Showing posts with label interim maintenance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label interim maintenance. Show all posts

Sunday, 5 July 2026

Karnataka HC: Financially Independent Wife Earning More Than Husband Can't Claim Maintenance Merely Because She Is A Woman

 Only because a woman more particularly a wife files

a petition invoking the provisions of Domestic Violence Act or

the provisions of Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act or the

provisions contained in the Code of Criminal Procedure, where

the right to claim maintenance is recognized, the Courts cannot

straight away pass an order awarding some amount towards

maintenance payable by the husband. When the wife is

financially sound and in case where the income of the wife is

more than that of the husband and where no other liabilities are

found on part of the wife, like looking after the children, Courts

should not be inclined to pass an order granting maintenance on

the ground that women are required to be maintained by men

or wife is required to be maintained by her husband. It should

be borne in mind that only when it is shown that the wife has no

financial sources to maintain herself according to the standards

of her husband, then only Courts are required to award

maintenance either interim or final. {Para 9}

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

WP No. 2327 of 2026

DATED THIS THE 18TH DAY OF JUNE, 2026

SRI RAVI S @ JEEVAN S., Vs SMT. SAHANA DEVI A.,

CORAM: HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE CHILLAKUR SUMALATHA

Citation: NC: 2026:KHC:30140
Print Page

Monday, 8 September 2025

Madras HC: How to decide interim maintenance enhancement application filed by wife even though she is having sufficient income?

Further, the fact that the respondent has received substantial monies for the last three financial years is also not in dispute. The object of Section 24 is only for providing interim maintenance to the wife to enable her to get sufficient income to live a comfortable lifestyle. I do not see that the respondent is not possessed of such sufficient income already, warranting further monies from the petitioner by way of interim maintenance. {Para 16}

18.In Rajnesh's case, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that there is no straight jacket formula for fixing maintenance and the Court has to waive the status of parties, reasonable needs of the wife and dependent children, their education qualifications, any independent source of income accruing to the wife and whether such income would be sufficient to enable the wife to maintain the same standard of living as she was accustomed to in the matrimonial home, whether the wife was employed before and after marriage, etc.

19.Even applying the ratio laid down in Rajnesh's case, I do not find that the respondent requires any further amounts by way of interim maintenance to lead a comfortable lifestyle. In view of the aforesaid discussions regarding her holding of immovable properties as well as the substantial income by way of substantial dividends of the Company. 

 THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

CRP.No.2590 of 2025

& CMP.No.14720 of 2025

Dr.C.Amarnath Vs  Dr.J.Remabarathi 

CORAM: MR. JUSTICE P.B.BALAJI

Dated : 22.08.2025.

Print Page

Sunday, 18 February 2024

Whether husband can refuse to pay maintenance to wife if she is residing in matrimonial house?

The mere fact that she is residing in the matrimonial home is not a pretext to disentitle her to a reasonable amount of maintenance. She still needs some amount towards food, medicine, clothes and educational expenses for the child. Thus, considering the status of the parties, reasonable needs of the wife and minor son are parameters to be considered while determining the sufficiency and the reasonableness of the quantum of interim maintenance to be adjudged so that the wife is able to maintain herself and the minor son in reasonable comfort.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

WRIT PETITION NO. 11007 OF 2023

Rajkumar Amruthrao Guddadigi, Vs Shilaja Rajkumar Guddadigi,

CORAM : DR. NEELA GOKHALE, J.

PRONOUNCED ON : 4th January 2024.

Print Page

Monday, 16 May 2022

Whether the court can grant interim maintenance to wife in proceeding for restitution of conjugal rights under muslim law?

The above mentioned Full Bench judgment of Orissa High Court is also quoted with approval in para 36, 37 and 38. At the end of para 38, it has been stated that inherent power of a Court, as is well known, can be denied only by way of statutory interdiction. There does not exist any provision either in Civil Procedure Code, or in the Act, disbelieving the Court from granting interim maintenance". In para 45, it is also held that independent of inherent powers under Section 151 of Civil Procedure Code, even under the provisions of Act itself, by necessary implication, power has been conferred in the Court to grant interim maintenance to wife and minor children where circumstances so warrant.

