Showing posts with label clean hands. Show all posts
Showing posts with label clean hands. Show all posts

Thursday, 18 October 2018

Whether a litigant can take contradictory stand in same proceeding?

A litigant can take different stands at different times but cannot
take contradictory stands in the same case. A party cannot be
permitted to approbate and reprobate on the same facts and take
inconsistent shifting stands. The untenability of an inconsistent stand
in the same case was considered in Amar Singh vs. Union of India,
(2011) 7 SCC 69, observing as follows:
“50. This Court wants to make it clear that an action at
law is not a game of chess. A litigant who comes to
Court and invokes its writ jurisdiction must come with
clean hands. He cannot prevaricate and take
inconsistent positions.”

REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 10322 OF 2018
(arising out of S.L.P.(C)No.12073 of 2017)

SUZUKI PARASRAMPURIA
SUITINGS PVT. LTD. Vs THE OFFICIAL LIQUIDATOR OF
MAHENDRA PETROCHEMICALS LTD.
(IN LIQUIDATION) AND OTHERS 

NAVIN SINHA, J.
Dated:OCTOBER 08, 2018.
Print Page

Saturday, 11 November 2017

Whether plaintiff has legal duty to come to court with true case and prove it by true evidence?

Inspite of the courts repeatedly stating and reaffirming the principle that it is the duty of a party asking for an injunction to bring to the notice of the Court all facts material and relevant to the issue, the litigants continue in their efforts to obtain favourable orders from the Court, ex parte, without disclosing all material facts to the Court. 
Thereafter again the Supreme Court in the case of S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu v. Jagannath, observed as follows :
"KULDIP SINGH, J.:---"Fraud- avoids all judicial acts, ecclesiastical or temporal" observed Chief Justice Edward Coke of England about three centuries ago. It is the settled proposition of law that a judgment or a Decree obtained by playing fraud on the Court is a nullity and nonest in the eyes of law. Such a judgment/Decree- by first Court or by the highest Court-has to be treated as a nullity by every Court, whether superior or inferior. It can be challenged in any Court even in collateral proceedings."
"7. The High Court, in our view, fell into patent error. The short question before the High Court was whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, Jagannath obtained the preliminary decree by playing fraud on the Court. The High Court, however, went haywire and made observations which are wholly perverse. We do not agree with the High Court that There is no legal duty cast upon the plaintiff to come to Court with a true case and prove it by true evidence". The principle of "finality of litigation" cannot be pressed to the extent of such an absurdity that it becomes an engine of fraud in the hands of dishonest litigants. The courts of the law are meant for imparting justice between the parties. One who comes to the Court, must come with clean hands. We are constrained to say that more often than not, process of the Court is being abused. Property grabbers, tax evaders, bank-loan-dodgers and other unscrupulous persons from all walks of life find the Court process a convenient lever to retain the illegal gains indefinitely. We have no hesitation to say that a person whose case is based on falsehood, has no right to approach the Court. He can be summarily thrown out at any stage of the litigation."
The passages quoted above leave no manner of doubt that a dishonest litigant loses his remedy, when discretionary relief is obtained by misrepresentation. The affidavit in support must make a candid and fair statement of facts. Facts must not be stated in a manner to mislead the Court as to the true facts. There must be no concealment of material facts. It is no excuse for the party to say that he/she was not aware of the importance of any facts which he/she has omitted to bring forward.
Bombay High Court
Agarwal Industries Ltd. vs Golden Oil Industries (P) Ltd. on 8 April, 1999
Equivalent citations: AIR 1999 Bom 362, 1999 (3) BomCR 390, (1999) 2 BOMLR 476, 2001 106 CompCas 78 Bom, 1999 (3) MhLj 684
Bench: S Nijjar


Print Page

Thursday, 19 October 2017

Whether court can grant injunction to person whose possession over property is not legal?

It is a settled principle of law that in order to claim prohibitory (temporary or permanent) injunction, it is necessary for the Plaintiff to prima facie prove apart from establishing other two ingredients, namely, irreparable loss and injury that his possession over the suit land is "legal". In this case, it was not so and nor it could be for the simple reason that as far back on 21.08.1976, the Tribunal had already declared the land held by the Plaintiff to be in excess of the ceiling limits prescribed under the Act. In these circumstances, the Plaintiff was neither holding the land nor could he be held to be in its lawful possession so as to enable him to exercise any ownership rights against any other private party over the suit land. The Appellant had then very limited rights left to exercise under the Act in relation to the suit land and such rights were available to him only against the State. Such is not the case here.


