                                            ... Petitioner/A1 in
Crl.O.P.(MD) No.                                                                                14889 
of 2016
Sikanthar Mohideen                                 ... Petitioner/A2 in
Crl.O.P.(MD) No.                                                                                15234 
of 2016

-vs-


The State represented by
The Inspector of Police,


Print Page

Sunday, 28 August 2016

Whether court can permit recall of witness using its inherent powers U/S 151 of CPC?

There is no specific provision in the Code enabling the parties to re- open the evidence for the purpose of further examination-in-chief or cross- examination. Section 151 of the Code provides that nothing in the Code shall be deemed to limit or otherwise affect the inherent powers of the Code to make such orders as may be necessary for the ends of justice or to prevent the abuse of the process of the court. In the absence of any provision providing for re-opening of evidence or recall of any witness for further examination or cross-examination, for purposes other than securing clarification required by the court, the inherent power under section 151 of the Code, subject to its limitations, can be invoked in appropriate cases to re- open the evidence and/or recall witnesses for further examination. This inherent power of the court is not affected by the express power conferred upon the court under Order 18 Rule 17 of the Code to recall any witness to enable the court to put such question to elicit any clarifications.
Reportable
Supreme Court of India
K.K. Velusamy vs N. Palaanisamy on 30 March, 2011
Bench: R.V. Raveendran, A.K. Patnaik
Citation:2011 AIR SCW2296
Print Page

Whether court can permit recall of witness when case was fixed for delivery of Judgment?

 I have heard the learned counsel for the parties at length. Order xviii Rule 17 runs as under: 104 "The Court may at any stage of the suit recall any witness who has been examined and may (subject to the law of evidence for the time being in force) put such questions to him as the Court thinks fit." On a plain reading of this provision it is obvious that discretion vests in the Court to recall a witness who has been examined earlier at any stage of the suit which would evidently mean any stage before the judgment is pronounced. So, the discretion vesting in the Court under this Rule can be exercised even after evidence of the parties has concluded, of course, it mist be exercised judicially and on well accepted judicial principles and not arbitrarily or capriciously.
The learned counsel for the respondent has adverted to a couple of reported decisions, viz ,T. Ramachandra Murthy v. K. Rama Murthy and others, Air 1980 Andhra Pradesh 265 and Altaf Hussain v. Nasreen Zahra, , in support of his contention that the power vesting under Rule 17 cannot be exercised so as to enable a party to fill up the lacuna in evidence. In the former case, there is no doubt, an observation to this effect. In the said case an application for recalling a witness was made after the judgment had been reserved. The learned Judge, therefore, observed that "the jurisdiction of the Court was sought to be invoked for recalling the witness at the time when the hearing of the case was over". With great respect I do not agree that the stage of the case alone should weigh with the Court to an extent as to over-shadow the other aspects of the matter. As observed by me above and also in Altaf Hussain's case (supra), the power under this rule can be exercised even of the stage of writing a judgment. It bears repetition that the object in the instant case is not to fill up the lacuna by adducing any fresh evidence but it is only to bring the proper admissible evidence on record which was somehow left out and instead photostat copies had been filed.
(8) In the second case, it was observed by a learned Judge of Allahabad High Court that the power under Rule 17 should not be exercised lightly and it should be used sparingly and in exceptional cases only. I am in respectful agreement with this view and I feel that the instant is a case in which the interests of justice demand that the petitioner should be permitted to bring proper documents on the record rather than be punished for certain lapses on his part which may well be attributed to inadvertence or lack of proper advice. Certainly the respondent can be compensated by awarding costs and also by affording an opportunity to adduce any evidence in rebuttal, if he so wishes.
Delhi High Court
Suresh Kumar vs Baldev Raj on 24 May, 1984
Equivalent citations: AIR 1984 Delhi 439, 26 (1984) DLT 213, 1984 (7) DRJ 101, 1984 RLR 631

Bench: J Jain
Print Page

When court can permit recall of witness for exhibition of documents?

 In Ram Sahai v. Kuberdan, (1956 Raj LW 306) (supra) it was held that certainly Order 18 Rule 17 authorises a court to recall a witness but for the purposes of putting any questions which the court itself might think necessary. It does not authorise a party to have a witness, whom he has already cross examined, recalled for the purpose of further cross examination. This citation obviously does not apply to the case in hand because here the plaintiff is himself recalling the witness because certain documents were not exhibited due to the lapse on the part of the advocate. In Shyamapada Neogy's case, (1967 (71) Cal WN 747) (supra) it was observed that it is only under special circumstances that such an order can be passed. I am of the view that when the court below after having considered ail the points has allowed the application under Section 151 CPC, the order should not be interfered with as no prejudice is, being caused to the defendant as they have been compensated by payment of cost of Rs. 2,000/-and will have opportunity to cross examine witnesses. The trial court has not committed an error of jurisdiction.
Rajasthan High Court
Jodhpur Gums & Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. vs Punjab National Bank And Ors. on 30 October, 1998
Equivalent citations: AIR 1999 Raj 38, 1999 (2) WLC 280

Bench: M Yamin
Print Page

Saturday, 20 August 2016

Whether court can permit recalling of witness U/S 151 of CPC?

 It has been argued by the learned counsel for the petitioner
that even if such power may not expressly been read in the
provisions contained under Order 18 Rule 17, the Court can
exercise its inherent power under Section 151, therefore, to
do complete justice in the matter the trial Court should have
allowed the application.13. It is not a case where the CPC has not made any provision
for recalling the witness. Once a provision has made in form
of Rule 17 Order 18 of the CPC restricting the same to be
invoked by the Court for putting some questions to the
witness, but not allowing any party to the litigation to recall a
witness, in such a situation provision contained under
Section 151 of the CPC cannot be applied for recalling a
witness, which is otherwise not made permissible in CPC.
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH : BILASPUR

Single Bench : Hon’ble Shri Prashant Kumar Mishra, J.

Writ Petition (Art.227) No.918 of 2013

Ajay Kumar Agrawal
Versus

Smt. Sushila Bai and another

 (Passed on this 6th day of January, 2015)
Print Page