13. Thus, the Full Bench judgments above clearly show that in a suit cognizable under Section 9 of Civil Procedure Code, the power to grant interim maintenance is available to Civil Court. The same power is also available to Family Court. Here, though the parties are Mohammedan, the maintainability of proceedings is not in dispute and hence till the question of entitlement to final relief remains pending for adjudication, Case before the Family Court is not for recovery of maintenance and, it has jurisdiction and power to award interim maintenance to the respondent - wife during restitution proceedings. The Family Court has correctly appreciated the law on the point.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY (NAGPUR BENCH)

Writ Petition No. 3232 of 2010

Decided On: 12.08.2010

Mohammed Anis-Ul-Haq Vs. Asma Anjum

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

B.P. Dharmadhikari, J.

Citation:  MANU/MH/0908/2010

Print Page

Sunday, 26 September 2021

Whether criminal appeal or revision would lie against order of interim maintenance passed under domestic violence act?

 As rightly pointed out by Mr. Bahl, imposition of a limitation on the statutory remedy of revision/ appeal under Section 399 of the Cr.P.C. or Section 29 of the DV Act- as the case may be, also falls foul of Article 14 of the Constitution of India for the reasons noticed by the Division Bench in Gagan Makkar (supra). Even if the condition in question - of the nature directed by the learned Single Judge in Rajeev Preenja (supra), were to exist in the statutory framework, the same may fail the test of reasonableness under Article 14 of the Constitution of India. This is for the reason that, in a given case, the order granting interim maintenance passed by the Ld. Magistrate either under Section 125 Cr.P.C or under Section 29 of the DV Act, may be so harsh and so unreasonable, as to make it impossible for the opposite party/ husband to comply with the same. Experience shows that in a large number of cases, the arrears of interim maintenance- which may be granted from the date of moving of the application before the Ld. Magistrate, may accumulate to a very large amount running into lakhs of rupees. The arrears of interim maintenance may not necessarily be a meager amount in all cases. It would be most unjust and unreasonable to bar his statutory remedy of revision/ appeal as the case may be, merely because he may not be in a position to deposit the entire arrears of interim maintenance.{Para 29}

30. Thus, we answer the reference by holding that the general direction issued in Rajeev Preenja (supra) in paragraphs 15, 16 and 20 are not sustainable. The said directions could not have been issued by the learned Single Judge as they seek to curtail the statutory remedy of revision available under Section 399 read with Section 401 of the Cr.P.C, and of appeal under Section 29 of the DV Act, against orders granting interim maintenance under Section 125 Cr.P.C. and Section 23 of the DV Act respectively. The direction in question over steps into the legislative field, which was impermissible for the Court to do. We agree with the view taken by the learned Single Judge in Brijesh Kumar Gupta (supra), that there cannot be an absolute rider that the entire maintenance amount, as granted by the Trial Court, should be deposited prior to the entertainment of the statutory remedy, because it would leave the remedy of statutory revision/ appeal illusory. Accordingly, we hold that a revision under Section 399 read with Section 401 Cr.P.C. and an appeal under Section 29 of the DV Act, against the order granting maintenance under Section 125 Cr.P.C. and under Section 23 of the DV Act respectively, would be maintainable, and would be entertained and heard without any pre-condition of deposit of the arrears of maintenance as ordered by the Ld. MM. We further hold that the pendency of such a Revision or Appeal- as the case may be, shall not operate as a stay of the operation of the order granting interim maintenance. The reference is answered accordingly.

Delhi High Court

Sabina Sahdev & Ors vs Vidur Sahdev on 9 July, 2018
Print Page

Sunday, 3 January 2021

Whether earning wife is entitled to get interim maintenance U/S 24 of Hindu Marriage Act?

 By application (Exh-14), the petitioner submitted that she was

unable to maintain herself since the couple has separated in the year 2016. She has been residing with her parents. She is unable to work because of the psychological pressure and harassment meted out to her by the respondent.

As against this, the respondent is a Medical Officer earning around Rs.60,000/- to Rs.65,000/- salary. No-one is dependent on him and therefore, she claimed interim maintenance at the rate of Rs.15,000/- per month and also claimed Rs.200/- for rickshaw fare for attending the Court for each date and Rs.25,000/- for engaging Advocate.

5. The respondent-husband opposed the application by his say

(Exh-19). He contended that the petitioner is also a doctor by profession and is also a Dermatologist. She was also earning Rs.50,000/- to Rs.60,000/- per month. She has continued her profession in a flat owned by her father. He denied that she was suffering from any psychological pressure and was unable to pursue her profession. He denied that he earns Rs.60,000/- to

Rs.65,000/- per month and prayed to reject the application.