38. Lastly, this being a simple suit for grant of permanent injunction between the two private parties in relation to the land which was subject matter of the State Ceiling Laws, was liable to be dismissed on the short ground apart from many others as detailed above that any order that may be passed by the Civil Court would adversely affect and interfere in the rights of the State under the Act, which had not been impleaded as party Defendant.



IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA



Civil Appeal No. 5817 of 2012



Decided On: 13.04.2017



 Agnigundala Venkata Ranga Rao Vs.  Indukuru Ramachandra Reddy (dead) by L.Rs. and Ors.



Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Abhay Manohar Sapre and Navin Sinha, JJ.
Citation:(2017) 7 SCC 694,2018(1) MHLJ 94
Print Page

Thursday, 15 September 2016

Whether court should lift corporate veil if it is used to perpetrate fraud?

 In “Juggi Lal Kamlapat Vs Commissioner of Income
Tax, U.P.” [AIR 1969 SC 932] the Apex Court had gone on to
observe -
“7. …….It is true that from juristic point of view
the company is a legal personality entirely
distinct from its members and the company is
capable of enjoying rights and being subjected to
duties which are not the same as those enjoyed or
borne by its members. But in certain exceptional cases the
 Court is entitled to lift the veil of
corporate entity and to pay regard to the
economic realities behind the legal facade. For
example, the Court has power to disregard the
corporate entity if it is used for tax evasion or to
circumvent tax obligation or to perpetrate fraud.
17. Similarly in “Dalip Singh v. State of U.P. and Ors.”
[(2010) 2 SCC 114, the Supreme Court made these scathing
comments -
“2. In last 40 years, a new creed of litigants has
cropped up. Those who belong to this creed do not
have any respect for truth. They shamelessly
resort to falsehood and unethical means for
achieving their goals. In order to meet the
challenge posed by this new creed of litigants,
the courts have, from time to time, evolved new
rules and it is now well established that a
litigant, who attempts to pollute the stream of
justice or who touches the pure fountain of
justice with tainted hands, is not entitled to any
relief, interim or final. ”

19. In “R.N. Gosain Vs. Yashpal Dhir” [(1992) 4 SCC 683],
the Apex Court held -
“10. Law does not permit a person to both
approbate and reprobate. This principle is based
on the doctrine of election which postulates that
no party can accept and reject the same
instrument and that "a person cannot say at one
time that a transaction is valid any thereby
obtain some advantage, to which he could only be
entitled on the footing that it is valid, and then
turn round and say it is void for the purpose of
securing some other advantage".

21. The alternative contention raised on their behalf to the
effect that any document executed by the petitioner no. 2
(Director) in his personal capacity does not bind the Company
is also unconvincing in view of the highlighted observations of
the Supreme Court in “Juggi Lal Kamlapat Vs
Commissioner of Income Tax, U.P.” and “Dalip Singh Vs.
State of U.P.” (supra). In essence, the petitioner no. 2 is trying
to both approbate and reprobate by on the one hand
purporting to stand as Guarantor for the loan of his sons’
Partnership Firm, and then denying any liability by contending
that the property mortgaged does not belong to him but to the
Company, of which he appears to be the sole Director
according to the Cause Title of the Writ petition.
22. Such conduct of the petitioners is not appreciable. They
have clearly not come before this Court with clean hands and
are therefore not entitled to the relief prayed for.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(Ordinary Original Civil Jurisdiction)
 Original Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Sudip Ahluwalia
W.P. No. 493 of 2011
With
G.A No. 2776 of 2012
Angel Distribution Co. Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
Vs.
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. & Ors.

Judgement On : 20-05-2016

Print Page

Sunday, 29 May 2016

When court will not grant injunction in favour of plaintiff?

A perusal of record further indicates that after obtaining
ad-interim order of status-quo from this Court, the appellant has
extended the temporary structure in the suit premises. A perusal of
the photographs produced on record by the Municipal Corporation as
well as by the intervenor clearly indicates such further extension
carried out by the appellant. In my view, the reliefs under the
provisions of Order 39 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure are
equitable reliefs and are discretionary and such discretion can be
exercised by the Court only when the person has come to the Court