6. After hearing both the sides, the learned Judge of the Family

Court rejected the application (Exh-14). Hence this petition.

7. Mr. Warma, learned Advocate, by referring to the recent

judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Rajnesh Vs. Neha and Anr.;

Criminal Appeal No.730 of 2020, decided on 04.11.2020, submitted that the

Supreme Court has now laid down several guidelines and directions in the

matters of grant of maintenance/alimony, including interim maintenance,

awardable under different Statutes. He would point out that assuming that

that the petitioner is a duly qualified medical practitioner, still she is entitled

to claim interim alimony as has been laid down in this decision of the

Supreme Court. Her capacity to earn her livelihood cannot come in her way

to claim alimony. As against this, the respondent is also a Medical Officer

regularly earning sumptuous salary. The learned Judge of the Family Court

has grossly erred in appreciating the law and the facts and has illegally

refused interim alimony, which order may be reversed.

8. Mr. A.M. Gholap, learned Advocate for the respondent strongly

opposed the petition. He submitted that the petitioner has not come with

clean hands and has hidden that she is pursuing medical profession. The

record was produced before the Family Court to that effect and no error is committed by the learned Judge in refusing interim alimony to her.

9. As far as right of a wife, who is capable of earning, to claim

alimony is concerned, the Supreme Court in the case of Rajnesh (supra) has

considered it in clause (c) of Part-III under the head of `Criteria for

determining quantum of maintenance’, which reads thus :-

“(c) Where wife is earning some income

The Courts have held that if the wife is earning, it

cannot operate as a bar from being awarded maintenance by the

husband. The Courts have provided guidance on this issue in the

following judgments.

In Shailaja & Anr. V Khobbanna, this Court held that

merely because the wife is capable of earning, it would not be a

sufficient ground to reduce the maintenance awarded by the

Family Court. The Court has to determine whether the income

of the wife is sufficient to enable her to maintain herself, in

accordance with the lifestyle of her husband in the matrimonial

home. Sustenance does not mean, and cannot be allowed to

mean mere survival.

In Sunita Kachwaha & Ors. V Anil Kachwaha, the

wife had a postgraduate degree, and was employed as a teacher

in Jabalpur. The husband raised a contention that since the wife

had sufficient income, she would not require financial assistance

from the husband. The Supreme Court repelled this contention,

and held that merely because the wife was earning some income,

it could not be a ground to reject her claim for maintenance.

The Bombay High Court in Sanjay Damodar Kale v

Kalyani Sanjay Kale while relying upon the judgment in Sunita

Kachwaha (supra), held that neither the mere potential to earn,

nor the actual earning of the wife, howsoever meagre, is

sufficient to deny the claim of maintenance.

An able-bodied husband must be presumed to be

capable of earning sufficient money to maintain his wife and

children, and cannot contend that he is not in a position to earn

sufficiently to maintain his family, as held by the Delhi High

Court in Chander Prakash Bodhraj v Shila Rani Chander

Prakaash. The onus is on the husband to establish with

necessary material that there are sufficient grounds to show that

he is unable to maintain the family, and discharge his legal

obligations for reasons beyond his control. If the husband does

not disclose the exact amount of his income, an adverse

inference may be drawn by the Court.

This Court in Shamima Farooqui v Shahid Khan

cited the judgment in Chander Prakash (supra) with approval,

and held that the obligation of the husband to provide

maintenance stands on a higher pedestal than the wife.”

10. Suffice for the purpose, therefore, to conclude that even if the

petitioner in the matter in hand is a medical practitioner and is earning something for her livelihood, it cannot be a ground to refuse alimony to her under Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act.


 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

WRIT PETITION NO.4014 OF 2019

Arpana Vijay Manore Vs Dr. Vijay Tukaram Manore,

Print Page

Friday, 18 December 2020

Whether the court should draw an adverse inference if the husband fails to disclose his earnings as per the direction given by the Supreme Court in the case of Rajnesh vs Neha?

 Now coming to the quantum of maintenance, though the

petitioner has produced her Income Tax returns, the respondent has not

reciprocated the gesture. It is to meet such situations that the Supreme Court

in the case of Rajnesh (supra) has also laid down several guidelines requiring

both the parties to make several disclosures in the form of affidavits inter alia

touching the income aspect as well. Conspicuously, in that matter, the

Supreme Court had directed the husband to produce Income Tax returns

before passing the order for granting interim maintenance. In my view,

instead of resorting to such a course now, which is likely to further delay the

proceeding, it would be appropriate to draw an adverse inference, which is

also held to be permissible in this order of the Supreme Court in the case of Rajnesh (supra). Consequently, without indulging into further discussion,

failure of the respondent to come with a disclosure as to his own income and

taking into consideration all the aforementioned facts and circumstances and

bearing in mind the guidelines laid down by the Supreme Court in the case of

Rajnesh (supra) and resorting to an inevitable guesswork, it would be just

and proper to award interim maintenance to the petitioner at the rate of

Rs.10,000/- per month from the date of her application i.e. 03.10.2017.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

WRIT PETITION NO.4014 OF 2019

Arpana Vijay Manore Vs Dr. Vijay Tukaram Manore,


CORAM : MANGESH S. PATIL, J.


JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED ON : 09.12.2020

Citation: 2020 SCC OnLineBom 3925,

Print Page

Thursday, 9 July 2020

Whether the court can stay the application of the husband for custody or access to the child until he pays interim maintenance to his wife and child?

1) Finally, I cannot forget the fact that here is before me a father, who refuses to fork out the amount, which the competent Court has determined as justly due and payable towards maintenance of the wife and child. It is not in dispute that the arrears of the interim maintenance have accumulated to about Rs. 1,40,000/- till today. Interim maintenance is made payable, so that the wife and child can sustain themselves.

2) After much anguishing soul-searching, I have reached the painful conclusion that, for reasons more than one, the petitioner must be denied access to the child until he displays evidence of contrition, penitence and reform; in shori, until he pays up the arrears of interim maintenance and shows readiness to pay from month to month the amounts ordered, I do not consider him a fit person whose influence should be allowed to rub off on the child.


24. In my view, for the aforesaid reasons, it is necessary, in the interests of welfare, well-facing and all round beneficial development of the child, to deny the petitioner access to the child till such time, at least, that he reports, relents and becomes agreeable to comply with orders of the Courts.

25. In the result, the notice of motion is made absolute in terms of prayer (a), and it is made clear that the petitioner shall have no right of access to the minor child until he deposits with the Family Court all arrears of maintenance up-to-date, and gives an undertaking in writing to the Court that he shall continue to abide by the order of the Court from month to month.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Notice of Motion No. 1554 of 1992 in Interim Petn. No. 32 of 1990 in Custody Petn. No. 31 of 1990

Decided On: 24.07.1992

Vinodchandra Gajanan Deokar  Vs. Anupama Vinodchandra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
B.N. Srikrishna, J.

Citations: AIR 1993 Bom 232, 1992 (3) BomCR 129, I (1993) DMC 537
Print Page

Sunday, 8 December 2019

Whether unemployed husband is bound to give maintenance to wife in domestic violence proceeding?

A perusal of Domestic Violence Act shows that Domestic Violence Act does not create any additional right in favour of wife regarding maintenance. It only enables the Magistrate to pass a maintenance order as per the rights available under existing laws. While, the Act specifies the duties and functions of protection officer, police officer, service providers, magistrate, medical facility providers and duties of Government, the Act is silent about the duties of husband or the duties of wife. Thus, maintenance can be fixed by the Court under Domestic Violence Act only as per prevalent law regarding providing of maintenance by husband to the wife. Under prevalent laws i.e. Hindu Adoption & Maintenance Act, Hindu Marriage Act, Section 125 Cr.P.C - a husband is supposed to maintain his un-earning spouse out of the income which he earns. No law provides that a husband has to maintain a wife, living separately from him, irrespective of the fact whether he earns or not. Court cannot tell the husband that he should beg, borrow or steal but give maintenance to the wife, more so when the husband and wife are almost equally qualified and almost equally capable of earning and both of them claimed to be gainfully employed before marriage. If the husband was BSc. and Masters in Marketing Management from Pondicherry University, the wife was MA (English) & MBA. If the husband was working as a Manager abroad, the wife with MBA degree was also working in an MNC in India. Under these circumstances, fixing of maintenance by the Court without there being even a prima facie proof of the husband being employed in India and with clear proof of the fact that the passport of the husband was seized, he was not permitted to leave country, (the bail was given with a condition that he shall keep visiting Investigating Officer as and when called) is contrary to law and not warranted under provisions of Domestic Violence Act.