with clean hands and has not suppressed and/or material facts and
makes out a prima-facie case. In my view if a person violates the
order of status-quo granted by this Court, cannot be granted any
relief by exercising discretionary power by Court. A perusal of the
order passed by the learned trial Judge clearly indicates that the
appellant was given an opportunity to produce all the documents. The
learned trial Judge considered each and every document produced
by the appellant before him and has rightly rejected the ad-interim
relief. Though this Court has granted sufficient opportunity to the
appellant to convince this Court that the suit structure was a pacca
structure and that the appellant was carrying on business in the suit
premises since 1961-1962. In my view, the learned counsel
appearing for the appellant could not demonstrate any of these

crucial facts to seek any interim relief from this Court.
 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPEAL FROM ORDER NO.75 OF 2015
WITH
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.89 OF 2015
Mohd. Ismail Gulam Shaikh 
V/s.
Municipal Corporation of Gr.Mumbai & Anr.
 CORAM : R.D. DHANUKA, J.
 DATE : 1ST FEBRUARY, 2016.
Citation;2016(3) MHLJ247

Print Page

Sunday, 3 April 2016

What are Basic principles for conduct of writ litigation?

On the basis of said Supreme Court judgments, following principles may be culled out:-
1. A writ remedy is an equitable one. While exercising extraordinary power a Writ Court certainly bear in mind the conduct of the party who invokes the jurisdiction of the Court.
2. Litigant before the Writ Court must come with clean hands, clean heart, clean mind and clean objective. He should disclose all facts without suppressing anything. Litigant cannot be allowed to play "hide and seek" or to "pick and choose" the facts he likes to disclose and to suppress (keep back)/ conceal other facts.
3. Suppression or concealment of material facts is not an advocacy. It is a jugglery, manipulation, manoeuvring or mis representation which has no place in equitable and prerogative jurisdiction.
4. If litigant does not disclose all the material facts fairly and truly or states them in a distorted manner and misleads the Court, the Court has inherent R.P.No.161/2015 (Central Ware House & Ano. v. Union of India & Ano.) power to refuse to proceed further with the examination of the case on merits. If Court does not reject the petition on that ground, the Court would be failing in its duty.
5. Such a litigant requires to be dealt with for Contempt of Court for abusing the process of the Court.
6. There is a compelling need to take a serious view in such matters to ensure purity and grace in the administration of justice.
7. The litigation in the Court of law is not a game of chess. The Court is bound to see the conduct of party who is invoking such jurisdiction.
Madhya Pradesh High Court
Gwalior bench

Central Warehouse Thr vs Union Of India Thr on 11 May, 2015
R.P.No.161/2015
Print Page

Tuesday, 18 August 2015

Whether party who has not come to court with clean hands is entitled to get decree for specific performance of contract?

It is settled law that the party who seeks to avail of the equitable jurisdiction of a Court and specific performance being equitable relief, must come to the Court with clean hands; In other words the party who makes false allegations does not come with clean hands and is not entitled to the equitable relief. The Division Bench has pointed put in the judgment three grounds which disentitle the plaintiff to the equitable relief as he came with a positive case of incorrect and false facts as set put in para-graphs 4 to 6 thus:
Supreme Court of India
Lourdu Mari David And Ors vs Louis Chinnaya Arogiaswamy And ... on 9 August, 1996
Bench: K. Ramaswamy, G. B. Pattanaik
     Citation; (1996) 5 SCC 589
Print Page

Wednesday, 4 June 2014

Those who come to court must come with clean hand


 It may be noted that when the writ petitioner filed the petition on 21st January, 2006, he was aware of an investigation that was going on by the Delhi Police in connection of the forgery of annexures A and B. Even then he filed the petition with those annexures and without a proper affidavit.
48. It therefore appears that the petitioner has been shifting his stand to suit his convenience. In 2006, the gravamen of the petitioner's grievances was against the respondent no. 7, and the basis of his petition was the information that he derived from the said Anurag Singh. On the basis of such a petition, he invoked the jurisdiction of this Court and an interim order was issued in his favour, which is still continuing.

Now when the matter has come up for contested hearing, he suddenly withdraws his allegations against the respondent no. 7 and feels satisfied with the investigation of the Police in connection with the aforesaid case of forgery and also states that the same Anurag Singh "edited and tampered certain conversations of the petitioner".
50. This Court wants to make it clear that an action at law is not a game of chess. A litigant who comes to Court and invokes its writ jurisdiction must come with clean hands. He cannot prevaricate and take inconsistent positions.

Supreme Court of India
Amar Singh vs Union Of India & Ors on 11 May, 2011

Bench: G.S. Singhvi, Asok Kumar Ganguly
REPORTABLE
 Citation: 2011 4 AWC3726SC, 2011(5)SCALE606, (2011)7SCC69
Print Page