5. We are living in an era of equality of sexes. The Constitution provides equal treatment to be given irrespective of sex, caste and creed. An unemployed husband, who is holding an MBA degree, cannot be treated differently to an unemployed wife, who is also holding an MBA degree. Since both are on equal footing one cannot be asked to maintain other unless one is employed and other is not employed. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI

Crl. M.C. No. 491/2009

Decided On: 27.08.2010

 Sanjay Bhardwaj Vs. The State and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
S.N. Dhingra, J.

Print Page

Sunday, 29 September 2019

Whether court can issue arrest warrant for recovery of interim maintenance granted in Hindu marriage petition?

 By order dated 15th February, 2017, the learned trial Judge issued warrant against the Petitioner for enforcement for direction for payment of interim maintenance. The order records that the warrant was returned un-executed possibly because the judgment debtor is a police officer and has played a material role in creating hurdles in such execution. The learned counsel for the Petitioner points out that the Petitioner is not a police officer. Possibly the learned trial Judge was mean to say that Petitioner's mother was Sr. Police Inspector. Be that as it may since, the Petitioner is admittedly in arrears of maintenance, there is nothing wrong in issuing warrant against him. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 13993 of 2016 and Civil Application No. 852 of 2017

Decided On: 20.12.2018

 Amol Chandrakant Mahamuni Vs.  Swati Amol Mahamuni

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
M.S. Sonak, J.

Citation: 2019(3) MHLJ 493
Print Page

Sunday, 7 April 2019

Whether registration of a person as Advocate does not mean that he is practising and earning?

 As per learned counsel for the petitioner, respondent was
registered with Uttar Pradesh Bar Council. As per the case of the
petitioner, respondent along with her husband resided for few days at
District Azamgarh and thereafter at Pune wherefrom she separated.
The fact that the respondent had been shifting her place of residence
would prima facie show that she might not be in a position to practice
as an advocate. No material has been placed on record by the
petitioner to show that she is working as an advocate. In any
eventuality, petitioner has been given an opportunity to establish his
defence at trial.
The mere fact that the
respondent is qualified and registered as an advocate does not ipso
facto imply that she is practicing as an advocate and earning.

 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

 Judgment delivered on: 03.04.2019

 CRL.REV.P. 389/2019

ASHOK KUMAR PASI  Vs STATE 

CORAM:
 MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV SACHDEVA

Print Page

Sunday, 17 March 2019

Whether court can grant interim maintenance to wife under DV Act on basis of notional income of husband?

The petitioner claims that he is non-matriculate and has no source of income, he having been engaged in earning his livelihood as a driver of three wheeler scooter (TSR) till 2006, cannot be acted upon. He has not disclosed as to how he has been surviving all along. It cannot be believed that a person who was capable of supporting a family by getting married and raising a child would all of a sudden become devoid of all sources of income.
6. It is clear and is evident from the order of the sessions that the petitioner is concealing facts, intentionally withholding information about his income. It is noted that the Metropolitan Magistrate faced with a situation wherein respondents were also unable to muster clear proof, has assumed the income notionally on the basis of minimum wages and on such basis has passed the order of interim maintenance. The approach of the Metropolitan Magistrate in these circumstances cannot be faulted.

In the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi
(Before R.K. Gauba, J.)

Khem Chand  v. Bhagwati alias Laxmi

Crl. M.C. 812/2016 & Crl.M.A. 3423/2016
Decided on January 22, 2019
Citation: 2019 SCC OnLine Del 6776
Print Page

Saturday, 22 December 2018

Whether order for interim maintenance can be executed within twelve years from date of order?

It is fallacious to appreciate that the order or decree passed by the Court under the Hindu Marriage Act as well as by the Family Court, would be enforced under the provisions of Article 137 of the Limitation Act. There is specific provision under Article 136 of the Part I of the Third Division of Schedule of Limitation Act for period of limitation to execute the decree or order of the Civil Court. It would be reiterated that the decree or order under Hindu Marriage Act as well as passed by the Family Court all are having same force and effect as a decree or order of the Civil Court and liable to be executed in the same mode and manner as prescribed under the Code of Civil Procedure for execution of decree or order of the Civil Court. The provision of Article 137 is applicable to the proceedings of "any other application" for which no period of limitation is given elsewhere in the Third Division to the Schedule. As referred above, when the specific period of 12 years is prescribed for execution of decree/order of Civil Court, the same provision of 12 years period of limitation is essential to be made applicable to the decree/order by the Family Court or by any Court under Hindu Marriage Act. The procedure meant for execution of decree/order of Civil Court is required to be adopted for execution of decree/order of Family Court or any Court under Hindu Marriage Act. Both the procedures for execution are to be considered analogous with each other. Therefore, when there is a limitation period provided under Article 136 for execution of decree/order of the Civil Court, the decree/order of Family Court under Hindu Marriage Act are permitted to be executed within 12 years period with same force and effect as well as with the same mode and manner prescribed for execution of decree/order of Civil Court. In the result, the procedure would be governed by Article 136 and not by the provision of Article 137 of Limitation Act. The Single Judge of the High Court of Orissa in the case of V. Krishnaveni Vs. V. Narasingha Rao, MANU/OR/0174/1984 : 1984 Law Suit (Ori.) 148 also held that the order under Section 24 of the Act is enforceable within a period of 12 years under Article 136 of the Limitation Act.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY

Writ Petition No. 11581 of 2017

Decided On: 07.08.2018

Parag Subhash Parelkar Vs. State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
K.K. Sonawane, J.

Citation: 2018(6) MHLJ 504,AIR2019 Bom 9
Print Page

Wednesday, 15 August 2018

Whether interim maintenance granted to child can be stayed if he is not ready to meet his father?

The only remedial measure in such situation is to counsel
the child so that he will be ready to have access with his father but
staying the order of interim maintenance and thereby depriving him
from the essential requirements of the life cannot be called a legal,
equitable or correct. After all the grant of maintenance is for his
survival and such order of maintenance cannot be conditional, in the
way that if the child refuses to have access to his father, he will not
be entitled to maintenance. The impugned order passed by the
Family Court linking payment of maintenance to the access of child
being not justified or legal needs to be set-aside.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 11308 OF 2015

Uma Ashish Ghate  V/s. Ashish Anil Ghate 

CORAM : DR. SHALINI PHANSALKAR-JOSHI, J.
DATED : 9th OCTOBER, 2017.
Citation: 2018(4) MHLJ 365
Print Page

Saturday, 23 June 2018

Whether interim maintenance granted under DV Act can be adjusted against maintenance granted U/S 125 of CRPC?

When the interim order came to be passed
under the DV Act, there was no other order in
existence awarding any maintenance to the wife
and the daughter. Therefore, it cannot be said
that the amount, as has been awarded by way of
interim maintenance under the DV Act, is in

addition to the amount of maintenance awarded
under any other provision of law. Had there been
any earlier order in existence awarding some
maintenance to the respondents and in spite of
the said order, if the learned Magistrate dealing
with the proceeding under the DV Act, by
recording reasons, would have granted some more
amount by way of maintenance in addition to the
maintenance already granted in favour of the
aggrieved person, the position would have been
different. In such a case, the adjustment could
not have been permissible. In the instant
matter, since the interim maintenance awarded
under the DV Act is not in addition to the amount
already granted in any other civil or criminal
proceeding, the same is certainly liable to be
adjusted against the amount of maintenance
finally awarded under Section 125 of Cr.P.C. even
though the husband has not challenged the said
order before any higher court.

 It is directed
that while computing the amount of maintenance
payable to the respondents for the period from

27.8.2014 to 26.8.2015, as per the order passed
under Section 125 of Cr.P.C., the learned Judge
of the Family Court shall take into account the
amount of maintenance paid by the husband under
the DV Act for the aforesaid period and adjust
the said amount against the amount payable under
Section 125 of Cr.P.C.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL REVISION APPLICATION NO.203 OF 2017

Vishal S/o. Rajesaheb Gore  Vs  Sow.Aparna W/o Vishal Gore


CORAM : P.R.BORA, J.

DATED : 1 3 t h June,201 8

Print Page

Tuesday, 15 May 2018

Whether muslim woman is entitled to get rights conferred under domestic violence Act?


As   till   the   time   the   Talaq   is   not   proved,   the
respondent continues to be legally weeded wife of the petitioner and
in   that  contingency   the   question   is  whether  the   wife   who  is  in
domestic relationship with the petitioner is entitled to seek the relief
under the provisions of the Domestic Violence Act.   Though the

learned counsel for the petitioner had vehemently argued that the
parties are governed by Muslim Personal Laws and therefore the
provisions  of   the   Domestic   Violence  Act   cannot   be  invoked,  per
contra  Mrs.Irani  would   submit  that  there   is  no  intention  of   the
legislature to restrict the provisions of Protection from Womens of
Domestic Violence Act, 2005 to a particular category of women and
to specifically exclude the women belonging to the Muslim religion.
8. Perusal of the provisions of the Protection of Women
from   Domestic   Violence   Act,   2005   would   reveal   that   it   is   an
enactment   to   provide   for   more  effective  protection   for   rights   of
women   guaranteed   under   the   Indian   Constitution   who   are   the
victims of the violence.  The enactment no way intends to restrict its
application to any particular category of women but it intends to
protect the women aggrieved, who are victims of Domestic Violence.
The   definition   and   connotation   of   “Domestic   Violence”   under
Section­3  of   the  enactment   do  not  indicate   any  intention   either
express or implied to exclude Muslim women.   Section­36 of the
said enactment provides that the provisions of the Act shall be in
addition to and not in derogation of the provisions of any other law
for the time any force.  Thus, the scheme of the enactment do not
restrict the applicability of the provisions of the Act to a particular

category   of   women,   nevertheless   to   a     woman   belonging   to   a
particular religion.  No doubt the Muslim women are also governed
by   several   other   enactments   in   the   form   of   Muslim   Women
(Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986, Dissolution of Muslim
Marriage Act, 1939 etc., however, the rights conferred under the
said enactments can in no way curtail the operation or Protection
granted under The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence
Act.  In these circumstances the contention advanced by the learned
counsel for the petitioner that the respondent­wife could not avail
the   provisions   of   the   Domestic   Violence   Act   is   not   sustainable.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 114 OF 2018
WITH 
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.518 OF 2018

Mr.Ali Abbas Daruwala  V/s. Mrs.Shehnaz Daruwala.

­­­­
CORAM : SMT.BHARATI H. DANGRE, J

PROUNCENED ON : 04th MAY 2018.
Citation: 2018(6) MHLJ 596

Print Page

Sunday, 21 January 2018

Whether wife can be denied interim maintenance U/S 24 of Hindu Marriage Act if she has converted herself from Hinduism to other religion?

We have heard the learned counsel for both sides and perused the materials placed on record. In an application filed either by the husband or wife under Section 24 of The Hindu Marriage Act, the financial status of the parties and his or her capability to maintain himself or herself as the case may be during the pendency of the matrimonial proceedings alone is required to be considered. At this stage, what is required to be decided is the resourcefulness or otherwise of the applicant to maintain himself or herself during the pendency of the matrimonial proceedings. For this purpose, the Courts are not required to take note of the conversion of either the husband or wife to any other religion as contemplated under Section 18(2)(f) of The Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 or it will be a ground to deny interim maintenance sought for in an application under Section 24 of The Hindu Marriage Act. In other words, Section 18(2)(f) The Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 has no application for considering the claim of the husband or wife as the case may be for interim maintenance under Section 24 of The Hindu Marriage Act. 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADRAS

Civil Miscellaneous Appeal No. 1409 of 2017

Decided On: 06.07.2017

 K. Gurusamy Vs.  G. Malliga

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
R. Subbiah and A.D. Jagadish Chandira, JJ.

Citation: AIR 2017 Madras 286
Print Page

Sunday, 22 October 2017

Whether court can determine quantum of maintenance to wife on basis of lifestyle of husband?

The perusal of the impugned order passed by the Trial Court reveals that the Trial Court has considered the Income Tax Returns filed by Respondent No.2 and found that, in the column of 'Balance Sheet', his various assets, as on 31st March 2011, have been shown and those assets reveal that he holds Mangal Keshav Securities of Rs.5,00,000/-; Silver Palace Assets of Rs.5,25,000/-, Assets of Mukesh P. Jain to the tune of Rs.13,00,000/- and the assets of Citizen Co-operative Bank Ltd. toWP-2270-16.doc the tune of Rs.4,33,000/-. These assets are very much reflected in the Income Tax Returns itself. There may be some liabilities, as submitted by learned counsel for Respondent No.2, but the Income Tax Returns clearly reflect that Respondent No.2 and his family is dealing in the business and earning substantial income. Therefore, he could have his assets and liabilities.
6. Needless to state, that whatever income is given to the Income Tax Authorities in the 'Returns' may not be necessarily reflecting the true picture and, therefore, Court has to take into consideration the lifestyle of the parties and all other aspects. If one considers the same, then, it goes without saying that, Respondent No.2 has made every attempt to conceal his real income, just in order to avoid the payment of maintenance.
7. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of MVs. A, CDJ 2017 SC 352, has observed, in paragraph No.39, that;
"39. .................................... It has now become a matter of routine that as and when an application for maintenance is filed, the non-applicant becomes poor displaying that he is not residing with the family members, if they have a good business and movable and immovable properties, in order to avoid payment of maintenance. Courts cannot, under these circumstances, close their eyes when tricks are being played in a clever manner."
8. In the case of Tejas Vs. Urmishta  CDJ 2016 BHC 1568, the learned Single Judge of this Court has observed, in paragraph No.7, that;
"7. In case of Shirish H. Garg Vs. Nidhi S. Garg, 2011 (5) Bom. C.R. 372, this Court has held that the ascertainment of the income has to be done judicially and sensibly and not arbitrarily or only arithmetically. In consideration of income contemplated under these proceedings, cognizance need not be restricted to only the numerical figures shown in the Income Tax Returns, nor can such figures be taken for the gospel. The Court is required to take into consideration the attendant circumstances, before the figures stated in the Income Tax Return are accepted as they stand."

Bombay High Court

Pinky W/O. Mahendra Kumar Jain vs The State Of Maharashtra And Anr on 6 October, 2017
Bench: Dr. Shalini Phansalkar-Joshi
CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO.2270 OF 2016
Print Page

Tuesday, 20 June 2017

Whether wife is entitled to get interim maintenance if husband takes contrary plea?

After hearing the learned counsel for the appellant, first of all it is required to be observed that on the one hand, appellant himself has filed u/s. 9 of the Act of 1955 for restitution of conjugal rights, though he has levelled allegations of adultery against his wife, and on the other hand, he took a plea in the reply to the application u/s. 24 of Act of 1955 that his wife (respondent) is having illicit relations with one Wasim Khan and living in adultery. In our opinion, that issue is required to adjudicated by the court in the proceedings initiated by the appellant by way of filing application under Section 9 of the Act of 1955. When the appellant is taking plea of respondent having illicit relation with Wasim Khan, then, it cannot be said that his application u/s. 9 of the Act of 1955 is bonafide. More so, it is obvious that on the one hand the appellant has leveled allegations about the character of respondent/wife and on the other hand he is seeking a decree of restitution of conjugal rights u/s. 9 of the Act of 1955. In our opinion, the intention of the appellant is obvious that somehow or the other he does not want to live with the respondent/wife and initiated the proceedings u/s. 9 of the Act of 1955, in which respondent/wife filed application claiming maintenance u/s. 24 of the Act of 1955.
10. It may be true that certain documents viz. PAN card of respondent, and other documents with respect to character of respondent were filed before the court below but at the same time, it is obvious that no documentary evidence has been filed by the appellant to show the income of the respondent except pleadings being made in the reply, that too without any supporting documents.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF RAJASTHAN (JODHPUR BENCH)
D.B. Civil Misc. Appeal No. 197/2017
Decided On: 20.01.2017
Sunil Soni

Vs.

Khushbu Soni

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:

Gopal Krishan Vyas and Goverdhan Bardhar, JJ.

Citation: AIR 2017(NOC) 117 Raj
Print Page

Sunday, 2 April 2017

Whether application for interim maintenance can be rejected considering contents of FIR filed by wife?

 The wife in her petition filed under Section 125 Cr.P.C. did not disclose that she was a Physiotherapist or was earning but in the First Information Report lodged with the police in September 2013 she had mentioned that she was a Physiotherapist (doctor). The information was provided by the complainant. There was no reason for the complainant to mention that. When it has been specifically mentioned it can be assumed that she was a practicing Physiotherapist. The husband is posted in Rajasthan. It is not possible for him to collect the information whether she was running a clinic or about her income. The trial Court had noted this and had declined the application for interim maintenance and rightly so.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
Criminal Revision No. 2625 of 2014 (O&M)
Decided On: 29.09.2016
 Monu Songra
Vs.
Pinki
Coram:Anita Chaudhry, J.
Citation:2017 ALLMR(CRI)JOURNAL 57
Print Page